ipl-logo

Constitutional Convention Dbq Essay

1222 Words5 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Arguments between Federalists and Anti-Federalists

5
Introduction

The Constitutional Convention was called to order so that the Articles of Confederation could be amended. However, the Founders soon realized the Articles of Confederation provided an insufficient platform of which to erect necessary safeguards of democracy including, separation of powers, and federalism. Establishing a new constitution was not an easy feat. Many different clashing ideas would have to be weighed, measured, and agreed upon. In the end, Alexander Hamilton would reflect on the document, “For my own part, I sincerely esteem it a system, which, without the finger of God, never could have been suggested and agreed upon by such a diversity of interests.”[footnoteRef:1] [1: Ford, Paul Leicester, et al. Essays on the …show more content…

The initial lack of a Bill of Rights was the chief objection of the antifederalist[footnoteRef:8] The antifederalist were concerned over local control of civil liberties. However, Federalist insisted the because the Constitution gave the federal government only certain delegated powers, a Bill of Rights was not needed.[footnoteRef:9] Additionally, federalist argued that enumerating individual rights could be dangerous because it may be interpreted as a comprehensive list, thus forfeiting unmentioned rights.[footnoteRef:10] Eventually, the Bill of Rights was adopted and ratified. However, the Bill of Rights was not as comprehensive as Thomas Jefferson had proposed.[footnoteRef:11] For example, Jefferson proposal featured far more extensive language in his proposals for the right to trial by jury, provisions regarding standing armies, writs of habeas corpus, alongside other concerns.[footnoteRef:12] While the ambiguity of the Founding Fathers may be genius on the one hand, on the other hand, history has supported the need to “spell it out.” If the Founding Fathers were aware of how ignorant the citizens of 2017 would be regarding foundational concepts of the Constitution, one must wonder if they would have implemented additional safeguards even beyond the Bill of Rights. [8: Ibid.,349] …show more content…

Finding answers to these challenges was difficult due to the plethora of positions on various issues. The delegates were faced with issues surrounding popular and political sovereignty. The founders were faced with the challenge of how to ensure the people and states were properly represented in electoral politics. Proper representation would ensure the United States Government operated under the “consent of the governed.” Additionally, while the Constitution implied certain liberties, the Bill of Rights was created to protect civil liberties further. The Bill of rights contained the most important accomplishment of the convention-The Establishment Clause. The Establishment Clause was designed to protect religion from government infringement. It’s survival and proper interpretation, may directly correlate to the survival of the United

Show More
Related

Confederation Vs Constitution Dbq Essay

656 Words | 3 Pages

Therefore, the anti-federalist proposed the Bill of Rights to be added along with the Constitution. The Anti-federalist felt secure with the Bill of Rights in the Constitution because it protects citizens liberty and freedom. In the end, the founding fathers gathered and agreed to add the Bill of Rights when ratifying the Constitution. Furthermore, Anti-federalists were mainly farmers and they feared that under the Constitution economic policies their business will be endanger.

Read More

Shay's Rebellion Dbq Essay

867 Words | 4 Pages

In the late 1700’s, it was America’s goal to create a republic that had a representative government that was based upon the approval of the people. Unfortunately, the people feared a strong central government because of the previous trouble the colonies had when they were ruled by Britain. They were always being unfairly taxed and had very few rights. In order to avoid this, a very weak government was developed that seemed to satisfy the people, but would not satisfy the well being of the country. It wasn’t until Shay’s rebellion which brought light to the fact that the Articles of Confederation were not going to cut it, so the Constitutional Convention was created and convened to find an alternative solution which was the creation of the Constitution.

Read More

DBQ Essay: The United States Constitution

1159 Words | 5 Pages

DBQ Essay The United States Constitution is a document that or founding fathers made in order to replace the failing Articles of Confederation (A of C). Under the Constitution, the current government and states don’t have the problems they faced when the A of C was in action. The Constitution was created in 1788, and held an idea that the whole nation was nervous about. This idea was a strong national government, and the Federalist assured the people that this new government would work. The framers of the Constitution decided to give more power to the Federal government rather than the state governments because the A of C had many problems, there was a need for the layout of new government, rights, and laws, and there was a need for the Federal

Read More

Compare And Contrast The Three Fifths Compromise

1157 Words | 5 Pages

In Massachusetts, the Anti-Federalists, led by James Madison, argued that the Bill of Rights was necessary to protect people rights from the government because the government might get too powerful and hurt people’s rights and freedom. They had this fear because they suffered from the British tyranny and worried that the highly centralized government would make the miserable history happen again. Nevertheless, in favor of the government, the Federalists insisted that the Bill of Rights were unnecessary because the Constitution already limited the power of government, so it would not get too powerful. Also, they worried that people might forget to list certain rights in the Bill of Rights, so if later they were fighting for their rights that were not written in the document, the government might use it against them. Eventually, a compromise was made through a vote in Massachusetts; Anti-Federalists agreed to ratify the Constitution without the Bill of Rights, but they should also submit amendments for the Congress to consider adding the Bill of Rights.

Read More

Constitutional Convention Dbq

398 Words | 2 Pages

The Constitutional Convention took place from May 25th, 1787 to September 17th, 1787 in the city of Philadelphia. The official purpose of the convention was to amend the articles of Confederation/ how the country was going to be governed. Although the convention had been called for revising the Articles of Confederation, two delegates (James Madison and Alexander Hamilton) wanted to make a totally new government. Seventy delegates from each original state were supposed to come to the Constitutional Convention, but only 55 out of the 70 arrived. The first two months of debating were only about the 15 points of the “Virginia Plan” that James Madison thought of to replace the Articles of Confederation.

Read More

Pros And Cons Of The Articles Of Confederation

1471 Words | 6 Pages

The Thirteen Colonies had now been free for a while and had grown into a nation with an abundance of land with a strong sense of responsibility. The United States of America was not like the other nations found throughout the world. It differed though its principals and morals, it radiated a sense of comfort and freedom that was hard to find anywhere else. However, it still lacked a strong government that could support such an important and developing nation. The Articles of Confederation had its achievements that supported it; however, it also had its great shortcomings that made the nation doubt its support to the large nation.

Read More

Ratification Of The Us Constitution Dbq Essay

827 Words | 4 Pages

Hence Federalists came up with the Bill of Rights as a way to get the Constitution ratified and for people to really see a needed change. The Bill Of Rights which lists specific prohibitions on governmental power, lead the Anti-Federalists to be less fearful of the new Constitution . This guaranteed that the people would still remain to have rights, but the strong central government that the country needed would have to be approved. The 1804 Map of the nation shows that even after the ratification of the United States Constitution there still continued to be “commotion” and dispute in the country.(Document 8) George Washington stated that the people should have a say in the nation and government and everything should not be left to the government to decide.(Document 3) Although George Washington was a Federalist many believed he showed a point of view that seemed to be Anti-Federalists. Many believed that The Bill of Rights needed to be changed and modified and a new document’s time to come into place.

Read More

Analysis Of The Constitution Dbq Essay

959 Words | 4 Pages

The Constitution of the United States, created in 1787 in hands down the most creatively named building ever, (Independence Hall, pfffft.) has been symbolic of liberty in America. Abraham Lincoln once said that “Don’t interfere with anything in the Constitution. That must be maintained, for it is the only safeguard for our liberties.” Do you agree with this quote? (I mean, this is the same guy that said “When I do bad, I feel bad.

Read More

Constitution Of 1787 Dbq Essay

1020 Words | 5 Pages

To them, it was clear that the Articles of Confederation were not upholding America, and therefore, America could not succeed. While they did to some extent listen to the fears of the Antifederalists—as is evidenced by the passing of the Bill of Rights—they altogether tended to be more optimistic when it came to the Constitution. One of the founding principles of the Federalist Party was their support of a strong central government. A strong central government would provide needed stability, more so than the Articles of Confederation ever could. The Federalists were also generally less concerned with ensuring individual’s rights, as many of them felt it was the government’s duty to serve the people, and such rights did not need to be formally written because they should already be in place.

Read More

Constitutional Convention Dbq Essay

629 Words | 3 Pages

Not long after the Constitutional Convention of 1787 had ended and the Constitution had been introduced to the American people for the ratification, there was a debate regarding those who supported the Constitution (Federalists) and those who opposed it (Anti-Federalists). Among those debates, one of the most central debates was whether to unite the thirteen states into a great nation or under the federal government. Perhaps, this question was the reason why some of the delegates kept their mouth shut in Philadelphia. Outstanding delegates such as James Madison and James Wilson had developed a plan that would renovate the American Union from loose independent states to a central nation that under the control of federal government but still

Read More

Explain What Compromises Were Made At The Constitutional Convention

705 Words | 3 Pages

It took the convincing of the Anti-Federalists to explain how the Constitution gave too much power to the central government and did not state the rights and freedoms of the people, therefore lacking a Bill of Rights. The Federalists agreed to a Bill of Rights, and later the Constitution was ratified with nine out of thirteen votes on June 21 of 1788. Soon after the Constitution was ratified, the separation of powers was understood in the United States government. The separation of powers separated each branch of government.

Read More

John Proctor And Gamble Essay

1091 Words | 5 Pages

Anthony​ ​Bell​ ​II Mrs.​ ​Brubaker AP​ ​US​ ​History​ ​Period​ ​5 25​ ​September​ ​2017 Interpreting​ ​The​ ​Constitution The​ ​foundation​ ​of​ ​American​ ​democracy​ ​lies​ ​within​ ​our​ ​most​ ​important​ ​document,​ ​the​ ​US Constitution.​ ​​ ​However,​ ​since​ ​this​ ​document​ ​was​ ​created​ ​there​ ​have​ ​been​ ​those​ ​who​ ​believed​ ​that it​ ​was​ ​to​ ​be​ ​interpreted​ ​exactly​ ​as​ ​it​ ​was​ ​written​ ​and​ ​there​ ​have​ ​been​ ​those​ ​who​ ​believed​ ​that​ ​it was​ ​open​ ​for​ ​interpretation.​ ​​ ​The​ ​federalists,​ ​led​ ​by​ ​Alexander​ ​Hamilton​ ​believed​ ​in​ ​a​ ​loose interpretation,​ ​while​ ​the​

Read More

Dbq Anti Federalism

239 Words | 1 Pages

The arguments between the Federalist and Massachusetts Anti-Federalist caused by Federalist paper #84 would have been very difficult to resolve without modifications to the items that were to be included in the Constitution like the Bill of Rights. The Bill of Rights were considered to be relevant and deleterious to the Constitution by Federalist Alexander Hamilton, who stated in the essay Federalist Paper #84 that the Bill of Rights is “...not only unnecessary in the proposed Constitution, but would even be dangerous.” In addition Hamilton pointed out that many natural rights, like the right to redress grievances, were already implied in the body of the Constitution, therefore no further listing was necessary. However, Anti-Federalist counteracted

Read More

Ratification Of The Constitution Dbq Essay

1004 Words | 5 Pages

Following the end of the American Revolution marked a new set of problems for the United States. As impending war debts were threatening to crush the new nation, America knew they needed to address the flaws of the Articles of Confederation through a Constitutional Convention. The United States Constitution of 1787 was created in hopes of developing a stronger and more effective governing body while still upholding America’s virtues of freedom. Unfortunately, with change, comes opposition, and many people feared that the Constitution would be oppressive and undermine the autonomy of the individual states through its strong central government. Because of this, the issues that sparked the greatest controversies during the ratification of the

Read More

Analysis Of Compromises Made At The Constitutional Convention

1185 Words | 5 Pages

Compromises Made at the Constitutional Convention Under the Articles of Confederation the government was weak and had little success. Shay’s Rebellion led to the changing of the laws made on the government under the Articles of Confederation. It also led to a convention which introduced the idea of making a new form of government. In 1787 the Constitutional Convention awoke the ideas of making new compromises that the Founding Fathers had to face. Two of the most important compromises included the voting on president which was called the electoral college system and the decision making of how to ratify the Constitution.

Read More

More about Constitutional Convention Dbq Essay

Related Topics

Open Document