ipl-logo

Comparing Oliver's First And Second Argument In The Song Of Roland

1277 Words6 Pages

The Comparison between Roland and Oliver’s first and second argument in the song of Roland
The Song of Roland was written at the end of the eleventh century. It is a French epic, and it is considered the most ancient in the medieval times. However, its author is unknown. The poem is referring to the times of the King Charlemagne, or Grand Charles, who reigned in France during this time. He was considered an elderly Christian leader, who ruled with warmth and compassion. In this epic, King Charles was in war for seven years with King Marsile, the king of Spain, and his people Saracens. The epic mostly describes the battle of Roncevaux, where Saracens attacked the rear guard of King Charlemagne. Among other characters described in the song, there were two …show more content…

These knights fought heroically in the valley of Roncevaux for their king Charles and their people. Even though, they were great friends, and would sacrifice themselves in place of the other, they both shared differences and similarities of their personalities, characters, and decision making capacities in this epic. Some of these differences and similarities of these heroic knights, are painted in the laisses 80-87 and 129-132 in the Song of Roland, where they argue whether or not, to sound the Oliphant, the symbol of help at that time.
In the lasisses 80-87 in The Song of Roland, Oliver was the first one to see the Saracens coming to attack the rear guard. He was not only brave and loyal knight, but also wise and practical. He realized that Saracens army outnumbered the Franks, and they did not have a chance to win the battle unless they would ask for help. The comparison between the number of the Saracens and the Franks was repeated several times by making it more intense and vivid every time was brought up. The author used similar words and numbers to describe the enemy force like: “great force” (81, 1030) “greater number” (82, 1040) “a hundred thousand shield” (82, 1041)

Show More
Related
481 Words | 2 Pages

The Spaniards demonstrated their military might when “they all dressed and equipped themselves for war” and “arranged themselves in rows, files and ranks.” They had full armor and their weaponry included, iron swords, shields, iron crossbows, harquebuses, and “iron lances and halberds”, which combined three

Read More
836 Words | 4 Pages

A rifle carries four hundred paces. That calls for two different kinds of tactics entirely” (138). Solomon is also very confident in his ability to lead, because he acts like he has already won with this bold of a statement, “…the redcoats danced, didn’t they, and now they have to pay the piper…” (Fast

Read More
677 Words | 3 Pages

His troops and horses arrived tired after the long march which in battle is not something you want to be. Furthermore he was known as rash and went

Read More
936 Words | 4 Pages

The Carefully Crafted Legend: Einhard’s distortions in The Life of Charlemagne Einhard’s The Life of Charlemagne is a famous biography that provides a firsthand account of the deeds and character of Charles the Great. Einhard was a close contemporary to Charlemagne and his court, with Walahfrid Strabo’s preface describing how there “was almost no one else among the many officials of the king’s majesty to whom the king . . . . Entrusted so many secrets.” Despite Einhard’s seemingly well researched and honest biography, there are far too many distortions and inconsistencies in this work to completely trust this work. Einhard’s information on Charlemagne’s birth and early childhood is suspect.

Read More
1713 Words | 7 Pages

Author of the book, Becoming Charlemagne, by Jeff Sypeck provides a clear glimpse into the life of one of the world’s greatest kings and ruler and later emperor Charlemagne, otherwise known as Karl or Charles the Great. Sypeck creates a vivid and strong look into the time of Charlemagne, early medieval Europe and some other important world leaders, including Pope Leo III, Irene the Byzantine emperor, Alcuin the scholar and Harun al-Rashid ruler of Baghdad. These figures are crucial to the story of Karl becoming Charlemagne, and their stories included in the book help form and symbolize Charlemagne the Ruler. Understanding Charlemagne and early medieval Europe is presented vibrantly throughout the book by in-depth stories, facts and a clear

Read More
442 Words | 2 Pages

”The battle of al-Yarmouk was of the fiercest and bloodiest kind” (F). The Byzantines had a grand total of 200,000 men versus 24,000 Muslims. “By Allah 's help, some 70,000 of them (Byzantines) were put to death”(F). With the help of “Allah,” the “unbelievers” were defeated and the Muslims won.

Read More
1389 Words | 6 Pages

With the fall of the Carolingian Empire, Europe was left in a frantic and militaristic state marked by violence amongst fluctuating kingdoms and territorial leaders. In the early 12th century, however, France was beginning to experience a positive change in the monarchy when Louis the VI became king in 1108. Also known as Louis the Fat (due to his massive weight towards the end of his life), Louis was able to assert his force as king by giving just, and often violent, punishments to criminals and enemies. Once a confidant to the king and eventually the abbot of St. Denis, Suger writes about Louis’ various acts in The Deeds of Louis the Fat. These deeds helped to shape France’s monarchy into a powerful, centralized unit that would continue for

Read More
1894 Words | 8 Pages

"The Murder of Charles the Good." Readings in Medieval History. 4th ed. Toronto: Published by University of Toronto Press, 2010. 382-93. Print.

Read More
1103 Words | 5 Pages

The story begins with Charlemagne's army fighting the Muslims in Spain, and the last city standing is Saragossa. Roland bravely offers to lead the rear guard. Pagans attack them at Roncesvals and the Christians are overwhelmed by their sheer numbers. Seeing how badly outnumbered they are, Roland is asked to blow on his oliphant by another officer to call for help from the main body of the Frankish army. Roland proudly refuses, saying that they need no help because the rear guard is strong enough to hold them.

Read More
547 Words | 3 Pages

Clear Chivalry: (A Discussion of Chivalry in King Arthur’s Story) In the days of King Arthur, there was something called “Chivalry”. It was something used by Knights to instill discipline and honor. These fearless knights were to follow a strict code of conduct. If they didn’t, they were not a true knight.

Read More
853 Words | 4 Pages

Charlemagne was the one of the great rulers of early European history. He was the King of the Franks in the 8th century and facilitated great expansion of his empire through conquest and diplomacy. Einhard was a monk who lived under Charlemagne’s rule, and, in a glowing light, he wrote a biography of Charlemagne. Einhard describes many of Charlemagne’s achievements, and he also writes about Charlemagne’s character. Einhard believed Charlemagne was a great leader because of his military success, his beautification of the kingdom, and his exceptional character qualities.

Read More
481 Words | 2 Pages

b. Beowulf i. Chose to fight with his men around him to help if

Read More
273 Words | 2 Pages

The Christians in The Song of Roland perceive the Muslims to be evil villains, incapable of any act of good. Although Ganelon is the overall lowest form of a man in the poem, this is because as a Christian he allowed himself to fall into the temptation of the devil as a means of the Muslims. By playing on Ganelon's hatred of Roland and his greed, the Muslims are able to entice Ganelon to become a traitor. Thus, even in Ganelon, the desperation of the Muslims is present. When confronted with the emir, it is almost humorous that the Christians are still unable to address their misconceptions about the people they are fighting.

Read More
545 Words | 3 Pages

A Code of Conduct         In the Medieval era, aristocrats considered knights the nobility in feudal society. Arthurian Knights are equipped with weapons and armor, while partaking in violence and bloodshed. As highly skilled fighting men, they hold power over other members of society. The only way to restrain a knight’s actions is through chivalry, or a code of conduct they have to follow. Without chivalry, Gawain, the “Prologue” knight and the “Wife of Bath’s Tale” knight would not have been able to call themselves knights.

Read More
628 Words | 3 Pages

Benjamin Franklin; a renowned printer, author and inventor favored appearance far more than he favored reality. Several times in his Autobiography Franklin discusses ways to better one’s appearance, all the while facing brutal reality. Throughout Franklin’s work he insists on making it clear to his readers that it is not the reality of things that is important, rather the appearance of things that play a more wholesome part in one’s character. Franklin continues to discuss in his Autobiography appearance and how this continues to be an important virtue for an individual to possess.

Read More

More about Comparing Oliver's First And Second Argument In The Song Of Roland

Related Topics

Open Document