ipl-logo

Differences And Similarities Between Melians And Athenians

628 Words3 Pages

“War does not determine who is right - only who is left” - Bertrand Russell. A statement far too true with its application to many wars throughout history. The strong will survive and the weak will be eliminated. In the Melians dialogue, the Melians refused the Athenians as their ruler. That sparked the war between these two groups of people. On the topic of our war in Afghanistan, the war on terrorism, it all started after the historical event that happened on September 11, 2001. The terrorists waged attacks on America by hijacking four planes, with two planes succession in crashing into the twin towers. In respond, our nation decided to go to war in Afghanistan against the terrorist group Al-Qaeda. In present day, the Al-Qaeda group has long been …show more content…

Yet our presence in Afghanistan is still prominent. The similarity between these two wars now is the imposition of power. In one, the Athenians wanting to conquer the Melians and in the other, the U.S wanting to stabilize the situation in the Afghanistan by imposing a westernized governmental system. Neither opposing party share the same view with the other. As a result, the Melians went to war with the Athenians and the decentralized groups in Afghanistan rejected the view of westernized government because no group likes to be controlled by another group or no one likes to be controlled by someone else. Rejection of control by one group who doesn’t share the same view of the other group attempting control is exceedingly common. The Athenians want to impose their power by taking the Melians under their control. The Melians however, proposed to be a neutral party to the Athenians, that way the Athenians do not need to conquer them. The reason being they wished to be a standalone group without being under control by another

Show More
Related
1229 Words | 5 Pages

Zareef Peeroo Tim Bailey October 15, 2014 Athenians vs. Spartans The differences between government, the role of women, and the education status of Athens and Sparta led to similar yet very different societies residing in the same area; therefor I will deconstruct these issues using an analytical comparative framework. In, Athens and Sparta, it shows all the differences between the Athenians and the Spartans. Although the two City States shared a common heritage, their differences grew so large in their own minds that they were ultimately willing to engage in a life-and-death struggle to support their separate realities (Spielvogel).

Read More
659 Words | 3 Pages

Throughout modern times, one of the American government’s greatest influences in social and political conflicts internationally is the use of covert operations. In the documentary Dirty Wars, based on Jeremy Scahill’s novel, Dirty Wars: The World Is a Battlefield, Scahill’s main goal as an American war journalist is to uncover what NATO or National Atlantic Treaty Organization is hiding beneath all the battles in Afghanistan. What NATO tells war journalists when it comes to night raids are the only times at which they took place. This lead Scahill to investigate in a city named Gardez in Afghanistan that was recently attacked in a night raid, and this event will alter Scahill’s viewpoint on American government policies worldwide. While visiting Gardez, Scahill is shocked as residents told him of U.S soldiers shooting and killing innocent people without a warning or a reason as to open fire and then leaving without ever leaving a trace of there being U.S

Read More
332 Words | 2 Pages

I agree with your assessment that the President Reagan’s policy objectives in Afghanistan were ultimately achieved & the Soviets were forced to leave within nine month , May 15, 1988 – February 15, 1989. . Of course that success was short lived and the Mujahideen & Osama Bin Laden became our new national security headache , less than 3 years after the Soviets departed . The Russian defeat , however , would not satisfy few lingering questions such as ; was it prudent to wait almost 6 years after the Soviet occupation of Afghanistan before deciding to abandon the “ harassment “policy and adopt a more aggressive one that was bent on “taking the war to the Soviets “? This policy change was cited by Coll , “ “initiated with Reagan's

Read More
548 Words | 3 Pages

I agree that the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan was driven by Soviet regional concerns, and was not based on the Cold War rivalry with the United States. I did a lot of research on this topic as well as read The Hidden War book. On page 4 of The Hidden War it states, “there are all kinds of theories as to what actually triggered the fateful

Read More
160 Words | 1 Pages

Why are Spartan and Athenian societies different Athenian and Spartan societies were mostly different as the Spartan society was more focused on war and the Athenian life was more creative and wonderful. Firstly, the Spartan army was more strong and fierce. They were trained a lot from a young age. The men in the Spartan army were taken away from their families when they were seven years old and located in barracks, where they would live with other children.

Read More
813 Words | 4 Pages

invaded Afghanistan after the attacks on September 11th to rid the country of the Taliban regime and to stop Al-Qaeda and its leader. The terroristic group Al-Qaeda set up camps in Afghanistan that indoctrinated and trained over 10,000 to 20,000 men before the fatal attack on America. ("Afghanistan War"). These camps also became bases for weapons and for coordinating terrorist attacks. ("Afghanistan War").

Read More
1770 Words | 8 Pages

The origins of the War Between

Read More
909 Words | 4 Pages

On October 7, 2001 The United States invaded Afghanistan. This is the violent response of the most powerful country in the world to a poor and backward people, Afghan; Afghanistan in this way becomes a testing ground for new American weapons, remembering that The United States is the most powerful in the world in all aspects, military, economic, etc. The invasion is justified by the pursuit of Osama Bin Laden, the cause is that the Al Qaida terrorist group launched an attack on "the vital points of the heart of the empire": economic (Wall Street), military-political (Pentagon). Years after this tragedy the United States backed Afghanistan insurgents remove the ruling of Islamic fundamentalist Taliban from power, bringing hope to a devastated country. The Afghanistan transition from the Taliban not only affected the economy but also the government and the society of the country.

Read More
721 Words | 3 Pages

Today, many of the world’s government structures were based on the principle of one of Greece’s city-states. Greece became a country advancing well before its time, strong in both military and brain power. This country was able to produce two city-states that became foundations to advancing the rest of the world. The first city-state, Athens, is thought to be the first to implement a democratic government while Sparta became known for their military power. While Athens and Sparta provide the world with advancements they differ in the ways of government structures, social motivations, and cultural differences.

Read More
258 Words | 2 Pages

What is interesting here is that the law gives protection to all, but a penalty can be exacted only through a citizen’s intervention. This is similar a slave would expect court to play out for them, they would rely on their master to represent them in court. With this law metic’s inferior status is marked out. They had to rely on someone else’s intervention in court, and in the case of this law he or she was no better off than a slave; with the Athenian citizen being their master. Penalties were also significantly different, a killer of a metic was exiled while the murderer of a citizen was sent to death.

Read More
713 Words | 3 Pages

“‘Family” isn’t defined only by last names or blood. It’s defined by commitment and by love. It means showing up when they need it most. It means having each other’s backs. It means choosing to love each other even on those days when you struggle to like each other.

Read More
1206 Words | 5 Pages

This decrease in Soviet-US relationship played a factor in the Soviet-Afghan War. Lack of relationship creates a void in cooperatively. This void is the reasoning behind the failure to ratify the SALT II. The Soviets cause mistrust through their invasion of Afghanistan and the US by the delay of ratification. This delay in SALT II was another punitive reactions of the Carter Administration in order to try and ease the Soviets off.

Read More
1051 Words | 5 Pages

Carthage was a colony of Tyre, before becoming a commercial giant, it was the capital city on the coast of North Africa.(Morey, W,C, 1901). The government of Carthage was similar to that of Rome in structure, they had two suffettes which were the equivalent of Roman consuls, it also had a council of elders called the ‘Hundred’ which were the equivalent of the senate of Rome. The government was although similar in some respects was also greatly different, as we have seen before in Greece, Carthage was ruled by a few wealthy families (Morey, W,C, 1901). The main problem Carthage had was that it failed to understand the Roman philosophy of incorporating its citizens from conquered cities, therefore Rome had more loyalty from their citizens than Carthage could hope for.

Read More
788 Words | 4 Pages

Bush announces war on Afghanistan, the Taliban, and Osama bin Laden. The Taliban refused to relinquish bin Laden due to the pashtunwali code of ethics. “The coalition forces have driven the Taliban out of every major city, pushed them across the border to Pakistan and to the mountains in the south and east of Afghanistan. ISAF, an international peacekeeping force, has been sent to Kabul. The country has an interim president now, Hamid Karzai.”

Read More
1027 Words | 5 Pages

Some people believe that the continuation of the conflict in Afghanistan is necessary, but the United States should depart from this conflict with it being a waste of money, resulted in unnecessary loss of lives, and has caused harm to the Afghanistan civilians. Than again, many people believe that the War in Afghanistan is a necessary part of the war on terror. At the

Read More

More about Differences And Similarities Between Melians And Athenians

Related Topics

Open Document