ipl-logo

Ethical Issues Of Section 230

2414 Words10 Pages

The modern internet is a critical tool for communication, information distribution, and commerce, however, it has also created new challenges for society, including the spread of disinformation, hate speech, and other harmful content. This paper explores the controversy surrounding Section (§) 230 and the legal responsibility of internet platforms for content promoted by their algorithms. § 230(c)(1)) of the Communications Decency Act states, “No provider or user of an interactive computer service shall be treated as the publisher or speaker of any information provided by another information content provider". This provides immunity to internet service providers (ISPs) and platforms when they make targeted recommendations and host information …show more content…

The ongoing Supreme Court case, Gonzalez v. Google, is pertinent to the determination of the future of §230 and the Internet as we know it. Ultimately, any approach to holding internet companies responsible for algorithm-promoted content must balance concerns related to free speech, innovation, and user safety. The broad interpretation of Section 230 provides internet companies with near-blanket protection and undermines the incentive to create a healthier online environment. The intersection of modern technology and media law is a rapidly evolving field, and though it is constantly changing directions, one aspect remains constant, Section 230 requires reformation–not eradication–to better balance the competing interests of free speech and user protection and will not infringe on the constitutionally protected First Amendment speech rights of internet platforms when specified and implemented …show more content…

The importance of free speech and innovation is just as important as holding online platforms accountable for the content they promote so that users are protected. This paper argues that tech giants should be held legally responsible for content promoted by their algorithms and that Section 230 should be reformed to balance the competing interests of free speech and user protection. By doing so, we can create a healthier online ecosystem that promotes free speech, innovation, and user safety. The Supreme Court's decision in Gonzalez v. Google will have a profound effect on the regulation of online platforms and the protection of free speech. It will also set an important precedent for future cases involving the liability of online platforms for harmful content posted. Balancing free speech and user protection is a complex issue that requires careful consideration of the interests involved. “Without Section 230(c)(1)’s broad immunity, platforms will need to grapple with a wider range of substantive legal questions about how their platforms operate and defend their decisions on the merits in court. Some cases will lead to liability, forcing platforms to think more carefully about the ways that algorithms can cause harm. But some—perhaps even most—cases will not,

Show More
Related

Summary Of Black Code By Ronald Deibert

1319 Words | 6 Pages

“Black Code: Surveillance, Privacy, and the Dark Side of the Internet,” written by Ronald J. Deibert, outlines different issues and benefits that have arised due to the growing use of the internet. Deibert begins his essay providing information about the internet such as the rapid growth of smartphones, how the internet has taken over most of societies lives, and key differences between previous technological innovations compared to the internet. He continues his essay by discussing the U.S.A. Patriot Act and how this law should be retracted based on the fact that various companies, like Google, can give the government our personal searches if they ask. Then, he talks about various types of cyber crimes and how we need stronger regulations to control the internet so these crimes would not be possible. Deibert concludes his essay explaining how the internet has provided many benefits in today’s nation, but the internet needs stricter regulations for our own protection.

Read More

Analysis Of Is Google Making USupid By Nicholas Carr

569 Words | 3 Pages

There are tendencies in this society, to expect the worst from various forms of new technologies and how they can affect people long term. However, a counterargument states that the increasing amount of technologies people use can be beneficial in a variety of ways. Within the persuasive essay, “Is Google Making Us Stupid” written by Nicholas Carr, demonstrates both opinions and elaborates on each of the arguments specified. Within this essay, I will illustrate how technologies, such as Google are not posing significant harm to its’ consumers. Arguments made within the article that demonstrate “Google” and other various forms of social media as being harmful to people, state that the overindulgence and massive exposure to a large amount of

Read More

Summary Of Is Google Making USupid By Nicholas Carr

694 Words | 3 Pages

Throughout “Is Google Making Us Stupid?”, Carr explores the theory that the Internet, which is viewed as one of the greatest inventions of all time, is actually harming the human race, and making us less human, and more machine. This is a perfect example of how seemingly favorable change can actually have a serious, long-lasting destructive effects on the recipients. Similarly, many seemingly atrocious changes may have silver linings, waiting to be

Read More

Rhetorical Analysis Of Vox By Rani Molla

979 Words | 4 Pages

For example, she acknowledges that Facebook has taken steps to address some of the concerns around its data collection practices, such as introducing new privacy tools and limiting data access for third-party apps. However, she argues that these measures are insufficient and that Facebook's business model is fundamentally at odds with user privacy and democratic values. By anticipating and addressing potential objections to her argument, Molla is able to strengthen her overall case and make it more difficult for readers to dismiss

Read More

Camp Delta Detainees Essay

474 Words | 2 Pages

How would you feel if you were mistreated and tortured? Detainees in Camp Delta face these in their everyday life. Camp Delta is located at the U.S. military base in Guantanamo Bay, Cuba. America set the camps up in 2002 to hold foreign terror suspects captured during the war against the Taliban and al-Qaeda in Afghanistan. Detainees were first kept in an improvised facility called Camp X-Ray which was replaced by a more permanent structure, Camp Delta, in 2003.

Read More

Adam Wells Third Era Of Legal Innovation In Today's Legal Industry

1993 Words | 8 Pages

Today, any legal problem is a short internet search away. Nonetheless, this online transformation, ultimately accelerated by the COVID-19 pandemic, has left a gap in the sector requiring development.

Read More

Research Paper On Is Modern America Like Fahrenheit 451

1149 Words | 5 Pages

According to a report by the Knight Foundation, 86% of college students believe that social media companies censor political views that they disagree with (Grimmer & Tucker, 2020). This is a concerning trend because it is leading to a lack of diversity of thought and ideas, which is essential for a healthy democracy. This technology addiction distracts people from reality and limits our ability to think. This excessive use of technology is a cause for concern because it is leading to a lack of meaningful human interaction and critical thinking. If America continues down this path, it may end up like the society depicted in Fahrenheit 451, where people are unable to think for

Read More

Decentralized Decision Making In The Crucible By Arthur Miller

797 Words | 4 Pages

In her article titled The Flip Side Of Internet Fame, Jessica Bennett focuses on how social media is a place that’s full of hysteria. Bennett says, “Online there are few checks and hardly any monitoring. Moreover, studies show that the anonymity of the net encourages people to say things they normally wouldn’t.” In an attempt to fit in, many take the side of the most common posted opinion even if extremely vulgar or offensive, which can send a large group of people in the same state of fury. These incidents on the internet can have a more hysteric effect, entire cities, states, and countries have felt endangered over a post on a website.

Read More

Federal Communication Commission's Ruling On The Open Internet Rules

2179 Words | 9 Pages

By now, you have probably heard about the Federal Communication Commission's, also known as the FCC, ruling on the Open Internet rules, but do you know what it means for you? The ruling is important to understand because it encompasses everyone who uses the internet and details the rights those users have. The ruling covers what internet service providers, what you can do, and what the FCC can do and required 400 pages of legal document to cover every avenue that could possibly be attacked in hopes to keep what we see as the internet today as what it will look like ten years from now. This essay will cover a few of the main rulings on the FCC decision of the Open Internet rules: an explanation of some rules, how they apply to consumers by using past examples, arguments against the Open Internet rules, critical responses to those arguments, and what will be ahead for the FCC.

Read More

Summary: The First Amendment

530 Words | 3 Pages

According to James Madison, “Congress shall make no law…. abridging the freedom of speech….” The First Amendment was written in 1789 and it has worked for decades. However, after the introduction of internet in human’s daily life, the society is now challenged with the idea of government’s role in monitoring the internet content. With situations that include threats, substance unsuitable for children, and online malicious behavior, there is a need for government’s regulation on people’s speech.

Read More

Essay On Why The Government Should Limit The First Amendment

800 Words | 4 Pages

"To define the government's role in internet content, we must first understand our constitution and what it allows. Right in the Bill of Rights, the 1st Amendment, free speech. To this country, there is nothing more important than that right. Without it, we wouldn’t be the country we are today. In wake of all of the negativity surrounding free speech, no one quite realizes what the bigger picture it about it.

Read More

Us National Government

1071 Words | 5 Pages

A major problem that has dominated the world in today’s society is the development of mass media. The mass media is said, “to be divided into two types: print and broadcast,” but the advancement of the internet became problematic. The internet allows the public to view the news by providing information between the citizens, and government faster than any other source. Consequently, this resulted in the decline of newspapers while more people began reading online. The negative effect of the internet is described as, “a wild west atmosphere” in which individuals may post whatever they wish online, “without professional, organizational, or legal concerns about its source” (Janda, Berry, Goldman, Schildkraut, and Manna, 2017, 148).

Read More

First Amendment Essay

1326 Words | 6 Pages

The legality of these orders was challenged in court, with courts ultimately blocking the ban from going into effect. These debates highlight the ongoing tension between free speech and regulation, particularly in the context of new and emerging technologies. While the First Amendment provides protections for freedom of expression, the challenges posed by social media and other online platforms raise important questions about how to ensure that these protections remain relevant in a changing media

Read More

First Amendment Protection

1159 Words | 5 Pages

1a) The internet is compared to provide an interpretation of the first amendment protection as it was not present at the time of passing protection laws as a communication medium to find a common ground because it has similarities and as well as differing natures, values, abuses and dangers to the library, television and public places which the law treats differently. Libraries: It requires the libraries to enable the filter to Internet access for adults as well as children if they want to receive funds for Internet hookups.

Read More

First Amendment Free Speech Analysis

651 Words | 3 Pages

The primary step in First Amendment free speech analysis is to determine whether the statute is conduct based or content neutral, and then apply the proper level of scrutiny.(Burson v. Freeman, 504 USC 191, 197-198). The limitation of sex offenders’ ability to access certain commercial social networking sites is content neutral. There may be certain times that where the government’s regulation has an incidental affect on expression. A regulation that serves purposes unrelated to the content of expression is content neutral, even if it has an incidental effect on some speakers or messages. (Renton v. Playtime Theatres, Inc., 475 U.S. 41, 47-48 (1986).)

Read More

More about Ethical Issues Of Section 230

Related Topics

Open Document