ipl-logo

Constitutional Differences And Similarities Between The United States And Russian Federation

778 Words4 Pages

With 195 countries throughout the world, there are varying policies and rights given to citizens of each. These policies and rights provided to the citizens are typically stated through the constitution of the country, with areas that compare and others that contrast. Constitutions of the United States and Russian Federation follow this pattern; these differences and similarities can lead to a different meaning of being a good citizen of a particular country. Constitutional and governmental policies of Russia and the United States share commonalities and differences, with similarities and differences of being a good citizen in each.
To begin with, numerous resemblances are embedded within the two constitutional documents of the US and Russia, …show more content…

One of those contrasting points are the differences in the balances of powers. In the Russian Federation, the Executive Branch, specifically the president, appears more powerful than the other two branches, legislative and judicial. The only power the legislative and judicial branches have to prevent the president from becoming too powerful is the act of impeaching him. This is dissimilar to the United States where there is an accepted system of checks and balances that prevents one branch from becoming more powerful than the other two. An additional point of diversity of the two are the governmental structures. Although Russia states in the preamble they want to practice a democracy, their methods point more toward a republic. Some of these republican ways include their system of proposing amendments, where only state representatives can propose them. This amendment proposal process is different than the United States where the citizen themselves has the ability to propose the amendment, such as through a convention. The Russian Federation is further proven closer to a representative government as the president appoints the state representatives, in opposition to the people of the state appointing representatives in the United States. Plus, the structure of the Russia’s government involves granting immunities to many of its

Show More
Related

Explain How Does The Federal Government Regulate The Economy

279 Words | 2 Pages

How does the federal government regulate the economy for the benefit of the public? Discuss specific policies and programs, including their effects. The federal government has many programs and abilities to regulate the United States economy. On of which is the fiscal policy which allows government to raise and spend money.

Read More

Comparing The US Constitution And NYS Constitution

497 Words | 2 Pages

The U.S constitution and NYS constitution are similar regarding separation of powers divided among the executive, legislation and judicial and were the intention of establishing local authorities to protect people ’s right. As Bowman state, state constitution represents the fundamental laws of that state, which provide a set of rules, regulations, and procedures (Bowman 47-48). These constitutions were designed similar to the US, therefore transferring over its strengths and weakness. In NYS constitution, the legislation lies with the senate and assembly, the governor holds the executive power, but it does not specify it judicial roles, except for the court systems (Pecorella and Stonecash 106 and 113).

Read More

Similarities Between Us And Texas Constitution

985 Words | 4 Pages

and Texas Constitutions are similar documents. They both represent the principles of representative democratic government, in which power originated from the people. Both contain a bill of rights that protects civil liberties from government infringement, both provide for two branches of legislature with a House of Representatives and a Senate and both request a system of checks and balances and separation of powers between legislative, executive, and judicial branches of government. They also both divide government power between upper and lower levels of government. In the U.S. Constitution the states are subordinate to the federal government, and in the Texas Constitution the counties are subordinate to the state government.

Read More

Similarities And Differences Between Russia And North America

947 Words | 4 Pages

CIV 102: Essay Outline Name: Dawar Fuad Section: 2 Question: Compare and contrast the fur trade in North America with the fur trade in Siberia. Context: In the early modern era, the process of global commerce started to gradually appear between the prominent empires and states. The merchants had focused on only some specific types of materials to trade with, and one of the most profitable materials was the “soft gold” fur. Europeans and Russians were at the top of this trade process because they had a giant access to a numerous number of fur-bearing animals in their colonies in North America and Siberia.

Read More

Similarities Between Constitution And Iroquois Constitution

542 Words | 3 Pages

To show that there are similarities and differences you have to give examples. It became obvious that both sets of constitutions had it in their seams to protect the government and keep the people at peace. Yet a subtle

Read More

Summary Of Tocqueville's Footsteps Of The Good Citizen

2049 Words | 9 Pages

Introduction In the chapter 8 named In Tocqueville’s Footsteps of The Good Citizen, Russell Dalton (2008) strengthens his argument about changing citizenship norms in the United States by comparing with other advanced democratic nations. Dalton (2008, 139) emphasizes how crucial cross-national comparisons are in a national political analysis by quoting the well-known saying of Seymour Martin Lipset, an expert in contemporary chronicler of American society and politics, as “those who know only one country, know no country”. By comparing nineteen advanced industrial democracies with the America, Dalton (2008, 142) determines that there are many similarities as well as differences of norms changes in the United States and in those democratic

Read More

Stoner And Mcfaul's Essay

502 Words | 3 Pages

Russians need protection from these dangerous Western ideas.” This statement is worth considering for. The lists of dissents given regarding

Read More

Russia Government Vs Us Government Essay

1342 Words | 6 Pages

Additionally, the Russian government runs on a federation while the United States operates on a Constitution-based federal republic; having a strong democratic tradition. About the Legal System, Russia mainly uses the civil law system which in other words is the judicial review of legislature acts, and the U.S. government uses the Common Law System which is based on the English Common Law from the federal level; using state legal systems based on Common Law except for Louisiana. Lastly, relating to the basis of executive legitimacy, Russia’s presidency is independent of legislature meaning the ministry focused on the parliamentary confidence, while the U.S. presidency is independent of primarily the

Read More

Essay Comparing The Oklahoma Constitution And The United States Constitution

481 Words | 2 Pages

The Oklahoma Constitution and the United States Constitution have a variety of similarities and differences, thus creating an array of topics of discussion. The very structure of the state 's constitution holds close similarities to the U.S. Constitution, given the fact that it was ratified over a century later. At the time of the making of the Oklahoma Constitution, there were arguments between the left and right areas of the state. These arguments were based on the fact that the people involved in the making of the state 's constitution wanted to have the area that was labeled "Indian territory" and make it a secure part of the state of Oklahoma. After doing so, the two areas merged and created the document that the state still uses to this day.

Read More

The Funeral Home Summary

674 Words | 3 Pages

In a way, the Russians are mirroring what America did to the Western Hemisphere in terms of spreading their governance policies and ideologies. In addition, Russia also started putting certain political groups in power, most notably the communist party in Germany, which would look suspicious and biased from Winston Churchill’s perspective. Unfortunately for Germany, doing this will only end up conflicting the country, because half of it is already being influenced by western ideology, and now putting in Russian influence on the eastern part of the country will only serve to set the people up for separation and segregation based on different ways of life and

Read More

Compare And Contrast The Articles Of Confederation And Us Constitution

823 Words | 4 Pages

Articles of Confederation vs. U.S. Constitution The Articles of the Confederation and the U.S. Constitution are two articles that where written and accepted by the United States as a foundation for their new government. They are both very important documents that have similarities and differences. Some of the main things the Articles of Confederation and the U.S. Constitution have in common is that they addressed the needs of its constituencies.

Read More

Comparing The Missouri Constitution And The United States Constitution

895 Words | 4 Pages

The Missouri Constitution and the United States constitution cover the same ideas including bills, taxes, and powers. The constitutions have an option to change and or add to them. The constitutions also contain a rule stating a certain amount of votes are needed to change

Read More

Republicanism Vs Absolute Monarchy Essay

1043 Words | 5 Pages

Systems of government are ensured to maintain structure in order for nations to develop significantly. Various systems are supported by different political principles, ideologies and distinctive ways of leading a civilization. Governments are formed to provide economic security for the welfare of their inhabitants and protect people’s rights. (Oak) Republicanism and absolute monarchy are examples of two contrasting systems due to their own strengths and weaknesses. Burkina Faso accepted a parliamentary republic but recently faced civil political tensions.

Read More

Advantages And Disadvantages Of American Imperialism

233 Words | 1 Pages

Greetings classmates or commodores, The climate of Russia is harsh, continuous and very cold. The advantage for the imperialist was just the sheer size of Siberia. The Ural Mountains and Caucus Mountains have acted as buffers.   the Great expanded Russia. Peter the Great modernized Russia.

Read More

Russian Federalism Analysis

1617 Words | 7 Pages

Russian Federalism - a unique combination of constitutional , political and socio-economic asymmetry- has been governed by extra-legal, political and economic relations rather than constitutionalism and the rule of law . The Russian state that rose out of the ruins of the Soviet Union in January 1992, characterized a highly authoritative political culture accompanied by a weak and an immature civil society. Post communist elites have maneuvered federalism essentially as a protective cloak for the advancement of their own narrow political and economic interests and as a bulwark to carve out electoral dictatorships. Under the presidency of Putin, the principles of federalism and democracy have come under attack and electoral authoritarianism

Read More

More about Constitutional Differences And Similarities Between The United States And Russian Federation

Related Topics

Open Document