ipl-logo

Comparing Rapunzel And Gothel In The Brothers Grimm

1461 Words6 Pages

5. Research Question and Hypothesis
Research Question: How has the representation of women changed through the characters of Rapunzel and Gothel in the Brothers Grimm version of the tale, Rapunzel compared to Walt Disney’s adaptation and can these representations be explained through Deleuze and Guattari’s theories on war machines and desire-producing machines?

Hypothesis: The changes reflected in the female characters of the narrative Rapunzel suggest that women have advanced or rather progressed in society as indicated in the progressive state of Rapunzel herself, however, these changes are still limited or restricted as shown through the overall stagnant portrayal in the character of Gothel in both literary narratives. These portrayals …show more content…

Furthermore, it is a perpetual and continuous debate that encourages new or re-invented viewpoints. By examining the issue of feminism through fairy tales and equating it to Deleuze and Guattari’s theories on war machines and desire-producing machines, a new dimension is added to the debate which may allow for new ideas or viewpoints to be explored.

7. Research Aim and Objectives
Extensive research has been conducted and offered around the issue of gender roles within fairy tales as well as the negative by-products produced through the reinforcement of stereotypical society ideals and concepts when addressing, discussing and portraying women. However, minimal attention is paid to the progressive state of the princess versus the regressive state of the ‘evil’ witch.

As previously discussed, this research study looks to investigate the role or rather representation of women through the medium of children’s fairy tales to uncover and explore how these representations and ideals may have evolved and changed through the ages. It is suggested that cinema and popular culture continues to act as a medium of social …show more content…

Secondly, by addressing the issue of feminism and gender roles through films and fairy tales by focusing on the specific narrative of Rapunzel through the Brother Grimm’s and Disney’s interpretations. Thirdly, linking these ideas to the backdrop of the study, the characters of Rapunzel and Gothel. This will allow for an analysis to be conducted on the similarities and differences between the characters. Moreover, an analysis of the character allows for the exploration of Deleuze and Guattari’s theories. Ultimately, through the research conducted offer an educated conclusion as to if the character of Rapunzel changed through the various adaptations and highlight how these changes may reflect the difference in societal perception of

Show More
Related
508 Words | 3 Pages

Since the beginning of literature, women have been depicted as devious individuals. As a result, women put use to this stereotype to get what they want. This is proven, especially in medieval literature. Examples of this are shown in works like “Macbeth,” * Sir Gawain and the Green Knight,” and “The Canterbury Tales”.

Read More
1631 Words | 7 Pages

In “Cinderella”, by the Grimm Brothers, the authors utilize a multitude of fairy tale genre conventions such as frequent usage of rhetorical devices, magical creatures, and the classic “Happy Ever After” fairy tale ending, to emphasize the importance of genuineness and the dangers of pursuing superficiality. The authors use several rhetorical devices such as symbolism and juxtaposition

Read More
559 Words | 3 Pages

Although this genre has evolved in some elements such as its motifs or structure as I have explained, it maintains its conventional function of transmitting values and confront human conflicts. Driven by this educational aspect, the fact that this book has been introduced in schools to teach about the Holocaust is not fortuitous. This is a book that retells a traditional fairy tale that children could be familiarized with but describing a modern issue. Furthermore, I consider that this book narrates facts about the Holocaust in a contemporary manner as it deviates from the traditional gender roles of fairy tales. The rescued woman is not

Read More
312 Words | 2 Pages

Villains are a huge part of movies, stories and books. Without a villain in a plot, the story isn 't the same. Villains provide a problem in the story of the movie or book. The rudest, meanest, dirtiest villain that I know, is Gothel: Rapunzel 's evil step mom.

Read More
615 Words | 3 Pages

The prejudice that the author brings forward strongly is the notion of feminism. The author’s main purpose of writing this novel is to examine the role of women played around

Read More
1195 Words | 5 Pages

The actions themselves within these two stories characterize the interior life of Jeanette’s character, first within the stories of Sir Perceval. An example is the stories’ disruption of traditional gender roles. The non-binary roles manifest within the story through the cross-gendering of characters, which expands possible identities for Jeanette. In Sir Perceval’s story, Jeanette experiments with a male.

Read More
494 Words | 2 Pages

Princesses’ in Disney movies are tied down to a recurring theme: the princess that must be saved from the evil woman by the charming prince. A significant contrast to the usually weak and easily persuaded figure of the father. Even though the women are portrayed as weak, nobody stops to think how strong they have to be to carry the responsibility of an entire household on her shoulder, while the men always seem to be traveling or ill. Fairytales are based on a patriarchal way of thinking and as time passes by, it’s proven to be detrimental to society Women and men are constantly being bound to a series of stereotypes.

Read More
1466 Words | 6 Pages

Textual composers use literary archetypes as a vehicle to represent society's attitudes and values, particularly those that have changed throughout the years and those that are still evident in society today. Through the comparison of the classic 'Snow White' Grimm's novel, director Tarsem Singh's 2012 Snow White adaptation 'Mirror Mirror' and Matt Phelan's 2016 Snow White graphic novel, we can analyse how character archetypes have changed throughout time, featuring similar characters in three vastly different adaptations of the fairy-tale, Snow White. Character archetypes represent society's ideals of different genders, roles and various individuals that each have personal attitudes and goals throughout the tale that carry the story. Different

Read More
421 Words | 2 Pages

Justyna Deszcz wrote an article based on Zipes’ political and socio-historical approach and added a variety of facts she had collected from many other authors and articles. Deszcz believes that the reason we have shifted into the submissive and “family-friendly” theme of fairy tales is because “the fairytale has been reduced to a mass-produced commodity, to be purchased and owned, and to bring in considerable profit. What is more, the fairytale is being used as a source and a vehicle of powerful self-mirroring images affirming the existing value system, and thus lulling audiences into passivity and compliance.” This point proves that the original thought of harsh realities needing to be exposed in story telling has converted to just being a profitable way to tell simple-minded children’s

Read More
1025 Words | 5 Pages

In Margaret Atwood’s poem “There Was Once”, Atwood uses irony to point out the societal problems within the genre of fairy tales. Charles Perrault, the author of the short story “The Sleeping Beauty in the Wood”, writes about fantastic creatures, magic, and love, following the generic conventions of fairy tales. When compared to Perrault’s short story “The Sleeping Beauty in the Wood”, Atwood’s poem both compliments and contrasts Perrault’s. These two texts, although similar, offer different views on the genre of fairy tales. Margaret Atwood’s satirical poem, “There Was Once”, aims to disrupt the generic conventions of a traditional fairy tale.

Read More
547 Words | 3 Pages

The main character being a mermaid longing for the human world is an homage to Andersen’s fairytale The Little Mermaid, although the contemporary setting allowed me to explore different implications. 
Fantasy is excellent for metaphors and parallels - one of its premises is to talk about issues of our society while discussing something that is apparently the furthest away from it. I’ve encountered feminist themes in Angela Carter’s re-imagined fairytales, where she gives women the agency they lacked during her time. The movie Maleficent deals with growth, rape, self-healing and the role of women through a retelling of Perrault’s Sleeping Beauty from the antagonist’s point of view. 


Read More
1276 Words | 6 Pages

Most of the children read about many fairy tales, especially Snow Whites, Sleeping beauty, and Cinderella when they grew up. It is a surprising fact that to discover a hidden, unexpected political intention in the simple plot of fairy tales. That is a feminization of woman. The fairy tale world suggests a male-centered patriarchy as an ideal basic society and impliedly imply that man and woman need to have a proper attitude toward this opinion. However, Jewett’s A White Heron describes a new perspective of fairy tale’s plot.

Read More
881 Words | 4 Pages

Numerous schools of criticisms have attempted to find the meaning behind most of our favorite childhood stories. From Marxist who pursue the idea of social classes portrayed in literary works, to Psychoanalysts who depict the sexual tensions and desires that are subconsciously embedded behind characters’ motives and actions, to Historicists who try to show the preservation of tradition in stories, many different concepts exist for each fairy tale. The Feminist school of criticism greatly focuses on unveiling the patriarchal system and sexist roles that are displayed in stories, and more specifically, fairytales. Four versions of the well-known fairytale of The Little Mermaid will be compared and discussed while focusing on many distinctive

Read More
1351 Words | 6 Pages

“Beauty and the Beast” is an original fairy tale and over time have incorporated social, religious and cultural themes. An analysis of the Disney version of “Beauty and the Beast” exemplifies the stereotypes of the more subtle forms of social manipulation that fairytales undergo to employ. The question of whether these stories are made for entertainment or send a much larger picture, depicting to children their gender roles within a society. In this paper gender roles will be represented showing the typical female and male character within a society. Historian Sylvia D. Hoffert defines a gender ideal as “the cluster of characteristics, behavior patterns, and values that members of a group think a man or a woman should have, a set of cultural expectations.”

Read More
1184 Words | 5 Pages

Freedom. The importance of freedom is often forgotten as Americans live day by day taking this gift for granted. In this day and age, freedom seems as a “simple gift’ obtained by every American, but one forgets to think about those who were once unable to enjoy the freedoms one is promised daily. Back in the day, freedom seemed as nothing more than a dream to those of color. Everyday of a colored person’s life consisted of harassment and discrimination as no one cared to treat them as equals.

Read More

More about Comparing Rapunzel And Gothel In The Brothers Grimm

Related Topics

Open Document