ipl-logo

Essay On Dismiss The Defense

568 Words3 Pages

Dismiss the Defense

How many criminals are we allowing to slip through the Law on the grounds of insanity and are they actually crazy or just crazy smart. The insanity plea allows criminals with a psychotic disorder to be reprieved of a trial because they weren’t working of their own accord during the time of their offense (Bikel, Ofra). Although psychosis can influence mentally and physically (IMH) the plea of insanity is an unjustified form of defense in the American Judicial System.

The insanity plea is a unjustified form of defense because of many different reasons. To start with “when someone is developing a serious mental illness with psychosis, such as schizophrenia, they usually do not know it” says Gerald Goodman, PhD in psychology (Kam). It is not possible to say your psychotic if you can not distinguish or acknowledge the existence of your disorder. The definition of psychosis is a severe mental disorder in which thoughts and emotions are so impaired that contact is lost with external reality. Impairment of thoughts or emotions can be a cause and effect of a crime, but it can also result in the inability to understand the fact that impaired thoughts or emotions are part of a psychotic lifestyle. People with psychosis are not competent enough to distinguish the line between fact and fantasy (IMH). …show more content…

Pure malingering is making up a non-existent disorder in order to get out of duty or gain benefits such as being reprieved from tria (Harris, Michael R)l. Malingering is more likely to occur when the personal stakes are extremely high and no other options appear viable. Escaping criminal liability and potential incarceration is a common motivation to malinger. The existence of malingering in the population of criminal patients who are seeking compensation has been estimated to be 25% to 50% (Moorhead, Joel F). Malingering is

Show More
Related

Insanity Defense Of Andrea Yates

935 Words | 4 Pages

Dr. Mark Nolan, Senior Lecturer at ANU College of Law, says that the NGRI plea “enables defendants to avoid criminal liability and standard criminal punishment” (Nolan 8). The main disagreement with America is the focus whether if the “guilty defendant” pursues to misuse the “Not Guilty by Reason of Insanity” as an alternative to imprisonment or if the criminally accused was at the time of committing the crime “clinically insane” and in need psychotherapy. Therefore, during this discussion of opposing viewpoints concerning the insanity defense being misused or ethical are going to be

Read More

Two Arguments Against The Insanity Defense By Thomas Szasz

242 Words | 1 Pages

So what can be done? A few numbers of American writers have argued that the insanity defence should be abolished. Two arguments have been relied upon. The first is that the insane defendant should be able to rely upon the same defenses as a sane defendant. For an instance, if an insane person lacks mens rea for an offence he deserves to be acquitted.

Read More

The Insanity Verdict On Trial By Scott O. Lilienfeld

1669 Words | 7 Pages

What exactly is the insanity defense? In a criminal trial situation the insanity defense is used to explain that the defendant was not responsible for his or her actions at the time the crime was committed due to a mental health illness or a mental handicap. Now you have to think of the reasoning, is this form of defense used as an actual defense for one who irresponsibly committed a crime or as a last resort hoping for an acquittal before a defendant is about to be handed a guilty verdict? Most people being asked would say it is being used for sane people trying to get out of a crime they committed, but I believe the insanity defense is misunderstood by society and should strictly be used for its creation of mentally ill individuals.

Read More

Use Of The Insanity Plea By Andrea Yates

2597 Words | 11 Pages

During my true crime podcast era, I came across Andrea Yates. Yates was a mother who killed her five young children by drowning them in a bathtub. While listening to this case, it was revealed that the insanity plea, or also known as the insanity defense, was used. It got me thinking about how the plea works and how people would allow this outcome over a jail sentence. The insanity plea is a tough topic to tackle in the world of criminal law.

Read More

The Pros And Cons Of The Insanity Defense

1562 Words | 7 Pages

Most courts require additional elements to acquit the defendant even if he or she has proven not in control of his or her behavior (“Insanity Defense Pros and Cons”). Other elements include witnesses or the previous medical records of the defendant. Without the prior knowledge of the defendant's mental situation the defense has no back up information or proof. Jurisdictions allowing the defense to still stand will undoubtedly turn down the plea for insanity without those records shared in court. The records need to hold substantial information stating that the defendant was so mentally ill that they did not know right from wrong during the time of the crime or has a disease such as schizophrenia or other causing sporadic mental incapacities in order to prove the burden of proof of beyond a reasonable doubt.

Read More

Case Study Lorena Robbitt

1241 Words | 5 Pages

Malingering Malingering is, “exaggerate or feign illness in order to escape duty or work” (Google Search). No evidence of malingering was involved in Lorena’s case, if anything she took on the role/title of a domestic abuse survivors, but this does not correlate to her taking a sick role of depression. She had already had that mental disease and was not escaping trial or anything, she was found competent to stand trial and was acquitted by reason of temporary

Read More

Pros And Cons Of The Insanity Plea

1086 Words | 5 Pages

This was later carried out through twenty-six other states, including the U.S., which created a precedent against the execution of the mentally ill in 1986. Even though the mentally ill cannot be executed, if the person who claimed mental illness is no longer mentally ill he or she can be executed. While the insanity plea proves that some criminals are mentally unstable, it should be used with caution because many convicted criminals abuse it during court cases, imitate being mentally ill during an examination, and are able to avoid the death penalty. Despite that the insanity plea can potentially help someone in defense for a mental illness case, many people can also take advantage of these precedents to alleviate their trials. The public in most insanity plea cases, do not typically agree with the rulings because most criminals use the

Read More

The Pros And Cons Of The Insanity Defense

1114 Words | 5 Pages

In the American legal system, there is a well known criminal defense strategy called the insanity defense. This plea ultimately claims and acknowledges that the person being tried was involved in the crime but was not, however, in a sound mental state and should therefore be pardoned from their actions. This idea was created in order to provide a defense for the criminals who do not have a sound mind, getting the court to label them as innocent as a result of their insanity. This particular method of defense falls under something called the excuse defense category, which uses an excuse, in this case insanity, to remove the responsibility of one's actions that resulted in the harm of others or the crime committed. In order for this plea to actually

Read More

Insanity Plea Pros And Cons

543 Words | 3 Pages

Penal institutions in America are already over packed making it harder for the prison guards to look out for everyone. Mental diseases such as schizophrenia and bipolar disorder can make it hard to control for their thoughts and actions, which results in them committing malicious crimes, such as murder. But, these personas do not know that they are doing something terribly wrong. Because of this, they sometimes end up in prison. But with the insanity plea, the accused have a chance in defending themselves.

Read More

Lee Robin's Case Summary

593 Words | 3 Pages

An incident where pleading insanity worked in one’s favor is heard in the case of Lee Robin. Lee Robin was a 30-year-old doctor who was charged with murder of his wife and his two year old daughter. Robin admitted to killing his wife with an ax and drowning his infant daughter. After the murders, Robin called the police and reported that there was “a problem” at his home. Soon after, the police arrived.

Read More

Insanity Plea Persuasive Essay

733 Words | 3 Pages

The fact is that the insanity plea only covers those who are truly insane, and even then, they must provide “clear and convincing evidence”, meaning that there must be some sort of absolute that provides their excuse.(Source C) Many of the crimes that are pleaded for insanity actually fall under diminished capacity. This is where the controversy is born, under the belief that those who are pleading for insanity are only incapacitated, not insane. The Courts are able to distinguish these differences. “Insanity plea statistics reveals that almost 70% of defendants withdrew their defense on insanity plea when their respective state appointed experts found out that they were legally san persons.”

Read More

Arguments For The Insanity Defense

2547 Words | 11 Pages

The insanity defense proves defendants not guilty by arguing that at the time of the crime they lacked the mental capacity to realize that they were committing a crime. This defense is currently used in 46 states, some of which allow defendants to argue that they had no control over their actions even if they realized that what they were doing was unlawful (Mental Health America). The insanity defense was created to impose a moral check on the judicial system; many people argued that if children aren’t punished for crimes because they are too young to realize that their actions are wrong, then adults who aren’t mentally capable of making this distinction shouldn’t be punished either. This defense, however, is often abused, which defeats its

Read More

Arguments Against Insanity Defense

874 Words | 4 Pages

Most defendants found “not guilty by reason of insanity” are incarcerated in a mental institute. Usually their sentence is longer than if they can been convicted and sent to prison (Smith, 2012). Overall, the insanity defense is an interesting concept. While implemented to help those who needed it, over the years it has made many question its existence. Yet, it should be understood that it is not an easy plea to use or a slap on the wrist when the defendant is convicted.

Read More

Arguments Against Insanity Defense

1951 Words | 8 Pages

The Insanity Defense is used in about 1% of all court cases, in which only about 26% of them are actually successful (Asia-Pacific). By definition, Insanity Defense is “A defense asserted by an accused in a criminal prosecution to avoid liability for the commission of a crime because, at the time of the crime, the person did not appreciate the nature or quality or wrongfulness of the acts (West’s).” This is one the most controversial defense strategies used in the judicial system. It can be taken advantage of. Pleading not guilty by way of insanity should not be used in the Judicial System because in most cases, it is abused, used as a legal maneuver, and does not allow the death penalty.

Read More

Mental Defense Essay

500 Words | 2 Pages

Mental illness is all we seem to hear about lately in relation to crime. According to a Bureau of Justice statistical analysis roughly 61% of inmates have a recent history or are currently showing symptoms of mental illness. With those kind of numbers, it is reasonable to think that not guilty by reason of insanity (NGI or NGRI) is a common defense tactic. However, NGI, according to a 1991 study by the National Institute of Health, is used in approximately 1% of criminal cases.

Read More

More about Essay On Dismiss The Defense

Related Topics

Open Document