ipl-logo

Comparing Day To Remember And Martyn Hereward's The Clearing

1162 Words5 Pages

James Clavell’s Day to Remember and Martyn Hereward’s The Clearing are both overwhelming short stories that demonstrate how different people experience shocking situations. The two texts are a part of The New Paper Windows, ‘Anthology of Short Stories’ book, produced by Richard Baines. Day to Remember is concentrated around a lonely woman, Maudie. The Clearing shows many points of view, featuring the perspectives of Captain Maitland, Private O’Brien, Sergeant Fallon, and Private Bushell. The two texts both accommodate a main theme of War and History, due to the fact that they are both based on events occurring in the war time period. Both of the protagonists that are killed die in peace, however, each text is composed in different ways that show different perspectives about how the characters deal with what they are going through. The overall message displayed by the texts is that such innocent …show more content…

There are many similarities and differences between the two texts. The first similarity is both short stories are set in the time period of World War II. Maudie in Day to Remember explains that her home in London has been hit by a V-2 bomb. It is also explained that she is “…lying in the rubble...”. Captain Maitland in The Clearing tells the story about how he has been shot by the Japanese in the war. In addition, the texts portray how both characters die in peace. Maudie states in her story how “There's a god in heaven and, all in all, you've been as good as a person can be. So there is nothing to fear.” Which shows to the reader that she is accepting the thought of dying and finding a positive side to it. Captain Maitland

Show More
Related

Compare And Contrast Machaut And John Dowland

257 Words | 2 Pages

Guillame de Machaut, unlike John Dowland, has a well-known composition called Agnus Dei, and it is a prayer for mercy and peace. Machaut created music for the church and was the first to do in a polyphonic approach. Agnus Dei became a staple in the mass ordinary, as it referred to “speaking of christ”. This song was meant to appeal to the mind and not so much the ears, it was a revamp on the Middle Age Gregorian chant. John Dowland was from 1563-1626, so he is from the late Renaissance period in which he primarily wrote melancholy songs based off of popular consort songs and dance music from that time period.

Read More

Comparing Night And Prisoner B-3087

679 Words | 3 Pages

Both books tell a story about a young teenage boy’s experience living a normal life but then going through the worst experience he could imagine. ” In the two books, the young boys and their families are overtaken by Germans.” From this moment on, you are under the authority of the German Army.” The Germans take all of their valuables. The Germans set specific rules for the Jewish people like not allowing them out past a certain time, limiting any food supply to them, restricting them from prayer and

Read More

Comparing The Sniper And Just Lather That's All

754 Words | 4 Pages

Segregations of family members is shown in both stories, this is a dilemma that the characters and family members need to cope with. Another example these two short stories need to cope with is the disappointing result of many people dying in war. Many of the people that fight in battle hardly make it out alive, the death results are higher than the amount of survivors. The story, The Sniper, deals with innocent deaths, "A man's head and shoulders appeared, looking toward the sniper.

Read More

Comparing This Boy's Life And The Other Wes Moore

770 Words | 4 Pages

From my perspective, I believe that both stories show us that no matter what bad situation you are in there is always a solution to be happy. I can see love, respect and strong woman the authors is talking about, that they choose to give a better life to their kids. The similarities that I have found in these two stories are basically the love of a mother towards their children and teach them that even if you love someone and that person is hurting you, you need to move on to provide a better life.

Read More

Long Walk To Water By Linda Sue Park

481 Words | 2 Pages

Another similarity between the two is the courage and hard work that got the boys through the terrible conditions they had to walk through. According to the poem “Yet the courage these boys have inside them never seems to fail.” (lines 15 and 16) This shows that the boy's courage helped them overcome the obstacles to get away from the war. While there are similarities between the texts, there are also differences.

Read More

Comparing To Kill A Mockingbird And Elie Wiesel's Night

494 Words | 2 Pages

The two texts grant readers a deeper understanding

Read More

Similarities Between A Raisin In The Sun And Frederick Douglass

943 Words | 4 Pages

" Mama, that ain't no kind of job … that ain't nothing at all." and "I was now about twelve-years-old, and the thought of being a slave for life began to bear heavily upon my heart. " These situations that the characters are in, along with delicate word choice, elicit the audience to feel for them. These powerful stories are the main similarity between the two texts.

Read More

Comparing Wiesel And Kamens

805 Words | 4 Pages

The tones of both stories are both compatible because both have serious/ allusive tone. The tones can clearly be seen from lines one and two in, “Never Shall I forget.” These two tones create an atmosphere for the reader of the poem to infer or notice the theme both poems show. The emotional feelings presented by these two tones provide us with the major message of the literature that we are

Read More

Essay Comparing The Odyssey And Sundiata

447 Words | 2 Pages

Another item that is extremely important in both stories is the use and importance of fate. Both characters rely on their fates for assistance and for achieving

Read More

What Are The Similarities Between The Lottery And The Hunger Games

518 Words | 3 Pages

There are common themes for both of the stories, like life lessons in nature. It is showing how life in a dystopian society is different from reality. In a dystopian society, people are picked and fight to death, while in reality it is the norm to not fight for your

Read More

Comparing The Odyssey By Homer And The Odyssey By Louise Erdich

1753 Words | 8 Pages

They are both courageous people who act instantaneously in the face of danger to save themselves and others. The authors of both stories use literary devices to describe their stories in depth, making the reader get a better understanding of the theme. Although these narratives differ from each other in the way they are portrayed, they share

Read More

Compare And Contrast Learning To Read And Write And Professions For Women

1632 Words | 7 Pages

This provides the audience with his personal perspective and thoughts during this time. Although, there are some minuscule differences when it comes to the audience. The differences come down to whom the writing is directed at. Individuals will gravitate to the texts that they share similar problems and experiences too. In both narratives, the gender and race of the individuals are important and influence the audience.

Read More

Civil War Book Comparison

458 Words | 2 Pages

The books that are being compared and contrasted are both about The Civil War and what these soldiers went through. Each book has a few differences that separate them. The books are based on the same time period so they are going to have a lot in common. The books describe what both characters had to go through during the war. The differences in the book will show you how each soldier went through the war differently and the similarity’s will show you how it was for most of the soldiers in the Civil War.

Read More

Symbolism In Where Are You Going, Where Have You Been?

966 Words | 4 Pages

I think both of the authors use symbolism in way that readers can view and understand the story in different ways. Both of the stories use people or objects to help them get there point across u can see how this

Read More

Comparing Punishment And Shirley Jackson's The Lottery

1230 Words | 5 Pages

One should read both stories more than once to see these similarities. The reader can quickly notice an obvious similarity that is death. Both stories end with the death if a character. Three elements were compared between these stories: theme, setting, and foreshadowing. Each element was analysed and compared between the stories.

Read More

More about Comparing Day To Remember And Martyn Hereward's The Clearing

Related Topics

Open Document