ipl-logo

Freud Vs. Lewis Argument In The Question Of God

1448 Words6 Pages

Throughout my adult life I have always known what my worldview is. I have always sided with the spiritual side as opposed to the material. I am a Christian and believe in one God who has sent his son, Jesus, to forgive us of our sins. Through my later years, my faith has never wavered. Through my adolescent years, however, I had lost my faith a few times do to different events that transpired in my life. It took some time and great trust, but I eventually found my spiritual belief again. Based on my own experiences, I tend to favor Lewis’ argument in The Question of God. Lewis and Freud both begin the book with the same atheist belief. They found no faith or comfort in God. They believed that God was just a figment of one’s imagination. Freud claimed that God was simply a way to fulfill mankind of their needs and wishes. He had stated that …show more content…

Lewis explains that finding faith in God is done by first accepting that it might be true. I agree with this because I personally did not find faith in God again until I personally believed that there is a chance that such a being could exist. Lewis bases his worldview on simply accepting the fact that all situations in life are possible-even the possibility of a higher being. However, Freud’s counter argument seems flawed to me because he bases all his beliefs on what he can physically research and be given a definite answer to. Years ago when, I was an atheist, I would have agreed with Freud, but having the faith I have now I do not. I cannot see God, I have never physically felt God, and I cannot research the proof of God and get a definite answer. However, I believe there is a God based on my own acceptance to all possibilities. Once I opened my mind to this idea, I found comfort in my pain, joy in my sorrow, and presence in my emptiness. I, as well as Lewis, base my belief in God on what I have read-The Bible- and what I have personally

Show More
Related

How Did Owen Irving Use Miracles In The Production And Destruction Of Faith

998 Words | 4 Pages

Miracles in the Production and Destruction of Faith In basic religion classes, students are told that as Catholics, they need to have a faith in God and that their faith may not seem reasonable at times. As the students get older, they are told that in order to strengthen their faith, doubts, and working through these doubts, are an expected part of their lives while miracles may strengthen their growing beliefs. To further complicate the matter, students are taught that too many doubts can bring about a loss of faith, as can doubts from these same miracles. In John Irving’s A Prayer for Owen Meany, Irving discusses this balance between healthy doubts bringing about faith and too many doubts eroding faith.

Read More

Comparing Homer's Odyssey And O Brother Where Art Thou?

927 Words | 4 Pages

An example of non-belief in the film O Brother Where Art Thou? is: Ulysses’ has a continual struggle with the existence of God. Finally when prays to God asking to be saved from the sheriff, God sends a flood. Seeing this Ulysses does not believe it was God but that it was the people flooding the valley. These works show how the belief in a god has evolved over

Read More

Summary Of C. S. Lewis Mere Christianity

965 Words | 4 Pages

By making this argument Lewis is almost planting a seed of doubt in non-believers, maybe they just heard a bad explanation of religion or maybe they just need to hear the “real” explanation of religion to understand why such a large portion of the world believes in a religion and is so devoted to the teachings and laws of the religion. Also i find the description of religion as “complicated” as fitting and addresses the shortcomings that i found with the previous book. The concept of religions is an inherently confusing thing to try and grasp. The idea that a person or power is watching over you and guiding you almost like an invisible shephard is hard to believe, especially when one tries to consider all of the incredible abilities and powers that this God must have to be able to do these things. Another part of religion that confuses many people is the sin or evil that fills the world and why an almighty force would let such tragedies take place.

Read More

Why Do C. S. Lewis Believe In Their Eyes Were Watching God

756 Words | 4 Pages

1: The two mistaken beliefs are to believe devils do not exist and the second belief is to feel excessive and unhealthy interest in them. You must believe in the devil or demons because even God believes in them. Although second of all you must understand that they are dangerous and not to be messed with or admired. 2: C. S. Lewis acts like he found the letters himself and didn't even write the letters himself. Also C. S. Lewis seemed to not completely understand the letters leaving it up to the readers to decipher the rest.

Read More

C. S. Lewis Speech Analysis

531 Words | 3 Pages

C.S. Lewis is known for the world-wide phenomenon, The Lion the Witch and the Wardrobe but Lewis is also a phenomenal orator. One of Lewis’ most famous excerpts Beyond Personality uses superb precedents of said techniques. C.S. Lewis’ Beyond Personality speech uses effective techniques to motivate his listeners and to get people to believe what he believes. C.S. Lewis uses figurative language, anecdotes, and repetition and parallel structure to help his audience withhold a better understanding of his point. C.S. Lewis often intertwines superlative examples of figurative language into his works.

Read More

What Is The Core Jigsaw Pieces That Make Up Your Worldview Essay

460 Words | 2 Pages

The core jigsaw pieces that make up my worldview on all aspects of faith, science, and reason are numerous. My faith is solely based on God and The Bible. Everything that The Bible says are things that I take into consideration when coming up with my worldview. I know that God will take care of me and that He will answer my prayers. I can lean on Him as a child of God and receive answers if I remain true to Him.

Read More

Freud Vs Lewis Essay

1351 Words | 6 Pages

While Lewis agreed that parents have a major influence on morals, he concluded that morals do not come solely from human creation, but rather on God’s everlasting truth and standards. Conversion While Freud experienced no conversion, Lewis experienced a total transformation. Up until he was thirty, Lewis was an Atheist.

Read More

Comparing The Views Of C. S. Lewis And Freud Debate

1990 Words | 8 Pages

Both men agreed that one’s worldview impacts their experience of happiness throughout life. Only Lewis resolved his pessimistic worldview when he converted to Christianity. Freud basked in his pessimistic worldview until death and he never attempted to change it since he was an atheist. As a Christian who has seen people convert to Christianity from an atheistic background, it would have been fascinating to see how Freud’s life would have been different had he been convinced of Christ.

Read More

Comparison Of Christianity And Pantheism By T. S. Lewis

406 Words | 2 Pages

Lewis goes on the talk about the Christianity-and-water views of God, that simply say there is a good God in Heaven and everything is all right--leaving out all the difficult and terrible doctrines about sin and hell and the devil, and the redemption. (pp.40). I believe that Christianity adequately explains the

Read More

Lewis's Argument For The Existence Of The Law Of Human Nature

623 Words | 3 Pages

He goes from general thinking and indicates that there can be two different views on how the universe came to be, then he goes further into specifics by providing examples and evidence of how there really is a higher power, or a “Power Behind” (Lewis). In the end, I believe the more effective approach to stating one’s theory with logic would have to be with deductive reasoning. With deduction, one can make a broad observation before going into specifics and providing evidence to make the generalization more precise and restricted. Therefore, when Lewis made his argument with deductive reasoning, he was able to convince the audience with a more advantageous

Read More

Of Kierkegaard's Argument For The Existence Of God

177 Words | 1 Pages

Kierkegaard believes that the existence of God could not be proven by reasons. However, he did not think that it was rational to believe in God, but to have faith in God. In Kierkegaard reading I disagree in his perspective because I believe that a person should have faith to believe in God and his existence. I also disagree in how he believes in faith of God, but not in God itself.

Read More

Trolley Dilemmas

1662 Words | 7 Pages

There is a difference between understanding something and actually believing it. While I already believed in God before this paper, I feel as though I have a deeper understanding of Him because of what I have learned through His first

Read More

Overview Of The Psychology Of Religion

1724 Words | 7 Pages

1. Psychology of Religion Sigmund Freud Sigmund Freud 's understanding of the psychology of religion comes from a place not without disdain. This might be somewhat understandable given he lived not too long removed from a time in which any statements that were deemed to be blasphemous could lead to very serious consequences for the author. He touches on this very point and even lists arguments against his coming out so vociferously against even the potential veracity of religion; however, he quickly attempts to demolish these arguments so as to make his real point (Freud, 2018, pp. 179,188). Put quite concisely, Freud explains that the idea of God is nothing short of an illusion – even a form of neurosis.

Read More

Examples Of Psychobiography

2186 Words | 9 Pages

Greenberg (1986) believes Freud’s case studies do not place enough stress on revealing the outcome of the treatment and that Freud’s aim was more to illustrate his theoretical points (p.240). In cases, Greenberg asserts that many of the presented cases would not even be considered acceptable examples of psychoanalysis and, in short, that virtually all of the cases studies had basic shortcomings (p.240). Furthermore, many other powerful criticisms about Freud inaccurate and subsequently flawed evidence have been published. These critics contend that Freud’s evidence is flawed due to the lack of an experiment, the lack of a control group, and the lack of observations that went unrecorded (Colby, 1960, p.54).

Read More

Models In Human Science

1161 Words | 5 Pages

You also cannot generalize the results Freud got from the experiences he made with individuals to a large number of people. This is one reason of why the use of models in human sciences can be extremely difficult and untrustworthy and therefore can hinder the gaining of knowledge. In response to the counter claim, even though the results from Freud’s experiments cannot be fully generalized, the model can still be useful. Still nowadays it’s used in patient analysis.

Read More

More about Freud Vs. Lewis Argument In The Question Of God

Related Topics

Open Document