ipl-logo

Compare Aristotle Voluntary And Involuntary Action

764 Words4 Pages

To asses this situation as Aristotle would, we must look at his writings on voluntary and involuntary actions. In Aristotle’s writings he states that voluntary and involuntary action can be distinguished by several different factors. The first of these factors is the virtue of the agent, which is defined as the alignment of ones passions and their actions (pg. 307). Virtue is also concerned with praise and blame that is bestowed on the agent after the repercussions of their actions (pg. 307). Aristotle sates that virtue cannot be fundamentally decided. It carries from situation to situation. In the situation stated above, Aristotle would asses all the factors that drove Taneah to make this decision, though in the end he would say that her passion drove her beyond was is fundamentally virtuous. This does not mean that Taneah herself was not virtuous, …show more content…

He describes choice as to be voluntary but not the same thing as the voluntary (pg. 310). Choice is beyond the irrational. Taneah’s decision was driven by passion not by rational thought. Aristotle would say that her action was beyond choice but was her demanded by her humanity (pg. 311). In addition to value and choice Aristotle considers deliberation as a factor that affects involuntary and voluntary action. He states that no one has the ability to deliberate about their external material universe (pg. 312). We can only deliberate about what is in our own power
Deliberation is used when things are uncertain or obscure. We ask for help in deliberation when we find our self not being equal to the decision. We deliberate about possible things, things that we are able to bring by our own efforts (pg. 312). In Taneah’s situation, she did not deliberate at all. She did not give the time or the energy to validate her actions with deliberation. Aristotle states this happens with the moving principle is moved back to the core desires of the person deliberating (pg.

Show More
Related

Aristotle's Nicomachean Argument Analysis

313 Words | 2 Pages

In Nicomachean Ethics, Aristotle argues that the human good is the soul’s activity that expresses virtue. Aristotle concludes this from an invalid argument. On the one hand I do agree that the activity expressing virtue is a requirement for the human good. But on the other hand, I insist that the human good is a state and not an action. By modifying this argument, I believe we can reach a new conclusion that will help us better understand what Aristotle meant by these concepts.

Read More

Romeo And Juliet Wrong Quotes

242 Words | 1 Pages

Individuals allow themselves to be placed in horrific situations. They can be influenced by the society of other individuals but, it ends up being their own decision whether to go through with it or not. The decision comes down to their own moral compass to guide them to make the right decision. However, losing a good moral compass could lead an individual down the wrong path. William Shakespeare explores the idea of poor decisions leading to a downfall in his tragedy, Romeo and Juliet, as Juliet risks the safety and love of her family by putting herself in difficult situations.

Read More

Comparing Bless Me, Ultima And House On Mango Street

1255 Words | 6 Pages

Another example of the characters making illogical decisions because of their ambition is in the beginning of the play when Egeus takes Hermia, Lysander, and Demetrius to Theseus and asks him to force his daughter to marry Demetrius lest she becomes a nun or faces death. While Egeus uses the possible death sentence as simply a threat and does not mean to actually execute his daughter, his ambition does blind him from seeing his daughter’s feelings and

Read More

Analyzing Socrates Argument In Plato's Meno

1060 Words | 5 Pages

The world we live in is filled with crime, evil, and injustice, but do people have the desire to do bad things knowing that they are bad, or do they do them thinking that they are good? In this essay, I examine Socrates argument, found in Plato’s Meno, that no one knowingly desires bad things. If Socrates were right, it would mean that it is impossible for someone to perform a bad action based on their desire for that bad thing. Instead, all bad desires result from the ignorance of the person performing the action in falsely believing that the action is good. Though Socrates presents a compelling argument, I argue that it is possible for someone to act badly, all the while knowing that what they desire is bad.

Read More

Objectivism In Ayn Rand's Anthem

1284 Words | 6 Pages

Objectivism in Ayn Rand’s Anthem Ayn Rand established her philosophy of objectivism in order to eliminate the traditions she experienced while she was growing up under collective governments, and to emphasize the importance of the individual over the collective group. It can be defined as a philosophy for living stating that man himself is the greatest power, and man must decide what is best for himself based on reason. The four basic tenets of objectivism are reality exists as an objective absolute, reason is man’s only method of interpreting his surroundings, man must exist as an individual in order to pursue his own interests, with the ultimate goal being happiness, and the economy of an objectivist society should be laissez-faire capitalism,

Read More

Evaluating Aristotle's Nicomachean Ethics

1495 Words | 6 Pages

  This argument, though most people would intuitively disagree with it, is in reality quite compelling.   Just as those who are colorblind can not paint, and the crippled can not run, those with a naturally flawed or warped view of what is good can not be virtuous.  Similarly, the virtuous can not take credit for their virtue because they are simply gifted with a clearer view of what is good, which is completely out of their control.

Read More

Analysis Of Aristotle's Nicomachean Ethics

1025 Words | 5 Pages

This principle lies at the heart of the great-souled man, the first of Aristotle’s peaks of humanly excellence. The great-souled man is chiefly concerned with—and strikes the mean with—external goods. The greatest of these goods is “the one that we assign to the gods, and at which people of high standing aim most of all, and which is the prize given for the most beautiful deeds; and of this kind is honor” (67:1123b19-21). A man who has achieved greatness of soul is deserving of great honors, but more importantly, he understands his own desert and acts appropriately.

Read More

Character Determination In Antigone

813 Words | 4 Pages

Determination In the play, Antigone, different characters demonstrated the difference between being determined and being stubborn. For example have you ever been determined to do something for the cause of good or even been stubborn. In this story characters there are some characters that were the same way, The first person that I have to bring up is Antigone.

Read More

Skepticism In Hume's View Of Stoicism

771 Words | 4 Pages

Visualize someone hitting your hand with a hammer until it breaks. Instead of stopping them you simply say “you’re going to break my hand if you don’t stop.” After more hitting, they break your hand and your response is “see I warned you, you would break it.” That’s how I think of Epictetus’ stoicism, an unrealistic view of human’s internal situations. In contrast, Hume’s view of scepticism applies more to the reality and truthfulness of human internal and external insights and beliefs.

Read More

Morality In Socrates 'The Ring Of Gyges'

661 Words | 3 Pages

If the opportunity arose, where no consequences were given for someone’s actions, do you think that individual will still commit an unfavorable action such as killing for his own personal need? In “The Ring of Gyges” the disposition of justice is called into question. As humans continue to live we must contemplate the true driving force for our morality. A discussion between Socrates and Glaucon is one main focal point into explaining the differences in how humans truly established their morality. Glaucon believes humans are restrained by consequences and human’s happiness comes from being an unjust person rather than Socrates’ belief of being just truly leads to happiness.

Read More

What Makes Right Acts Right Analysis

728 Words | 3 Pages

Jieni Peng CA1 “What Makes Right Acts Right” by W.D Ross In the article “What Makes Right Acts Right” by W.D Ross, he debates the about idea of duties and how humans in general understand if their actions are correct. Ross mentions that humans do not deliberately execute their duties because of the consequences resulting from those duties. Rather, they perform those duties because of an innate form of common sense that humans possess inside of themselves. One example of this is the act of fulfilling a promise that an individual made to themselves or others not because of the end results but because of their sense of “duty.”

Read More

The Dualist Relationship Between The Mind And Body

785 Words | 4 Pages

In the realm of Philosophy, different views about the definition of the mind and its interactions exist. Among the many, Dualism stands as one of the most debatable, thanks to its position about the relationship of the mind and body, and its repercussions. This assignment discusses the dualist relationship between the mind and the body, as well as its impact on the individual free will. It asserts Interventionism as an extension of Dualism, as well as an alternative to Determinism. The objective of this endeavor is to present the Dualist approach to Mind and Body as an alternative or possible solution to the dilemma of Determinism.

Read More

Essay On Divine Command Theory

1218 Words | 5 Pages

The last theory is Aristotle’s virtue ethics which states that we should move from the concern towards good action and to focus on the concern with good character. This paper argues that Aristotle’s virtue ethics is better than the other ethical theories. The divine command theory says that what is morally right and what is morally wrong is determined by God and God alone. People who follow the divine command theory believe that God is the creator of all things, therefore, he must also be the creator of morally right and wrong acts.

Read More

Aristotle's Hierarchy Of Voluntary

232 Words | 1 Pages

Aristotle says earlier in his writing that the highest good is happiness, and that this is achieved through the formation of a state. Living in a state allows for certain people (free men) to have time to follow their passions in search of happiness. This luxury is only available to them however, because they have their wives taking care of the home, and slaves doing all the physical labor they would otherwise be required to do. Without slaves, Aristotle argues, this hierarchy in society would break down as men would have to spend their time doing their own work, and thus be less likely to achieve the ultimate goal of happiness.   The question then becomes, are some people destined to be slaves, and others leaders?

Read More

Aristotle Excess And Deficiency Analysis

1098 Words | 5 Pages

Though, a virtuous person will be in the mean which lies between extremes of excess and deficiency. That person will neither be a coward or reckless. This ability doesn’t come inherently, and the person will need persistent teachings and logical control over their feelings. After these accomplishments are met, then

Read More

More about Compare Aristotle Voluntary And Involuntary Action

Related Topics

Open Document