ipl-logo

Edgar Sawtelle Sign Language Analysis

2115 Words9 Pages

Humans have an inherent desire to understand the world and the humans around them. Though some attempt to unveil one’s thoughts through alternative means, a single method consistently prevails: sharing thoughts and emotions. Expression and communication are the foundations of a stable relationship; without them, misinterpretation occurs. In The Story of Edgar Sawtelle by David Wroblewski, Edgar Sawtelle cannot speak, so he uses sign language to communicate. In Hamlet by William Shakespeare, Hamlet can talk, but only to a certain extent, as he must bury his inner dialogue. Edgar and Hamlet attempt to connect with their respective uncles, Claude and Claudius, but barriers restrict these interactions, resulting in confusion and anger. These arousing …show more content…

In other words, there is a human restraint to avoid open conversation. In The Story of Edgar Sawtelle, it is evident that Edgar attempts to converse with his uncle, yet he does not know sign language, hindering his ability to receive Edgar’s messages. Edgar tries to teach Claude basic signs at the beginning of the novel, but Claude fails to retain them or make an additional effort to translate Edgar’s words. This showcases Claude’s dismissal of Edgar; if he desires to consider Edgar’s opinions and listen to his emotions, Claude would be an understanding and sympathetic father figure. Edgar dismisses sign language and attempts to communicate with Claude through alternative means. By climbing an apple tree that oversees his mother and uncle, Edgar physically demonstrates his desire to know what Claude is scheming. Claude admits that the boy could “read [his] mind, can hear these thoughts” and it prompts him to “wonder what else he has seen, what else he might know” (Wroblewski 250). Without saying a word, Edgar desires Claude to understand him clearly. On the other hand, Hamlet pretends to go mad to cover up his true intentions of murdering Claudius. Claudius is aware of Hamlet’s disapproval of him and Gertrude, and Hamlet questions his mother marrying Claudius “with such dexterity to incestuous sheets!” (1.2.160) Hamlet delivers unhinged …show more content…

As a teenager, he cannot cope with the trauma of losing his father, and these conflicting emotions interfere with his psychological well-being. Edgar’s inner thoughts start to darken, and he overthinks every action of Claude, questioning its deceptive motive. This interference prompts hesitation and the inability to carry out his task: to kill Claude. Claude even notes that Edgar is “better off run away” and that “he’s too wild” to have around (Wroblewski 435). The issue is that Edgar can communicate these emotions with neither his mother, for she would worsen his conflicting feelings, nor Claude, for he would not understand them. Bottling up his emotions halts his ability to move past exacting revenge. Hamlet faces a comparable difficulty while attempting to communicate his feelings; when he discovers he must avenge his father’s death, he cannot act. This hesitation frustrates Hamlet, but Hamlet does not release these worries by revealing them to Claudius or his mother. When handed the ideal chance to kill Claudius, Hamlet questions the circumstances and concludes he must kill the King when he is “about some act that has no relish of salvation in’t then trip him, . . . and that his soul may be as damn’d and black as hell.” (3.4.93-97) While Hamlet is distracted, Claudius schemes in the distance and neither one establishes a relationship with the other. Moreover, Hamlet’s obsession

Show More
Related
708 Words | 3 Pages

Throughout Shakespeare’s drama, “Hamlet,” he uses very sophisticated and artful diction. In Shakespeare’s first soliloquy, he is very graphic and straightforward with the meaning behind his distressed demeanor. “Oh, that this too, too sullied flesh would melt, Thaw, and resolve itself into a dew,” affirms Hamlet’s graphic, artful diction used to describe the way he feels about his mom, Gertrude, marrying his father’s brother, Claudius. The hatred of Claudius stems back earlier in Hamlet’s life, his father’s death.

Read More
707 Words | 3 Pages

Hamlet is a Shakespearean play about a distraught prince who comes home to Denmark at the news of his father’s death. Once he finds out that his uncle Claudius has married his mother and become king himself, Hamlet suspects foul play. When his father 's ghost comes back to tell him of Claudius’s sins, he is asked to murder Claudius for revenge, but he isn’t sure if he can do it. Some scholars, researchers, and casual readers would argue that this drives Hamlet mad by burdening him with decision. Others would say that after he accepts his father 's plea for vengeance, that he uses this cloak of madness as a disguise so Claudius cannot see his murderous intentions.

Read More
668 Words | 3 Pages

Claudius’s distrusting nature is first revealed to us because he believes there has to be a bigger reason for Hamlet’s behavior, rather than

Read More
668 Words | 3 Pages

By analyzing Hamlet’s decision-making process and highlighting key moments in the play, such as the encounter with the ghost and his reluctance to take immediate action or seize opportunities for revenge, Gurcu sheds light on the web of relationships and events that unfold due to Hamlet’s actions. He states that “Hamlet’s delay, which has not up to now done any irreparable harm, will affect everyone: “In sparing the King, Hamlet sacrifices Polonius, Ophelia, Rosencrantz and Guildenstern, Laertes, the Queen and himself.” Hamlet is presented with the task of exacting revenge on Claudius for the murder of his father. With this, he cleverly devises many plans to kill Claudius but hesitates to do so when the opportunity approaches him. This choice that he made to spare Claudius would end up sacrificing many lives in addition to his.

Read More
266 Words | 2 Pages

Shakespeare has created many unique and peculiar characters throughout his works but Hamlet probably has to be one of the most bizarre personas within any of his writings. Hamlet’s simple inability to act upon his father’s death ultimately led to his own demise and destruction of the ones around him. He exhibits multiple times where he fails to follow through with his motives. On one occasion Hamlet misses the opportunity to assassinate Claudius, “...how all occasions do inform against me, and spur my dull revenge!... I do not know why yet I live to say ‘This thing’s to do;’...

Read More
679 Words | 3 Pages

As a result, secrets are also impelling behind Hamlet which makes him angry. Hamlet is very angry how his life got when his mother married Claudius, which leads Hamlet to start his revenge on King Claudius. For example, when Hamlet was talking to himself he says,” ...there she was marrying my uncle… that's not good, and no good can come of it either,” (Shakespeare 29). Hamlet does not like his mother and Claudius together because he knows something terrible will come from it. It leads Hamlet into finding out that his uncle, King Claudius, killed his father King Hamlet.

Read More
900 Words | 4 Pages

Accordingly, Hamlet is all too aware that he is behaving like a coward, and yet he cannot bring himself to act. He does not lack anger or passion, but he is correct when he says he lacks any “gall” (II. 2.

Read More
1013 Words | 5 Pages

Hamlet In Class Essay Hamlet is a play written by William Shakespeare around the 1600s that highlights what vengeance can do to people and how it changes the soul. Much like any other series that has come to life on the big screen, there are noticeable differences between the book and the film such as how they dress, speak, and much more. Compared to the text, the film made reader's imaginations of how the play is interpreted into reality, though with noticeable changes, helped readers visualize how the play would actually have looked like during the time it was written. To start off, the emotions felt during some scenes in the text can be interpreted differently from person to person while the film clearly shows how the characters felt

Read More
255 Words | 2 Pages

In Act I, Scene 2, we are introduced to Hamlet through development in relation to the other players at court. His uncle Claudius appears to run things as smoothly as possible, even in light of such a massive power shift, leaving Hamlet ever unconvinced: “A little more than kin, and less / than kind … Not so, my lord, I am too much in the sun” (Act I, Scene 2, Lines 64-67). He openly expresses his dissent as those closest to him devote sole focus on securing their own power, rather than mourning the loss of their fallen king. Hamlet rejects these illusions presented before him, instead choosing to turn inward and indulge in his own despair: “O God, God , / How (weary), stale, flat, and unprofitable / Seem to me all the uses of this world!” (Act

Read More
1228 Words | 5 Pages

Some people may believe that the connection and strong affection between Hamlet and his father caused his anger to kindle even more towards Claudius, eventually leading to Hamlet's ambition towards killing his uncle. However, Hamlet is not able to take revenge because of his emotions, but when he sets them aside he is able to take action and therefore is not affected by the love of his father. Hamlet says “[i]s it monstrous that this player here,/ But in a fiction, in a dream of passion,/ could force his soul so to his own conceit/ That from her working all his visage wanned,/ Tears in his eyes, distraction in his aspect,/ A broken voice, and his whole function suiting/ With forms to his conceit?

Read More
1071 Words | 5 Pages

In this tragic play, Hamlet is initially seen resenting his uncle, but an unexpected event that occurred gave Hamlet an even more valid reason to loathe his uncle, Claudius. When his fathers spirit had appeared one night, Hamlet visited the place where he was last seen. Promptly after, he is told to “revenge [his father’s] foul and most unnatural murder” (1.5.31). Seeing as Hamlet thought very highly of his father, there is no doubt that he would obey him and take revenge against the person who took his father’s life, especially after hearing that it was a cold-blooded and greedy murder. Hamlet spends the majority of the play feigning madness with not one intention of letting Claudius get away with his sin, as seen in act 3 when Hamlet decides that he will murder his uncle when he is “drunk asleep, or in his rage” (3.3.94) to ensure that he goes to hell, and not heaven.

Read More
739 Words | 3 Pages

The Tragedy of Hamlet is amongst the most influential and significant tragedies in English literature. Being one of Shakespeare’s most popular woks and among his most performed, Hamlet raised several symbols and themes that remains partly unsolved as its ambiguity survived to modern times. As a dramatic text, the play conveyed problematic themes through distinguished elements as well as specific modes of representation. This extract, from Scene 5.Act 1, highlights three main elements: context, form and content that not only forge the dramatization of the speech but also foreshadow the coming crucial actions. This paper sheds the light on these three elements to analyse how the relevant extract is dramatized.

Read More
718 Words | 3 Pages

He calls him a murderous villain, heartless, disloyal, and lustful. Hamlet’s insanity can be seen in this soliloquy because his mind is so caught up with everything and anything. He is so distressed with insignificant things as well as his desire for revenge. Hamlet’s mind is racing and he is filled with several emotions which he feels one after another, from distress and confusion to self-pity

Read More
1259 Words | 6 Pages

Throughout the conversation and various parts of the play, Hamlet expresses his disgust for his mother 's actions. He insults her by comparing his father to Hyperion and Claudius to a satyr. He tells Gertrude not to sin by sleeping with him and tells her she is nothing but lustful for marrying a man like Claudius when he says, “That blurs the grace and blush of modesty,/ Calls virtue hypocrite, takes off the rose/ From the fair forehead of an innocent love/ And sets a blister there, makes marriage vows/

Read More
575 Words | 3 Pages

Hamlet had heard of his fathers ghost coming to the kingdom and Hamlet finally sees it for his own eyes. The ghost had told Hamlet how Claudius was the one who actually killed King Hamlet. Telling Hamlet to get revenge on Claudius but not his mother. From that day Hamlet had been plotting on how to get revenge on Claudius. Hamlet planned to act as if he’s become mad so he would not get any attention of him knowing about Claudius being a murderer.

Read More

More about Edgar Sawtelle Sign Language Analysis

Related Topics

Open Document