ipl-logo

Examples Of Expansion Dbq

1128 Words5 Pages

Jessica Ho 20 October 2017 Expansion DBQ Feedback Introduction: For my thesis, my main problem was relating continuation and departure to similarities and differences. I think the best way to fix my thesis would be to change “similar” to “continuation” and “difference” into “departure” since I can argue the continuation and departure in my body paragraphs. First Body Paragraph: My usage of Document 1 is flawed in that it does not directly correlate to the White Man’s Burden. The document talks about how the Anglo-Saxons are the superior race compared to all the other races. I also forgot to address that it is one person’s idea/opinion. Given that the document was written for the American Home Missionary Society, can lead to the conclusion …show more content…

I want to change my argument because the document supports the ideas of Manifest Destiny and Social Darwinism. With this in mind, I can analyze the document by noting key words and clues to point to these ideas. The mention of Christianity can support Manifest Destiny while the reference at the end of the document of “survival of the fittest” supports Social Darwinism. I can reference that Manifest Destiny was used as justification to expand westward into North America because it was their duty. These were two ideas to justify the expansion of America. This is continued in the turn of the century as people began to justify expansion using America’s rising power because of Manifest Destiny and and Social Darwinism as a reason. At this point I can use document 4, in which Beveridge mentions religion and how America was God’s “chosen people”, who could lead the world. This is Manifest Destiny because he says how it was God’s mission and America’s duty to expand. Also, it can be related to Social Darwinism because it is a competition among races, even though Beveridge makes it clear that America is the “fittest” and most successful. Taking into …show more content…

In Document 6, it shows a towering Uncle Sam holding a key to China under a literal open door. This represents America being successful in trading with China (presumably because of the territorial gains of the Philippines), and being able to block other countries from trading with China. I should include this in my DBQ next time. Also, I can relate this to the Open Door Note, which was America’s way of trying to make sure no other country could dominate trade in China. This ties back into my argument of a political continuation because it supports America’s constant motivation to prevent other nations from dominating a region. Third Body Paragraph: I did not explain why I accepted the league’s position, as their opinion is not a fact. I can support their position with facts about the war, such as the killing of many Filipino civilians and the denial of independence to the Philippines. I can also use this document to argue it was a departure from previous territorial gains because of the creation of this league. The league's creation implies that something changed since the past, which they cites as a new “[destruction] of our institutions”. The Supreme Court ruling was not against using the Constitution to be applied to unincorporated territories, but rather that the United States could decide whether the Constitution would be applied to the territories. I should fix that

Show More
Related

Annexation Philippines Dbq

588 Words | 3 Pages

Abraham Lincoln said :“No man is good enough to govern another man without that other’s consent.” In 1898 America won the Spanish-American War and during the aftermath the US was faced with a few choices when it came to the Philippines: hand the Philippines back to Spain, give the Philippines independence, or the US could annex the Philippines. The act of annexation was imperialistic, and imperialism was the practice of building an empire by founding colonies or conquering other nations. In the end the US decided to annex the Philippines, welcoming them to be a part of the US territory. Should the United States have annexed the Philippines?

Read More

Hoganson's Views On The Annexation Of The Philippines

616 Words | 3 Pages

Both Nell Irvin Painter and Kristin L. Hoganson have two different prospective on the annexation of the Philippines. Painter’s approach of explaining the annexation was more of an economic view rather then Hoganson’s, which was a more sexiest view. An example of Painter’s view is when he said,” the culprit, it seemed, was agricultural and industrial overproduction” (Painter). He is saying the America simply produced too much, and they did not care. Business thought taking over The Philippines would help American gain access to trading with China.

Read More

Ap Us Expansionism Dbq Analysis

447 Words | 2 Pages

Many Americans thought occupying foreign countries, like the Philippines after the Spanish American War, was a bad idea because it contradicts the American values of equality found in the Declaration of Independence and the Constitution. (Doc D) However, a majority of America sided with people like Senator Albert J. Beveridge who believed people were chosen by God to expand into China and the Philippines to open more Asian markets. (Doc E) This was a continuation of past expansionism because acquiring land for money Manifest Destiny have been motives for expansionism for

Read More

Shay's Rebellion Dbq Essay

1150 Words | 5 Pages

The Shay’s Rebellion, as well as economic depression in the United States, opened doors for protests and questions regarding the effectiveness of the Articles of Confederation. The question of whether a powerful central government was necessary to provide citizens fundamental rights caused deliberation among officials. After years of debate, the Articles of Confederation was overturned, resulting in the establishment of the United States Constitution. The Constitution, perceived as a supreme document, served as a solution to the defects of the Confederation. In 1787, the same year the Constitution was ratified, an essay was written, presumably by Robert Yates.

Read More

Albert Beveridge Annexation Of The Philippines Summary

790 Words | 4 Pages

The following publication of Albert J. Beveridge’s powerful speech, strongly advocates the annexation of the Philippines, which took a virtually major relationship between religion, race, and profit for imperial expansion. The most striking point about Albert J. Beveridge text, however is his five poorly thought out reasons justifiying Americas to colonize the Phillippines, which were religion, trade, keeping up with other countries, resources, and “barbarous” natives. Albert J. Beveridge, a first-term Republican senator from Indiana, was one of the most ardent advocates of imperialism. Noted for his speaking abilities and fervent nationalism, Beveridge traveled to the Philippines in order to gather information. In Albert J. Beveridge’s 1900

Read More

Annexed Philippines Dbq

749 Words | 3 Pages

In 1899, the United States annexed the Philippines after a short but bloody war with Spain. These rich, plentiful islands full of resources were in great demand. The U.S. saw the Philippines; fighting against Spain so like them when they were rebelling, and decided to step in and aid ‘the spirit of 1776’ (Doc. A). However, the question still remains: should the United States have annexed the Philippines?

Read More

James K. Polk Book Review

1155 Words | 5 Pages

It was the time when Manifest Destiny concept, an idea in special role and destiny of the United States, was highly popular. The concept that consequently justified the expansionism and nationalism. Therefore, Polk’s expansionist impulse, though strong and quite successful, was a product of dominant thoughts that were circulating among Americans.

Read More

Territorial Expansion Dbq Analysis

891 Words | 4 Pages

During the war of 1812 an important issue was that the British had continuously harassed and attacked many American ships carrying out goods to trade, therefore interfering with the American economy (Doc. B). It’s the same situation with the expansion issue from 1800 to 1855, the people who are opposing expansion are holding back any and all potential economic explosions that could happen with the expansion of the United States. Another reason the supporters of expansion had a greater influence on the idea of territorial expansion was that these people pulled out the patriotism card. Document G recognizes how the pro-expansion people said that riches and happiness would come from the new expansion, how wealth and happiness were patriotic, therefore, necessary for the United States to

Read More

To What Extent Were The Ideals Of The Declaration Of Independence Dbq Essay

801 Words | 4 Pages

The Declaration of Independence was a treaty declaring our separation from Britain. It had a set of rights promised to all human beings. These rights include, life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness. In the 1850s the U.S. did not fulfill the ideals of the Declaration of Independence because women and African Americans did not have equal rights.

Read More

Slavery Dbq Essay

909 Words | 4 Pages

In the years 1777 to 1865, the African American people, also known as Blacks, were used as slaves for the white men of America. Eventually, enslavement was abolished and was outlawed, as it is today. According to the map, The Abolition of Slavery, slavery in the northern states was still around during the years 1777 to around 1787. The New England states of Vermont, Maine, New Hampshire, Rhode Island, Massachusetts, and Connecticut got rid of slavery first, followed by the Midwest states and the Mid-Atlantic states.

Read More

William Mckinley On American Expansionism

374 Words | 2 Pages

William McKinley in his thoughts on American Expansionism has identified the reasons why America had no other choice but to incorporate Philippines as a part of it. This writing has been lifted from the excerpts of an interview with William McKinley soon after Spain had surrendered in the Spanish-American war. McKinley cleverly talks in this interview about how Philippines just came and fell into the laps of America thereby suggesting the helpless stance of America. He talks about how America’s sole intention and purpose had only been to safeguard its own interests as a country. He had to order that the Spanish fleets in Manila be destroyed because if left unattended, they would have crossed the Pacific and wreaked havoc in the American states

Read More

Arguments Against The Articles Of Confederation

1111 Words | 5 Pages

It should be the thought of any person capable of reason that the Federalist argument regarding the system of government is one requiring the utmost consideration possible. Those that argue against the ratification of the United States Constitution are arguing in favor of a document in need of too many corrections to be practical when a replacement is ready to take its place. The Articles lasted this young country through the War for Independence but they are unstable and now is the time to replace them with a basis that will provide America with unity, strength, and balance: exactly what this Constitution will provide. Under the Articles of Confederation, this nation will become weak and be ripe for the picking by the empires across the sea.

Read More

Trail Of Tears: Horrible And Genocidal Act

739 Words | 3 Pages

Americans were focused on western expansion in the name of manifest destiny, they thought that god wanted them to have the land.

Read More

Manifest Destiny By John L. O Sulliv Article Analysis

493 Words | 2 Pages

“Manifest Destiny,” written by John L. O’Sullivan, explains how expansion is needed for america and how it could better our nation. The painting “American Progress,”supports expansion by displaying what it looked like when the settlers moved in. The text, “Reporting to the President, September 23-December 31,1806,” by Stephen Ambrose, supports westward expansion by talking about how lewis and Clarke did good things to help westward expansion. What do you think about westward expansion?

Read More

What Role Does Race Play In American History

678 Words | 3 Pages

The study of American literature and history must take into account the roles that race played in the history of the United States. Throughout history the viewpoints on race have been different. American Literature will take you through time and inform you on how certain people viewed race and that must be understood when studying literature and history because of the fact that the way we think in this era is different. Nowadays, Racism and ethnic discrimination in the United States is highly frowned upon, but back in history different races were discriminated as “good or bad” playing significant, historical roles.

Read More

More about Examples Of Expansion Dbq

Related Topics

Open Document