ipl-logo

Ethical Evaluation Of The PHS Decision Regarding The Tuskegee Study

686 Words3 Pages

Nicole Mills Professor Gilson Ethics and Moral Problems 1 May 2024 Ethical Evaluation of the PHS Decision Regarding the Tuskegee Study The Tuskegee Study of Untreated Syphilis in the Negro Male stands as a dark chapter in the history of medical research, raising profound ethical questions that continue to resonate to this day. The decision by the U.S. Public Health Service (PHS) to continue the study, despite its clear violations of ethical principles, warrants examination from multiple ethical perspectives. To begin, one ethical position that can be applied to evaluate the PHS decision is consequentialism. Consequentialism assesses the morality of an action based on its outcomes. From this perspective, the decision to continue the Tuskegee Study may be viewed as unethical due to its detrimental …show more content…

In contrast, some proponents of the PHS decision may argue that the study provided valuable insights into the natural progression of syphilis and informed subsequent medical practices. They contend that the lengthy nature of the study provided a unique opportunity to observe the disease’s evolution over time, including its various stages, which may not have been possible by other means. However, while acknowledging these potential contributions, it is essential to recognize that the purported benefits of the Tuskegee Study must be weighed against its profound shortcomings and the harm inflicted upon its participants. The knowledge gained from the study could arguably have been obtained through ethically sound research methods that prioritize the well-being of participants. The ends cannot justify the means when the means involve the violation of ethical principles and the promotion of harm and injustice. In conclusion, the PHS decision to continue the Tuskegee Study was ethically unjustifiable, as it violated fundamental

Show More
Related

The Immortal Life Of Henrietta Lacks By Rebecca Skloot

1631 Words | 7 Pages

This experiment, conducted by the U.S. Public Health Service, was intent to study the natural progression of syphilis in African American male population. The study participants voluntarily participated in the study but the researchers did not properly inform the participants on the availability of treatment or the risks of the disease if untreated. To make the matter worse, the participants were deliberately led to believe that they were receiving treatment from the Public Health Service for free, while the actual treatment was being withheld to achieve the purpose of the research. In today’s point of view, it is surprising that even the federal agency did not respect the dignity of human rights for the sake of research. In Henrietta’s era, even the federal agency did not follow the proper informed consent procedure, and a prestigious institution like John’s Hopkins did not have any regulations or office such as Institutional Review Boards (IRBs) to govern their research protocols to protect human subjects and their rights.

Read More

Outlook At Chapter 14 In Bad Blood Tuskegee

1003 Words | 5 Pages

This chapter reviews the long-term effect the experiment had on the African American population. Specifically, it discusses the effects the experiment has on the relationships between black and the American population and health care professionals. After the Tuskegee Syphilis Experiment, the African American population became very critical of health care professionals, therefore, they ignored the warnings given about the prevention and epidemic of AIDS. If it was not for the experiment that rightfully made black individuals not trust health care professional the rate of AIDS would have been lower, and less people would have been infected. Overall, the chapter goes to show that it is important for health care professional to be honest and transparent with patients and the population, so that a strong relationship can be formed so that there can be advances in health

Read More

Chapter Analysis: The Beauty In Breaking By Michele Harper

1283 Words | 6 Pages

This article gives multiple examples of unethical experiments performed on Black people one being the Tuskegee Syphilis Study. For 40 years, the Black men in the study were led to believe that they were being treated for “bad blood,” but in reality, they were not given proper treatment for syphilis. The result of withholding treatment from these men led to treatable deaths and their wives and children getting infected. Another unethical experiment mentioned in Medical Experiments on African-Americans in America was the work done by James Marion Sims, who is considered The Father of American gynecology. He performed multiple procedures on black slave women without anesthesia which was available at this time.

Read More

Why Is Henrietta Lacks Unethical

1416 Words | 6 Pages

In Tuskegee, Alabama a group of men were chosen for an experiment involving the observation of how syphilis occurs in black men and its long term non-treated consequences. At the time of the experiment, the only treatment that was available was a heavy metal therapy; however, the scientists believed it was doing more harm than good. Therefore, they did not inform the men about the treatment and distracted them with basic incentives like hot meals and transportation. When penicillin, a cure for syphilis, was discovered the doctors made the decision to shield the cure away from the men. This is proof that scientists are

Read More

Miss Evers Boys Ethics Paper

876 Words | 4 Pages

Miss Evers' Boys Ethics Paper. The Tuskegee Syphilis research, which started in the 1930s, was an unethical prospective research that focused on the disparities between white and black males. In order to test the impact of untreated syphilis, black men and their families were mistreated in this study. One of the worst injustices in American history, the Tuskegee Syphilis Study involved volunteers who knew very little about the illness or the study.

Read More

Summary Of Miss Evers Boys

1109 Words | 5 Pages

In the movie “Miss Evers Boys”, Nurse Eunice Evers takes an offer to work with two doctors on a program that was federally funded to treat patients afflicted with the syphilis disease in Tuskegee Alabama. The patients were only men and they agreed to take part in it because of the free treatment. After a while the program ended and money was offered to conduct an experiment. The experiment was the study of the effects of the syphilis disease on these men, specifically African Americans, whom didn’t receive treatment. Nurse Evers finds out from doctor Brodus that the four hundred plus men along with 200 uninfected men who served as controls, will be studied and not treated.

Read More

Similarities Between The 13th Amendment And The Fourteenth Amendment

1259 Words | 6 Pages

The USPS did not inform the participants about the reality of the experiment, and the subjects believed that they were treated for “bad blood,” another term for syphilis. Difficulties arose in finding the subjects to participate in the experiment because the overall rate of syphilis was below the expected thirty five percent. The subjects only agreed to participate because the physicians promised them free care, but the Tuskegee Study was not about treatment since USPHS did not test any new drugs nor improve the efficacy of the old treatment. It was aimed at collecting data on the evolution of syphilis at different stages on black males. Physicians performed a series of tests and medical examination on the subjects and called for blood testing intermittently to supplement the information from clinical examinations.

Read More

Tuskegee Syphilis Experiment Case Studies

1561 Words | 7 Pages

The Tuskegee Syphilis experiment was a case study conducted by the United States Public Health Service, a federal agency within the Department of Health and Human Services that is responsible for fostering health and safety in the country. The case study was conducted from 1932 to 1972 in the city of Tuskegee, Alabama. In this study, 399 African-American men who had syphilis, and 201 African-American men who were used as control groups were used as the subjects of this experiment. The main objective of this experiment was to observe the natural progress of untreated syphilis in African-American men.

Read More

Summary Of The Tuskegee Study

1741 Words | 7 Pages

Finally, the study further demonstrates the tendency of researchers to recruit subjects who were unable to resist participation or understand the risks involved in the research. The press reported that Tuskegee, Alabama was chosen as the place to perform the study because of the high incidence of syphilis. However, it was more likely chosen because of the race and economic status of those who lived there

Read More

Essay On Tuskegee Study

546 Words | 3 Pages

The Tuskegee study of Untreated Syphilis began in 1932, mainly designed to determine the history of untreated latent syphilis on 600 African American men in Tuskegee, Alabama. 201 out of 600 men were non-syphilitic just unknowingly involved in the study as a control group This study is known to be “the most infamous biomedical research study in the U.S history”. Most of these men had never visited a doctor and they had no idea what illness they had. All of the men agreed to be a participant thinking they were being treated for “bad blood” and plus they were given free medical care and meals.

Read More

Tuskegee Syphilis Experiment Essay

520 Words | 3 Pages

It has now been a quarter of a century, and yet the images and heartache that still evolve when the words "Tuskegee Syphilis Study" are brought up, still haunts people around the world and touches upon many professionals such as social workers, medical examiners, and so forth. Sometimes people hear about this disgusting human experiment in a highly visible way directed to the entire country as an example of what we as a country and people, in general, should not do. This occurred when the study first made national news in 1972, when President Clinton offered a formal apology, or when Hollywood actors star in a fictionalized television movie of the story. On the other hand the audience may become fainter: kept alive only by memories and stories told in the African American community, in queries that circulate over the world wide web and radio talk shows, or even in courses such as this one being taught by social workers, historians, sociologists, or bioethicists. This is neither the first nor the last unethical human experiment done under the human study for the medical purposes umbrella, basically stating it is ok to sacrifice a few people in the name of medical research.

Read More

Essay On The Tuskegee Syphilis Experiment

698 Words | 3 Pages

In the 25 years since the secrets of the Tuskegee syphilis experiment were revealed, it has become a powerful symbol of racism, medical miscount and the abuse of the vulnerable. The study, initially involved 600 black men, all whom were residents of Macon County, Alabama. The purpose of the study was to examine the progression of Syphilis among black males as it was left untreated. Before the test began the diseases causes and effects were well understood; and there was already a known cure “penicillin”. The Tuskegee Syphilis Experiment was morally, legally, socially and politically wrong.

Read More

Essay On The Tuskegee Study

630 Words | 3 Pages

Lasting forty years, the Tuskegee Syphilis Study still stands as the longest and most well-known case of researchers’ abusing African American subjects of an experiment in unethical ways. In 1932, the U.S. Public Health Service (PHS) started the project as a way to study the manner in which syphilis presented itself in blacks verses in whites. Researchers used 600 poor African American sharecroppers in Macon County, Alabama, as test subjects. The researchers also never told the subjects what was happening to them. For years, the subjects were under the impression that they were receiving free medical treatment for their illness; however, in reality these government medical personnel were withholding treatment and gathering data on syphilis.

Read More

Essay On The Tuskegee Experiment

745 Words | 3 Pages

Autopsy and physician assessments were done at local hospitals. This means a bunch of Tuskegee Institute faculty and staff were involved in the study. The fact that these doctors knew what was going on and didn’t do anything to stop the situation means they were not respecting their rights to be doctors, if you ask me. A doctor is obligated to help anyone they can and these doctors just turned their heads and looked the other way. Though this is one of the reasons the study was unethical, the main reason became known in 1940 when penicillin was discovered to cure syphilis and the researchers still did not offer the medicine to the test

Read More

Ethical Principles In The Film 'Miss Evers Boys'

1121 Words | 5 Pages

This study was referred to as the “Tuskegee Study of Untreated Syphilis

Read More

More about Ethical Evaluation Of The PHS Decision Regarding The Tuskegee Study

Open Document