ipl-logo

Comparing Medieval Films 300, El Cid And Naser Salah Ad-Din

826 Words4 Pages

The Medieval film industry unexpectedly emerged as a relatable, highly entertaining industry in the 20th Century and many weren’t sure why. Medieval films have two layers to them: the first being of historical precedent and the second being of creational bias. The following paper will address how the three movies 300, El Cid and El Naser Salah Ad-Din provide insight to the denial that members of the three Abrahamic religions portray against each other, as well as how the creators of each film frame the plot in order to validate events happening at the time of the movie’s creation. In order to best get a grasp on how denial transcends time, it is imperative to not focus on what is wrong in a movie, but why it is wrong. El Naser Salah Ad-Din …show more content…

300 provides a unique interpretation of Sparta’s relationship with the Persians. There is widespread controversy over the accuracy of the Persian’s portrayal, but it is far more productive to look at why this discrepancy was present, not what the discrepancies were. Screenwriter, Frank Miller, from the US was quoted in an interview with NPR about President Bush’s State of the Union Address in 2007 saying, “It seems to me quite obvious that our country and the entire Western World is up against an existential foe that knows exactly what it wants … and we’re behaving like a collapsing empire.” Miller is clearly demonstrating denial towards the ability for Islam to be compatible with Westernization and this comes through very evidently in 300. Throughout the film, the Persians are represented as deformed, piercing filled mutants who are looking to take the Spartan’s freedom away, while the Spartan army of 300 are perfectly sculpted white men. The shear number of parallels in appearance to the American battle against Iraqi insurgents in 2007 becomes monotonous. In the case of 300, the borderline racist representation of the Persian/Spartan encounter is framed purposefully by screenwriter Frank Miller in an attempt to prove with historical precedent that Islamic ideals do not and can not be merged with Western

Show More
Related

Baghdad Burning Comparison

749 Words | 3 Pages

The book Baghdad Burning and the film Turtles Can Fly can both be very influential to a reader or viewer. These two works give an insightful look into Iraq during the time of the war on Iraq in 2003. Either of these works can provide a reader or viewer with many important lessons about Iraq, the Iraqis, and their culture. But, even though Riverbend’s book Baghdad Burning and Bahman Ghobadi’s movie Turtles Can Fly are both important works, Baghdad Burning by Riverbend is more important to help people think critically and understand important aspects of the world around them.

Read More

Zero Dark Thirty Analysis

818 Words | 4 Pages

Hence, the demonization of the Orient as "degenerate, uncivilized and retarded" parallels Oriental discourse and perpetuates Islamophobic sentiments. In summation, Zero Dark Thirty may be interpreted as a very problematic film due to its parallels with Orientalist discourse. The film’s inaccuracies and stereotypical representations of Muslim peoples culminate to demonize Islam, and “turn Islam into the very epitome of an outsider against” European civilization. Ordinary viewers may have a dominant reading of this film, however, from a religious studies student’s perspective, it is much more indicative of American ignorance than it is of genuine Islamic

Read More

Cinematic Techniques In Anthony Burgess A Clockwork Orange

1712 Words | 7 Pages

This sense of hostility springs forth from the misconstrued view of literature being the superior art form among the two, extending to the apparent artistic inferiority of cinematic adaptations, which seemingly “betrays” its source material. But the idea of cinema as a potent and dynamic art

Read More

An Imam In America Summary

784 Words | 4 Pages

His new role as a new Imam was tied with other responsibilities such as being the police, marriage counselor, matchmaker, and the judge of the local Muslim community. Shata’s story takes a turn to reflect the various concerns he had to face in his role as the Imam of the new modern culture. The concerns were more intense compared to the ones he faced in Egypt due to the tempting environment Muslims had to live in. The author then presents the conflict in the story, which revolved around the Imam’s role in “reconciling of two worlds.” The “two worlds” referred are the conventional and conservative laws and culture of Shata’s home, and the unparalleled and conspicuously controversial issues, which faced the Muslim community in the new

Read More

Aesthetic Of Astonishment Analysis

1441 Words | 6 Pages

In “Aesthetic of Astonishment” essay, Gunning argues how people first saw cinema, and how they are amazed with the moving picture for the first time, and were not only amazed by the technological aspect, but also the experience of how the introduction of movies have changed the way people perceive the reality in a completely different way. Gunning states that “The astonishment derives from a magical metamorphosis rather than a seamless reproduction of reality”(118). He uses the myth of how the sacred audience run out the theater in terror when they first saw the Lumiere Brother Arrival of the train. However, Gunning does not really care how hysterical their reaction is, even saying that he have doubts on what actually happened that day, as for him it the significance lied on the incidence--that is, the triggering of the audience’s reaction and its subsequence results, and not the actual reactions and their extent. It is this incident, due to the confusion of the audience’s cognition caused by new technology, that serves as a significant milestone in film history which triggered in the industry and the fascination with film, which to this day allows cinema to manipulate and

Read More

What Is A Movie Historically Accurate

676 Words | 3 Pages

The film “300” is directed by Zack Synder and depicts the Battle of Thermopylae in 480 BCE when King Leonidas and 300 Spartans went to battle against the Persian empire led by King Xerxes. While the film has outstanding cinematography and encapsulates Spartan warrior culture, however, it does drastically exaggerate historical accuracy. In terms of accuracy, the film is more of a hyperbolic interpretation than one that could be considered entirely historically accurate. Many obvious reasons allude to this being more for entertainment than accuracy, as the movie has overdramatized the strength the Spartans have.

Read More

Darius The Great Is Not Ok Sparknotes

925 Words | 4 Pages

Have you ever wondered about your culture and who you really are? In my book, Darrius wants to find out more about himself and who he really is as a person. Darius goes on an adventure to Iran to see his dad and see what he thinks about his Persian culture. Darius' story sheds light on the intricate journey of self-discovery in the face of cultural expectations of himself and his family. Through his struggles, we're prompted to reflect on our own identities and societal influences.

Read More

Medieval Romantic Influence On Modern Films

984 Words | 4 Pages

Clairerencia Hudson Ms. Morris English 12- 6th period 1 December 2016 The Influence of Medieval Romantic literature on modern films Does medieval romantic literature influence how modern films are made? Romantic literature started during the mid-12th Century (“Romance,” par.1). Medieval romances are stories and plays in which kings, knights, and damsels in distress go on some sort of adventure (from Sir Gawain and the Green Knight from Morte d’ Arthur). In addition, medieval romances consist of heroic figures showing acts of chivalry.

Read More

Essay On The Battle Of Thermopylae

595 Words | 3 Pages

Also, I am impressed with Leonidas’s reign. He was a wise military leader, and he acted magnanimously, so Spartans could have cooperation mind and keep loyalty to him. Also, I respect the Sparta’s a mind of steel. In my case, I often fall into idleness to do my work, but the Spartans carry out their obligation as well. As this 300 movie, I could remind what I learned in class and go over Ancient Greece part

Read More

Racism And Prejudice In War Movies

1043 Words | 5 Pages

This is the problem of the contemporary war movie– regardless how good it reconstructs the historical reality, it very often bears hallmarks of racism, because discrimination is inscribed in the everyday life of the past. Sometimes we should consider racist elements in war movies as the mindless reconstruction of the

Read More

Why Is It Important To Francis Ford Coppola's Apocalypse Now?

547 Words | 3 Pages

While exploring this topic, I intend to consult Edward Said’s Orientalism, debates about “otherness,” scholarly interpretations of Apocalypse Now, historical evidence about Americans’ attitudes toward the Vietnam War, and biographical information about Francis Ford Coppola.

Read More

Argumentative Essay On Sparta

1474 Words | 6 Pages

Stephen Hodkinson & Ian Macgregor Morris for inclusion in Sparta in Modern Thought: Politics, History and Culture (Swansea: The Classical Press of Wales, 2012) ch 8 However, what is being witnessed in modern times is the erosion of the freedoms and liberties of common individuals in these democratic societies (per Socrates’ prediction) as the integrity of each country’s sovereignty is possibly being compromised by multiculturalism, global economic dependency, rapid technological advancement, lack of immigrant assimilation, global energy interdependence, and the growing divide of who possesses the lion’s share of the world’s wealth. It is in this context the Spartan way can be defended, and perhaps be implemented in moderation for the good of the state, and the people in which it should

Read More

Noah And The Ark Compare And Contrast Essay

774 Words | 4 Pages

Audience members who do not know the original telling of the story would think the movie is incredible. On the other hand, the Christian audience members were outraged because the quality of a film can never outweigh the changes made of Holy

Read More

Role Of Religion In Movies

1203 Words | 5 Pages

We can take an example from the latest movie “PK” which has very well portrayed the arising issues on religion of society. Such movies create awareness among people in society which tries to show the existence of frauds who calls themselves a messenger

Read More

Mediatization Of Religion

1197 Words | 5 Pages

In actuality it points toward the fact that religious practices and functions may be transformed and re-contextualized in more secular domains. The specific impact media has had upon religion is often undermined and frequently contradicted, however it is clear when viewing media as a ‘conduit, language, and environment’ are largely responsible for the validation and confirmation of the mediatization of

Read More

More about Comparing Medieval Films 300, El Cid And Naser Salah Ad-Din

Related Topics

Open Document