ipl-logo

Fallacies In Waiting For Superman

997 Words4 Pages

We often think of the United States as the world hegemon or world geo political leader. However, despite what many would proudly proclaim, unlike military power or economic power, we are not the leader in education. The system is admittedly not perfect, but we are far from failing. Across the country, tons of prosperous ,successful, learning institutions are busy at work preparing the next generation for the challenges that lie ahead. But, there are those who think the system is in shambles. A great example of such can be seen in none other than in Davis Guggenheim’s acclaimed investigative documentary, Waiting for Superman. The roughly two hour long documentary, released back in 2010, shows some of the problems with the US education system …show more content…

The biggest sign of this, is Guggenheim’s crusade against the teacher’s unions, an establishment that he relentlessly attacks in the film as a major reason for educational malaise and poor teacher. However, Guggenheim only shows one minute isolated incident from the 1990’s in which one apathetic teacher sits idly by with a newspaper letting his students go unattended. And while admittedly, this is unacceptable for an educator to do, it doesn’t show the situation for all teachers in the country, nor does it even show the situation for all teachers in inner city schools. Throughout the film we never see a teacher or group of teacher voice their opinion on the problem in schooling, nor do we see them provide solutions. We only see opinions from those against public schooling and against the status quo of teaching. Guggenheim sets up a false reality in his film, a reality in which teachers are constantly on trial without any fair transparent recourse to defend or exchange ideas. The only teacher input shown in the film is one clip of a teacher union rejecting the idea of merit based pay. But that clip doesn’t give any insight from the perspective of an educator about teaching is really like, nor does it show any information from successful teachers that actually benefit education. All it does, is further Guggenheim’s crusade against teachers and public education. Guggenheim works to convey his point by suppressing the opposing side and not allowing for adequate rebuttal. Guggenheim focusses his lens on teaching instead of other issues in education like funding equity and federal management. And while there are certainly issues with the education system, Guggenheim misrepresents his

Show More
Related
474 Words | 2 Pages

In the book, “Rereading America,” written by Toni Cade Bambara along with Gary Colombo and Robert Cullen, Bambara focuses on the challenges and desire to teach by contras of what you don’t have and what you can achieve. (Bambara, pg. 253-259) It is without doubt that even though a cookie cutter theory is used in most schools; there will be certain social economical neighborhoods in which a teacher or adult will have to vary the process of communication in order to get his or her point across with dedication and teach the love for learning. Ms. Moore had been a wise educated woman who did not avoid the challenging attitudes of children going up in a disadvantaged economical community.

Read More
397 Words | 2 Pages

David Sirota's “Kenneth Cole gets Schooled”, is an essay that discusses Sirota’s thesis; that an “ongoing campaign against organized labor; for decades deeply rooted in American political culture, the crusade has been periodically amplified in popular culture as well, from 1954’s “On the Waterfront” all the way to the Sopranos’ depiction of mob-controlled unions (and sometimes pop culture and political culture have even fused)”. Sirota goes on to give great supporting evidence to support his thesis. He goes on to describe how an advertising campaign by Kenneth Cole’s foundation “portrays the national debate over education as one that supposedly puts “Teachers’ Rights vs. Students’ Rights.”

Read More
1226 Words | 5 Pages

If you were to change something about the education system in the U.S, what would you change? How would you critique the quality of education? Education historian Diane Ravitch answers these questions in her excerpt that was published in 2014, “The Essentials of a Good Education.” In her text Ravitch argues that the education system is flawed and that the vision of a good education is unfair and unequal. Ravitch supports her claim by providing examples of the negative effects of the educational system and using historical context.

Read More
898 Words | 4 Pages

He does this by explaining that as a parent, he also worries and cares for the success of his own children and is very aware of the degradation of the public education system. He also relays how his feelings about the public education system have come full circle as he opens up about a previous film he created in which he was actually supporting the idea that public schools worked. Guggenheim sincerely expressed why this has happened saying, “Ten years later, it was time to choose a school for my own children...and then reality set in. My feelings about public education didn’t matter as much as my fear of sending them to a failing school” (Waiting for “Superman”). Beginning with his own experience gains the audience’s trust.

Read More
252 Words | 2 Pages

The Book; Prisoner B-3087, by Alan Gratz is pretty good. It’s a novel about a nazi concentration camp, and a boy named Yanek who travels from camp to camp, being worked and worked. This book is a little gruesome, but its a great read. Never once did I want to put down the book, and the story gets better and better as you read. The Main Character, is named Yanek Gruener, or as the guard call him, B-3087.

Read More
1700 Words | 7 Pages

Nelson Mandela once said, “Education is the most powerful weapon which you can use to change the world” (Education). Education is a crucial making an intelligent and prosperous world. Every person is entitled to an equal education, deserving to be taught and have the ability to learn at the same beneficial level as any other person. However, the disparity between what some have for a school and what others have for schools that far surpass the others is unacceptable. Children in the United States are not getting the education they deserve to receive.

Read More
188 Words | 1 Pages

n “The Failure of American Public Education” (February 01 1993), John Hood explains the sundry perspectives on the American education system. Hood tactfully uses cause and effect to demonstrate the viewpoints of a myriad of individuals regarding American schools and their approaches to effectively educating students; he explains how “free-market thinkers believe that applying market competition to the public schools will solve many of America’s educational problems” (Hood) ; “critics believe that public education reforms fail because they are compromised or sabotaged by the education lobbies—teacher associations, administrators, and the legislators in their pockets” (Hood) and “many conservatives believe that American public education is in

Read More
933 Words | 4 Pages

Diane Ravitch, in her book, Reign of Error: The Hoax of the Privatization Movement and the Danger to America’s Public Schools (2013), takes on the privatization movement that has been limiting public school funding and straining the education of students across the nation. She highlights different issues and solutions with each chapter, most of which are issues that we all have faced throughout our lifetimes whether we knew it or not. In chapter twenty-one of her book, “Solutions: Start Here,” she addresses the fact that if poverty and educational equality are issues worth taking on, it must be taken seriously and backed by two intentions: changing society as a whole and improving schools and the educational system at the same time.

Read More
1522 Words | 7 Pages

Districting the New Segregation? Education has been a major influence on government policy and social standards concerning American youth. With hard work and education, one can better themselves and open up more opportunities for financial and social success. Waiting for Superman directed by Oscar winner, Davis Guggenheim, counters that the current education system is failing students by limiting their upward mobility, particularly among minority and low income groups. The documentary advocates for a radical change in the modern education system, modeled after charter school curriculums.

Read More
1057 Words | 5 Pages

The idea of classroom causing problems for America’s society is elaborated when President Johnson explains that many children in America don’t have enough money to afford school. “There your children’s lives will be shaped. Our society will not be great until every young mind is set free to scan the farthest reaches of thought and imagination.” In order for a society to be great, education is the foundation; schools are where child learn about their world, and what it is they will do in the future to earn money to live a good life. And to better prove his idea Johnson states, “Each year more than 100,000 high school graduates, with proved ability, do not enter college because they cannot afford it,” then questions what will happen in years when time has become elapsed to conclude any efforts are needed to come into play for there to be a Great Society.

Read More
221 Words | 1 Pages

The documentary relates to the United States in the way of that the public school system is broken. Government and political officials have repeatedly promised to correct the public school system and have failed to deliver. Programs such as the no child left behind act and standardized tests have been created to correct this system. But these programs and tests actually hurt this system since they are based on a narrow curriculum not measuring an individual student 's skills and talents. Other issues which are mentioned in the documentary and affect our country are teachers unions and tenure.

Read More
1845 Words | 8 Pages

Without a teacher, doctors would not be able to save the millions of lives that they do every day, nor would an engineer be able to lay out a civilization's prospective future, nor would a politician learn to lead and represent—there is a root to all, and education is what fuels the flame of growth and prosperity. The current educational policy and reform is taking the preconceived notion that there is something magical about teaching and assuming that all teachers can teach. For instance, former President Barack Obama’s Every Student Succeeds Act (ESSA) is a revival of the 50-year-old Elementary and Secondary Education Act (ESEA); both fortify the relationship between national law and commitment to ensuring the success of the nation’s students—America’s

Read More
575 Words | 3 Pages

The essay, The Seven Lesson Schoolteacher, by John Taylor Gatto addresses educational curriculum with a cynical truth that transpires around the United States. His brutal honesty grasps the reader by using common sense and a hint of sarcasm to appeal to humor. The main point of his argument in my perception, states that we must develop children to be critical thinkers and not always agree with authority. By allowing the schooling in a child’s development expecting them to not question an adult’s words does lead to a population that has accepted being dumbed down. Following what has been indicated, a direct quote positions people deprived forever of finding the center of their own special genius (Gatto, part III, pars 3).

Read More
405 Words | 2 Pages

Metaphor: “Why do I give my emotion an animal’s name, give it that dark squeeze of death?” The quote is a metaphor because the author is talking about the “bearhug” and mentions it as a dark squeeze of death. This establishes the fact that the squeeze or bearhug might be something that relieved the father and the son of their problems and longing just like death.

Read More
853 Words | 4 Pages

The movie, Freedom Writers did a very good job displaying the poor education system that was changing the lives of students already barely surviving in the violence and gangs. The use of the comparison of visuals what something the producers seemed to commonly use. The comparison of good to poor school materials was agonizing to see, especially with a up-close shot to Mrs. Gruwell trying to keep a smile on her face. Children are the future of our world, but many still will disown kids that aren 't the same ethnic background. Realizing this was essential, and luckily Erin Gruwell was able to do it and ultimately save her kids lives.

Read More

More about Fallacies In Waiting For Superman

Related Topics

Open Document