ipl-logo

Comparing The Drummer Boy Of Shiloh And Drumbeats And Bullets

501 Words3 Pages

The Drummer Boy of Shiloh and Drumbeats and Bullets are two different stories, and both are about drummer boys in the Civil War. Although they are both about drummer boys, they still have some differences. Both stories are at least part nonfiction.
The Drummer Boy of Shiloh is about a specific drummer boy named Joby. Joby is a young drummer boy who is getting ready for the war. Drumbeats and Bullets is about many drummer boys, many unnamed. It is and informational story. The story says "Drumming wasn’t the only thing these boys did, either. While in camp, they would carry water, rub down horses, gather wood, or cook for the soldiers. There is even evidence that one was a barber for the troops when he wasn’t drumming. After a battle, most drummers helped carry …show more content…

The Drummer Boy Of Shiloh is fictional. Joby probably was not a real drummer boy.
You know, because of the specific setting and events that happened in the story, such as the talk with the general. Drumbeats and bullets is nonfiction. Drumbeats and Bullets has less opinion and more facts about drummer boys in the Civil War.
The Drummer Boy of Shiloh only talks about what it was like at the camp. This gives you less information about what it was like. Drumbeats and Bullets mostly only talks about what it was like on the battlefield. This changes a lot what they show. Drumbeats and bullets says "Fighting in the Civil War was particularly bloody. Of the 900 men in the First Maine Heavy
Artillery, 635 became casualties in just seven minutes of fighting at the Battle of Petersburg. A
North Carolina regiment saw 714 of its 800 soldiers killed at Gettysburg. At such a time, these boys put down their drums and took up whatever rifle was handy." (199) This tells a lot about what it was like on the battlefield, but The Drummer Boy of Shiloh says nothing about what it was like on the battlefield.
Both stories are different, but still have some similarities. For example, both

Show More
Related
2063 Words | 9 Pages

The picture above is a depiction of LTC Joshua Chamberlain and the 20th Maine at the Battle of Little Round Top. In late June of 1863, the Confederate Army under General Robert E. Lee was massing near Gettysburg, PA. Gettysburg would arguably become the key battle of the Civil War. It was the pivotal moment where momentum in the war would change. It was the bloodiest battle of the entire war.

Read More
1180 Words | 5 Pages

1.) How did the Dread Scott decision change the political landscape of the United States? How did it gainsay the Missouri Compromise of 1820 and the 1850 Compromise? The Dread Scott decision change the political landscape because it impacted on the political party system. It shattered the regional peace and party unity.

Read More
615 Words | 3 Pages

To Kill A Civil War Soldier It all ended on May 9, 1865. Over 620,000 soldiers, combined from both sides, died during the Civil War ever since the Confederates had bombarded Union soldiers at Fort Sumter, South Carolina, on April 12, 1861. It is a common misconception that most of those soldiers died during the bloody battles in action. In fact, twice as many of Civil War soldiers died from infection and disease than the various battle wounds one could receive, from getting shot clean through from a Minié ball to being blown to smithereens by a cannon.

Read More
473 Words | 2 Pages

An unprecedented number of Soldiers from the North Union Army and South Confederate Army perished in the American Civil war. The number of war dead is estimated to have exceeded 618,000. The Battle of Stones River was known as the six costliest battle of the war due to the fact that only 74,000 Soldiers participated in this pertinent turning point of the war. The Battle of Stones River also known as the Second Battle of Murphysboro was responsible for the highest casualty rate on both sides with no decisive winner once the gun smoke lifted and the cannon fodder was cleared. The battle did put the first dash of doubt in the Confederate commander’s hearts, having them feel as if the control of the South and could be lost.

Read More
1416 Words | 6 Pages

Angels on the Battlefield In the Battle of Gettysburg that took place on July 1, 1863, and ended on July 3, many casualties and injuries resulted from the fighting between those few days, leading to the victory of the Union Army. It is roughly estimated that 620,000 men lost their lives fighting, many for liberty and freedom, others for new opportunities. The Civil War was considered the deadliest and bloodiest battle. Medicine has come a long way now, in comparison to the 19th century, although many lives were lost on the way.

Read More
388 Words | 2 Pages

Both works focus on the horrors of war and what it does to the soldiers. The message the works convey both demonstrate how awful war is. They both demonstrate soldiers opinions on fighting and the war in general. Both are very good at using descriptive words and painting a very visceral picture

Read More
483 Words | 2 Pages

When you read these two stories, they are both involved in war. The first story is named, "The Sniper" and "Cranes" is the name of the second story. The author of the first story "The Sniper" is Liam O ' Flaherty. The author of the second story "Cranes" is Hwang Sunwon. Even though "The Sniper" and "Cranes" share a common topic about war, there are other different aspects.

Read More
643 Words | 3 Pages

Compare & Contrast Essay “POW! POW! POW!” Gunshots were heard around the tavern in Massachusetts. While hiding in an empty barrel with my gun and some food that might not last too long, I wondered.

Read More
333 Words | 2 Pages

Did you know that after the Battle of Gettysburg, the troops on each side had lost many soldiers? The Battle of Gettysburg, was part of the Civil War that lasted 4 years and it was the Union (North) against the Confederacy (South). This battle, was a win for the Union boosting up their moral, but giving up confidence for the Confederacy. Each side had many casualties and therefore, the Battle of Gettysburg was a turning point during the Civil War because of the effects that came with the battle. After the battle, the Confederacy leader named Robert E. Lee had given up his hope and his confidence of making the Confederacy win and become independent.

Read More
704 Words | 3 Pages

The Battle of Shiloh The Civil War resulted in in Union victory by winning a series of “mini battles”. Before the Civil War ended the Battle of Shiloh was known as the bloodiest conflict in US history. With the war already in motion an early victory was needed. As influential as this battle was for the Union’s upper-hand, people’s lives on and off the battlefield were shook to their very core.

Read More
933 Words | 4 Pages

For thousands of years the stench of gun powder and drying blood has burned the innocence out of boys, turning them into men hardened by years of violent warfare. Joby, a young drummer boy in the American Civil War, is just one example of a young man being greatly impacted by events that occurred in the war. The short story follows Joby’s fears before the Battle of Shiloh, he feels defenseless, hopeless, and scared as he believes his position as the drummer boy is all but preferable. Joby’s attitude changes after a well-respected general comes to speak with him at night while Joby is crying out of fear. The General offers Joby support and reassures him of his importance, leaving Joby feeling important and confident.

Read More
520 Words | 3 Pages

On the parade ground, young drummers often found it difficult to maintain the regulation 28 inch pace during a march while carrying a standard issue drum. The tedium of drilling was also very hard on a young, restless mind. Bullying from the older soldiers also dampened a young recruit’s spirit. Stockwell encountered one soldier who “liked to try all recruits to see if they could fight” or “I didn’t enlist to fight that way”. These young recruits were also exposed to the previously forbidden adult vices of tobacco, alcohol, gambling and prostitution.

Read More
430 Words | 2 Pages

Have you ever heard of the story the “Drummer Boy of Shiloh?” If you have you know the story. If you haven't then you should read it it's a good story. This story was written by Ray Bradbury .

Read More
1618 Words | 7 Pages

Have you ever walked into 1,200 guns aiming straight at you? Drummer boys in the Civil War have, some even did it more than once. Drummer boys, who also served as soldiers, were some of the bravest boys in the country during the Civil War. These boys walked at the front of the marching column beating their drums to regulate soldiers’ marching steps. They were also the first ones to be shot if there was an ambush.

Read More
948 Words | 4 Pages

Glory: Directed by Edward Zwick, Columbia TriStar Motion Picture Group, 1989. 122 Minutes Reviewed by Mike Edward Zwick’s Glory is a movie in which the balance between entertainment and history was perfectly managed. He uses the letters sent by contemporary Col. Robert G. Shaw to his wealthy family back in Massachusetts as the historical foundation of the movie while imagining conversations between characters. Through Col. Shaw’s eye, we are able to uncover the birth, the development, and the end of the 54th Massachusetts Regiment, the first colored regiment fought in Civil War. Just like any other war movie, Glory has several battle scenes that were unpleasantly bloody, yet they managed to stay authentic.

Read More

More about Comparing The Drummer Boy Of Shiloh And Drumbeats And Bullets

Related Topics

Open Document