ipl-logo

Columbus Day Myth

673 Words3 Pages

“Myth of the essential white American”- that the essential American soul is a killer” (Ortiz, 2014, pg. 94). Chapter 5, The Birth of a Nation, concluded with this quote and I thought it was interesting. As I reflect on the opening vignette which quotes Martin Luther King Jr.; stating that “our nation was born in genocide” and we are probably the only nation that tries to wipe out an entire nation and even to today, we as a nation has not been allowed to feel ashamed of our history (Ortiz, 2014, pg.78). These are some powerful statements which critiques our nation’s history and people for all the genocides, oppression and domination that has taken place over centuries and one can argue this cycle of behaviors have trickled down into our society …show more content…

The sole purpose of that protest was because of conflicts regarding the removal of certain confederate’s statues which many argued represented slavery and memorialized white supremacy. One can argue that we should not celebrate Columbus Day because of the injustices that has occurred to Native Americans because of his arrival on Indigenous land. Furthermore, one can also argue that we should not celebrate the founding fathers of the United States because under their administration, particularly George Washington; land was being conquered. In addition, it was Washington who “determined that only war not diplomacy would break up the Indigenous alliances” (Ortiz, 2014, pg. 81). Under Washington governance, Miami’s towns were destroyed, women and children held captive and other tribes such as the Iroquois and Seneca women and children lived in fear that this may happen to them as well. Shawnee leaders refused to submissions and US forces destroyed villages and fields while murdering women, children and old men all because the establishment and conquest of land. Yet with all this occurring, from the perspective of this book, President George Washington did not do anything that help the people of the land, so this raises questions as to whether Americans should also debate about the removal of his statues and impact on American

Show More
Related

Response To Tecumseh's 'Voices Of Freedom'

765 Words | 4 Pages

Andrew Gendel Professor Coburn History 17A 22 October 2015 Response Paper Chapter eight in the book, Voices Of Freedom, we read into the years of 1790 through 1815. In the coming chapters we learn about the French Revolution (1792-93), but also skim past Judith Murray and the equality of sexes, George Washington’s farewell address, George Tucker on Gabriel’s rebellion, Mercy Otis Warren on religion and Virtue (1805), Tecumseh on Indians and lands (1810), Felix Grundy, and Battle Cry of the War Hawks (1811). Although chapter eight follows the process of the republic and securing it I find that through this chapter an argument that is most presented in chapter eight is that of Indian rights in the New America, the rise of colonization and the amelioration of Native ways. Tecumseh was a chief who refused to sign the Treaty of Greenville

Read More

Differences Between The French And Indian War Dbq

413 Words | 2 Pages

In 1742 the chief of Onondaga of the Iroquois Confederacy knew that his land that the people shared would become more valuable than it has ever been. (Doc B)The reason for this was because the “white people” also known as the Americans wanted the land of the chief. The feelings of the Chief result in complaining to the representatives of Pennsylvania, Maryland and Virginia,

Read More

Dakota Reservation Summary

1374 Words | 6 Pages

Native groups often took land and materials from weaker groups whenever it suited them. They understood the concept of ownership by conquest. From the time the first settlers landed on Turtle Island [America], the Natives were pushed from their home. In 1783, George Washington wrote a letter to James Duane, outlining principles of the Indian Policy of the Continental Congress. Washington outlined ‘an enlightened People’ would consider the Native to be deluded and that “as the country is large enough to contain us all; and as we are disposed to be kind to them and to partake in their trade…we will draw a veil over what is past and establish a boundary line between them and us beyond which we will endeavor to restrain our People from Hunting or Settling” (4).

Read More

First Seminole War Dbq

717 Words | 3 Pages

During the early to mid 1800s, the colonization of “Indians” and subordination of “women’s rights in the American society,” was very essential to those in authority. They were perceived as a mere means to an end by promises of a better life in exchange for “land and work.” Although locals complied, those in offices took advantage by using antagonistic tactics in achieving wealth, power, and ownership. However, these actions lead to “The First Seminole War, The Monroe Doctrine, Andrew Jackson’s leadership, The Indian Removal Act, The California Gold Rush, The Seneca Falls Convention, and the Birth of the Republican Party.” Although some Americans have been perceived as heroes, their actions have said otherwise about their character.

Read More

Tecumseh's Vision Summary

550 Words | 3 Pages

As the Shawnees were attempting to reunite in the Ohio Valley, they found themselves displaced and had to defend their territory from western expansion. The Shawnees placed all their trust in the British, which didn’t turn out positive for them, for when the British ceded all lands west of the Appalachian Mountains, which endangered the lives of the Natives. “For the

Read More

Christopher Columbus Propaganda

922 Words | 4 Pages

The marketing of products and ideas influence all people 's lives and has been a part of the human experience for thousands of years. This marketing can take on a number of different forms, but one of the most common forms is propaganda. According to Fleming, propaganda is the use of specific "techniques to influence thinking in whatever direction" the author wants and in most cases to "sell" an idea or product (3). Two of the earliest accounts of this popular marketing method, in Western Hemisphere, come for the letters and reports of both Christopher Columbus and John Smith. Both of which tried to marketed the newly discovered and settled North American continent.

Read More

Christopher Columbus Isn T Worthy Of A National Holiday

89 Words | 1 Pages

Christopher Columbus isn’t worthy of a national holiday. For one thing, he slaughtered and killed Native Americans and brought over diseases as well. Also Colombus started the American holocaust such as the murder, torture, pillaging, robbery, kidnapping, and slavery of the native people. Additionally, he once said “They would make fine servants with fifty men we could subjugate them all and make them do whatever we want.” In the long run due to the slavery and murderings of the Native Americans Christopher Colombus isn’t worthy of a national holiday.

Read More

Analysis Of Columbus The Indians And Human Progress

251 Words | 2 Pages

“Columbus, the Indians, and Human Progress”, chapter one of “A People’s History of the United States”, written by professor and historian Howard Zinn, concentrates on a different perspective of major events in American history. It begins with the native Bahamian tribe of Arawaks welcoming the Spanish to their shores with gifts and kindness, only then for the reader to be disturbed by a log from Columbus himself – “They willingly traded everything they owned… They would make fine servants… With fifty men we could subjugate them all and make them do whatever we want.” (Zinn pg.1) In the work, Zinn continues explaining the unnecessary evils Columbus and his men committed unto the unsuspecting natives.

Read More

The Trans-Mississippi West

784 Words | 4 Pages

During the “Gilded Age” period of American history, development of the Trans-Mississippi west was crucial to fulfilling the American dream of manifest destiny and creating an identity which was distinctly American. Since the west is often associated with rugged pioneers and frontiersmen, there is an overarching idea of hardy American individualism. However, although these settlers were brave and helped to make America into what it is today, they heavily relied on federal support. It would not have been possible for white Americans to settle the Trans-Mississippi west without the US government removing Native Americans from their lands and placing them on reservations, offering land grants and incentives for people to move out west, and the

Read More

Persuasive Speech Columbus Day

454 Words | 2 Pages

The U.S. should not continue to celebrate Columbus Day. We aren’t celebrating a man who discovered a new world, but a man who enslaved and killed a myriad of Natives. We, as a country and as an Earth, celebrate a lot holidays each year. They all have inspiring and beautiful stories behind them, and Columbus day seems to be among them.

Read More

Why Is Columbus Day Be Celebrated

686 Words | 3 Pages

Now many people say that is should be celebrated, but most of those people are uneducated in the subject. When Columbus came in his first voyage he had disease from animals that the natives have the natives immune system have never felt which means they were more likely to get the disease and it was harder for the natives to get rid of the disease therefore many of them died. Columbus might not have been morally responsible for the deaths for disease, but he did go their and spread their germs to the natives.

Read More

Women In Powhatan Society

522 Words | 3 Pages

Thesis: The English were a prideful group, entangled in ethnocentrism, that caused a condescending and harsh treatment of the Native Americans, while the Native Americans were actually a dynamic and superior society, which led to the resentment and strife between the groups. P1: English view of Native Americans in VA Even though the English were subordinates of the Powhatan, they disrespected him and his chiefdom due to their preconceived beliefs that they were inferior. “Although the Country people are very barbarous, yet have they amongst them such government...that would be counted very civil… [by having] a Monarchical government” (Smith 22). John Smith acknowledges the “very civil” government of the Natives but still disrespected them by calling them “very barbarous,” which

Read More

Argumentative Essay: Should We Celebrate Columbus Day?

604 Words | 3 Pages

Putting aside all the horrible things Columbus did, he did help colonize North America. He opened up a new world where people could go to freely express themselves, it was the land of the free. People could freely practice their religion and many could start a new life. Another reason why people don't want Columbus day to change is because of his Italian background. Many italian americans are proud of Christopher Columbus because of his italian background.

Read More

Why Do We Celebrate Columbus Day Essay

823 Words | 4 Pages

Finally, we should celebrate Columbus Day because he brought value to America. When I say "value" I mean he made America worth something. Not money-wise but more livable through goods and services for citizens here in America. Basically the "west Indies" people lived off natural resources and made shelter from their surroundings. When Christopher Columbus arrived he made businesses for people who wanted to work, and he made trade markets for people who wanted to buy goods from the old world such as jewelry, jewels, spices, perfume, etc; only the wealthy bought such items.

Read More

We Should Abolish Columbus Day

630 Words | 3 Pages

Columbus Day is an American and patriotic holiday celebrated in all 50 states of the U.S since 1971, when congress passed the law. America should not continue to celebrate Columbus Day because he brought cruelty, heś been given false credit, and the legacy of the day is not as wonderful to Native Americans and African Africans. With ¨discovering” America, he also brought cruelty to the the indigenous people because he tortured, killed, and encourage his men to rape the native women. There are things that he didn't even do and he was still given credit such as discovering America. The legacy of the Columbus Day is not as remarkable to the Native Americans and African Americans because it just reminds them the cruelty that happened.

Read More

More about Columbus Day Myth

Related Topics

Open Document