ipl-logo

Comparing The Third Wish And The Monkey's Paw

554 Words3 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: In the monkey's paw which detail foreshadows the results of the third wish

In this paper I will be explaining the differences in plot and mood of the stories “The Monkey's Paw” and “The Third Wish”. “The Monkey's Paw”, by W.W. Jacobs is about the cursed monkey's paw. When the White family becomes in possession of they are pleased to find they have three wishes, but they have three bad consequences. In “The Third Wish’, by Joan Aiken Mr. Peters is also rewarded with three wishes, however he is much carefuller with them.

The first difference between the two stories that I will be comparing is plot. The plot of “The Monkey's Paw’ begins with Mr. White obtaining the paw from an old friend, the Sergeant Major Morris. Despite the Sergeant Major's warnings, Mr. White made a wish. He wished for two hundred pounds to pay off the mortgage. But the next day they find their son, Herbert died while at work. To help them with their loss the company rewarded them two hundred pounds. Mrs.White, still not over the trauma and grief over the loss of her son, uses the paw to bring Herbert back. Mr.White fears that …show more content…

Peters driving down a forestry road when he hears a swan call in distress. He helped the creature escape and watched it turn into a little man who called himself the King of the Forest. He rewarded Mr. Peters with three wishes, but not before warning him to use them wisely. Mr. Peters did not want to waste any of his wishes, so he pricked his tongue with a thorn. For his first wish he wished for a wife as beautiful as the forest. A beautiful girl named Leita appeared and married him. They lived happily together for a long time until Mr. Peters noticed that she was spending more and more time by the river. He soon found out that Leita was once a swan and she was visiting her sister who was still a swan. Mr. Peters used his second wish to turn Leita back into a girl. He Lived a long and happy life with Leita and her sister visiting often, and never used his last wish because there was no need for

Show More
Related
458 Words | 2 Pages

Why did he take the paw if he knew what happened to the last man that had it? Tension was introduced by the author when the soldier threw the monkey’s paw upon a fire. When Mr. White retrieved it, Morris’ solemn response was, “Better let it burn.” This leaves the reader once

Read More
738 Words | 3 Pages

In the story, “The Monkey’s Paw,” by WW Jacobs, the White family have their friend, Sargent- Major Morris over at their house. With him, he brought stories of the wars he fought in, but he also brought the story of The Monkey’s Paw, which was a legend that said that the three people who were in possession of the monkey’s paw were granted three wishes. Mr. White received the monkey’s paw from Sargent Major and decided to make a wish. The course of his events, documented in the story, were soon made into a movie.

Read More
298 Words | 2 Pages

This paragraph is going to about the differences of the stories, “The Monkey’s Paw”, and “The Third Wish.”. So the differences of the moods are “The Monkey’s Paw.” is horror. The “The Third Wish” was happy

Read More
541 Words | 3 Pages

Sergeant Major Morris was conversing about the paw and the topic was unnecessary. Even if the family asked about it, he didn’t have to go into detail the way he did. “He wanted to show that fate ruled people’s lives’ and those who interfered with it did so to their sorrow…three separate men can have three wishes each.” Since the family saw this as a special offer, they were extremely curious and it was all because of Sergeant Major Morris, the only person who was capable of continuing the conversation. The details of the topic lead the family to desire to wish more.

Read More
2073 Words | 9 Pages

Mister White, being the third and final holder of the paw, wishes for two-hundred pounds to pay off the family’s mortgage. As a result of Mr. White’s selfishness and the paw’s

Read More
526 Words | 3 Pages

He was warned to wish conscientiously. When his wife appears, he is faced with a painstaking decision. “Poor Mr. Peters was very distressed on his wife's account and did his best to make her life happier” (Aiken 2). Mr. Peters loves his wife and he tries his best to satisfy her even though she is separated from her sister who is a swan. “Now he understood that Leita was really a swan

Read More
430 Words | 2 Pages

#1 about “The Monkey's Paw” The cause is that Morris said If you keep it, don't blame me for what happens. Sargent-Major Morris was the when Mr. White the paw, that night he gave it to him because he wanted it for it's power, Morris told Mr. White that the last wish will be evil. The fear in the charters words what they say it is like they

Read More
753 Words | 4 Pages

Imagine you were granted three wishes; and that's all. You can make whatever wishes you desire, but if not justifiable or reasonable, there could be a price to pay. The short story "The Monkey's Paw" by W.W. Jacobs discusses the alarming tale of an older couple being granted "three wishes" from a monkey's paw given to them. However, the purpose of the paw isn't to grant wishes; it is to show that you shouldn't change your fate. The film adaptation of the short story by Ricky Lewis Jr. also showcases that moral.

Read More
1566 Words | 7 Pages

Arthur St. John Adcock is an English novelist and poet as well as a journalist. He mentions that “the uncanny grimness of ‘The Monkey’s Paw’ by a pathos that is wrought to a pitch of almost painful intensity when the knock comes on the door at night and the heart-broken mother, after struggling desperately with the bolts, flings the door open and there is nothing there” (Adcock 3). The family makes an avoidable mistake by wishing with the monkey’s paw, but when they finally realize that, it is already too late. Their first innocent wish flips their lives upside down and they bring themselves irreversible pain and sorrow through a few words. Carl Mowery, a professor at several universities with a doctorate in rhetoric and composition, gives a great statement about the story as a whole.

Read More
764 Words | 4 Pages

In the other story “The Monkey’s Paw”, Mr. White’s

Read More
483 Words | 2 Pages

“(of the paw)...which betokened no great belief in its virtues.” This is foreshadowing later events in the story when the wish made by the monkey paw comes true. Jacobs adds onto the foreshadowing by writing the family making jokes about how the wish will come true the next morning. The quote, “She was watching the mysterious movements of a man outside…” leaves many questions in the reader’s mind. Neither the reader nor the character know who the enigmatic character is and what they are being introduced for.

Read More
916 Words | 4 Pages

Mr. White was still no happy at the end while Mr. Peters was. In “The Monkey’s Paw” and “The Third Wish,” the theme and the characters had many similarities and differences. The two short stories, “The Monkey’s Paw” and “The Third Wish” both express an important theme. The theme they both

Read More
546 Words | 3 Pages

In The Monkeys Paw, Mrs. White used the magical object (monkey’s paw). One out of the three wishes granted using the monkeys paw was to have her son back. The outcome of this was pounding at the door, not knowing exactly who was behind the door. The Monkeys Paw is all about granting wishes and not expecting its outcome. This is comparable to The Story of an Hour because Mrs. Mallard wished to have her husband back in her life, but she didn’t expect the outcome of actually seeing her husband alive.

Read More
582 Words | 3 Pages

The conflict in the story is not only the monkey’s paw but was somewhat Mr. White’s attitude. If he never was that greedy the story would have changed he would have agreed with Morris and burned the monkey’s paw but he didn’t want to do that creating the plot. Any change in the plot could have/ would have altered the course of the story but also altering the theme. In “The Monkey’s Paw,” the downfall of the White family is when they receive the two hundred pounds as a compensation for the son’s death which was actually caused by messing with fate.

Read More
825 Words | 4 Pages

In the short story, The Monkey 's Paw we are first introduced to the White, the Mrs.White, Mr.White, and their son, Herbert White. Later in the story, we are introduced to Sergeant Major Morris who brought the mummy-like monkey’s paw to the Whites house. The theme of the Monkey 's paw is to never interfere with fate. The theme is shown through many forms in the short story. The forms are the events, the foreshadowing, and the actions.

Read More

More about Comparing The Third Wish And The Monkey's Paw

Related Topics

Open Document