ipl-logo

Ethical Issues In Michelle Harper's The Beauty In Breaking

521 Words3 Pages

In the memior “The Beauty In Breaking” by Michelle Harper, we are presented with many ethical issues Dr.Harper faces as an African American female emergency medicine doctor. Doctor Harper is overqualified for many occupational positions and opportunities she is turned down for because she is female. It is essential to recognize that even though progress has been made to prevent sex-based discrimination in the workplace, it still occurs. Although discrimination against gender in the workplace has lessened in recent years, women will still face unfair systemic inequality in professional settings, including underrepresentation in leadership roles and lack of authority.
Women also commonly face a lack of promotional opportunities in the workplace. Men are often favored or given more opportunities than women for leadership positions. Women are even overlooked for these positions, even when highly (or overly) qualified. Michelle Harper covers this issue in many different interviews and in her book. She was often turned down promotional opportunities due to being a woman in medicine. Harper refers to when she is turned down from a promotion, not because there was someone more …show more content…

Being a doctor requires patients to feel confident in their provider, and when coworkers provide a sense of powerlessness, it can make patients feel scared to be treated. This is a continuation of the idea that women are underqualified for their positions. Doctor Harper is also faced with this issue, being discriminated against by her coworkers. “... I am waiting for a callback from hospital ethics. I told them the whole case because I do not think he can refuse an exam and medical interventions… Her tone was more indictment than question” (Harper 103); Harper is referring to the “questions” she received from her coworker that seemed to question her authority more than it intended to ask a

Show More
Related
938 Words | 4 Pages

Being both African American and female took its toll on Crumpler’s practices, yet she persisted. While focusing on her studies at the New England Female Medical College, Crumpler was ridiculed by colleagues. “She faced intense racism and sexism working as a physician in the postwar South” (Balzer). Knowing the light at the end of the tunnel would be her promising career as a physician, Crumpler kept going despite the abuse. “White doctors ignored her, made jokes at her expense and discounted her work” (“Dr. Rebecca Lee Crumpler”).

Read More
1023 Words | 5 Pages

Henrietta Lack was an African American woman born in 1920 who helped science define some of the world’s medical discoveries. Many woman were dying every year from cervical cancer. Little did she know what the future held for her and millions of other people. This situation saddens me as a medical professional because a human was treated as a specimen rather than a person. Even though this was many decades ago, I feel as though there still should have been standard practices in place that prevented this kind of behavior from those who are supposed to be trusted most, health care professionals.

Read More
1568 Words | 7 Pages

Despite their instrumental contributions, women often found themselves marginalized within male-dominated leadership structures.

Read More
1001 Words | 5 Pages

This is the strongest piece of evidence as the author is providing researched facts to support her argument. Finally, O’Rourke employs stories of those around her who have also witnessed or experienced discrimination in the medical field. All in all, O’Rourke does an excellent job of backing up her argument with the use of her own experiences and other individuals’ experiences together with convincing

Read More
1874 Words | 8 Pages

African American Women’s Medical Mistrust in Relation to the US Healthcare System The relationship between African American women and the US healthcare system is often described as mistrust. This mistrust stems from a history of unethical practices, systematic racism, and lack of equitable care. The radiologic technologist is a key provider of diagnostic imaging and plays a vital role in healthcare delivery. They must apply proper communication skills with all patients, regardless of cultural background and beliefs, to provide care and build trust among diverse patients.

Read More
532 Words | 3 Pages

Unconsciously, medical professionals make unfair assumptions about one’s character based on one’s skin color, a behavior that is surprisingly learned by medical students during their time at medical

Read More
1945 Words | 8 Pages

Stone’s personal experiences shed light on the difficulties that women encountered in their work, as well as the discrimination and prejudices that they faced. A challenge that Stone describes is the lack of respect and recognition that women received for their work. She writes, “The surgeons do not seem to think we can do much good” (Stone, 1865 p.27). Women were often viewed as inferior to male doctors, and their contributions were not always valued or recognized. Stone also writes about the gendered expectations and prejudices that women faced when serving as nurses.

Read More
1762 Words | 8 Pages

hospitals during the 1960s and 1970s when many women, primarily Latina women were forced into sterilization in attempts of a population control mechanism. The film describes the negative affects these women faced from guilt and the rejection of their families and husbands. Although ten women who were affected from this forced sterilization filed a lawsuit to the supreme court, they lost the case due to a cultural difference that was unforeseen by doctors. Even though the ruling was clearly based off racial privilege, the awareness of the unspoken political agenda by systemic racism and was able to shed light into furthering women autonomy during medical visits. In the same way, the article mentioned earlier by Dorothy Roberts serves as a reinforcement of systematic discrimination done through larger institutions to retain ethnic oppression by regulating population

Read More
524 Words | 3 Pages

As modern society has made clear, women have the ability to perform with equal skill and success in virtually every endeavor engaged in by men, including employment, athletics, academics and politics. Yet discrimination on the basis of sex has a long history in the United States, and its residual effects still operate to keep women's salaries lower and opportunities fewer in the employment

Read More
829 Words | 4 Pages

Racism is still immensely prevalent in today’s medical field. No matter which way society spins it, people are racist, sexist, and homophobic to everyone who does not look or act exactly like them. Doctors are the people in this world who are supposed to help everyone. They’re here to save lives,

Read More
1049 Words | 5 Pages

What I mean by this was well described by Tweedy, “As doctors, there is ultimately only so much that we can do for our patients, especially for the more disadvantaged in our society… But as doctors, we can do one simple thing for them: We can make our very best effort to treat everyone fairly” (Tweedy pg 152). As a future PA, I won’t be able to help all of my patients get jobs, pay their bills, ensure they are eating healthy and exercising, or even come in for help when they are ill. But what I can do, as Tweedy says, is ensure that when they do seek my help and care, that I give them excellent care. In order to do this, I hope to continue to educate myself on racial biases and disparities.

Read More
1280 Words | 6 Pages

Women have actually become a key part of not only the workforce, but the consumer market. However, it can still be challenging for a hardworking woman to get a decent pay raise or promotion compared to an average male who can start from the bottom and move straight to the top in

Read More
1516 Words | 7 Pages

There are many countries with controversial laws surrounding abortion and the reproductive rights of women. For the sake of focusing on certain moral issues surrounding these laws, this essay will focus on the country of El Salvador. Before analyzing the various moral issues it is important to first understand just how strict the abortion laws in El Salvador are. An article written by Michelle Oberman focuses on comparing the most recent abortion regulations in the United States to those of El Salvador. In 1998 El Salvador revised their penal code that gave passes to women needing an abortion due to cases of rape, incest, or threat to maternal health to one that banned abortion altogether.

Read More
1752 Words | 8 Pages

Respect and equality are two aspects anyone would least expect to not have in an industry that saves lives. From the earliest of time in the medical care, there have been cases in the nursing profession the indicate racial discrimination and sexism by the result of others unnatural behaviors, following claims and the show unnoticed. In the issue of these cases, the Civil Right Act of 1964 begins to show unrecognized. For coming up nursing, they must think is this the right fit for them. The wrongful racial discrimination and sexism have been established in a nursing career recently through the influence of false behaviors of respect and equal rights in the industry.

Read More
760 Words | 4 Pages

Gender Stratification in The Workplace Over the years, women have fought their way through the various barriers thrown at them by society, they are now more educated, matching male participation rates in the labour force and they are seen to create more opportunities for themselves in the workplace. Despite these achievements, gender stratification still exists in organizations and corporations in the 21st century; this paper seeks to analyze the numerous reasons why women remain underrepresented in leadership positions in the workplace and how this causes a trickle-down effect for other females in non-managerial positions. One of the major factors influencing the progress women experience in their career advancement stems from the deep cultural-infused gender stereotypes associated

Read More

More about Ethical Issues In Michelle Harper's The Beauty In Breaking

Related Topics

Open Document