ipl-logo

Comparing Paper Menagerie And The Fall Of A City

975 Words4 Pages

The contrast in themes between “Paper Menagerie” and “The Fall of a City”
The bildungsroman issues are present in most stories today. Stories with completely different premises can be connected by these issues. This topic is usually used to further character development and show how conflict can change characters. Throughout both “Paper Menagerie '' by Ken Liu, and, “The Fall of a City '' by Alden Nowlan, the bildungsroman themes of discrimination and adult influence are the driving forces that result in the characters coming of age.
The theme of discrimination was the initial spark which initiated the growth of the characters. In “Paper Menagerie” the main character Jack experiences discrimination from his peers, which results in him changing …show more content…

In both stories, the behaviour and presence of parental figures are what result in how the characters respond to discrimination. After experiencing discrimination and confronting his parents about the name-calling he experienced, Jack’s father responds by attempting to change his wife's behaviour, instead of addressing his son’s feelings which is shown by him saying, "‘You have to’ [...] ‘I've been too easy on you. Jack needs to fit in’"(Liu 4). Instead of attempting to help his son get through the discrimination he was experiencing, Jack’s father rolls over and accepts the fact that the only way Jack will be happy will be to fit in by adopting western culture. By allowing young and immature Jack to dictate how the family behaves, he is permitting and indirectly influencing Jack’s behaviour and personality. If the father took a more strict approach to deal with his son's bullying, Jack could have matured past a need to fit in, and instead embrace his culture. Ultimately, the way that Jack’s father decides to handle his son’s discrimination, influenced Jack and his identity. On the other hand, the adult influence experienced by Teddy is much more direct. Instead of being influenced by an adult's lack of action, Teddy was directly influenced during the altercation with his uncle. The ridicule Teddy experiences is what results in a change in mentality. This is shown in paragraph 53 where it states, “The city was as he had left it. Yet everything had changed. Always before when he had come here, his flesh had tingled, his eyes had shone with excitement. Now there was only a taste like that of sour milk” (Nowlan 4). After being the victim of ridicule by an adult parental figure, Teddy's perspective on his kingdom completely shifted. The behaviour of Teddy’s uncle influenced how Teddy perceived his passion and

Show More
Related

Analysis Of Sex In The Heartland By Beth Lawrence

1097 Words | 5 Pages

In Sex in the Heartland, Beth Bailey details how the cultural revolution of the 1960s and 1970s manifested in the seemingly polarized town of Lawrence, Kansas. Though the town was small and was in no way revolutionary like the cities of New York, Los Angeles, and San Francisco, the city of Lawrence was conditioned by many outside social, cultural, and political aspects, which led to it having such an intricate role in the sexual revolution and the other cultural and social movements of the 1960s. Beth Bailey seems to argue that Lawrence, despite being a small town in the heart of the American farmland and no where near any so-called powder-kegs of the 1960s was still able to become a central location for vocalization because of the roles of

Read More

Sociological Analysis Of The Movie Pleasantville

1313 Words | 6 Pages

Discrimination, according to the textbook, is the unequal treatment of various categories of people. (Macionis pg.86) In the movie, when the younger generation and some of the older generation start to turn to color from black and white, the townspeople get angry and can’t accept the change. As a result, they start to hang up signs in the stores saying

Read More

Common Themes In The Outsiders

1152 Words | 5 Pages

These instances are examples of how no one is born better than others or has to fit their title if they don’t want to. Each character in this book is human, with problems and struggles. They judge each other based on whether or not they

Read More

Memoir 'This Boys Life' By Jack Wolff

437 Words | 2 Pages

Jack also engages in fights with his best friend, which at first is truly disheartening and unfair from the reader’s perspective, is later sympathized with the knowledge and understanding that it is Jacks true best shot at gaining the approval of his abusive stepfather Dwight and protecting himself. Jacks life is driven with emotional neglect and constant abuse; Dwight being the largest cause. Jack is desperate to transform himself into the masculine and happy person he wants to be, a deluded image and way of thinking that he believes will solve all his problems and hardships. Readers eventually gain the knowledge that his lies and deceit are his way of achieving this and providing him with comfort and hope as well as relief and escpae from his currently tortuous youth. ‘I couldn’t help but try to introduce new versions of myself as my interests changed, and as other versions of myself failed to persuade.’

Read More

Rhetorical Devices In Just Walk On By

1013 Words | 5 Pages

The main character continuously faults himself for the way that others treat him . When the character is treated as though he is as bad as a rapist he feels “ embarrassed, and dismayed..” (542), when he has done nothing wrong to get this kind of treatment ,and he is only being judged by his race. Staples uses diction and syntax to make it sound as if the character believes that it’s his fault that he is stereotyped. This emotional appeal grabs the audience’s attention and their sympathy.

Read More

The Importance Of Life In Alden Nowlan's The Glass Rose

1363 Words | 6 Pages

He encounters the external issue of physically disparity with the people that he get along with, and the internal conflicts between being a man with the characteristic that his father modeled for him or being a unique

Read More

Innocence In Alden Nowlan's The Fall Of A City

704 Words | 3 Pages

When Teddy is faced with predicaments with his aunt and uncle, he succumbs to pressure. As his uncle is blaring out irrational comments at him, he does nothing but “[sits] by the window and [looks] out at the rain” (Nowlan 2). Teddy’s lack of rebellion is the conflict that portrays his inability to express his own opinions in words which is a key to obtaining individuality. He is blinded by his own innocence and succumbs to his uncle’s words when he sits alone which implies that he agrees with him. Another example of his innocence that stops him from becoming an individual is when he destroys his creation.

Read More

Similarities Between Indian Horse And To Kill A Mockingbird

650 Words | 3 Pages

In this situation young Scout is a social outcast from her peers solely for the reason of her father defending a black man. It is evident that both parties experience prejudice commonly in the societies that they live in. While both cases are different, they both receive distaste that isolates them from the people around them because of their beliefs and appearance. Scout and Saul also end up handling these problems rather differently. Saul’s racist co-workers are deterred from bothering him one night when Saul gets pushed past has limit.

Read More

Adversity In The Story Of John Purcell

605 Words | 3 Pages

John Purcell was a man who faced a tremendous amount of adversities throughout his lifetime. As we can see as this short story these adversities prove to be to great and send him down path filled with neglectful parenting and alcoholism. The Father depicts countless times where John is unable to connect with or understand other characters in this book. We are shown this with his family and friends numerous times. John repeatedly allows adversity craft his identity throughout his lifetime.

Read More

Available Houses In The Bronx: A Short Story

573 Words | 3 Pages

When he came out his mom was making him breakfast but without even looking at her he just walked out to school. He looked as mad as a bull that saw the color red. The whole day he was at school he didn’t say a word to anyone. After school ended Jack realized that he had to make a decision whether to accept that he’s moving and that he wants to move or he denies his mom’s choice and never talks to her again. When Jack got home he saw a car that he didn’t recognize outside his house.

Read More

Contradictions In The Fall Of A City

710 Words | 3 Pages

Chances are, when one is in a fight or flight situation one will usually choose flight, to escape the situation and ignore it. In Fall of a City by Alden Nowlan, the protagonist Teddy escapes his unhappy family life. His refuge takes the form of an imaginary world that he constructed as a place where he feels safe. Ultimately, this illusion is shattered when his uncle discovers his creation and ridicules him for it. Through the portrayal of setting and characters, Nowlan presents imagination as a necessary method of escape to maintain one’s mental stability.

Read More

Examples Of Allusions In Lord Of The Flies

806 Words | 4 Pages

For example, when Roger was tempted to throw a rock at one of the younger boys he held back because his arm was “conditioned by a civilization” (Golding 62). This quote shows how earlier in the novel, the Christian-based morals of society held Roger back from throwing a rock at another boy. But Roger goes on to murder a different character, proving the nearness to his faith was the anchor keeping him from brutality. Jack’s character is an ideal example of this idea, because in the beginning of the book, although arrogant, he was friendly with Ralph and still ‘normal.’ However, throughout the book, we start to see a different side of him, shown through his unusually vigorous desire to hunt, his need for power, his idolatry, and his violent nature.

Read More

Coming Of Age In To Kill A Mockingbird

1720 Words | 7 Pages

In all three works, the protagonist comes of age and realizes his/her true identity and purpose in the world. At the circumstances, a Bildungsroman best represents the three works because it looks at an overall perspective, unlike the other plotlines, in which only aspects of them may show up in the story. Anne Frank’s words continue to ring in the lives of people and characters facing the world in their own Bildungsroman

Read More

Character Analysis Of Jack Torrance In 'The Shining'

1455 Words | 6 Pages

”14 Jack's history with his abusive father and his own problems causes him to become a danger. Hutz also states that the transformation of Jack shows how a “child victim” transforms “into the adult abuser. ”15This makes him a source of horror as it is a realistic, seemingly uncontrollable

Read More

How Does Jack Change In Lord Of The Flies

663 Words | 3 Pages

During a time of war, a british plane carrying a group of schoolboys is shot down over the Pacific, killing all adults and leaving the group of boys stranded on an island. One of the two leaders of the group, Jack, is the perfect character to portray humanity changing from civilized to savage. Jack is power-hungry, violent, and savage. In the beginning of the book, Jack is innocent and carelessly follows the leader, Ralph.

Read More

More about Comparing Paper Menagerie And The Fall Of A City

Related Topics

Open Document