ipl-logo

Comparing The Nightmare Before Christmas And How The Grinch Stole Christmas

1515 Words7 Pages

When people are asked to name some of the classic Christmas movies, they are quick to say movies such as Rudolph the Red Nosed Reindeer (1964), Frosty the Snowman (1969), and How the Grinch Stole Christmas (2000), but they forget to mention the dismal, chilling The Nightmare Before Christmas (1993). But why is that, doesn’t Tim Burton still show the joy that Christmas brings, but in a slightly new perspective? Aren’t The Nightmare Before Christmas and How the Grinch Stole Christmas quite similar depictions of how some may deal with the “Christmas blues”? The Nightmare Before Christmas and How the Grinch Stole Christmas both originated as poems with rhythms similar to most Christmas poems. Tim Burton and Dr. Seuss both portray the cliché themes …show more content…

In The Nightmare Before Christmas, Sally, a ragdoll made in a lab by Dr. Finklestien, constantly warms Jack of the danger he will put himself and everyone else in if he takes something that doesn’t belong to him. As noted by Alan Bond in his “Skeletons, Rag Dolls, and Ambiguous Swamp Creatures: Gender In Tim Burton’s The Nightmare Before Christmas,” Sally “ is the only person in all of Halloweentown to not get caught up in the excitement of Christmas, and as such she works alone to stop Jack and fix the situation,” (Bond 3). Sally shares a similar role with the female protagonist in How the Grinch Stole Christmas. In Ron Howard’s take of the old story, Cindy Lou Who goes beyond all to show that the Grinch is not a malicious being who is solely evil. In contrast to Sally, Cindy Lou tries to amplify the Grinch’s role in Christmas celebration by nominating him as Cheermeister to lead the Christmas Whobilation (How the Grinch Stole Christmas). Even though both female characters try to steer the main character back on the right path, there are some differences regarding the interests and characteristics of Sally and Cindy Lou. Sally is in love with Jack, unlike Cindy Lou who just wants to show the Grinch that he is still a decent person. Sally and Cindy Lou are connected by their deep admiration for Jack and the Grinch. Another …show more content…

Each lesson learned by the characters contains many sub-morals that all underlie one: the lesson of acceptance. The overall similarity in this case revolves around what the revelation came to each character. In the end both Jack and the Grinch realize that they accept the circumstances they are in and come to terms with liking themselves for who they are. Instead of Jack becoming the ruler of a different holiday, he is completely content with being the Pumpkin King. For the Grinch, he comes to terms with the fact that Christmas is a time for coming together with people that love you. Not only does he realize this but he also learns that he is a good person with a huge

Show More
Related
335 Words | 2 Pages

Christmas is seen as something joyful and family oriented which the Who’s admire, while on the other hand the Grinch despises such festivities. The Grinch stole everything from the Who’s houses “On their walls he left nothing but hooks and some wire.” which led to making an image of evil. Grinch

Read More
195 Words | 1 Pages

It also explains why his fiancé left him and why she never returned. This explanation illustrates why Scrooge was so mean and hateful to others, and it allows the story to come to life. We all need to remember to love others, even when we are in an awful circumstance. The play had a little more symbolism than the movie did. In the play there was a little girl singing a song to her doll.

Read More
1018 Words | 5 Pages

The second story is called How the Grinch Stole Christmas. It has to do with a “Who” who is very mean, and the whole town, except one girl, hates him. It is very similar to A Christmas Carol, when it comes to the main character. Both of their societies sort of reject them, and they are very nasty people.

Read More
820 Words | 4 Pages

Did Scrooge only change because his life was on the line, did the Grinch's heart really grow two sizes? You surely would have heard the story of the Grinch and A Christmas carol, but out of the two, who changed more? They were both mean and cruel to everyone, but both of them changed into better people with the help of others and the circumstances they were put in. But again, who had the most character development?

Read More
512 Words | 3 Pages

There were very few differences in the two stories The two stories had a message for Christmas. It was to think about other families and being generous to people, and greeting them with a smile, don 't be selfish, grumpy, and mean. It was also showing you had a second chance of making things right like Scrooge. The other part of the message is that it’s better to give than receive like Scrooge gave Mr. Cratchit 's family a turkey.

Read More
1005 Words | 5 Pages

A Christmas Carol and How the Grinch Stole Christmas were two famous Christmas-themed stories. The protagonists, Scrooge and the Grinch, were memorable due to their dynamic nature and how they changed their perspectives. But the Grinch was notably more dynamic for several reasons. Although Scrooge was evil, this was due to his neglect and indifference to human suffering.

Read More
465 Words | 2 Pages

This allowed “The Grinch” to become the second highest-grossing holiday film of all time just behind the well-known film “Home Alone 2: Lost in New York”. It went on to win an Academy Award for Best Makeup and was nominated for Best Performance by an Actor in a Motion Picture in regards to Jim

Read More
373 Words | 2 Pages

In the movie and play A Christmas Carol Ebeneezer Scrooge discovers how his actions now could affect the afterlife. Both of these formats have many similarities, like how all the ghosts of Christmas are described and seen in the same way. Both have the Ghost of Christmas Past very bright, a woman, and held holly. The Ghost of Christmas Present is wearing a large green robe, very tall and mighty figure, and wears a beard. The Ghost of Christmas Future is black, frightening, and has bony fingers.

Read More
733 Words | 3 Pages

Looking for Change Hurts Many film and literature characters fail to leave an impact on the reader. This is not the case for Charles Dickens’ character Ebenezer Scrooge from A Christmas Carol and Frank Capra’s creation of a character, George Bailey from It’s a Wonderful Life. Both protagonists are beloved characters, but have drastic similarities and differences. Ebenezer Scrooge and George Bailey are best compared by their outlook on life, time spent with the spirits, and each character’s transformation in the story.

Read More
510 Words | 3 Pages

You may often come across the Christmas Carol story in many different forms but the play and movie are the most common. Say for example, the play written by Charles Dickens. This play takes place in various places in the city of London. The Christmas Carol play comes to life on Christmas Eve in the winter of 1843.(Dickens, 1) Ebenezer Scrooge is the main character who has absolutely no respect for Christmas at all. Matter of fact, he despises this merry holiday which is called to be the conflict of the play but Bob Cratchit, who works for him, is just filled with the thought of it.

Read More
700 Words | 3 Pages

Another difference is that in the Christmas Carol movie they sang while in the book they never sang. Another difference is that Scrooge said he will double

Read More
652 Words | 3 Pages

The Christmas Carol is a great and popular story, people have made movies and plays about it, though the play can be more accurate. The movies can be very accurate to the actual story. Although it is not a very long play there are many different things going on. The story overall has a great message to it. As in, never say that Christmas lame or not worth it.

Read More
1377 Words | 6 Pages

Once he finally gets past the pain and is able to view the truth of the world, he feels pity for the

Read More
451 Words | 2 Pages

Compare and Contrast A Christmas Carol is full of many twists and turns, and has been written in many different versions. Writers have taken artistic liberties and have added or taken away to the beloved Christmas story to make it their own. No two versions are going to be exactly similar, and most definitely are going to have many differences. The play and the movie both follow the basic plotline of the classic novel, A Christmas Carol.

Read More
704 Words | 3 Pages

Compare and contrast Christmas Carol Book VS. Christmas Carol Movie Are you into the Christmas spirit where everyone is enjoying their time with their family, then the Christmas carol is the right book for you. Today I am going to be discussing about the similarities and the differences between the book and the movie in the book and the movie Scrooge was the main character they both had the part where Scrooge had an argument with his nephew. In the movie and the book they had the same types of lessons learned. The difference is that in the movie Scrooge had a dog while in the book, it never mentions that Scrooge had a dog.

Read More

More about Comparing The Nightmare Before Christmas And How The Grinch Stole Christmas

Related Topics

Open Document