ipl-logo

Criticism Of The Canadian Childcare System

420 Words2 Pages

Criticism from certain provinces regarding the federal government's initiative to establish a Canada-wide early learning and childcare system stems from longstanding debates about federalism in Canada. At its essence, federalism in Canada delineates powers and responsibilities between the federal and provincial governments, aiming to strike a balance between national cohesion and regional autonomy, as expressed in class discussions as "a will to live together and a will to live apart" (La Selva, 1996). The roots of this criticism can be traced to historical tensions between federal and provincial authorities over jurisdictional boundaries. Rooted in classical federalism, provinces often advocate for increased autonomy and control over policy domains within their purview, including crucial areas like childcare. Provinces contend that decisions regarding childcare should rest within provincial purview, where governments possess insight into local needs and preferences, rather than at the national level, where the unique demands of each community may not be adequately addressed. Consequently, the federal government's endeavor to implement this system, while …show more content…

The discourse on federalism encompasses jurisdictional dynamics between provinces and the federal government, underscoring the transition from classical federalism to interdependent federalism (Wallner, pg160-162). The latter entails a symbiotic relationship between federal and provincial jurisdictions, fostering cooperation and compromise for mutual benefit, while upholding provincial autonomy and contributing to national imperatives. However, opposing viewpoints advocate for a more centralized government to ensure uniform access for Canadians regardless of their province of residence, and to maintain consistency across the

Show More
Related
2747 Words | 11 Pages

Additionally, Trudeau then was tasked with attempting to negotiate a settlement with the reluctant premiers, which argues that Trudeau's strategic maneuvers and the premiers' unyielding resistance reflect the clash between centralizing and decentralizing forces within Canada's political landscape. The disagreement over the language rights made the settlement process far more complicated than expected. The amending formula and the provisions on language rights became central points of contention, reflecting the deeply entrenched regional divisions and divergent views on federalism and individual rights. Trudeau was very passionate about his version of the Charter, and Graham argues that Trudeau used his abilities and background in his longstanding commitment to human rights and democratic freedoms, shaped by his experiences as a student and his efforts to combat oppression and discrimination in Quebec in the 1940s to push for said

Read More
597 Words | 3 Pages

An example of Federal governments making it difficult for provincial governments would be when the Federal government challenged Premier Dufferin Pattullo’s authority. He had introduced reforms to shorten the workday,increase minimum wage and increase relief payments, he also attempted to introduce many projects into BC. However, the federal government challenged his authority and didn’t allow him to carry out those

Read More
1182 Words | 5 Pages

The accord encompasses the larger debate over centralization and decentralization in the Canadian government.

Read More
987 Words | 4 Pages

For example, when the Parti Québécois leader René Lévesque proposed a sovereignty-association with Canada, which would enable Quebec to have political independence however they would have close economic ties with Canada in 1980, a separation seemed possible (Archibald, 2016). The referendum for a consensus on the sovereignty-association, held in May of 1980, resulted in a 60 percent rejection and thus the sovereignty-association between Quebec and Canada was not carried out (Hudon, 2013). Although the sovereignty-association referendum had ultimately failed, the Parti Québécois were re-elected in 1981, indicating that separatism itself had not yet died in the province and thus, the threat of Quebec’s independence was still very present (Stein, 2006). Quebec also isolated themselves from Canada when they had disagreed with the patriated and new Constitution in 1981, as their government felt that they were still not equal in comparison to the other provinces (Gall, 2006). All things considered, Quebec’s possible freedom from Canada became a real possibility in the 1980s and the threat of separatism was a key factor in the change of Quebec

Read More
1106 Words | 5 Pages

Interactions amid the provinces and the federal government, from constitutional issues to the most irresistible topics bang up-to-date in the country, are indemnified beneath the umbrella of “Federalism”. Authorities are shared so that on some matters, the state governments are decision-holders, whereas on the other matters, national government grasps the autonomy. In last twenty-five years, the upsurge of federal fiats on both governments, local and state, has shifted the power amongst state and national governments. Now, the national government is beginning to have more governance over the state’s engagements.

Read More
876 Words | 4 Pages

“Trudeaumania swept across Canada…for a few warm spring months in 1968 Pierre Elliot Trudeau synthesized the dreams, achievements, and illusions of the liberation era.” (Fellows and Wells, 2013). Trudeau ran under the slogan of creating “the Just Society” (Fellows and Wells, 2013) in Canada, and unlike Diefenbaker, Trudeau would manage to achieve what he promised the public. While Trudeau was in office he managed to implement reforms that expanded welfare, enabled parliament to be more efficient, and established true universal healthcare in Canada (Fellows and Wells, 2013) . All of these changes and reform were things that others had promised previous to Trudeau but constantly failed to

Read More
864 Words | 4 Pages

Today, with the Liberal Party of Quebec’s new leader, Philippe Couillard, showing his intentions to finally sign the Constitution, the relationship between Canada and Quebec has never been better. However, this relationship did not just seemingly appear out of nowhere; rather, Canada and Quebec have had their fair share of disagreements. These quarrels helped to shape their relationship into what it is now. Ultimately, most of these disagreements were caused by the differing views on the education system and the French Canadians, the importance of the English and French language, and the provincial status of Quebec.

Read More
728 Words | 3 Pages

While researching and analyzing the topic of absolutism, which relates to the conflicts between Liberalism and Conservatism, the conflict arises from both ideologies adhering to their traditional doctrine and belief as well as an absence of flexibility by both sides. I gravitated towards researching different influences on political policy and analyzing these policies and political ideologies from a Stability and Change perspective. Beyond this, I was able to focus specifically on the causes of political Stability and Change within Canadian politics, chiefly federal. Canadian politics lacks the inflexibility highlighted traditional meaning of the word; this has enabled Canada to harass the best of both ideologies, beneficially affecting our society.

Read More
1515 Words | 7 Pages

316). Rocher draws upon the same historical timeline as Trudeau when he alludes to the period of modernization in Quebec after WWII, however he focuses on the distribution of autonomy and responsibility to provinces for managing their own institutions separate from the central government (p. 316). The transfer of health care, education, social services, and economic development was representative of the pragmatism of the constitution and the sharing of jurisdictions between regional and central governments (p. 316). Although there is no mention of the role of nationalism by Rocher, he thoroughly mentions the role the central government plays in ensuring national unity, he describes the position of the federal government as “having to consult, coordinate and, inevitably, compromise in the face of mounting federal-provincial conflict”, this is connected to the discussion of compromise between the central and regional governments described by Trudeau (p.

Read More
1016 Words | 5 Pages

The 60's Scoop was a tragic time in Canada when many Indigenous children were taken away from their families and communities and placed in non-Indigenous homes or institutions. It lasted from the late 1950s to the early 1980s and was part of government policies to make Indigenous people conform to mainstream Canadian society. This caused trauma, cultural and identity loss, and other long-term effects for many survivors. In this essay, we will look at the history of it and how it came to be in canada and the history of it, how this system discriminatory against First Nations, Inuit and Metis peoples, and what were the long term effects of the foster care system/ 1960s scoop on identity, family relationships, parenting, culture, spirituality,

Read More
1122 Words | 5 Pages

In many countries, conflict between different groups of people is inevitable. In Canada, the divide between English-speaking and French-speaking regions has been a prominent political and cultural topic since the birth of the nation. The most well known of these conflicts goes to Quebec. The province has sprouted several movements and parties supporting the autonomy and independence of Quebec. One of those parties is the Bloc Quebecois.

Read More
452 Words | 2 Pages

Martin Luther played an important role in The Renaissance causing people to question and turn away from the church. Martin Luther was born on 1453 in Germany. He was a strong follower of Catholicism. In 1505 he quit law school to become a monk. A few years later in 1511, he received his doctorate from the University of Wittenberg and began teaching many aspects of the Bible.

Read More
1417 Words | 6 Pages

In this essay I will be considering how innovations in theory, policy and research have influenced the development of coordination, partnership and integration in childhood practice in my childcare setting in Scotland. I will analyse the development of policies concerning children and young people in relation to my setting and the professional groups involved within my setting. This will include the introduction of building the ambition and the Children and Young People (Scotland) Act 2014, which from 2016 will enforce the need for the named person to take any concerns seriously and report as required. It will also increase provision to 600 hours which in turn will help to safeguard vulnerable two year olds by placing them into early year’s

Read More
1081 Words | 5 Pages

For instance emotional disturbance, specific learning disabilities and autism (Hill, 2009). When a social worker takes a child into custody that child has just became a child of the state or some would say basically their child and responsibility. That leaves the social worker taking that child to doctor appointments and make sure the child is in a foster home that is taking care of the child’s need. The funding for this policy comes from the federal government, state systems, and local systems (A legacy training module from NICHCY, 2014). Most children that are in the system are supplied with Medicaid, and sometimes receives a check from the government if they are physically disabled or

Read More
835 Words | 4 Pages

McKeen (2006) explains that the framework of the current child welfare approaches was directed from the dominant discourse of ‘national children’s agenda’ initiatives. Since then, there have been many major changes happened in the mainstream social policy in child welfare sector. The national and global political influences and world economic pressure forces federal and provincial governments to control the social security and welfare programs and it reflects in child welfare system too (McKeen, 2006). Politics in Canada has a serious notion on key ideologies while restructuring child welfare policies (McKeen, 2006). Ontario’s Child and Family service Act 1984, was developed on the principle of minimal family intervention with a view that children need to be protected in their own homes (Dumbrill, 2006b).

Read More

More about Criticism Of The Canadian Childcare System

Open Document