ipl-logo

Essay On Circumstantial Evidence

769 Words4 Pages

The most essential part of our judicial system is that it is based on the presumption that the accused is innocent unless proven guilty beyond doubt. Also it is better that ten guilty are held free than one innocent being falsely implicated in a case. Thus the burden of proof in a criminal case is very high. Circumstantial evidence is basically the evidence which is furnished not by direct testimony of an eye witness to the fact to be proved, but by relying on the fact or other auxiliary facts which can be relied upon as incompatible with any result other than truth of principal fact. Circumstantial evidence can be fully apprehended if it is compared in context of direct evidence. It is a type of evidence which is simply direct evidence applied indirectly. The whole discussion brings us back to the most fundamental question i.e. whether the circumstantial evidence can be used as sole basis of conviction or not. The fact cannot be denied that circumstantial evidence plays a pivotal role in a criminal case. It has helped the courts in administration of justice in so many landmark cases which heavily relied on circumstantial evidence. Generally …show more content…

The law is well settled that each and every incriminating circumstance is required to be clearly established with supporting evidences and also the chain of events should be complete in such a manner that the only conclusion which could be drawn is guilt of the accused and no other hypothesis against the guilt is possible. The Supreme court also didn’t hesitate in giving death sentence to the murderer only because the case relied on circumstantial evidence. The general rule is that it is admissible in a court of law but they are required to be cautious when a case solely relies on circumstantial evidence. All the facts should be closely examined and it must be looked at

Show More
Related

Summary: The Case Of Sabrina Limon

708 Words | 3 Pages

This information is significant because it has provided the prosecuting team with direct insight into the conspiracy and what roles were played by the couple. The strength of this evidence added substantial weight to the case against Sabrina. Generally, physical evidence helps verify one’s testimony within a case, which is evident with Hearn’s testimony because he was assisted by recorded conversations and screenshots of text messages. Overall, the presence of strong evidence was fundamental in the Sabrina Limon case as it provided solid foundations for the prosecution’s arguments which ensured credibility of the witnesses’ testimonies as it would ultimately lead to a conviction that demonstrated beyond reasonable doubt that Sabrina Limon played a role in the death of her husband. This case stands as an indication of the intricate work of the judicial system as it navigates the complexities of a high-profile murder trial.

Read More

Gary Graham Case Study

637 Words | 3 Pages

There was a case study in Houston, Texas regarding Gary Graham. The state accused Gary of murder, and no one had sufficient evidence that he shot another person. After sustaining evidence, they started to realize that they prosecuted an innocent man. The witnesses who testified could not identify who killed the woman. The only evidence that the Law Enforcement officers had was a picture of Gary and a line up which pointed out Graham.

Read More

Anthro 3211: Test Your Knowledge

1333 Words | 6 Pages

Da-Nisha Mitchell Anthro 3211 Test Your Knowledge Chapter 3 1.Judge or Jury who listens to tell if statements are true. 2.Evidence is anything, objects, witness that are used to make a defendant guilty or Innocent. 3.Circumstantial, conclusive, conflicting and exculpatory 4.Evidence used to make the defendant look Innocent 5.Looking at what is left behind; events, evidence. 6.A direct transfer is when it goes to the source like a drug dealer selling drugs to someone.

Read More

Smell Of Death: The Casey Anthony Trial

593 Words | 3 Pages

The smell in the trunk of the car was tested and contained a large amount of chloroform and key compounds of human decomposition. Evidence is evidence but not all evidence is good, but the “smell of death” that was in the trunk could have been used as good evidence to the case. Why? Because they did not have any other good evidence to prove that she killed her daughter, but that one piece of evidence alone could have convicted her of murdering her daughter.

Read More

Amanda Knox Case: Defense Of Fallacies Of The Guilty Verdict

1251 Words | 6 Pages

However, after a critical examination of the evidence revealed serious flaws in the case against her with lack of forensic evidence, lack of motive, and improper collection of evidence. One of the most important pieces of evidence in a court case is the forensic DNA evidence. At the crime scene, there was

Read More

Lizzie Borden Research Paper

2476 Words | 10 Pages

A look at the evidence of the murder case proves

Read More

Summary Of The Supreme Court Case Of Brady V. Bobti

596 Words | 3 Pages

Introduction: The United States Supreme Court cases of Brady v. Maryland, Giglio v. United States, and United States v. Agurs all deal with the prosecution's obligation to disclose exculpatory evidence to the defense. These cases establish that prosecutors have a constitutional duty to disclose all evidence favorable to the accused. Failure to disclose this information violates due process and can result in a new trial or acquittal.

Read More

Wayne Williams Fiber Evidence Essay

629 Words | 3 Pages

The fiber evidence presented in this case was so overwhelming and simply was the driving force leading to Wayne Williams conviction. I do not believe the prosecution would have been able to obtain the same results without it. The credibility of the FBI forensics investigators and their reputable crime lab made for excellent testimony concerning the fiber evidence at trail, which the defense was simply ill prepared to counter attack its merits (The Atlanta, n.d.). Other evidence was presented in this case, and much of this evidence while certainly impactful on the case and to members of the jury, this evidence alone without the fiber evidence would surely not have held up to the standard of beyond a reasonable doubt.

Read More

James Richardson's Innocence

927 Words | 4 Pages

This shows that evidence is an important role in pleading someone guilty. When you convict someone of a crime, make sure you know the evidence and information on the case before sentencing

Read More

Why Do People Convicted When They Only Have Circumstantial Evidence

606 Words | 3 Pages

Why are people always convicted on something they only have circumstantial evidence on? I believe that there is many more ways for a jury to find out if a person is guilty or not and circumstantial evidence is one of the main things they use. Most of the time people get blamed for something they didn’t do and they don’t even have all the evidence to prove that one is guilty. So then they end up going to jail for a crime they did not commit. I don’t believe a person should be convicted of a crime based only on circumstantial evidence because I don’t think it’s fair for the victim.

Read More

Comparing The Salem Witch Trials And The American Criminal Justice System

478 Words | 2 Pages

Today, modern standards require the burden of proof be brought forth by the plaintiff, or prosecution in criminal cases. This means that the accused no longer has to prove they did not commit the crime, but the prosecution has to prove that all the evidence proves the accused did in fact commit the crime in question. Circumstantial evidence is not enough, but physical evidence, or forensic evidence is now required in modern courts for a conviction. Additionally, the modern standard when considering evidence, and for conviction is “beyond a reasonable doubt.”

Read More

The CSI Effect

738 Words | 3 Pages

In the article “ The CSI Effect: TV Crime Dramas’ Impact on Real Life Cases” by Madeline Anderson states “ People who regularly view such shows can come away with specific ideas about the reliability and integrity of forensic evidence.” This represents that these shows give the wrong impression to the viewers on forensic evidence. Anderson as well says “ These ideas may lead jurors to except to see more forensic evidence in trials or to weigh such evidence more heavily than they would otherwise.” This shows that everything in the TV shows related the crime dramas, evidence wise there is a limit for how much the evidence can do in the actually case or in the court. Anderson states that “ It can also create false sense of confidence when it comes to understanding such evidence..”

Read More

Eyewitness Evidence

127 Words | 1 Pages

Finally, to significantly reduce eyewitness error, the criminal justice system must view eyewitness evidence as a type of trace evidence.45 Like other types of trace evidence, such as fingerprints, DNA, and firearm patterns, eyewitness evidence has a physiological basis (i.e., biochemical changes in the eyewitness’s brain).46 Consequently, the accuracy of eyewitness testimony, like other types of trace evidence, depends in large part on the use of proper scientific procedures in collecting and preserving it. In short, before admitting eyewitness evidence, a judge should always first determine if valid scientific procedures were followed in producing it. If they were not followed, this failure should generally weigh heavily against admitting

Read More

Evidence In 12 Angry Men

488 Words | 2 Pages

Another piece of evidence is a woman who swears to have seen the young man stabbed the father through the last two windows of the train. The evidence says that she was asleep and when she woke up and turned to the window through the last two windows of the train, she was able to see how the young man stabbed his father. The only problem with this argument is that the woman wore bifocal glasses and nobody usually sleeps with glasses so it would be very difficult that without their lenses of such magnitude could see what actually

Read More

Cardinal Principles Essay

1076 Words | 5 Pages

The prosecution bears the legal burden to prove the guilt of defendant beyond reasonable doubt in criminal cases whereby the defendant bears the evidential burden

Read More

More about Essay On Circumstantial Evidence

Open Document