ipl-logo

Comparing Love In The Scarlet Ibis And My Brother's Keeper

441 Words2 Pages

Loving is hard, this is explored in two short stories, “The Scarlet Ibis” by James Hurst and “My Brother’s Keeper” by Jay Bennett, and in my personal life. In our first story, Brother, our narrator, loves his brother Doodle but is blinded by his pride. In the second story Jamie, our narrator, was pushed to the brink, making him put limits on his love towards his brother. So whether it is love towards a partner or to a brother, love can always be there but comes with its faults. Starting with “The Scarlet Ibis”, Brother failed to put forth his best intentions, causing the untimely death of Doodle. Towards the end of the story Brother recalls, “I cried, shaking him.it seemed forever, I lay there crying, sheltering my fallen scarlet ibis” (Hurst …show more content…

Following up with “My Brother’s Keeper”, Jamie was always there for his brother, Ted, but had reached his tipping point. Shown when Jamie recounts, “I can’t do it, Ted.and Jamie knew that he would never again be his brother’s keeper” (Bennett 29-30). This quote shows that even if you are there for someone, you can end up hurting yourself if you do not put yourself first. Stepping into my complex human life, I recall the idea of knowing I love my dog, however knowing I could have done more for him. Throughout his life he had everything any dog could have, a bed to sleep on, food to eat, water to drink, and people who would be there for him. Although he had all these things, I am not sure it was enough to satisfy the moments he was there for me at my lowest. Even if he lived a good life now, I know what it means to give anything to spend more time with him. Throughout the stories and my own experience, we can see love comes in many shapes and sizes, including its imperfections resulting in at least one of the people being hurt. In “The Scarlet Ibis” we explored the idea of not knowing what you have until it's

Show More
Related
514 Words | 3 Pages

Love is unconditionally caring about someone else that you care more about yourself. Love may give us joy, and happiness, but it also brings the worse out in us. In Celeste Rita Baker’s short story Jumbie from Bordeaux, the author presents love and the price paid for love through the indirect characterization of Jumbie, his aunt, and parents. In the story the author uses courage to show the love that Jumbie had for his parents. For example, when Jumbie witnesses the harsh beating of his parents, he immediately jumps in to interfere, by attacking the master.

Read More
121 Words | 1 Pages

Published during the twentieth century, the love between siblings in "No Missing Parts" shows us that the love of a family is unconditional and is in perpetual growth that is why the links between members of the latter are very strong and

Read More
355 Words | 2 Pages

He taught him to walk and surprised their parents one morning by showing them, it was all for Brothers image though, so he would no longer have to face the shame of having to drag his little 6-year-old brother every where he went. They heard a bird on that day, a Scarlet Ibis, and it had fallen

Read More
288 Words | 2 Pages

James Hurst uses suspense, characterization, and imagery in the “Scarlet Ibis” to convey that pride is a wonderful/terrible thing, a seed that bears two vines life and death. The author uses suspense to convey the message that the reader is thinking about what will happen to doodle. This is seen when doodle said “brother brother don’t leave me” (441). This example states that doodle does not like being alone.

Read More
234 Words | 1 Pages

“The Scarlet Ibis,” by James Hurst describes that if kin passes away, guilt, sadness, and confession may go through one's mind . The“Brother,”or narrator is filled with guilt over his actions leading to the death of his little brother Doodle. In the beginning of the story, the narrator speaks in a very sad and depressed way by mentioning things like “the summer was dead...ibis lit in the bleeding tree..the oriole nest in the elm was intended and rocked back and forth like and empty cradle”(Hurst 1). The narrator sets a very sad and dreary mood that gives clues that maybe the narrator is guilty or confessing something. Right after, the narrator has a flashback “...as I sit in the cool, green draped parlor,...

Read More
977 Words | 4 Pages

To recapitulate, the parting of the scarlet ibis is used to portray an adversity that later reveals itself to be the death of the narrator’s

Read More
1494 Words | 6 Pages

We live in a society that has increasingly demoralizes love, depicting it as cruel, superficial and full of complications. Nowadays it is easy for people to claim that they are in love, even when their actions say otherwise, and it is just as easy to claim that they are not when they indeed are. Real love is difficult to find and keeping it alive is even harder, especially when one must overcome their own anxieties and uncertainties to embrace its presence. This is the main theme depicted in Russell Banks’ short story “Sarah Cole: A Type of Love Story,” as well as in Richard Bausch’s “The Fireman’s Wife.” These narratives, although similar in some ways, are completely different types of love stories.

Read More
1054 Words | 5 Pages

Humans are inherently social beings that crave love, the sense of belonging and intimacy from others. The desire to feel love would help us create an understanding of who we are as we seek comfort through our personal experiences. Although we might fall short of these expectations they could also be the source of pain and angst. In a compilation of short stories ‘Like a house on fire’, Cate Kennedy explores different relationship dynamics through how they cope with life-changing events. Most relationships in Kennedy’s short story are portrayed as complex characters, and tend to be distant from other family members.

Read More
446 Words | 2 Pages

"Doodle!" I screamed above the pounding storm and threw my body to the earth above his. For a long time, it seemed forever, I lay there crying, sheltering my fallen scarlet ibis from the heresy of rain”(Hurst 6).This section shows from the end of Doodle’s life onward Brother has felt guilty. The whole story is Brothers story of the dangers of pride and his personal experience.

Read More
890 Words | 4 Pages

There are many things that factor into reasons for loving someone. Often times when people think of reasons for loving someone, they only think about the immediate motives. People do not consider reasons outside the obvious. However, there are many hidden motives that cause people t love one another. Flannery O’Connor’s “Good Country People” and William Shakespeare’s “My Mistress’ Eyes Are Nothing Like the Sun”, show that love can be influenced by an ulterior motive, through the use of specific word choice and storyline twists.

Read More
279 Words | 2 Pages

Brotherly love is strong and unconditional, even if you are oblivious of it, as Ponyboy Curtis learns in The Outsiders by S.E. Hinton. Ponyboy and his brother Darry have an interesting relationship because of the situation they are in with Darry having to play the role of the parent, and three ways that Ponyboy describes his relationship with his brother in The Outsiders is kill, firm, and care. Ponyboy feels that Darry puts a lot of pressure on him to not get into trouble in school or on the streets. In this novel, Ponyboy mentions, “Darry would kill me if I got into trouble with the police.” (1).

Read More
843 Words | 4 Pages

In the novella Of Mice and Men, readers may have been moved by the struggle of a character’s love for another when faced with difficult obstacles. For example, although not ready to, Candy was forced to give up his dog and allow Carlson to shoot and bury him under the pretense that they should put him out of his misery. “For a moment [Candy] continued to stare at the ceiling. Then he rolled slowly over and faced the wall and lay silent,” (Steinbeck 49). Because of Candy’s heartbreak, readers are forced to understand how Candy’s dog was his family.

Read More
1338 Words | 6 Pages

“Brod's life was a slow realization that the world was not for her, and that for whatever reason, she would never be happy and honest at the same time. She felt as if she were brimming, always producing and hoarding more love inside her. But there was no release...” (79). Brod’s inability to find love contains touchy matter because of its ability to be easily relatable for many readers.

Read More
1483 Words | 6 Pages

Love anticipation is a leading aspect for just about everyone in life. Nobody wants to feel rejected by someone that they really care for and want to be a part of their lives. This eagerness can either bring about happiness or pure hopelessness for the individual. In James Joyce’s short story, “Araby”, and T.S. Eliot’s dramatic monologue, “The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock”, the expectation of love is of high regard. Both of the main characters of these short stories are constantly fighting with themselves over whether or not love in is their favor.

Read More
804 Words | 4 Pages

Our love for our siblings is a very tricky love because we could love them or hate them. We could fight and argue all the times but that our way of showing we love each other. Mr. Geoffrey Philp, the author of the short story called “My Brother 's Keeper.” Show an excellent example of siblings love. The short story illustrates how one misses his father and soon after, he gains a brother.

Read More

More about Comparing Love In The Scarlet Ibis And My Brother's Keeper

Open Document