ipl-logo

Ethical Analysis Of John Anderton

959 Words4 Pages

Samantha Marie Dexter (J15019130), Loi Su Wen (J15018082), Low Ker Ann (J15018078), Low Yi Chean (J15019103), Ng Yew Ming (J15019456). Mr. Adriel Wong PHL3100 20 July 2017 An Ethical Analysis of “Minority Report” Does John Anderton have freedom of will, the ability to make free choices despite the influences of his heredity or his environment? Does anybody? What does it matter for the criminal justice system, whether or not we have the capacity to choose our actions freely? Explain. The ethical theory in this question has to do with freedom and determinism. Are the people in this movie totally free or are they totally determined? Or is it a matter of the degree of freedom and determinism. It is important to answer these questions first before …show more content…

It is impossible and illogical to hold people to different standards of freedom and determinism. These are metaphysical aspects. They concern the nature of reality and reality is not so fickle as to apply different standards of truth to different people. Due to this, everybody has limited freedom. Fate, environment, character, religion, and so on formed throughout a person’s life would cause a limited number of possibilities to be open for that person. However, people have the power to choose which among these possibilities they will follow. The choice may be subconscious, but a choice is still being made. To sum up, the roads a person can take may have been chosen for him or her, but the road the person actually takes is totally up to that person. Even Lamar Burgess had a choice in the end. The Pre-Cogs showed him the path of killing John and John himself showed him the path of not killing John. However, Lamar saw a third path, one where he could escape everything and made the choice to follow it. The existence of alternatives, however limited, means the existence of choice. And that is the very essence of soft …show more content…

Guilt and innocence only matter if someone has the ability to stop themselves from carrying out their desires. If life has determined a person to make that choice no matter what, then how can anyone blame another person or find them guilty of that act? Society can disagree with their actions, but society cannot blame them for it. Basically, a criminal justice system in a society with no free will would be redundant. It would be an illusion of justice. In contrast, as long as people have some choice, some limited freedom, then yes, they can be judged and found guilty and innocent. This is because having a choice means having responsibility and if a person has failed in that responsibility, then he or she is

Show More
Related

How Is Alton Harris Morally Responsible

760 Words | 4 Pages

The case of Robert Alton Harris, a convicted murderer who was executed in 1992 for his crimes, raises profound questions about free will and moral responsibility. In this essay, I will argue that Harris did not exercise free agency when committing the crimes, that he could not have done otherwise, and that he is morally responsible for his actions despite his background. Moreover, I will show how this scenario can be used to shed light on the possibility of free will and moral responsibility in a deterministic universe. First, let us consider the facts of the case.

Read More

Freedom In John Knowles A Separate Peace

461 Words | 2 Pages

“Freedom is the power to choose our own chains” (Rousseau). Rousseau discusses the idea that freedom gives us enough power to pick who or what has control over us, which is an idea that is continually presented in the novel A Separate Peace by John Knowles. When in a position to choose, people will strive to lack personal control as a way to relieve their physical or mental pain. People like to live without control to lessen the burden of their suffering.

Read More

Examples Of Fate Over Free Will In Dante's Inferno

644 Words | 3 Pages

Destiny over Free will Free will is a term unheard of nowhere days because of how much the media portrays that we have to do what other people say such as politicians. Some people are destined to think that everything we say and do has already been written out in a script somewhere in heaven and that God already knows what we are going to do before we even do it. People do not possess free will but are governed by fate because in Dante's Inferno the people who were brought down to hell were brought down because they were destined to go down the wrong path and that's why they are in hell and there are special places for people whose fate was a little too heinous and they were forced to go in the middle of heaven and hell and sometimes other people are also destined to lead us to our fate such as Virgil in Dante's inferno. People do not possess free will but are governed by fate because we think we have a choice to change our decisions but what if

Read More

Chisholm's Human Freedom And The Self

1445 Words | 6 Pages

In "Human Freedom and the Self", Roderick Chisholm has taken a libertarian approach on the issue of free will and determinism. Libertarians believe that humans have free will and make a distinction that free will and determinism are incompatible. Chisholm has the same opinion. On the problem of human freedom, Chisholm thinks that “Human beings are responsible agents; but this fact appears to conflict with a deterministic view of human action (the view that every event that is involved in an act is caused by some other event); and it also appears to conflict with an indeterministic view of human action (the view that the act, or some event that is essential to the act, is not caused at all).”(Page 3). He does not agree that determinism or indeterminism

Read More

Macbeth Fate Vs Free Will Essay

905 Words | 4 Pages

Fate versus free will. Free will determines how people reach their destinies. This is shown in Macbeth by William Shakespeare through the characters actions. In the play Macbeth, lady Macbeth and Macbeth’s choices lead to their predetermined destinies. Free will controls most of the actions within the play, but fate still controls what happens in the end.

Read More

Baron D Holbach's Theory Of Determinism

889 Words | 4 Pages

Actions are made by causes. We cannot predict everything in the future and with that said, human actions are made by laws. According to Baron d’Holbach, we have a will, but the will is not free because of self-preservation and well-being. Forces that are independent make an impact on us because it could create desires we didn’t think existed.

Read More

Explain Why People Should Be Held Accountable In Life

777 Words | 4 Pages

Equally people will say that that they should and shouldn 't be held accountable on this life or death situations. For instance… people have chosen this situation that they want to do and they know that they could be held accountable like for example in the story the life of pi, the boy was on a raft with the tiger and they were on each side of the boat but the boy was scared of getting eat by the tiger because the tiger had that look in his eyes of hunger so the boy decided to make a raft near the boat so he would still be alive. They should not be held accountable for this because it is there life and their choosing what they want to do to be free or take something off a bucket list. However... people can chose of what they want to do but they need to think before they do it to test if they are ready for it or that they won 't be scared and know the consequences of what might happen. Also how people even though they don 't know they should have checked first.

Read More

Criminal Justice Vs Free Will Essay

516 Words | 3 Pages

We tent to believe that we are free to make our own choices thus we as a population preside a sense of free will. Free will simply states that everyone has the power to make choices and our actions and choices are emanate of our own choosing (William &Arrigo, 2011, p.46). When free will comes into place in ethics “should” implies that you can, therefore we can choose between different course of action and ask ourselves which course of action is best (William & Arrigo, 2011, p.45). On the other hand, in criminal justice we postulate that those people who violate or commit a crime choose criminally over a different lifestyle or course of action (William & Arrigo, 2011, p.45). As a result those who violated or committed a crime receive the right punishment that meets the crime committed.

Read More

Persuasive Speech Outline On Abortion

1277 Words | 6 Pages

“I believe the freedom to choose my course in life but I do not believe I am free to choose the consequences of my

Read More

Determinism Vs Free Will

1777 Words | 8 Pages

Determinism, free will and moral responsibility (1681 words) Table of contents: Introduction. Blatchford’s view on determinism, free will, and moral responsibility. Schlick’s determinism, freedom and responsibility. Hospers’s position.

Read More

Extended Metaphors In The Road Not Taken By Robert Frost

1032 Words | 5 Pages

Which road will the speaker take? This question sets the literal and metaphorical divergence in the woods that the speaker will have to face: both an actual path through the woods and the life decisions implied by it. The first extended metaphor of choice happens in these line: the chosen path is the chosen life choices. The speaker will have to choose a road to go down and one not to, presenting the first conflict of choice. He is faced with two different roads that each lead to a different outcome.

Read More

Choice Theory Of Juvenile Delinquency

403 Words | 2 Pages

In learning about Juvenile delinquency and theories on why delinquency occurs, I found that the choice theory was most applicable to a variety of juveniles and the reason why they choose to commit crimes. The choice theory suggests that “Juvenile offenders are rational decision makers who choose to engage in antisocial activity because they believe their actions will be beneficial”. (Siegel and Welsh, 2016, p. 58) It is my opinion, that most juveniles do have the ability to think for themselves and weigh the pros and the cons to committing a crime. I liked this theory most because I strongly agree that in the majority of juvenile delinquency cases, the act is a product of choice.

Read More

Explain Why Safety Is More Important Than Freedom Essay

821 Words | 4 Pages

So imagine giving the choice to do whatever they want without any consequences. Many people would be in danger. In life freedom is great, but safety is more

Read More

Chronicle Of A Death Foretold Fate Analysis

1202 Words | 5 Pages

Fate, by definition, is the universal principle by which the order of things is seemingly prescribed. (Webster) Essentially, fate is events that are inevitable that we have no power to change. It is debatable that fate exists among everyone; however, humans are subject to making their own choices- free will. No matter what choices people make, they do not change our fate.

Read More

Symbolism In The Road Not Taken

1777 Words | 8 Pages

There will come a time in every person’s life where he has to make a decision that could alter his life forever. In fact, this exact situation may occur multiple times in his existence. In trying to make the right choices, a person might weigh both options and take into account all the possible effects and arguments for each. For example, when he was growing up, Robert Frost would take strolls with his friend, Edward Thomas, who would constantly face the struggle of choosing the right path and would always worry about whether he made the right decision. In his poem, “The Road Not Taken,” Frost portrays this relatable clash of choices.

Read More

More about Ethical Analysis Of John Anderton

Related Topics

Open Document