ipl-logo

Business Ethics Case Study: Deontological Perspective

1098 Words5 Pages

However, if Frank decides to do what the CEO asks and let those employees go, then he would have a negative impact on the employees and their families. Deontological Perspective. This perspective deals with decisions from a moral perspective. If Frank were a deontologist, he would make the decision of whether to go along with the CEO, based on his moral code. He would need to weigh both sides of the issue. Does his loyalty to the company, CEO and his family outweigh the process of doing the full due diligence of the employees performance of the past several years? Step Three: Identify the Affected Parties This step includes identifying the stakeholders and discuss how they are affected by the decision this Frank has to make. The stakeholders, …show more content…

The company will be affected immediately and for years to come. How will the company be affected in the long term and short term? Also, it is important to look at the message the company is sending. How do employees perceive Frank’s decision? Long-Term Versus Short-Term Consequences. The Executive Committee believes that the business there in is changing. They feel that in order to be successful in the long term they need to downsize the staff. In the short-term, the negative affects what would be that there will be some employees that lose their jobs. However, in the long-term the positive impact would be more employees keep their jobs increasing the chances of the company remaining successful. Symbolic Consequences. From the employee, perspective layoffs can be viewed in a negative way. This is often seen as the executive committee placing profits over employees. Frank represents the executive committee. If he chooses tonight investigate their performances of the employees without evaluations this could send a message to employees that the company is not really interested is the employee’s performance. If he does investigate those employees performances come that could send a signal to the employees that the company did the best they could to make a fair …show more content…

Frank’s options are either to follow the direction of the CEO and not look into the employees that have not received performance evaluations or risk his job and investigate those employees performances over the past few years. The CEO did mention that the employees that would be laid off would receive a severance package. If the CEO really did not want to keep the older employees around, who have not received the employee evaluations, he along with the executive committee could decide that they would offer in early retirement package for those employees. They could approach those employees giving them the option of early retirement or risk being laid off based on any findings of their performance evaluation. Because those employees are described as being close to retirement, this could persuade those employees to retire early and also avoid any negative consequences of Frank letting go of the wrong

Show More
Related
2294 Words | 10 Pages

Furthermore, it is the HR professionals duty to make sure the management team is fully aware on how to conduct business within the guidelines because in some cases knowingly or unknowingly laws can be broken and grave consequences will follow in suit. When we tie in the case of St. Mary's Honor Center v. Hicks legal risk management comes into play. I support the ideal that some risk management cannot be avoided by leadership and some risk taking may play a crucial role in the continuance of an organization. Although there are certain lines you should not cross and being able to cover your tracks are very important. In this case referenced, St. Mary's gave evidence as to how they made adverse employment decisions, but in the manner of doing so raised some red flags that enabled Hicks to have the opportunity for the case to eventually be heard in Supreme Court.

Read More
563 Words | 3 Pages

Relevant Facts: Nurofen, the pain-relief medication is made by Reckitt Benckiser Australia, a multinational company. The company was found misleading customers for all its specific range that contained the same active ingredient ibuprofen lysine 342mg and was seen to have same effect. The product was advertised the products as been targeting back pain, period pain and tension headaches. The Company was fined $1.7m for misleading customers on range of ‘specific pain’ relief contravening Australian Consumer Law has been brought forward by ACCC. The ACCC had asked federal court to impose $6 million fine.

Read More
905 Words | 4 Pages

For Rich’s decision to be successful, salary and hourly employees need to “trust their leader and feel they will be treated fairly and honestly” (Griffith and Gould 2008). Because the situation and impending decision impact the employees in different ways, he should consult the hourly and salaried employees face to face, but in separate settings. Rich should consult with the salaried employees first to gain insight on his decision. Their reactions will help Rich solidify his decision, then he will continue the consulting approach to share this information with his hourly

Read More
451 Words | 2 Pages

Changing the scenario still doesn’t bode well for the employee. The U.S. Supreme Court

Read More
549 Words | 3 Pages

Patagonia is a very popular clothing company that provides high quality wear designed for people that enjoy being outdoors. The provide good quality warm clothing such as jackets and flees for reasonable prices. Not only do they provide a great product, but they also make it their aim to make a positive impact by contributing to the industry and by also creating high standards and values which is something that popular brands should always do. Profitability for a company is linked to their ethical standards because it builds a reputation for the brand. It has been found that many investors determine if a company should be invested in by also looking at their social impact.

Read More
1380 Words | 6 Pages

When studying philosophy, a student becomes very aware of the contradiction and different opinions of highly remarked philosophers. Many students become frustrated with the opposition and question the importance of the study all together. Others choose to indulge in these differences to further their understanding beyond what he/ she thought capable of beforehand. The obvious contradictions between Kant’s deontology, and Bentham’s and Mill’s utilitarianism is a perfect example of such occasion in philosophy.

Read More
1306 Words | 6 Pages

1. Introduction – ethics – what are they? Ethics (or moral philosophy) is the kind of philosophy that define concept of right or wrong conduct. In practice, ethics try to resolve questions of human morality, by explaining concepts of good and evil. Ethics, culture, morals – are bind together, they are embedded.

Read More
2311 Words | 10 Pages

Question 1 Peter Loescher was hired by Siemens when the company was experiencing extremely difficult times. After the bribery scandal, the main goal was to gain back the trust and respect from the customers and partners, as well as building a new vision. The company’s board of directors decided that they needed a person from outside of the company, who had no connection and loyalty to previous vision, and no affiliation with previous management team. In my opinion, the company owners hired Loescher for a specific purpose to change the overall team perception of how work is supposed to be done.

Read More
1054 Words | 5 Pages

It could have broken their motivation but, his intentions were to challenge employees to exceed their previous performance. One trait of his personality can be described as being honest and far from being hypocrisy. Bill Gates once stated “Life is not fair, get use to it.” Developing a strategy to be a success is a good management tool by any business person. It all begins with an honesty, self-evaluation and creating goals.

Read More
1781 Words | 8 Pages

A positive result may result in the dismissal of the employee or is ineligible to receive employee

Read More
338 Words | 2 Pages

Margarita Rodriguez Philosophy of Nursing Millers College of Nursing October 16, 2015 How does deontology relate to an individual nurse?s professional practice of nursing? According to the American Nurses Association, Deontology, an ethical theory founded by Immanuel Kant, applies judgments based on the underlying morality, or the rightness or wrongness of an action. It is based upon adherence to rules.

Read More
788 Words | 4 Pages

Whereas other changes limited the impute of employees that should have been given more control. Hence Herold’s lack of understanding made the employees feel uncertain about their responsibilities and what they were supposed to do to contribute to the growth of the company that lead to the major failure in

Read More
735 Words | 3 Pages

Employees are the most important part for any organization. They are the associate degree and are the integral part of the organization, without the employees the company cannot imagine to grow and cannot additionally be ineffectual to realize something not even a single goal of the organization. Turnovers lead to more turnovers. Herd mentality is what men and women

Read More
1262 Words | 6 Pages

Introduction The key ethical issues that were presented in this case study were quality control, lack of customer care, responsiveness, and harming the customer. The Johnson and Johnson case may have been seen as a turning point due to many things the company did right. However, there were many ethical issues in this case which will be explored more throughout this paper.

Read More
1039 Words | 5 Pages

Basically, ethics are at their essence which is it is the moral judgments about what is right and what is wrong. Business ethics is focusing on examine the policies and conduct within the context of commercial enterprise in an organizational as well as in an individual level. In business, the ethics in business is an applied ethics where professionals and researchers use principles and theories to solve any ethical problems that exist in business. At the quarter of the 20th century, as technologies like internet have made world business or international business all more viable, the business ethics domestically have grown in importance along with the power and significance of major businesses. So that, international business ethics take center stage as a major concern of the modern era.

Read More

More about Business Ethics Case Study: Deontological Perspective

Related Topics

Open Document