ipl-logo

Comparing The Project Camelot Study And Murray Center Experiments

494 Words2 Pages

The Project Camelot study and the Murray Center Experiments were two research projects conducted in the 1960s that encountered significant ethical challenges. While both studies had different objectives and methodologies, they share common ethical issues, including issues of informed consent, confidentiality, and the use of deception and psychological stressors in research. This essay will compare and critically evaluate the ethical challenges and strategies used in these studies. In terms of informed consent, both studies encountered challenges. The Project Camelot study involved the use of deception in the informed consent process, where the participants were not informed of the study's true purpose. In contrast, the Murray Center Experiments did not provide adequate information to the participants, leading to issues of transparency and the undermining of the principle of autonomy. In both cases, the participants were not fully aware of the nature of the study, leading to significant ethical concerns. To address the issue of confidentiality, both studies implemented strategies to protect the participants' privacy. The Project Camelot study used pseudonyms to maintain the participants' anonymity, while the Murray Center Experiments took steps to ensure that the participants' personal information was kept confidential. These …show more content…

In the Project Camelot study, the use of deception undermined the principle of informed consent and raised concerns about the legitimacy of the research findings. In the Murray Center Experiments, the use of intense psychological stressors could potentially harm the participants' psychological well-being, and questions the ethics of subjecting individuals to such stressors in the pursuit of knowledge. However, in both cases, the researchers used post-experimental debriefing to explain the nature of the study and minimize the potential harm

Show More
Related
1228 Words | 5 Pages

These

Read More
479 Words | 2 Pages

This is a problem in the documentary and is very disrespectful. What is "informed consent?" Informed consent is a common litmus test for many of the ethical issues. Participants in a study should be told the consequences.

Read More
1937 Words | 8 Pages

The job of the “Commission was to identify the basic ethical principles that should underlie the conduct of biomedical and behavioral research involving human subjects and to develop guidelines which should be followed to assure that such research is conducted in accordance with those principles.” (The National Commission for the Protection of Human

Read More
1030 Words | 5 Pages

Secondly, the report discuses that safety must be kept in mind. Scientific advancement cannot happen unless the experiments are safe. Thirdly, participants have to be chosen fairly, not from populations who could be coerced into participating, such as prisoners or institutionalized children. And, of course, consent is

Read More
948 Words | 4 Pages

In the context of medical research, informed consent provides individuals with the opportunity to accept or decline involvement in research, and thereby adheres to their right to choose. Obtaining consent from donors is not limited to simply seeking permission, but involves explaining the nature and consequences of research in an honest and understandable manner. When this aspect of informed consent is ignored, unethical research ensues. For example, during the infamous Tuskegee Syphilis Experiments, US Public Health researchers studied the progression of syphilis in African American men, under the false pretense of curing their “bad blood”. Though a treatment of penicillin was available at the time, researchers idly observed as subjects died painful, preventable deaths.

Read More
1420 Words | 6 Pages

During any kind of research, the researcher needs to follow ethics. The National Commission for the Protection of Human Subjects of Biomedical and Behavioral Research adopted a code of ethics in 1978. The commission issued the Belmont Report, which provided a model for many disciplinary guidelines (Polit, Beck, 2021 p. 132). Ethical guidelines were introduced after the time that Truman Capote did his research, so there were no guidelines to follow when conducting research. However, throughout this film, there are some noticeable questions that are related to how the research was conducted by Truman Capote that go against ethical standards.

Read More
888 Words | 4 Pages

This is something that the subject is going through they are being deceived on a emotional level, as they were not informed about the study directly, in this case it is unethical as the subjects privacy and rights have been violated as the experiment denies that on part of the subject , lacking in consideration for the subjects welfare and emotional well being from the experimenter. Action and Competence of researchers:when one is conducting a test ,they must conduct themselves in an ethical behavioural manner,eg when working with others they should not be biased. They should be able to justify themselves in a justifiable manner as well as be able to conduct themselves with sufficient knowledge about what they were researching. Although the Behavioural Study of obedience in my opinion was not ethical in many ways the results were proven to be precise and concluded with the desired

Read More
654 Words | 3 Pages

Delving into the ethics behind the Stanford Prison Experiment done by Philip Zimbardo, it has come to the public’s attention the questionability as to whether or not the experiment had followed traditional scientific manner. If the research does not follow ethical guidelines, then there is reason to believe the Stanford Prison Experiment was corrupt due to the lack information to participants, and absence of human morals Mr. Zimbardo portrayed during the time of his findings. Ethical rules provide the guidelines used to identify what is wrong and right. These decisions occur with the daily lives of average people, influencing the way they interact with the world. In the Prison Experiment, participants were not fully disclosed information about the study, resulting in stressful measures and ultimately traumatizing those who took part.

Read More
1564 Words | 7 Pages

The Belmont Report is now a required read for all participants involved in human research (ZZZ).   The Belmont Report addresses three ethical principles for human research participants.   One ethical principle is respect for the person.   Respect for the person requires medical researchers to obtain informed consent from study participants.   Additionally, the participants must be given accurate information about their circumstances and treatment options so they are allowed to decide what happens to them(ZZZ).

Read More
459 Words | 2 Pages

Diana Baumrind provides her reasoning on why the study of obedience was unethical. The study of obedience became one of the most controversial experiments in psychology.

Read More
794 Words | 4 Pages

Name: FerhinAkther Madonna Id: 250502 Subject: Medical Ethics-Assignment 1 Stanley Milgram Experiment At Yale University, Stanley Milgram a psychologist carried out the most famous study of obedience in psychology. The experiment was focused on the conflict between obedience to authority and personal ethics. In 1963, Milgram was interested in researching how far a person would go in obeying an instruction if it involved harming another person. Milgram was interested to see how an individual could be influenced by committing murders, for instance the Germans in World War II. Milgram wanted to investigate whether Germans were obedient to their superiors as that was the common explanation for assassinations in the Nazi in World War II.

Read More
2216 Words | 9 Pages

Without the subjects' knowledge or agreement, these tests were conducted with utter disregard for their welfare. The protection of human life and dignity cannot be compromised in the name of scientific progress. They serve as a sobering reminder of the value of sustaining moral standards in all scientific study and the ethical ramifications of these experiments, which are still being argued today. The legacy of the Nazi medical experiments serves as a sobering reminder of the atrocities that may be perpetrated in the name of a belief system and the repercussions of disrespecting human

Read More
1572 Words | 7 Pages

Consequently, patients did not have a proper informed consent or the required to skills or tools to make an educated decision to either continue with the research or to quit. The study went to great extent to prevent its participants from actually obtaining information about the purpose of the study and treatment when it became available. One of the examples in the study paper explains how the draft during World War II was abandoned specifically as it related to the Tuskegee participants. (cite) Patients were misled by coercion into accepting participation without a choice to make an educated decision to continue with the study that provided no

Read More
2332 Words | 10 Pages

The Stanford Prison Experiment, conducted by psychologist Philip Zimbardo in 1971, is one of the most infamous and controversial studies in the history of psychology. This study investigated the psychological effects of perceived power, specifically in the context of a simulated prison environment. However, the experiment quickly spiraled out of control and resulted in ethical concerns that continued to provoke discussions within the field of psychology. One of the primary ethical concerns surrounding the Stanford Prison Experiment is the lack of informed consent, the way participants were treated during the experiment, and how it continued. Participants were recruited for the study as it was advertised as a "psychological experiment" without being fully informed

Read More
540 Words | 3 Pages

Clinical trials have been a boon to modern medicine by broadening the knowledge surrounding disease plaguing the human race and providing a tangible measure of the success and symptoms of treatments to combat these diseases. However each progression in science comes with unintended consequences, in the case of clinical trials it was corruption at the expense of the human volunteers. The Tuskegee Study, conducted by the U.S. Public Health Service and Tuskegee Institute in 1932, is an infamous example of clinical trials crossing the ethical line. However what is ethics? As noted by The Basics of Social Research by Earl Babbie, ethics are a social construction and subjective.

Read More

More about Comparing The Project Camelot Study And Murray Center Experiments

Related Topics

Open Document