Do You Think That Jack And Roger's Tribe That Show Good

“Do you think that Jack and Roger’s tribe is a tribe that shows evil and Piggy and Ralphs bond is one that shows good?” Well to answer this I do I do believe that Jack and Roger’s tribe is one that shows evil and that Piggy and Ralph represent good.

One important reason that Jack and Roger and their tribe show more evil in the novel and Ralph and Piggy show more good is that once the boys split Jack and Roger’s tribe have done bad things that have bad endings in the end. Such as in the book Jack and Roger’s tribe think they killed the so called “beast” but actually it was Simon someone from their own tribe. Also,while this was happening Ralph and Piggy were just alone by themselves at their own fire because Jack and Roger’s tribe ended

When Jack,Roger and their tribe invaded Ralph and Piggy’s camp place Jack ended up taking Piggy’s glasses and even Ralph called Jack a thief “You could have had fire whenever you wanted. But you didn’t. You came sneaking up like a thief and stole Piggy’s glasses!” (254). The point is since Ralph and Piggy had a positive bond and Ralph wanted to get Piggy’s glasses back it shows that he really does care about Piggy and what happens to him and he cares for what was his and what is gone from Piggy since Piggy needs those glasses to see. Of course is it possible to disagree with the view that Piggy and Ralph had a positive bond and instead will argue that Ralph and Piggy were also wanting to do negative things and they wanted to split up to. However, stronger evidence is on the other side. What must be remembered is that Ralph and Piggy were the ones who wanted to talk with Jack and Roger’s tribe to work things out with the two tribes wanting to come back together. This is essentially why Piggy and Ralph having a positive bond together, Jack and Roger’s tribe having a negative one show that Jack and Roger’s tribe represents more evil in the novel and Ralph and Piggy represent good in this