ipl-logo

Edward Snowden's Paradoxes Of Whistleblowing

1443 Words6 Pages

It is the revelation of Edward Snowden: a complaint of violation of fundamental rights of the human being, or a crime of treason against his own country?
The dissemination of secret information has become common in recent times. Words like WikiLeaks1 have become popular quickly and characters such as Julian Assagne, Bradley Manning or Edward Snowden are recognized all over the world. Manning accused of leaking military and diplomatic documents has been sentenced by a military court to 35 years in prison. Edward Joseph Snowden, US technology consultant, informant, a former employee of the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) and the National Security Agency (NSA), He is the man of the moment, the man who became world news for make public, by The …show more content…

One of them, It was written at that time by Richard De George, in his text “Business Ethics”5. A different approach is supported by Michael Davies in his work “Some Paradoxes of Whistleblowing”6 (Appear in the magazine Business and Professional Ethics Journal). David model know as (the theory of complicity)6 lists certain conditions to complete: 1) the disclosure must come from the institution where the agent works, 2) the agent must be a person working in the institution, 3) the organization, being legitimate practical actions that are ethically questionable, 4) the agent believes that he will be accomplice morally unacceptable acts if he doesn’t disclosed publicly. Also Davies consider that, the points 3 and 4 are understood as concrete knowledge, which the Agent considers justified and true (for it must have solid evidence to back their actions). It is important to mention, moreover, that several countries have legislated with varied and disparate impact regard to Whistleblowing in particular as regards the protection of persons that they have put into practice (Whistleblowing Protection Act, US, Public Interest Disclosure, UK and Australia, or the Public Servants Disclosure Protection Act, in Canada)7. In the United States exists the Whistleblowing Protection Act since 2007.In other hand It is prohibited by Espionage Act any disclosure of confidential information from military bodies, security and

Show More
Related
59 Words | 1 Pages

Being an Intelligence Analyst in the military, Chelsea Manning’s job was to handle classified information, but she discovered documents that revealed atrocities committed by the US in Iraq. Feeling compelled to let people know what was happening in the Global War on Terror, she promptly released this sensitive information to a website known as Wikileaks for all to see.

Read More
441 Words | 2 Pages

“Ed Snowden from the N.S.A 30 year-old former contractor for N.S.A

Read More
518 Words | 3 Pages

For example, Edward Snowden exposed the National Security Agency for eavesdropping on Americans and people around the world, despite the possibility of being arrested and charged with heavy crimes. " So, what did the leaks tell us? First, they confirmed that the U.S. government, without obtaining any court warrants, routinely collects the phone logs of tens of millions, perhaps hundreds of millions, of Americans, who have no links to terrorism whatsoever,"(Source 3). The question is who is truly at fault? The government for doing that or Snowden for ratting them out to the public about

Read More
781 Words | 4 Pages

With Edward Snowden's NSA leaks, this issue was brought into relief. Was he full of moral superiority over a gray issue, or was he "that most awkward and infuriating of creatures-- a man of conscience," as John Cassidy wrote in his article "Why Edward Snowden is a Hero." Because, while Jeffrey Toobin wrote in "Edward Snowden is No Hero" that Snowden's leak was cemented in grandiose narcissism over an issue American citizens should have already digested, wasn't it after his leak that there arose an uproar over the NSA activities, which inevitably placed a modicum of agency back in the hands of the American people? I still wonder whether my perspective would be the same had Snowden released files which did more lasting harm to national security. But in that case, would that activism now be violent, instead of

Read More
1065 Words | 5 Pages

No one has a name or a personality, no one is known for their own. This concept led to Snowden’s death. Right after Snowden was hit, Dobbs was the only one in the plane who was aware- he cried, “‘Help the bombardier, help the bombardier’ And Snowden lay dying in the back” (50). Yossarian kept telling Dobbs, “I’m the bombardier.

Read More
855 Words | 4 Pages

In cases where there is a conflict between the two, the need for national security must take precedence. The lessons of classified information are complex and multifaceted, shaped by historical events, technological advancements, and political developments. From the 1953 overthrow of Iranian Prime Minister Mohammad Mossadegh to the 2013 leaks by National Security Agency contractor Edward Snowden, many examples of classified information being protected and disclosed, with significant

Read More
1280 Words | 6 Pages

Snowden, who was a computer systems contractor, worked for the National Security Agency and revealed to the public how the American Government was spying on its own citizens and foreigners. Snowden was committed to the truth which allowed him to reason and understand the difference between what is right and what is legal. Snowden was convinced that the truth requires an individual to do the right thing and not necessarily what is legal. However, doing the right thing could sometimes require an individual to break the law.

Read More
1651 Words | 7 Pages

Nowadays, “privacy” is becoming a popular conversation topic. Many people believe that if they do not do anything wrong in the face of technology and security, then they have nothing to hide. Professor Daniel J. Solove of George Washington University Law School, an internationally known expert in privacy law, wrote the article Why Privacy Matters Even if You Have ‘Nothing to Hide’, published in The Chronicle of Higher Education in May of 2011. Solove explains what privacy is and the value of privacy, and he insists that the ‘nothing to hide’ argument is wrong in this article. In the article, “Why Privacy Matters Even if You Have ‘Nothing to Hide’”, Daniel J. Solove uses ethos, pathos, and logos effectively by using strong sources, using

Read More
846 Words | 4 Pages

A few weeks later, these documents were released by The Guardian, and Edward Snowden was the reliable source. Now, people all over knew that the United States Government was spying on its own people through messages, internet searches, browser history, smart T.V’s and many many more. This case is ongoing, as he seeks asylum in other countries. This newfound information raises the question, is Mr. Snowden a traitor, or did he save us all by “blowing the whistle” to warn us about the unconstitutional collection of our private possessions protected by

Read More
554 Words | 3 Pages

The intelligence community should continue to release as much as it possibly can about surveillance programs without compromising sources and methods—even if they have not been leaked. Given Snowden’s widespread public acclaim, coming clean about such controversial intelligence programs is not just good government, but also provides the surest way to preserve vital intelligence capabilities. With greater transparency, intelligence agencies can stay one step ahead of future leakers and earn back the trust of a skeptical public. The United States should also pivot from

Read More
1588 Words | 7 Pages

During times of war, there is a national crisis to protect the country and the citizens living in it. Secrecy of military endeavors is of utmost importance, and disclosing facts about these topics could lose a war or risk millions of lives. The government takes away people 's rights in order to protect the country. Many people argue against the suspension of the writ of Habeas Corpus, and the Espionage and Sedition acts.

Read More
1755 Words | 8 Pages

WikiLeaks: An Ethical Synthesis Since November of2010, WikiLeaks has held the controversial position of being the world's foremost digital whistleblower haven. The site, founded and orchestrated by Julian Assange, has made a mission of exposing the underbelly of international political, military, and social operations. In pursuit of this mission, the site routinely publishes sensitive government materials, earning it a reputation of ruthless dedication to transparency. In doing so, however, it has endangered a number of individuals and the relationships between the international actors that are vital to the stability of global politics. Because of this, many argue that the mission of WikiLeaks, while just in its intention, is unjustifiably

Read More
1089 Words | 5 Pages

He is known for his part in leaking top secret NSA documents leading to revelations about the US surveillance on phone and internet communications. Snowden is now seeking asylum in Russia. He does not have the documents with him anymore as he has handed them over to First Look Media set up by Glenn Greenwald. The US government believe that the documents will never be returned to the NSA which leaves them to wonder what will be the next story to be revealed as not even the government can get access to the documents. Snowden actually tried to leave digital breadcrumbs when taking the documents so that the government would see what documents he looked at and what ones he copied and stole.

Read More
1471 Words | 6 Pages

The main issue in the Snowden controversy is the conflicting rights of private individuals and the US government with regard to the use of telecommunications and the internet. There are ethical issues surrounding this controversy and the most applicable ethical approach for this case is “Ethics by Rights Approach”. As a background, the reason why US government had declared Edward Snowden a traitor is his involvement in the leaking of about 1.7 million confidential US documents, 15,000 Australian intelligence files and 58,000 British intelligence files from the National Security Agency (or NSA) to the public. These confidential information were acquired by the NSA through the PRISM program by collaborating with big internet companies such

Read More
1919 Words | 8 Pages

This essay will consist of a summary of the movie as well as the ethical and moral values being portrayed in Snowden by the four main characters. Before starting this essay, let me

Read More

More about Edward Snowden's Paradoxes Of Whistleblowing

Related Topics

Open Document