Father Jayme's Argument Analysis
I will outline the argument put forth by father Luis Jayme for support being sent from the Franciscian church to aid both neothytes (Indian converts to Christianity) and gentiles (non-converted Indians), who are allegedly subject to rape from the Portuguese soldiers. Father Jayme Is sympathetic towards the native Indians who he believes act in a better nature than that of the Portuguese soldiers. In summary, Jayme notes of his own Spanish Christians, he writes "I burst into tears to see how these neophytes were setting an example for us Christians"1. The outrageous acts of rape performed by the soldiers referencing personal accounts given to him by the native Americans as his main source of evidence. "some soldiers went their and raped their women ..... three other Indian villages about a league or a league and a half from here have reported the same thing to me many times"2. In many ways Jayme offers a very human argument appealing to the human condition in a contemporary limelight to help those of a noble and pious nature, to fend off the oppressor in this case the soldiers. Additionally he highlights the Indian actions that are in line with …show more content…
Secondly Father Jayme in aiding the Native Americans is going against the Spanish soldiers, many of them were Christians. Throughout the whole history of human kind our inability to go against people of our own cultures, skin colours has clouded peoples abilities to see the wrong in themselves. Such biases lie in line with the stereotypes of the time. For example Native American attire involved little clothing especially for women, they wore necklaces with no tops often times, or merely cloth. Whereas the Spanish were “fully clothed”, they saw this lack of clothing as a sign of barbarianism, It was such stereotypes that Jayme hoped to
Cabeza De Vaca Dbq Analysis
511 Words | 3 PagesAs a slave, “he befriended his captors and was therefore allowed to serve as a trader”(Document B). The Spanish conquistador met four Indian groups along his journey, which were the Charrucos, Mariames, Yguases, and Quevenes(Document A). Also, when the Spaniards, also known as the “Christians”, contacted “Cabeza, his fellow survivors, and the Indians following him”(Document D). When the Spaniards tried to convince the Indians that Cabeza was a person they should distrust, they were “not at all convinced, saying that the Spaniards were lying”(Document D). Because Cabeza respected the Indians, they grew trust in him so they helped the Spanish soldier to survive.
Why Is King Phillip Called The First Indian War?
1213 Words | 5 PagesKing Philip’s war of 1675 -1676 is sometimes referred to as the First Indian War. A war that was between New England colonists, the Plymouth settlers, and the Wampanoag with their leader Metacom. King Phillip, of the Wampanoag, was known to his tribe as Metacom but to the New England colonists as Phillip. The war between Metacom and the colonists would change the relationship between Indians and the English settlers for decades.
Friar Juan De Zumarraga Summary
1532 Words | 7 PagesBy the end of the sixteenth century, the new colonies in Mexico were thriving under Spanish control. The once vibrant and busy city of Tenochtitlan had become a distant memory, which the Europeans ensured to suppress by removing remanence of Aztec representation throughout the land. Moreover, the Spanish made every possible effort to impose its traditions on the conquered natives and rule in the manner, which favored the crown, primarily thorough the spread of Christianity. Moreover, European culture was not a matter of choice for the natives to adopt, in fact, entirely the opposite transpired. Upon arrival to the new world, the Spaniards expressed negative sentiments regarding the native’s religious affiliation and customs, which prompted
The Role Of The Jesuits In New France
318 Words | 2 PagesThe first Catholic missionaries, also know as Jesuits, came to New France in 1634 to spread Christianity and European values. The Jesuits established Sainte-Marie-aux-Hurons by the St. Lawrence River in 1639, creating a central base for all missionary work in New France. This paper will examine how the Jesuits ' feelings of superiority over the Huron people led to converting the native population to Christianity. Father Jean de Brébeuf saw both positive and negative aspects of the Huron confederacy. One aspect of the American Indians’ culture he approved of was their marriage customs.
Kevin T. Keith Argument Analysis
109 Words | 1 PagesKevin t. Keith uses quite a bit of personal anecdotes which unlike his questionable facts helps his argument. He uses personal anecdotes as a way to show his emotional connection and view on the topic. For example when he states “it feels like their family member has been ‘sacrificed’(because of course they do not agree that the treatment would be ‘futile’).” he seems to know what it's like being a family member of a patient whose treatment was futile. It shows a personal knowledge on the subject of futile treatment well.the use of personal anecdotes increases the validity of his credibility as well as his argument as a
Age Of Exploration Dbq Essay
624 Words | 3 PagesConquerors also threatened the natives. It was required that the natives accept the Church as the “Ruler”, and if they didn’t, war would be made against them and their family would become enslaved (document 7). The natives in America suffered severely during this time. In Latin America, the Spanish conquerors overworked the Indian natives and treated them harshly. The Spaniards broke apart families and relationships so that they would have limited contact with each other and would be forced to give up their customs.
Christopher Columbus Propaganda
580 Words | 3 PagesThis American Columbus and colonization mythistory influences the highest American statesman in Theodore Roosevelt to the lowest American marine to preface the Native American genocide as excusable for the sake of Western society. As Zin notes, an American officer in the Phillipines drew the aforementioned parallel between American Native and Filipino colonization: “There is no use in mincing words.. We exterminated the American Indians and I guess most of us are proud of it..and we must have no scruples about exterminating this other race standing in the way of progress and enlightenment, if it is necessary…” Indeed, as the American officer spoke of “progress and enlightenment” in exterminating the Natives and Filipinos, so Chauncey DePew spoke in reference to Columbus’ colonial triumph as marking American progress in terms of wealth and power. Suffice to say, the American officer’s account of the Native American colonization and genocide is replete with similar glowing and progress-driven terminology as present Chauncey DePew’s account.
Argument Analysis: Hi Yohan
197 Words | 1 PagesHi Yohan, I can see where you’re coming from in this discussion. I agree with you on some of your points. For example, I agree that Freire had an overreaction when he said that the banking concept had a “necrophilic” quality. Also, I agree that, due to their expertise, teachers should have more control in the room. The main fault I find in your post was when you said, “It is not the teacher’s job to spoon feed the information to the students and wait for them to understand the information, but instead to provide them the tools necessary to be successful in the future”.
Ken Hamm's Argument Analysis
329 Words | 2 PagesI was raised in a Roman Catholic household, however my parents never forced the idea of “Creationism” on me, they let me make the decision for myself and I simply followed what I had learned in school, which was that the universe was much older than 6,000 years. My biggest issue regarding Ken Hamm’s argument deals with the people he brought in to enhance his point particularly Dr. Raymond Damadian. Dr. Damadian is the inventor of the MRI, while his invention is an incredibly important part of science and medicine today, his opinion on the creation of earth is not related to the field he is in. Whether or not he is a Creationist does not impact his invention of the MRI. Hamm treated it as a lecture instead of a debate.
Jukka Varelius's Argument Analysis
656 Words | 3 PagesRECONSTRUCTION Jukka Varelius presents a sensitive topic about what should be done when a patient refuses a treatment that could save them. Patients have a right to refuse treatment due to autonomy, which is generally held with utmost importance in our culture when it comes to healthcare. However, Varelius argues that giving the refusing patient the treatment anyway may actually be the best way of upholding autonomy.
Encounter The Spanish Nichols Chapter 3 Summary
603 Words | 3 PagesIn Chapter two section “Encountering the Spanish” Nichols stated, “The Indians’ first experiences with the Spanish proved more violent and disruptive than their meetings with most other Europeans.” I believe that the intentions of the Spanish Invasion of 1513 was always of evil and served not for religious purposes, but to further greed and corruption. The invasion was to let the Indians know and be alert that the Spanish wanted them to give up, convert to christianity, or else they will be killed. Furthermore, the Spanish feel that they have met the legal and religious obligation to take possession of the land and wage war against the natives. The requerimiento was a recitation of the Christian history of the world followed by the requirement that the Natives come forward of their own free will to convert to Catholicism.
Rhetorical Analysis Of Bartolome De Las Casas
331 Words | 2 PagesOn his journey to the New World, Bartolome de Las Casas encounters the “Indians” of the New World, in which he describes as an innocent, undeveloped, people. As a first observation, Las Casas pays close attention to the Indians social appearance and clothing. He notices, “as to their dress, they are generally naked,” usually with minimal clothing worn and, instead of traditional European customs , “ they have no beds, but sleep on a kind of matting or else in a kind of suspended net called hamacas.” Specifically within this quote is the emphasis of the rhetorical device pathos. Las Casas’ diction is written in such a way that portrays the feeling of empathy toward the reader, and because an individual is more likely to help another individual
Howard Zinn's Story Of Columbus Through The Arawak
1148 Words | 5 PagesIn order to prove that the Arawak people were being abused by the Spaniards, Zinn uses sources from both Christopher Columbus and Bartolome De Las Casas. Zinn talks about Las Casas because he had the only information on what happened after Columbus met the Arawak people. One example that Las Casas states that Zinn brings up to display the cruelty of the Spanish people was “Las Casas tells how ‘two of these so-called Christians net two Indian boys one day, each carrying a parrot; they took the parrots and for fun beheaded the boys.’ ” .4 This quote alone gives the reader the proof that the Indians were mistreated horribly and that this changes how we should view Columbus and the Europeans in the New World.
Native Americans In 1492 Essay
883 Words | 4 PagesIn 1550, Emporer Charles V summoned a debate to determine how Spain would deal with the Native Americans. Juan Ginés de Sepúlveda and Bartolomé de Las Casas engaged in discourse about this topic: Sepúlveda denigrated the Natives while de Las Casas defended them. Sepúlveda felt that the Native Americans were basically barbaric sub-humans, and that the Europeans were greatly superior to them. He felt that Christianity was far more altruistic than the Natives’ religions. However, Las Casas felt that the Natives should be treated equally, since he believed Jesus died for the Natives just like he died for the Europeans.
Behind Mud Walls Analysis
1307 Words | 6 PagesWadley’s Behind Mud Walls: Seventy-Five Years in a North Indian Village is an insightful view into another culture. As an audience member who lives in a country where changes are created quickly and numerously, it was surprising (at first) how the villagers of Karimpur resisted change to their way of life. Though this reviewer is familiar with the concept of having landlords, she was surprised how Karimpur did not belong to the people but rather the landlords. It was also a surprise in how quickly children caught on to their social status.
More about Father Jayme's Argument Analysis
Cabeza De Vaca Dbq Analysis
511 Words | 3 PagesWhy Is King Phillip Called The First Indian War?
1213 Words | 5 PagesFriar Juan De Zumarraga Summary
1532 Words | 7 PagesThe Role Of The Jesuits In New France
318 Words | 2 PagesKevin T. Keith Argument Analysis
109 Words | 1 PagesAge Of Exploration Dbq Essay
624 Words | 3 PagesChristopher Columbus Propaganda
580 Words | 3 PagesArgument Analysis: Hi Yohan
197 Words | 1 PagesKen Hamm's Argument Analysis
329 Words | 2 PagesJukka Varelius's Argument Analysis
656 Words | 3 PagesEncounter The Spanish Nichols Chapter 3 Summary
603 Words | 3 PagesRhetorical Analysis Of Bartolome De Las Casas
331 Words | 2 PagesHoward Zinn's Story Of Columbus Through The Arawak
1148 Words | 5 PagesNative Americans In 1492 Essay
883 Words | 4 PagesBehind Mud Walls Analysis
1307 Words | 6 Pages