ipl-logo

Differences And Similarities Between Marji And Elie Wiesel

756 Words4 Pages

Michael Choi Ms.Scauso English 10 2A 5/1/23 Marji and Elie compare and contrast essay Marjane Satrapi and Elie Wiesel are two authors who have experienced some of the most traumatic events in human history. In Persepolis, the audience is introduced to Marji who we follow during a religious crisis called the Iranian revolution. During the Revolution Marji experiences many close relatives and friends dying; this ends up changing Marji making her more rebellious and cynical. Similarly, in Night, the audience is introduced to Elie Weisel who we also were introduced to during a religious crisis called the Holocaust. During the Holocaust Elie Weisel experiences starvation, physical torture, and inhuman deaths, all of this due to her religion. Trauma …show more content…

Marji witnessing the misuse of religion for political gain and the suffering inflicted caused Marji to question her to slowlydistance herself from the religion. She began to question the role of faith in society and ultimately started to rebel against her religion. Marji’s trauma led her to have a more secular worldview, and emphasised personal freedom. Similarly, Elie Wiesel's experience during the Holocaust challenged his religious beliefs. Elie is sent to a concentration camp due to him being Jewish; during the concentration camp Elie experiences many traumatic events such as, starvation, physical abuse, babies being thrown into a furnace, and seeing his own dad having no will, then dying. Elie questions the existence and benevolence of God because he struggled to understand why God would allow for him and others to endure such suffering. Weisel's trauma shaped him into a stronger person, who advocated for remembering and learning from the Holocaust, and also created an organisation to fight indifference, intolerance, and …show more content…

Marji often felt like an outsiderwithin her own culture, struggling to reconcile her Iranian heritage with her Western influences. Since Marji felt better about Western heritage, Marji rebelled against the religious schools she was taught in.This led her to stand on her own beliefs, and become more outspoken about her beliefs. In Elie’s case, the trauma of the Holocaust left an everlasting mark on his identity. The dehumanisation and suffering he experienced in the concentration camps stripped him of his sense of self, he felt insignificant. Elie’s traumatic past challenged his understanding of who he was and what it means to be human. Despite this, he emerged from the darkness with a profound commitment to make sure everyone remembers these atrocities and to learn from these mistakes. His identity as a survivor and advocate for human rights become his life’s purpose. Lastly, Trauma can disrupt and shape one’s childhood, robbing them of their innocence and normal development experiences. Both Elie and Marji endured traumatic events at such a young age, altering their perception of the

Show More
Related
300 Words | 2 Pages

In this book Elie speaks of his hardships and how he survived the concentration camps. Elie quickly changed into a sorrowful person, but despite that he was determined to stay alive no matter the cost. For instance, during the death

Read More
1331 Words | 6 Pages

Elie, his family, and many others were at gunpoint and being forced to leave their entire lives behind. Everything they built for themselves, just gone. Everyone was forced out of their homes, into cattle cars, and transported to a place that was unimaginable. They were transported to the concentration camp known as Auschwitz. When they arrived, immediately, Elie and his father were separated from Elie’s mother and little sister.

Read More
651 Words | 3 Pages

The heart wrenching and powerful memoir “Night” by Elie Wiesel depicts Elie’s struggle through the holocaust. It shows the challenges and struggles Elie and people like him faced during this mournful time, the dehumanization; being forced out of their homes, their towns and sent to nazi concentration camps, being stripped of their belongings and valuables, being forced to endure and witness the horrific events during one of history’s most ghastly tales. In “Night” Elie does not only endure a physical journey but also a spiritual journey as well, this makes him question his determination, faith and strength. This spiritual journey is a journey of self discovery and is shown through Elie’s struggle with himself and his beliefs, his father

Read More
436 Words | 2 Pages

Wiesel changed from a young, vibrant teenager to a spiritually dead man after witnessing the horrors of the Holocaust in the concentration camps. His faith in God was tested when he saw all the injustice happening. He became numb and lost hope. "For God’s sake, where is he?" This where-hanging here from this gallows… (65p)

Read More
686 Words | 3 Pages

Elie was beaten countless times by other people. No one was safe from the anger and hatred that fueled the Nazis. But what stood out to everyone in the camp was the tragic death of the young boy who was hanged. His death lasted longer and the horror the others had to witness as they walked away. Nothing could be done, this moment is where Elie no longer believes his religion.

Read More
825 Words | 4 Pages

Trinity Brown Ms. Scauso English 10 4/14/2023 Childhood Trauma The book “Night” is a memoir written by Elie Wiesel who known to of survived one of history’s greatest atrocities, the holocaust. In “Night” we follow the journey of a Jewish teenage boy named Elie Wiesel who is taken to a concentration camp toward the end of the second world war. In the autobiography “Persepolis” by Marjane Satrapi, we follow the story of a young Iranian girl named Marji. In “Persepolis”, Marji has to face adversity during a time of war and sorrow after the islamic revolution.

Read More
419 Words | 2 Pages

The severely cruel conditions of concentration camps had a profound impact on everyone who had the misfortune of experiencing them. For Elie Wiesel, the author of Night and a survivor of Auschwitz, one aspect of himself that was greatly impacted was his view of humanity. During his time before, during, and after the holocaust, Elie changed from being a boy with a relatively average outlook on mankind, to a shadow of a man with no faith in the goodness of society, before regaining confidence in humanity once again later in his life. For the first 13 years of his life, Elie seemed to have a normal outlook on humanity.

Read More
861 Words | 4 Pages

feelings and to inform us other generations about what happened to not only him but all of the other jews and their families. Elie Weisel changed significantly in the holocaust. He changed physically, mentally and spiritually. One of the ways Elie has changed was physically. Elie had gotten really skinny throughout his experience.

Read More
1359 Words | 6 Pages

Elie was left with severe damage to his body and a tattoo that would serve as a lifelong reminder of his trauma, he was forced to adjust to unthinkable conditions that contributed to a change in his personality, and he lost faith as he struggled to find answers for what he was put through. The Holocaust was the world’s largest genocide with indescribably devastating effects. Elie Wiesel was one of millions who suffered the consequences of Hitler’s tyrannous rule over Europe in the 1940s. It is of the utmost importance that victims such as Mr. Wiesel are heard and the tribulations they endured are acknowledged. It is horrifying to imagine a time during which innocent people were slain solely because of their faith while the rest of the world turned a blind eye.

Read More
735 Words | 3 Pages

Over 6 million innocent Jews lost their lives due to one man’s greed for power and satisfaction. This horrific event caused many people to be filled with hopelessness, tribulation, and adversity. In the book, “Night”, Elie’s identity was completely altered since the beginning to the end. His faith went from growing stronger every day, to gradually ceasing to exist. Everything that mattered most to him was slowly evaporating away during this life-changing catastrophe.

Read More
511 Words | 3 Pages

Elie went through many horrible things during the Holocaust. This included dehumanization, physical abuse, and a major lack of human rights. Many people who were forced into labor camps during the Holocaust were completely dehumanized. This dehumanization happened as soon as they entered the camp as they were stripped of their clothes, shaved bald, and tattooed with an ID number.

Read More
782 Words | 4 Pages

Elie was held captive in concentration camps from 1944-1945. During his time in the concentration camps, he became grateful for what he had, overcame countless obstacles, and more importantly kept fighting until he was free. [The Holocaust is very important to learn about because it can teach you some important life lessons.] You should always be grateful for what you have, no matter what the circumstances are. This lesson can be learned when Elie says, “After my father’s death, nothing could touch me any more”(109).

Read More
764 Words | 4 Pages

The time that Elie spent in the concentration camps had much impact on him, and this made Elie question the change between the two things that he thought would always be in his life, both his relationship with his father and

Read More
956 Words | 4 Pages

In Satrapi’s graphic novel, she describes her childhood and experiences living between the Iranian revolution and war. Over time, she starts to mature and obtain a deeper understanding of the war, overall changing her character and identity from an innocent, naive child, to more mature and understanding. In Wiesel’s novel, he talks about himself as a young boy who was forced to endure the harsh conditions of the concentration camp, as they continue to get harder, overall making it harder for him to survive. In Marjane Satrapi’s graphic novel Persepolis and Elie Wiesel’s novel, Night, both authors argue how change in identity is inevitable while living through traumatic events. Throughout Persepolis, Marji seems to grasp a better understanding of the war as time goes by, and starts to become reluctant to her faith and religion as she starts to learn about the loss of her loved ones.

Read More
945 Words | 4 Pages

His story displays how, though experiences affect decisions, it is the individual who chooses to either find purpose when there does not seem to be a clear objective, or allow one’s anguish to be fruitless. This concept is further explored with psychiatrist Viktor Frankl’s idea of logotherapy, and discussed in Elie’s interview with talk show host Oprah Winfrey decades after the Holocaust. In Night, Elie is overwhelmed by his suffering, as he experiences a deprivation of individuality, degradation of faith, and drainage of emotion, but he manages to find a way to channel this affliction into productivity and become a survivor rather than a victim. It is easy to misunderstand how devastating life in a concentration camp was, but through Elie’s loss of identity and distrust in God, the reader can discern the

Read More

More about Differences And Similarities Between Marji And Elie Wiesel

Related Topics

Open Document