SOCIOLOGY CIA 3 Critically analyze Durkheim’s Theory of Suicide Anshula Shankar II EPS 1313628 Suicide is a term that has become a part of our lives, we read about it in newspapers, we hear it about it on television, talk about and sometimes even lose our loved ones to it. It has become an issue of concern and affects millions of people. According to the World Health Estimates, in the year 2000, nearly one million people died because they committed suicide and people attempted it 10 to 20 more times around the globe. One person dies every forty seconds due to this and one attempt to commit suicide is made every three seconds. It is counted among the first three reasons of death among people from the age of fifteen to thirty …show more content…
This type of suicide exhibits the character of being optional in nature. Unlike obligatory altruistic suicide, this is not committed because public opinion forces one to do so but because public opinion favors it. Social prestige and esteem is attached to this type of suicide and it brings social approval and praise and if an individual does not sacrifice himself, he or she receives social disapproval which is similar to a punishment. Individuals are raised to attach no or little value to life and hence, they do not hesitate to offer a valueless sacrifice. This type of suicide is called optional altruistic suicide. The third type of altruistic suicide is called acute altruistic suicide in which an individual kills him or herself for no particular reason but simply for the ‘joy of sacrifice’ and because ‘renunciation in itself is considered praiseworthy’. This type of suicide is usually motivated by metaphysical and religious systems and the individual considers his or herself to be a part of something bigger and readily gives up his or her life in order to blend in with his or her ‘true essence.’ (Durkheim, Spalding, & Simpson, …show more content…
This was observed by Durkheim in the state of widowhood or divorce. Both these cases are situations in which the existing setup is disturbed. The rate of suicide in widowhood was also discussed by Durkheim with respect to egoistic suicide but the new observation in case of anomic suicide that was observed by him was in the case of divorce and he noted that divorced people tend to commit suicide more than married people. In the modern society, anomy is the main reason for suicide. Anomic suicide is similar to egoistic suicide as both types of suicide stem from the lack of society’s presence in a individual’s life but in case of the former, it is mainly because no force restrains them while in the latter the individual does not find any meaning or objective in life. (Durkheim, Spalding, & Simpson,
When it comes to the ethnics (religious reasons) of being for or against that falls under functionalism, “the theory that various social institutions and processes in society exist to serve some important (or necessary) function to keep society running” (Conley, 29), this is the perspective that various parts of society are interdependent; they all work together to make up one functioning society. Physician-assisted suicide is one of the small parts that are not necessary for society but wanted, “a society must change through a natural and gradual process. An implication to this perspective it that no part of society should be altered unless all of the society’s functions are clearly known” (Luhman, 35) in the United States, physician-assisted suicide has been slowly become legal since the 1990’s.
In the classical world of Greece and Rome, suicide was glorified as a noble death. As early as the second century, Christian teaching condemned suicide, stating it violates the commandment, “Thou shall not kill”, suicide cannot be repented of and lastly, it’s cowardly” (“Suicide.” Encyclopedia of Religion and the Law in America).
In his book, Suicide, Emile Durkheim explores the social reasons that would someone to commit suicide. The basis of his argument laid in his ideas of social integration and social regulation. Social regulation is the many facets in which a person can be involved with society, such as political groups, religious groups, and domestic groups. Social regulation in comparison are the social and moral rules that a society decides what is right and what is wrong. Durkheim believes that people need to find a balance within social integration and social regulation to live a healthy lifestyle.
Keiski acknowledges that, “Individual therapy with a psychologist or psychiatrist is probably the most common form of treatment for people suffering from any sort of depression or need help through a crisis.” (95). In most cases, suicide is a result of how lonely the victim may feel since they may not fully receive the love and care they deserve. Hence, it is important that professional caretakers reach out to them since they may feel too embarrassed of their negative thoughts. Directly connecting to this idea, most times family members and friends are not too sure about how to address this with the victim since they do not really know how to help.
People who committed suicide were in a state of immense despair; they could not see hope and find the courage to go on. They wanted to end their pain. At the same time, they might not realize that they were also being selfish.
In what follows, I will further explicate the arguments posed in ‘ A Right to Self Termination ?’ I find the view stated in the article is compelling and will argue with Velleman that it is morally wrong for a person to commit suicide on the basis that doing so reduces oneself to a mere means. I will argue that in the case of suicide the act of committing suicide is unjustifiable, we have a value inside us, in all humans that we all must live up
It is very important to note that this paper solely responds to many religious and philosophical points and do not endorse suicide to any circumstance. I will provide the structure of this writing as
Losing a loved one is very difficult to handle throughout your life. Have you ever felt like giving up on life as well because your other behalf or your loved one passed away due to suicide and not being able to see them again until the afterlife? Suicide is the act of ending your own death at your own hand to escape the pain or suffering from the world. It should be meant to enjoy life like everyone else and not taking your own life just by the opinion of others or by the disaster of the world or by any body failure you might be experiencing. Accordingly, to the organization of the American Foundation of Suicide Prevention, suicide becomes the 10th leading cause of death in the U.S.
This essay shows that Hume believes that suicide can be defined as the killing of self that is intended to remove misery and which may or may not be morally justified. On the other hand, it also shows that Aquinas defines suicide as the intentional killing of self that is “contrary to self love, self perpetuation[, and] natural law” and which is morally impermissible. Simply all that Hume attempts to accomplish in his essay “Of Suicide” is to show that Aquinas is wrong and that suicide may be morally permissible in certain circumstances. Various philosophers over the past two
The concept has been widely used by sociologists since. Anome is a French word which means normlessness or a state without rules or regulations. One of Durkheim 's most famous studies was concerned with the analysis of suicide. Durkheim showed that social factors employ a fundamental influence on suicidal behaviour. Durkheim defined suicide as "every case of death resulting directly or indirectly from a positive or negative act performed by the victim himself, which he knows will produce this result" (Aragwal, 2012).
Compared to countries outside Hong Kong, China, America, Singapore, Japan and Korean also find out the suicidal rate of elderly were also higher than any other people in different age group. Although sociologisit Emile Durkheim thinks that the suicide rates for a society typically shows a stable distribiution from year to year, there are always identification of periodic fluctuations and patterns of suicide
CRITICAL ANALYSIS OF EMILE DURKHEIM’S THEORY OF SUICIDE Emile Durkheim (April 15, 1858 -15 November, 1917) was a French sociologist and is mostly famous for his monograph the theory of Suicide (1897). He is also a French sociologist, social psychologist and a philosopher and has formally established the academic discipline and is commonly cited as the principal architect of modern social science and father of sociology. His most important work was apparently a case study of suicide which is a study of suicide rates in Catholic and Protestant populations, founded modern social research and served to distinguish social science from psychology and political philosophy. If we have a look at the suicide statistics it is known that precisely, 11.1 out of every 100,000 people have died by suicide (WHO 2011).
Over the years the issue of suicide has been slowly increasing. It is now the third leading cause of death among young people. The effects of suicide are tragic and felt long after the individual has taken their own life. Some people who consider suicide, however, never make a “serious” attempt at it. For every attempted suicide, there is said to be more than one person whose thought of suicide has never translated into an actual attempt.
INTRODUCTION This paper will be discussing suicide and Para-suicide among world views components of theology, philosophy, ethics, biology, sociology, psychology, politics, law, economics and history. Suicide is one of the major leading causes of death in the world. It is estimated that about one million people worldwide die by suicide each year and it is apparent in all cultures, religions, nationalities. DEFINITION TERMS
The statistics about teenage runaways, alcoholism, drug problems, pregnancy, eating disorders, and suicide are startling. Every year, thousands of people succeed in taking their lives and even more have attempted suicide at some point in their lives. Although we have reached the stage that hearing about suicide is now common, it is was viewed as trivial and petty back then. It seems like a reverse spectrum