ipl-logo

Einhard The Life Of Charlemagne Analysis

1519 Words7 Pages

The Life of Einhard:
Examining Bias in Einhard’s The Life of Charlemagne

Daniel A. Lastra
History 3120: Medieval Europe
March 4th 2016 Einhard’s The Life of Charlemagne is a biography of Charlemagne written by a contemporary, and a loyal courtier of Charlemagne. Due to the closeness between the subject of the biography, and its author, it is possible to get insight into parts of Charlemagne’s life, and his reign, that might not be available otherwise. However, Einhard’s close relationship with Charlemagne, whom he describes at one point as his foster-father, may create bias in his account of Charlemagne’s rule. Indeed, Einhard’s biography at times appears to present a one-sided account of the Merovingian King’s, Charlemagne’s …show more content…

Einhard is able to provide an account for the Merovingian Kings, though no living heirs were present of that Dynasty, and the dynasty had been out of power for several generations. However, Einhard is unable to do the same when it comes to the early years of Charlemagne’s life, due to nothing being written about it, and no living sources, or those familiar with it, being alive. While the early life of Charlemagne takes place contemporary to, and following, the seizure of the throne by Charlemagne’s father, he can find no similar sources to outline it. However, given that Charlemagne was the son of Pippin, who was the King of the Franks following the palace coup, and that the Carolingian dynasty recorded their deeds in annals, it seems unlikely that no deeds referring to Pippin’s son would be included within them. Further, the most influential annals, the Royal Frankish Annals, which recorded the major events for the Carolingians each year, and would likely have had information on Charlemagne, were certainly available to Einhard as it is from these very annals that Einhard drew his characterization of the Merovingian Dynasty. As Einhard had access to these records, his claim that no records of Charlemagne’s early life existed seems, at best, unlikely, and suggests that he purposely choose to ignore …show more content…

Whether it is the characterization of the Merovingians, the early life of Charlemagne, and his illegitimacy, or his failed campaign as part of an attempt to aid a Muslim ally in Spain, Einhard chooses to skip over facts that may be damaging to Charlemagne, and instead focus on the great deeds of the man he describes as a foster-father. For this reason, it is important to understand, when studying Einhard’s The Life of Charlemagne, that, while it is the single best source for information on Charlemagne as Einhard was indeed a contemporary with great access to the subject, it is written with a specific agenda. This leads to omissions in order to show the greatness of the character of Charlemagne, at the expense of a full accounting of events.
Bibliography
Bouchard, Constance. “Images of the Merovingians and Carolingians.” History Compass 4, no. 2 (2006): 293-307. Accessed February 24, 2016. DOI: 10.1111/j.1478-0542.2006.00315.x
Einhard, The Life of Charlemagne, trans. David Ganz. New York: Penguin Classics, 2008.
Ganz, David. Introduction to The Life of Charlemagne. New York: Penguin Classics, 2008.
Nitze, William. “Bedier's Epic Theory and the "Arthuriana" of Nennius.” Modern Philology 39, no. 1 (1941): 1–14. Accessed February 24, 2016.

Show More
Related
158 Words | 1 Pages

Charlemagne, also known as Charles the Great, ruled the Franks from 768–814 A.D. He was a kindhearted man, who also a merciless warrior. Charlemagne was resolved to expand his kingdom to a grandiose empire, which he completed especially well. He also converted the nation to Christianity and the nation’s customary language to Latin. People thought he ruled with the sword and with the cross.

Read More
133 Words | 1 Pages

Charlemagne (Charles the Great) was the elder son of Pepin the Short and a grandson of Charles Martel. A strong leader, Charlemagne wanted to create a new Christian Roman Empire in Western Europe. He defeated the Lombards in to protect the pope. Charles invaded spain and attacked the muslums. He also attacked the Saxsons andand converted them to Christianity.

Read More
813 Words | 4 Pages

The king saw it as their duty to “defend the holy Church of Christ from the attacks of pagans and infidels from without, and within to enforce the acceptance of the Catholic faith.” (Document 2) By this, his good intentions can be seen in forcing the conquered nations to accept Christianity, but he went astray with his methods. Charlemagne wished for the name of Jesus Christ to be glorified throughout the world as stated in the letter. The king himself, with great piety and devotion, “practiced the Christian religion in which he had been reared from infancy.” (Einhard, p. 36)

Read More
247 Words | 1 Pages

There are many examples in the document that reinforce Charlemagne’s status as a Christian warrior, particularly in his use of oaths and relics. First, Charlemagne’s war victories that were “…most skillfully planned and successfully fought...,” led him to the expansion of the Frank kingdom. He was also favored by the surrounding nations which helped the kingdom expansion by double. Charlemagne also valued his friendships with other kings or emperors in the area. It is stated that he left cities on the coast to the Greek Emperor for the sake of their friendship, “and because of the treaty that he had made with him”.

Read More
1713 Words | 7 Pages

Author of the book, Becoming Charlemagne, by Jeff Sypeck provides a clear glimpse into the life of one of the world’s greatest kings and ruler and later emperor Charlemagne, otherwise known as Karl or Charles the Great. Sypeck creates a vivid and strong look into the time of Charlemagne, early medieval Europe and some other important world leaders, including Pope Leo III, Irene the Byzantine emperor, Alcuin the scholar and Harun al-Rashid ruler of Baghdad. These figures are crucial to the story of Karl becoming Charlemagne, and their stories included in the book help form and symbolize Charlemagne the Ruler. Understanding Charlemagne and early medieval Europe is presented vibrantly throughout the book by in-depth stories, facts and a clear

Read More
184 Words | 1 Pages

Charlemagne was also known as Charles the Great. He was king of the Franks and he united the majority of Western Europe during the early Middle Ages. On top of that, he laid the foundations for modern France and Germany. He attempted to unite all Germanic peoples into one kingdom and convert his subjects to Christianity. Being a skilled military strategist, he spent much of his reign in warfare so that he could manage to accomplish his goals. Because of his position, he encouraged the Carolingian Renaissance.

Read More
922 Words | 4 Pages

Primary Source Paper 2 The Life of Charlemagne was written by Einhard a little after Charlemagne death in 814. Einhard wrote the biography to make sure that Charlemagne’s legacy would not be forgotten. He would list many points in this biography, but I’ve decided to only point out three of them. These three chapters are his deeds, his family life, and his life with the Christian religion.

Read More
458 Words | 2 Pages

When Charlemagne ascended the throne and had full control of the empire, he wanted to not only rule both his people and Romans, he was also interested in his people and the ones he conquered to convert to Christianity. (Pages 258-259). Charlemagne exceedingly cared about government as much as he cared about religion, which is why one of the things he did when first became an emperor was to make sure that the Pope Hadrian I, got his land back from the Lombard Kingdom and he has also helped the Pope on countless occasions. (Pg. 259). Yes, Charlemagne was truly successful in linking religion and governing, his people or the Romans did not rebel against him and during his ruling he was able to offer people opportunities to learn and deepen their understanding of the Christian faith.

Read More
1520 Words | 7 Pages

As an official in the palace and one of the king’s friends, Einhard had one of the best possible views of Charlemagne and his rule. In this “public history of this most distinguished and deservedly most famous king” (Einhard 51), Einhard writes to Charlemagne’s descendants and the rest of posterity about the fame of the Frankish Empire and to preserve the memory of its mightiest ruler. Einhard is an extremely biased author, however. Once upon a time, Charlemagne offered shelter and kindness to Einhard in his court, and in return Einhard ignored the more shocking facts about Charlemagne, like his true motives in practicing Catholicism and his dysfunctional family, specifically his daughters and grandchildren, even after Charlemagne’s death in

Read More
1894 Words | 8 Pages

Galbert of Bruges presents a story about Charles’ life as the Count of Flanders and how his death was plotted by the Erembalds Family. Galbert was an important notary to Count Charles because he provides an exceptional perspective by including different chapters to his progression. His work is definitely trustworthy because he describes all the succession and disputes that Charles has gone through as the Count of Flanders. As the notary for Charles, Galbert approaches his work with care and respect because he wants the readers to feel honored and pity for what Charles wanted to persuade throughout his reign. Additionally, Galbert provides significant evidences about Charles’ potential opportunities that he could have taken when he was offered many important titles as a result of a prodigious ruling to the Flanders.

Read More
853 Words | 4 Pages

Charlemagne was the one of the great rulers of early European history. He was the King of the Franks in the 8th century and facilitated great expansion of his empire through conquest and diplomacy. Einhard was a monk who lived under Charlemagne’s rule, and, in a glowing light, he wrote a biography of Charlemagne. Einhard describes many of Charlemagne’s achievements, and he also writes about Charlemagne’s character. Einhard believed Charlemagne was a great leader because of his military success, his beautification of the kingdom, and his exceptional character qualities.

Read More
1420 Words | 6 Pages

Charlemagne In the mid 800’s Einhard wrote The Life of Charlemagne. It was an accurate portrayal of character as well as honesty during a period of time where distortion was a common theme. Einhard was extremely biased in his favor of the patron. He claimed that after the last Merovingian King fell, there was no more power within the dynasty.

Read More
288 Words | 2 Pages

In the contemporary smartphone, internet, and infinite content society, there are no figures that present themselves in the same way Joseph Pulitzer, William Randolph Hearst, and Edward R. Murrow did in their respective time periods. The media market is far too diverse to support a system where there is only one source of news as was the case in the past. The internet provides a platform for ranges of voices that would not be heard in the age dominated by radio and television. This allows the general public the freedom of choice when it comes to selecting the type and political bent of journalism they want to consume and puts pressure on larger outlets to produce high quality journalism. However, it has allowed the phenomenon of fake news to

Read More
502 Words | 3 Pages

Among the final admonitions of his father, as recounted by Thegan in his Life of Louis, Louis was advised to: “Show unfailing mercy to his younger brothers and sisters, his nephews, and all his relatives.” Then he (Charlemagne) directed Louis to honor the bishop as fathers, to love the people as sons, to compel and direct haughty and worthless men into the ways of salvation, and to be a consoler of monks and a father to the poor. Louis was further advised “to appoint faithful and God-fearing ministers (bishops mainly), who would hold unjust gifts in loathing.” The exhortation of Charlemagne to his son greatly influenced his life and beliefs. De Jong makes the argument that kingship was conceived of as a sacred task (ministerium), shared with the various ordinances in the realm, bishops and counts first and foremost.

Read More
436 Words | 2 Pages

“ Our children are the rock on which our future will be built, our greatest asset as a nation. They will be the leaders of our country,the creators of our national wealth, those who care for and protect our people.” (Nelson Mandela). Before there were child labor laws, children often suffered many hardships. What is child labor?

Read More

More about Einhard The Life Of Charlemagne Analysis

Related Topics

Open Document