ipl-logo

Cultural Relativist Critique

1157 Words5 Pages

The journal “Cultural Relativist and Feminist Critiques of International Human Rights – Friends or Foes?” by Oonagh Reitman discuss the critiques of international human rights from cultural relativists and feminists. This journal divided into three main points, such as cultural relativism of Women’s Human Rights, Comparing the Cultural Relativist and Feminist Critiques of Human Rights, and Towards a Cooperative Approach. II. SUMMARY This section contains a summary of “Cultural Relativist and Feminist Critiques of International Human Rights – Friends or Foes?”. Oonagh begins her journal by stating that her purpose in writing the journal is to describe how these two critiques have come to against each other in the world of women’s international human rights. At the first section, it discusses the exposition of cultural relativist arguments that created in the term of women’s human rights. It explained through the crossing and disagreement between the feminist and relativist critiques. The first section also discusses about the suggestions over cultural relativism that likely have a negative effect on the implementation of women’s human rights. It discusses that cultural relativism brings bad influence towards feminist. Then, the second section discusses the comparison between …show more content…

Although there is almost all countries all over the world have signed the Convention on the Elimination of all Forms of Discrimination against Women (CEDAW), but it is very difficult to overcome the discrimination of women in practice. Human rights are rights that given to all human beings, regardless our sex, ethnic origin, color, religion, status, language, or nationality. In other words, each of us has rights to be treated equally, especially no discrimination between men and

Show More
Related

Oonagh Reitman's Journal Analysis

65 Words | 1 Pages

This journal by Oonagh Reitman is discussing about the similarities critiques regarding international human rights by two different perspectives, cultural relativism and feminism. The author argue that even though both have similarities in the critique, they actually have a strong contrary definition and perspective about the human rights itself. Besides, the author also pointed out the critique from cultural relativist to feminist and vice

Read More

Ruth Benedict's Argument For Cultural Relativism

141 Words | 1 Pages

James Rachels has a better argument than Ruth Benedict in defending Moral or Cultural relativism. Rachel agreed that the fact supporting the proposition for Cultural Relativism does not support the argument. Benedict argues from a functionality standpoint, where she used certain human traits to support her argument as being abhorrent in some society but being adequately functional in another society. Though Rachel and Benedict still drew the same analogy of using Homosexuality as an example of abhorrence in one society as being acceptable in another, Rachel argues that it is a matter of moral relativism and cannot be right or wrong, rather it depends on the society one is drawing his or her moral codes from, but Benedict is arguing from the

Read More

A Rhetorical Analysis Of Hillary Clinton's Struggle For Women

1477 Words | 6 Pages

The year of 1995 was a pivotal time regarding women’s rights. It was also a time in which society was rapidly changing due to increased activism, more global connections, and technological advancements. As the first lady at the time, Hillary Clinton was invited to speak at the fourth United Nations women’s conference in Beijing China, discussing the struggle for women’s equality. In her 1995 speech, Clinton asserted the importance of acknowledging women’s rights as human rights through the use of emphasis and appeals.

Read More

Argument Against Cultural Relativism

979 Words | 4 Pages

Introduction Ethics plays a central role in shaping the direction that different societies take. Primarily, societies fashion the governing norms based on predefined sets of ethical standards that act as guidelines. Nevertheless, the pretexts used in developing these norms vary from one society to another, thereby creating a conflict in the level of objectivity of each premise. Argument Against Cultural Relativism

Read More

Ethical Relativism Is False

234 Words | 1 Pages

In this paper, I will argue that ethical relativism is false because there must be a standard higher than culture to judge the rightness or wrongness of an action. I understand that we have to respect other cultures, but I think it is important to bring up that some cultures can violate human rights. I wanted to bring to your attention that it’s happening every day all around the world. Argument: 1.

Read More

Cultural Relativism: Rites Of Passage

1580 Words | 7 Pages

Cultural relativism is the understanding of other cultures in their own terms. To achieve the understanding of the rituals used in the cultures of another, one must be able to look at them from an emic (insider) perspective. One must also be able to look at his own culture from an etic (outsider) perspective. The ability to look at one’s culture from the etic point of view will make it easier to explain the rituals to someone from a different culture, for example, rites of passage. Rites of passage are used to mark a life stage and are celebrated by tradition or religion, meant to separate a specific group.

Read More

Who Is Machiavelli's The Prince Still Relevant Today?

871 Words | 4 Pages

). Gender is a socially and historical constructed concept, and has asymmetrical power in international relations, often excluding women from political life (Tickner and Sjoberg 2013: 206; True 2001: 236-237). Realists argue that they have put forward an objective and universal knowledge, however feminists argue that their ‘knowledge’ is socially constructed and favours the masculine ideals, and either denying or misrepresenting the women in politics (Tickner 1988: 432; Alexandre 1989: 6 cited in True 2001: 240). As argued by Cynthia Enloe, women have always been a part of international relations but have largely been ignored (True 2001: 239).

Read More

Cultural Relativist And Feminist Critique Of 'Friends Or Foes'

1469 Words | 6 Pages

Reitman, Oonagh. " Cultural Relativist and Feminist Critiques of International Human Rights—Fiends or Foes?. " Statsvetenskaplig tidskrift 100, no. 1 (1997), 100-110. The journal entitled “Cultural Relativist and Feminist Critiques of the International Human Rights –Friends or Foes”, written by Oonagh Reitman is a good fully equipped critical journal since the author put the focus on the discussion about the similarity between two branches of international human rights, the cultural relativist and the feminist in term of their critiques towards the international human rights and also present the fact of the clash between these two critiques when talking about women’s human rights.

Read More

International Human Rights Journal Analysis

810 Words | 4 Pages

Cultural Relativist and Feminist Critiques of International Human Rights Journal Summary The journal which is composed by Oonagh Reitman is really talking with respect to the conflict between all-inclusiveness of human rights and woman 's rights; and the conflict between comprehensiveness of human rights and social relativism. Women 's activist and social relativist has condemned the idea of human rights both in its practices and its fundamental idea, women 's activist concentrate on practice and social relativist on both practice and essential idea. The journal is not just clarifying on how both women 's activist and relativist censured the comprehensiveness of human rights, additionally the likelihood of concealed politic which is brought

Read More

Combahee River Collective Statement Analysis

979 Words | 4 Pages

Despite oppression women have always resisted. Women have resisted oppression in many ways. Women have responded to their multiple sources of oppression of sexism, racism, heterosexism and colonialism. Women resisted oppression by standing up for their rights. Women have been left out of the discussion of oppression for centuries.

Read More

Arguments Against Cultural Relativism

1020 Words | 5 Pages

Every society has its own unique cultures in which people will have different ideas of moral codes. The diversity of these cultures cannot be said to be correct or incorrect. Every society has independent standards of ethic within their society and these standards are culture-bound. Cultural Relativism has a perception in which rightness or wrongness of an action depends entirely within the bounds of the culture. This theory opposes the belief in the objectivity of moral truth.

Read More

Examples Of Cultural Relativism

827 Words | 4 Pages

Throughout this essay, cultural relativism will be questioned, but also supported in some ways. The idea of cultural relativism reminds me of a sociological term--ethnocentrism--that essentially means the opposite. Ethnocentrism is essentially a bias about your own culture against other cultures. One can only see their culture (usually as dominant to the others), rather than attempting to see the perspective of whatever culture is in question. An example of real-life cultural relativism is female circumsition or clitordectomy.

Read More

Women's Rights Analysis

1261 Words | 6 Pages

Women represent over half of the world’s population, and yet face some major human rights violations on a day to day basis. Women are viewed as less than men, and are treated accordingly. Though there have been some major strides in improving the world for women, it is important to acknowledge the historical and current treatment of many women across the globe. Of particular interest is women as property. Women are objectified and treated as property in almost every sector of life, particularly in marriage, sex, and before the law.

Read More

Persuasive Essay On Gender Equality

877 Words | 4 Pages

In our advanced 21st century, it is hard to imagine our society as anything short of perfect. After all, we have come a long way from our seafaring ancestors. However, the reality is that despite how we may sometimes avoid seeing it, our society is anything but perfect. A very prevalent issue today is that despite laws being set in place to enforce the equal treatment of men and women, women all over the world today still face poor treatment and discrimination. Because of how deep and long this problem has run, revising discriminatory laws may not abolish discrimination and legislating laws that endorse gender equality may not necessarily create equality.

Read More

Thesis On Gender Equality

1011 Words | 5 Pages

Aubrey Rose A, Barangot English 27B Title Gender Equality: An Established Human Right Thesis Gender Equality and Stereotypes Inroduction The gender equality has been accepted and acknowledged as human rights’ principles since the adoption of charter of United Nations in 1945. Most of the international agreements such as ‘the Millennium Development Goals (2000)’ and ‘the World Conference on Human Rights (1993) have highlighted and stressed the grave need for nations to take appropriate actions against such discriminatory practices. To give clarity to this research, the researcher uses the following definitions: “Everyone has a fundamental right to live free of violence.

Read More

More about Cultural Relativist Critique

Related Topics

Open Document