ipl-logo

Comparing Aristotle, Kant, And Mill

1327 Words6 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Immanuel kant views on morality

Philosophy is a unique and deeper thinking in which a philosopher provides well-structured thoughts which are abstract and in respect to the social needs or demands. In philosophy, the cardinal maxim is based on the fact that the thinking must be as a result of deeper understanding and quest of knowledge, characterized by independency in judgement while giving an opinion. It therefore follows automatically that philosophy is not a theory but rather an urge for wisdom. As a result, philosophy is never perceived as a way of life, because each philosopher does not have his or her own way of life, but all philosophers in general think independently, leading to a wider range of reasoning over the same topics and issues in society. For the purpose of this analysis, the concentration will be on three philosophers: Aristotle, Kant, and Mill. This will involve the analysis of their different perceptions based on their moral thinking.
Human good is normal reasoning and is referred to as the total wellness of a person. Good will on …show more content…

His argument is based on ethical theories in which he established what is right and wrong in the society. According to Mill, justice involves being law abiding and one should consider his or herself as a morally responsible person. In addition, a person should be able to face a penalty for committing acts which are not justified. Many people therefore will agree to be punished for committing wrong. However, in some circumstances a person may end up doing wrong due to lack of another alternative. Kant on the other hand argues that good deeds should be influenced by an individual instead of the society (Neill 41). Therefore, everyone should be responsible of their own actions. The three philosophers therefore agree that it is the responsibility of individuals to act in a responsible way and be law

Show More
Related

Enlightenment Dbq Essay

943 Words | 4 Pages

Introduction: After the prolonged and disparaging Thirty Years War, philosophers took up a new notion of life and how, what and why things are the way they are in the world. Many also took into effect believing in scientific reasoning’s over biblical outlooks, looking for logical answers to all the many mysteries of the world and the afterlife. Enlightenment philosophers also constructed ways in which they thought people should act. For example, philosopher Voltaire explained his reasons for how “people should be citizens of the world” (Voltaire, “Patrie, in the philosophers dictionary”, 1752). THESIS:

Read More

Angela Davis Abolition Democracy Analysis

596 Words | 3 Pages

Kant’s notion of freedom connects to morality, which displays contrast between duty and inclination, explaining how only the motive of duty, doing the right thing for the right reason, confers moral worth of an action. Kant believes that everything in nature, including humans, “works in accordance with laws,” that all actions must be appointed by law, The formula of universal law that basically states how you should treat humanity as an end rather than as a means. He says we should only act upon the maxim, a principle that gives a reason for action, without contradiction. Davis claims that law is not always reliable when insuring justice; moreover, Kant can support

Read More

The Prince Versus Kant's Analysis

1353 Words | 6 Pages

For centuries, philosophers have provided us with a greater understanding of the world around us, providing suggestions as to how we might reflect upon, criticise, or improve the societies in which we live. This has allowed us to speculate on many topics, such as politics, ethics, and morality. Among many others, two of the most influential thinkers to this day are Nicolo Machiavelli and Immanuel Kant. Their writings, The Prince and An Answer to the Question “What is Enlightenment?” provide insight as to how societies should be ruled and set up in order for all people within them to be content.

Read More

Comparing Socrates Apology And The Allegory Of The Cave

310 Words | 2 Pages

In this unit, we get to learn the origin of philosophy and the basics of this subject. To clarify these topics, we need to go back to the early time of philosophy, i.e. the ages Socrates and Plato. In this essay we are going to compare the Socrates' attitude about philosophy with that of Voltaire. The attitude of Socrates about philosophy can be best deducted from two works, the Apology and the Allegory of the Cave.

Read More

Comparing Mill And Kant's Theories

714 Words | 3 Pages

Mill and Kant have opposite idea and they support different moral philosophies. Mill exactly suppose the idea of social thinking, namely he claims that everyone attach an importance to other human beings. However, Kant considers that selfishness reflect people’s characteristics, in other words, each person should pay attention to themselves not others, because the most important thing for them is themselves. Kant also highlight that people can only behave in a good manner, if they have good will. In other words, Kant attach an importance to people’s instinct or characteristics, Mill gives weight to promoting happiness and dissolution of the pain.

Read More

Elizabeth Beardsley's What Is Philosophy?

630 Words | 3 Pages

A husband and wife duo, Monroe Beardsley and Elizabeth Beardsley, wrote an article called “What is Philosophy?”. In the article, they talk about their ideology in philosophy. The Beardsley’s philosophical ideology is a combination of three key concepts: a base for a large range of beliefs and philosophical

Read More

Classical Greece's Influence On Western Society

502 Words | 3 Pages

The works of famous philosophers such as Socrates, Plato, and Aristotle continue to influence modern thought. The emphasis on critical thinking, logical reasoning, and the search of knowledge in Greek philosophy laid the framework for fields such as ethics, metaphysics, and epistemology (Khan Academy, n.d.). As an example, we can mention Aristotle's systematic approach to observation, hypothesis, and logical analysis lies at the basis of the scientific method, which is central to current scientific investigation. Greek philosophy's ongoing effect can also be observed in ethics, where the concepts of virtue and moral reasoning are still significant (Khan Academy, n.d.).

Read More

Comparing Kant's Categorical Imperative And John Stuart Mill

507 Words | 3 Pages

Immanuel Kant’s categorical imperative and John Stuart Mill’s view of utilitarianism are two very different approaches to ethics and morals. In fact, they are the opposite of one another. Kant’s view of ethics is an ethics of pure reason- a deontological theory of ethics. He stresses that feelings and emotions should have no part in ethics because they are unreliable, changeable, and uncertain. He states that ethical principles must be universal and that ethics are distinctively human.

Read More

John Stuart Mill's Arguments Against The Death Penalty

900 Words | 4 Pages

In the speech that Mill’s presented in front of the government he speaks in favor of the death penalty being used as a punishment, but says it should only be used of a murder crime. Mill’s defends his position on the death penalty by stating that it would lower murder crime rates. Many argued with Mill’s opinion and commented on how sometimes people are wrongfully convicted, but Mill’s responded by saying that the government would have to have full evidence to make sure that person truly committed the crime and is eligible for the death penalty (Journal of the History of Economic Thought, A Note on John Stuart Mill’s View’s on Capital

Read More

Thomas Aquinas Argument Essay

203 Words | 1 Pages

The search for the unknown has been constant in philosophical and scientific revolutions in the west. From Aristotle’s theory of nature and the 4 different cause’s material, formal, efficient and final cause provided some reasoning’s. Then began the search for what it is to be happy? It later evolved into what is it to be an ethical person? A prominent religious and philosophical leader Augustine who had a wide spectrum of influences, struggled in answering questions that where larger than himself whether they were personal or intellectual.

Read More

Philosophy Teach It To Kids By Andy West Analysis

280 Words | 2 Pages

Philosophy is one of the oldest field of science. It forms a system of knowledge about reality, evaluates the interaction of a consciousness, a man and the world. Moreover, philosophy is considered as a part of humanities studies. Andy West, the author of the article "Philosophy saved me from poverty and drugs: that’s why I teach it to kids" that was published in the Guardian, shows the importance of philosophy on his own example. In recent years, philosophy is considered as an archaic science, almost not applicable on the practical level.

Read More

Similarities Between Nietzsche And John Stuart Mill

1242 Words | 5 Pages

Mill’s political protection of the right to freedom of thought could combine with Nietzsche’s perpetual self-overcoming: one’s evolving struggle to gain more personal clarity and power in one’s individual essence and beliefs. So, Mill could be viewed as a departure or starting point, from which Nietzsche can strive toward self-actualizing. In order for Nietzsche to have his say, there would need to be a political structure that allows for it. While Nietzsche might argue that value systems in political structures are part of the problem, no one would be reading his arguments if they were banned. “Genius can only breathe free in an 'atmosphere' of freedom,” according to Mill.

Read More

Kant And Mill Similarities

1385 Words | 6 Pages

Evaluating the morality within ourselves they evaluate morality on the principle of what is wrong or right. As equally

Read More

Discussion Of Philosophy Chapter 1 Analysis

1581 Words | 7 Pages

While philosophy may be considered by somebody as a one-piece field of knowledge, in reality, it consists of separate doctrines, sometimes quite different, which make one big whole. One of its groups may be formed of logic, epistemology, and metaphysics; the other one of ethics, philosophy of mind, language and science; the last one consists of separate groups which discuss the metaphysic science from ancient to modern times or philosophy of religion or politics and so on (Shand, 2003, pp. 3-4). The last group examines particular notions which relate to the first two groups, while the first two of them are interconnected and discuss the fundamental things (Shand, 2003, p. 4). Metaphysics touches the essences existing in the world; aesthetics studies the art and its existence; political philosophy is worried about the social organization (Shand, 2003, pp. 4-5).

Read More

Socialism Vs Communism Essay

913 Words | 4 Pages

Many philosophers have spent a lot of time in their life to determine the best way for society. However, there is no guaranteed solution to solve the problems, in the end, it depends on that country or society to search out their own

Read More

More about Comparing Aristotle, Kant, And Mill

Related Topics

Open Document