At this point, Gatsby’s American Dream had failed, as he did not get the opportunity to repeat his past with Daisy. Tom’s blindness causes him to view himself as a victim for losing Myrtle. I feel that it was Daisy’s stupidity and carelessness that lead to Myrtle’s death. Gatsby’s willingness to take responsibility for Myrtle’s death shows his unconditional love for Daisy as he is prepared to sacrifice anything for her. Gatsby corrupted himself and his dream to win Daisy’s heart.
Who is responsible for killing Jay Gatsby? Was it Tom? Daisy? George? Was it just simply himself?
While George was the man that ended Gatsby's life and the man who ended up pulling the trigger, Tom plays a huge role in planning the events leading up to Gatsby's death. Tom’s manipulation, recklessness and actions created a chain of events that led to the death of Gatsby. It is 100% a fact that he holds the responsibility for the death of Jay Gatsby. In chapter 7 of The Great Gatsby, Tom Buchanan manipulates Daisy and Gatsby by bringing up Gatsby's background and true character.
In “The Great Gatsby” by F. Scott Fitzgerald, George Wilson shoots Jay Gatsby as well as himself out of anger due to the loss of his wife. Although Wilson is legally at fault for killing Gatsby, Daisy and Tom are two characters that could both be morally responsible for the death as they fuel the events leading up to it. Daisy acted innocent and was a direct cause leading to the event as she was the one killed Myrtle. Tom let it build up and made assumptions out of spite towards Gatsby, he told Wilson it was Gatsby who was driving. Both played a role in being morally responsible for the actual event happening however I believe that one holds more responsibility.
Daisy is primarily the person at fault for Myrtle’s death, Tom also plays a role in the downfall after his mistress's death. Instead, Tom never confesses to Myrtle being his mistress and holds Gatsby accountable for her death. As for Daisy she allows Gatsby to take the fault for her mistakes and walks away with her hands clean. Following Myrtle's death comes Gatsby’s death. Rather than attending the funeral of the man she was in love with, Daisy leaves town with the man she “loved” in the past.
Throughout the novel, Gatsby is seen being dishonest by not telling people who was the person to really hit and kill Myrtle. Although Gatsby does not have any bad intentions, he could have prevented getting shot if he had only told the truth. After the accident, Gatsby and Nick were speaking and Gatsby happend to say, “yes, he said after a moment, but of course i’ll say I was” (Fitzgerald 143). It is clear that Gatsby is fine with taking the blame for Daisy since he is in love with her. The real reason Gatsby took the blame for daisy is because he felt that taking the blame will make him appear as a well respected, old money man.
Although he is a contributor to his death, George Wilson and Daisy Buchanan are ultimately who led to his death. Jay Gatsby is a contributor to his own death because he makes bad decisions to get his dream. An example of a bad decision is when he purposely let Nick stay in his guesthouse and be his neighbor. All he was really doing was using Nick for his own personal gain.
(102). But Daisy is never honest about being the one who was driving the car that hit and killed Myrtle. She let Gatsby take the fault for it and Gatsby ended up being killed because Wilson thought it was Gatsby who killed Myrtle. Daisy did what was best for her not what was right. John stayed and dealt with his consequence which ended in his death but he never ran from his mistakes he dealt with them head on.
Reed Zenisek 2/25/23 Ms.Kirby English � The one that started it all� In the book the Great Gatsby, when Daisy was driving Gatsby’s car and struck Myrtle, that's what started it all. Daisy should be held accountable for both the death of Myrtle and Gatsby. In chapter 7 is when Daisy is driving Gatsbys car and ends up hitting Myrtle with the car, in a way this started a mini chain reaction, because Myrtle's husband George Wilson kills Gatsby.
Even though other characters may have contributed, Gatsby is ultimately responsible for his own death because he wants to please Daisy, he is a liar, and he thinks he can repeat the past. The first reason Gatsby is responsible for his own death is because he did everything to please daisy. Gatsby bought his mansion and nice things to impress daisy. “He took out a pile of shirts and began throwing them one by one before us, shirts of sheer linen and thick silk and fine flannel which lost their folds as they fell and covered the table in many-colored disarray.”
Tom is also responsible for Jay Gatsby's death due to the lies he told to Mr. Wilson informing him of Gatsby’s responsibility in his wife's death. Although Mr. Wilson is legally responsible for the death of Jay Gatsby, Gatsby himself is morally responsible for his own death. This is due to Gatsby living in the past in hopes of rekindling his relationship with Daisy. Gatsby addresses Tom and Daisy Buchanan during a vehement argument, “ And what’s more I love Daisy.
In my opinion, Tom is most responsible for Gatsby’s death. I believe that Tom is most responsible because Tom forgot to tell George that Daisy was the driver of Gatsby’s car the night Myrtle was hit by it. Tom forgot to tell George that because him and Daisy were plotting this out. I could tell something was up when Nick refers that “Tom and Daisy talking in the house(146). I also think that Daisy is a little bit responsible because she took on some bad morals when she hit Myrtle because she could have stopped the car after she hit Myrtle.
In The Great Gatsby by F. Scott Fitzgerald Jay Gatsby was murdered by George Wilson Husband of Myrtle. In the court of law there’s only one person who was responsible and guilty for the murder of Jay Gatsby. Although in the eyes of god there was more than one person responsible for the murder or had the ability to stop the outcome of the murder. Weather it was Tom being honest about his affair, Daisy doing the right thing and stopping during the accident or Jay Gatsby himself by taking control of the situation and doing what was good for both Daisy and himself instead of just what 's best for Daisy. Tom, Myrtle, Daisy, and Gatsby were selfish and self centered leading them to become Morally responsible for the death of Jay Gatsby.
In Fitzgerald’s The Great Gatsby, Daisy is portrayed as a modern woman; she is sophisticated, careless and beautifully shallow. Daisy knows who she is, and what it takes for her to be able to keep the lifestyle she grew up in, and this adds to her carelessness and her feigned interest in life. In all, Daisy is a woman who will not sacrifice material desires or comfort for love or for others, and her character is politely cruel in this way. Daisy’s main strength, which buoyed her throughout her youth and when she was in Louisville, is her ability to know what was expected of her and feign cluelessness.
Jay was blamed for the death, but he was as innocent as a lamb. “Was Daisy driving?”, “Yes, but of course I will say I was” (80). Jay admits to taking the blame for the accident and is not the victim of the accident. Also, Gatsby was not driving his car at the time so it could not have been him. Daisy was in the Rolls Royce and deserves to be the one taking the blame of the death of Myrtle Wilson.