ipl-logo

Freedom Of Speech Vs Civility By Ann Wallace Scott Summary

839 Words4 Pages

We go on about our day, not realizing how much freedom we truly have. As Americans, we never have to fear persecution for speaking out against our elected government officials. We can vote for who we want, practice our faith, and come and go as we please from across the country. However, can the same be said for the youth of America, specifically students of American high schools? In her article "Freedom of Speech v. Civility," I argue that Ann Wallace Scott employs logical reasoning to prompt a more profound conversation among students about the boundaries of free speech and other rights within American high schools. Starting with the use of probing questions throughout the article, the author aims to shed light on the issue of restricting …show more content…

This portrayal suggests a lack of awareness of their rights, which contradicts reality. Nowadays, young people are actively engaging in politics and protesting against government injustices. Despite this, it is startling to learn about cases such as Tinker v. Des Moines (Scott 2), where a student faced punishment for participating in a silent protest. Despite the student's willingness to discuss the issue with the school, they were still suspended. However, the Supreme Court eventually ruled in favor of the student, establishing that students are protected under the Constitution. This landmark case serves as a precedent for future instances defending students' freedom of speech. Furthermore, Scott presents several cases in the article where outcomes differed significantly from the landmark Tinker v. Des Moines ruling. Instances of speech restrictions extended beyond school grounds to off-campus events. This ongoing suppression of student voices prompted parents and school boards to voice their concerns. For example, in the 2006 case of Gals v. Marinel, a student wore a shirt criticizing then-President Bush with vulgar language, resulting in disciplinary

Show More
Related

Tinker Vs Moines Case Study

303 Words | 2 Pages

Citation: Tinker v. Des Moines Independent School District (1969) Facts: In Des Moines, Iowa, a group of individuals met at a home to discuss ways to protest the United States involvement in the Vietnam War. The group decided beginning on December 16th and lasting until New Year’s Day, the members of the group would fast and wear black armbands to show their opposition to the war. School officials became aware of the students’ protest and implemented a policy that any student wearing a black armband would be asked to remove it. If the students did not remove the armband, then the student would be suspended.

Read More

Censorship: The Case Of Tinker Vs. Des Moines

125 Words | 1 Pages

As seen in previous cases like Tinker vs. Des Moines, students have the right to political say, unless it causes disruption at school of students are promoting something that goes against the law. In the case of Tinker v Des Moines the students were not promoting anything illegal but showed their thought on the Vietnam War by wearing black armbands (Tinker). Argued in court by Kenneth W. Starr in the Morse v. Frederick case, he gave the idea that the foundation for school censorship was the case of Tinker v. Des Moines (Morse). The Justices responded back saying, that case was a different scenario as the students weren 't doing anything against the law while Frederick was encouraging the use of marijuana which was illegal (Morse).

Read More

Analysis Of Free Speech Follies By Stanley Fish

103 Words | 1 Pages

People have the tendency to take the First Amendment for granted, but some tend to use it to their favor. Stanley Fish presents his main argument about how people misuse this amendment for all their conflicts involving from racial issues to current political affairs in his article, Free-Speech Follies. His article involves those who misinterpret the First Amendment as their own works or constantly use it as an excuse to express their attitudes and desires about a certain subject matter. He expresses his personal opinions against those who consistently use the First Amendment as a weapon to defend themselves from harm of criticism.

Read More

Erwin Chemerinsky And Giimportance Of Free Speech In The United States

493 Words | 2 Pages

The novel Free Speech on Campus written by Erwin Chemerinsky and Howard Giimportance explains the importance and need for protection of free speech in the United States. During the first two chapters the authors argue for the existence of free speech and the importance it has in our modern era. The central themes of chapters one and two are the history of free speech in the United States and how it has been debated in the courtroom. The most important question that was left unanswered by the authors is based off the last statement made in chapter two, this stated that protection of free speech is important in everyday society but is even more important on college campuses and universities.

Read More

Comparison Of The Supreme Courts And The Department Of Education

228 Words | 1 Pages

The Supreme Courts and The Department both protect teacher’s freedom expressions in the classrooms. The Courts and the Department of Education do not want to develop a hostile atmosphere in classrooms for teachers, so they allow teachers to support freedom of expression about political matters, however this matter is a controversial topic for parents and educators. The political topics allow teachers to engage students in the political arena for the enrichment of community concerns (White, 2013, para. 1). Political topics help students to use their critical thinking skills about issues that discussed in our government and help students to consider how politics are used in our society today. The Courts implemented freedom of speech as a part

Read More

Heckler's Veto Analysis

1154 Words | 5 Pages

The Court held that in arresting and convicting the students, South Carolina infringed upon the student’s freedom of speech and freedom of assembly rights. The above cases have helped create the theory and jurisprudence of the heckler’s veto. Through these cases, the Court that unpopular messages and speakers are protected under the First Amendment. Also, it is important to note that although their message is offensive to some groups, people who agree with their message have First Amendment rights to listen.

Read More

Bret Stephens's 'The Dying Art Of Disagreement'

814 Words | 4 Pages

In the current society of “protected feelings”, children are being taught that negative opinions are bad, and this type of thinking does not allow them to flourish intellectually.(p. 7) Sadly, children are not learning about what the First Amendment means, and as a result, college students are protesting against speakers which have different viewpoints from their own. In addition, Stephens contends that college students are not capable of thinking for themselves because they tend to identify with a particular group and own that groups views. (p. 8)

Read More

Why Is Free Speech Important?

535 Words | 3 Pages

Free speech facilitates the resolution of conflicts and optimal decision-making by the citizenry. Free speech, however, is not entirely without restraint; surrounding conditions dictate the reasonableness of any control thereof. The current legal position in the United States of America, where the Supreme Court has pronounced that speech, even belligerent speech, may only be impeded and regulated in the distinct and extant risk of impending conduct, contrary to the law, deviates from the norm internationally and in other nations. Among the few concessions to this legal

Read More

Heckler's Veto Speech

1199 Words | 5 Pages

The Court held that in arresting and convicting the students, South Carolina infringed upon the student’s freedom of speech and freedom of assembly

Read More

Pros And Cons Of Free Speech And College Campuses

709 Words | 3 Pages

Although many have always through there is a fake stereotype between the campuses students and their free speech rights, the author has clearly solved the issue and stipulated the underlying facts on the matter. Free speech is just but a platform for students to air out their grievances and make their voices heard. Zelizer, J. E., and M. Keller. "Is Free Speech Really Challenged on Campus?" 9 May 2018, www.theatlantic.com/education/archive/2017/09/students-free-speech-campus-protest/539673/. The authors of the article tried to scrutinize on the alleged threats on free speech for campuses. According to their findings, free speech among campus students has been under siege and slowly being abolished to stop and prevent students from airing their grievances and needs in their

Read More

Persuasive Dress Code

1220 Words | 5 Pages

In 1969, the U.S. Supreme Court case Tinker v. Des Moines Independent Community School District upheld the right to freedom of speech of students to protest the Vietnam war by wearing black armbands. The case explained the problem that “students do not “shed their constitutional rights to freedom of speech or expression at the schoolhouse gate.” (Student) As students, we are free to express ourselves through what we wear. As students, we have every right to proclaim our beliefs

Read More

The Pros And Cons Of Free Speech

821 Words | 4 Pages

Through the course of United States history, the First Amendment is known by every sort of citizen. Whether from the firebranded activists on different sides of every heated political issue that graced our nation, or taught by passionate academics wishing to instill the grand philosophy behind it to young students, the First Amendment is widely recognized and understood as a concept by our nation. Eloquently described by Justice Holmes in United States v. Schwimmer, proclaimed the nature of the First Amendment in his dissent: Not free thought for those who agree with us but freedom for the thought that we hate.” At its core, free speech is meant to be utilized by people of varying opinions. There are people, whether by nature or passion, who would use the safeguard of free speech in a way that is most detrimental not only society, but to the annals of scholars who longed observed its value.

Read More

Should Freedom Of Speech Be Regulated Essay

1656 Words | 7 Pages

The First Amendment of The Constitution is engraved in the minds of the American people for being the guarantor of the Freedom of Speech clause. Nevertheless, the vagueness of said clause has been subjugated to challenges that ask; “Should Freedom of Speech be regulated?” The Supreme Court appeared to be inconsistent for creating answers on a case-by-case basis. However, in the midst of said inconsistency, the Supreme Court’s most compelling standard to determine if speech can be constitutionally restricted is if said speech abridges people from other constitutionally guaranteed rights.

Read More

Freedom Of Speech In College Essay

905 Words | 4 Pages

The idea of free speech on college campuses and the complications of it stem from those on campuses expressing views that don’t align with popular views. Implications for students who use the idea of free speech as a method for hateful actions and comments should be reprimanded, but the question remains as to whether schools should enforce tougher limitations. The freedom of speech on college campus expands to the freedoms of religion, assembly, press, and protest as well. Freedom of expression allows students to show their own political, social, and cultural views. Removing freedoms of speech and expression have consequences deeper than surface issues.

Read More

Bilingual Classroom: A Literature Review

1351 Words | 6 Pages

Based on the information previously presented about early sequential bilingual education, there are some strategies and materials that foster second language acquisition in the early years and will be depicted below. These strategies include songs, flash cards, videos, games, and stories which serve as a tool to engage students, boost their motivation, creativity and curiosity, and well as to practice the vocabulary previously learned. To begin with, some authors explain the importance of implementing songs in the bilingual classroom. According to Murphey (1992), songs are tools that help teachers foster and improve their students' knowledge, this is due to a phenomenon called “The song stuck in my head”, this is a phenomenon that is compounded

Read More

More about Freedom Of Speech Vs Civility By Ann Wallace Scott Summary

Open Document