ipl-logo

Comparing The Protestant Ethic And The Spirit Of Capitalism By Max Weber

432 Words2 Pages

The “calling” and ascetic restrictions played an integral role in the development of capitalism. Through the increased desire to work, methodical and rational planning, In “The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism,” Max Weber argues that the “calling” and ascetic restrictions removed the human nature – that is to work only as much as necessary for survival – from the economic system. Once established, capitalism slowly removed these religious ideas and maintained the work ethic and the mentality on acquiring money intact as they were necessary for its survival. From removing human nature to maintaining the values, we shall explain how capitalism has been formed and changed by protestant religious idea; to become the capitalism we know …show more content…

In other words, a man only wants to have the comforts he has grown accustomed to and if given the choice, will only work just enough to still afford the comforts he enjoys. How then, does capitalism take shape? Through the protestant faith, this “nature” begins to dwindle as a need for salvation becomes prevalent among protestant followers. Salvation as it is understood here, can only be achieved by glorifying God through work. This work comes to be known as the “calling,” which describes each individuals “life-task” as each individual’s form of labor. Through this labor, salvation can be attained. The protestant faith goes on to explain how the labor is in fact glorifying God. If the labor in question creates wealth for the individual; it is a blessing and thus a sign of salvation from God. If however, wealth is attained through the pursuit of wealth itself, it is attributed to sin. There is then one other caveat, if the wealth is attained through glorifying works, but is then used to promote idleness or enjoyment not for the sake of glorifying God; it is attributed to sin. In other words, work is only glorifying God if it is done for the sake of work and nothing else. Since wealth was a sign of salvation from God, it made sense that protestant followers would attempt to make a profit to aid in their success of glorifying God, this lead to methodical and rational planning on all business

Show More
Related
1404 Words | 6 Pages

William T Cavanaugh (2008), wrote Being Consumed: Economics and Christian Desire which is a philosophical book, which focus on four (4) economic life matters that addresses the consumer culture within society. These four economic life matters are free market, consumerism, globalization and economic scarcity. In order for this topic to be discussed on a theological point of view, the author draws the reader’s attention to human life, the ends of life in God. The key question in every process is whether or not the transaction contributes to the flourishing of each person involved. In order to address these questions the author points to concrete examples of alternative economic practices in which Christians participate-: business, co-operatives, credit union, practices of consumption which marks the vision for Christian economic life.

Read More
1387 Words | 6 Pages

(Loc.8 and 14). Cavanaugh anwers and addresses these issues within the “four brief chapters” of his book. Thesis In the very beginning of Being Consumed, Cavanaugh states, “This book will be, I hope, a contribution to a kind of theological microeconomics. Rather than blessing or damning the ‘free market’ as such, I want to focus our attention on concrete Christian attempts to discern and create economic practices, spaces, and transactions that are truly free.”

Read More
908 Words | 4 Pages

In Jonathan Klemens’ essay “The Protestant Work Ethic Just Another Urban Legend,” Klemens goes in depth about the American work ethic. According to Klemens, the American work ethic is essential to Americans because it provides a strong economy, along with a strong society that keeps America going. The American work ethic is one that is represented through individuals who “provide both a service to society and personal satisfaction” (Klemens 122). Not only does Klemens argue that hard work and service are detrimental to society, but a strong commitment enhances one’s life’s devotion to work, along with one’s passion or “calling.” Furthermore, the work ethic is “firmly entrenched as a powerful and valued American social trait,” showing that hard work and dedication are core values ingrained within the lives of Americans.

Read More
471 Words | 2 Pages

As the country undergoes capitalism, class division is inevitable, leading to the takeover of semifeudal and monarchy over the feudal class. It ends the “feudal, patriarchal, idyllic relations”. Moreover, the bourgeoisie development also distorts the holy religious aspect to a selfish individual calculation, which is all about making benefits for oneself. Even the tight family relationship is also degraded to a mere “money relation”. Everything is for the purpose of monetary benefit of society and individuals.

Read More
1361 Words | 6 Pages

In “The Protestant Work Ethic: Just Another ‘Urban Legend?’” Jonathan Klemens states what the work ethic is and how it applies in American society. Klemens explains that the work ethic has helped the nation as a whole. Klemens explains that people work hard to achieve “the company or organization’s missions” (122). Not only that, Klemens also explains that people would work hard to gain the particular professions they desire instead of just working with no goals.

Read More
819 Words | 4 Pages

The business guys were very self-centered and didn’t care about the well-being of their employees. They demanded an abundant amount of back breaking work from their employee with no incentives for them. Many workers were getting annoyed with their bosses and wanted a change from them. the occurrence of The Working Man’s Prayer is a sarcastic critique of Andrew Carnegie’s philanthropy. In this critique, it is said how Carnegie lowers the pay of workers, how the workers are compared to slaves, and it says Carnegie spends workers’ wages in pleasuring himself with travels and goods.

Read More
340 Words | 2 Pages

He wrote "The Gospel of Wealth”. 2. This text is about the ‘evolution of labor’. It talked a little on how labor and capital fight and how they should combine. 3.

Read More
102 Words | 1 Pages

Abraham Lincoln deserved to be called the first statesman of America, because he really represented the saying that there are no rules in war. The constitution is the force of any country. However, with U.S during Lincoln’s administration it was the other way around as the historian George D. Fletcher says in his Our Secret Constitution that the country’s central constitutional event, the event from which it received its present meaning, is not the original founding but the civil war i.e. Lincoln took the task of a carpenter to reinterpret the Declaration of Independence and the constitution. He continues that civil

Read More
655 Words | 3 Pages

In the Bible, the “founder” of Christianity, Jesus, said, “a rich man shall hardly enter into the kingdom of heaven” (Doc. 1). Jesus spoke against the rich and said that Christian life and heaven would be easier to attain if one were poor. Also, the 10th century Christian St. Godric followed Jesus’ introductions and “sold all of his possessions and distributed them among the poor [and] coveted the life of a hermit” (Doc. 5). As a Christian merchant earlier in his life, he decided to give it all his wealth and live for Christ.

Read More
1450 Words | 6 Pages

In his famous Cross of Gold speech, Bryan uses a religious element to discuss the labour theory of economics and to illustrate the moral decline of the government. The true Americans are the “hardy pioneers who have braved all the dangers of the wilderness, who have made the desert to blossom as the rose- the pioneers away out there who rear their children near to Nature’s heart”. Not the … “few financial magnates who, in a back room, corner the money of the world”(811). This is what Bryan considers a problem in the United States. The true businessmen, the farmers and miners, who use their God-given talents, muscle and brain, to create wealth are being overlooked by the capitalists who call themselves businessmen.

Read More
1082 Words | 5 Pages

While it can be agreed upon that Jesus resented the qualities and attributes of those that are wealthy and love riches, it is apparent that He is not opposed to wealth as a whole. Wealth, in most cases, is a product of hard work and labor, which is often admired in the Bible. Jesus spoke of the importance of working for your deserved pay, something that is very relevant in a capitalist society. He commanded His disciples, “ ‘Go! I am sending you out like lambs among wolves.

Read More
998 Words | 4 Pages

As a whole, during the Gilded Age “the middle and upper-middle class seemed to be becoming, in part as a result of its wartime experience, less sensitive to the suffering and hardship of the poor” (Ginzberg 207). Subsequently, “[m]iddle-class Protestantism became increasingly defensive of privilege, insensitive to the poor, and harsh towards efforts to change from within” (Ginzberg 207). In fact, “[m]any ministers came to endorse a corporate defense of property and expressed hostility to labor organizing” and it was believed that in no place “did the business spirit find greater favor than in the Protestant church” (Ginzberg 207). Similarly, Carter finds that the Gilded Age “was a time when the gospel of Christ was felt to be in full harmony with the Gospel of Wealth” (Ginzberg 207 fix citation). Had it been religion that shaped the morals of the people during the Gilded Age then the protestant church still would have reflected the same “self giving love seen in Christ” (Latourette 83) that christianity was built on.

Read More
1451 Words | 6 Pages

Protestantism offers the concept of a worldly “calling” and also gives worldly activity a religious character. This implies to pursue profit but does not explain the need to. Weber argues that the spirit of modern capitalism views profit as an end in itself and pursuing profit as being noble and pure. He sees Calvinism as being the main source in explaining his

Read More
2521 Words | 11 Pages

Capitalism is a highly dynamic system which brought immense material wealth to the human society. This essay traces the historical dynamism of capitalism from its minority status to its majority status in term of demand and supply of investment capital. The emergence of capitalism as a mode of production out of pre-capitalist mode of production was fully formed by the mid-nineteenth century (Hobsbawn, Age of Capital: 1848-1875) this in no way implies that it was quantitatively dominant mode of production.

Read More
846 Words | 4 Pages

Capitalism is understood to be the “economic and political system in which a country's trade and industry are controlled by private owners for profit, rather than by the state.” In modern society, capitalism has become the dominant economic system and has become so integrated that it has resulted in a change in the relationships individuals have with other members of society and the materials within society. As a society, we have become alienated from other members of society and the materials that have become necessary to regulate ourselves within it, often materials that we ourselves, play a role in producing. Capitalism has resulted in a re-organization of societies, a more specialized and highly segmented division of labour one which maintains the status quo in society by alienating the individual. Karl Marx and Emile Durkheim theorize on how power is embodied within society and how it affects the individuals of society.

Read More

More about Comparing The Protestant Ethic And The Spirit Of Capitalism By Max Weber

Related Topics

Open Document