Simon J. Ortiz's "My Father's Song" and Seamus Heaney's "Digging" are two poems that explore the relationship between fathers and sons, and the roles that traditions and occupations play in shaping identity. Here's a comparison and contrast of these two poems.
One comparison between the two is the theme of family legacies. Both poems explore the idea of legacy, and how fathers pass down their traditions and occupations to their sons. Ortiz's poem is about his Native American father's connection to the land and nature, while Heaney's poem is about his father's connection to the soil and digging. Both poems show how the sons have inherited these legacies, but they have different perspectives on them. The use of imagery is another, both poets use imagery to create a sense of place and to take the emotions of their speakers. Ortiz's poem is full of descriptions of the natural world, such as the "soft damp sand" and the "sand moist clod". Heaney's poem uses imagery related to digging, such as "the coarse boot nestled on the lug", to create a sense of physical labor. Both are emotionally charged but in different ways. Ortiz's poem is more reflective as he
…show more content…
The cultural differences are reflected in the different traditions and occupations that are explored in the poems, as well as the different ways that the speakers relate to their fathers. The tone of the two poems is different. Ortiz's poem is humbler and more respectful, as he celebrates his father's connection to the land and the natural world. Heaney's poem is more hesitant, as he faces his own identity and his feelings of both admiration and guilt towards his father. The two poems use different styles of language. Ortiz's poem is more poetic, with repetition. While Heaney's poem is more straightforward and descriptive, with a focus on concrete