ipl-logo

Gay Marriage Controversy Analysis

1200 Words5 Pages

“I think that gay marriage should be between a man and a woman.” As of this past June, this stated belief by Arnold Schwarzenegger was rejected by the Supreme Court. The debate over legalizing gay marriage has been over for some time. This was arguably one of the most controversial issues that our nation had ever dealt with. Some people believed that we should redefine marriage to include homosexual relationships whereas others believed that the institution of marriage should be preserved strictly for heterosexual relationships. Along with these popular viewpoints, there is also this radical position that was represented by Michael Kinsley in one of his articles. In his article “Abolish Marriage”, Kinsley argued that ending the public institution of marriage is a favorable solution to the gay marriage controversy. Sadly, Kinsley did not have any valid support for his claim. Besides the …show more content…

However, he was patently false. Logically speaking, there is no reason to think that there could a solution that would please both sides of the gay marriage debate. According to the Washington Post, a poll conducted by themselves and ABC News in 2014 showed that 59 percent of people support same-sex marriage while 34 percent are opposed to it. On one side of this issue are conservatives that believe that marriage has been defined to be a sacred union between one man and one woman and on the other side are liberals that generally believe that marriage is a constitutional right attributed to two people that are of age and not related. Both sides want their definition of marriage to be completely supported by our government. Therefore, it is impossible to resolve this gay marriage issue in a way that appeases both parties. Kinsley himself hoped to provide a solution for this matter that would gratify both sides involved but failed in doing

Show More
Related
734 Words | 3 Pages

In the short essay, " Gay "Marriage": Societal Suicide”. Olson is headstrong towards the fact that gay marriage is unnecessary and will lead to the degradation of society. Clearly, Colson strongly opposes gay marriage and has given reason to his position however, in some parts, it lacks the necessary evidence needed to support the argument. Charles Colson writes an essay opposing gay marriage. He first cites his outrage towards the authorities for allowing it to be implemented in the law as he strongly believes that heterosexual marriage is the traditional building block of human society.

Read More
88 Words | 1 Pages

In 2015, the United States Supreme Court worked on Obergefell v. Hodges, a case regarding the legality of same sex marriage. Over 9 million people in the united states identify and associate themselves with the LGBTQ+ community. These members and others in the past have fought for their constitutional rights since before the 1950’s. The legalization of same-sex marriage under the United States Constitution is beneficial to the nation, as it has positively influenced members of the LGBTQ+ community and their families, the nation’s economy, and it’s reputation.

Read More
1600 Words | 7 Pages

Of the nine judges, all except Clarence Thomas made remarks and made inquiries, giving signs as to their positions on the Constitution and the fate of same-sex marriage. In ringing dialect, Justice Anthony Kennedy said same-sex couples regard marriage and "request rise to respect in the eye of the law." That right, he said, is granted by the Constitution. They came to the conclusion that the majority held that state same-sex marriage bans are a violation of both the Fourteenth Amendment Due Process Clause and Equal Protection

Read More
797 Words | 4 Pages

Recently a case at the Supreme Court level legalized gay marriage across the United States. This court case has received a lot of backlash from many people, people like Chris Christie. “Chris Christie said on Sunday Supreme Court justices of his liking would not have legalized same-sex marriage and would have struck down a key provision of a national health care law.” (Fredericks). His point is, people that thought the same way as him would not have legalized same sex marriage.

Read More
270 Words | 2 Pages

I find this to thoughtless. Same-sex marriage is just as unique as any other marriage. Same-sex marriage

Read More
963 Words | 4 Pages

Bennett conveys the point that marriage is already in a bad place with divorces and people having children outside of marriage. He believes that allowing homosexuals to marry would ruin the traditional marriage because it would be an unnecessary, flawed social experiment (411). Sullivan indirectly tries to debunk this statement by stating that ninety percent of lesbian and gay political equality problems would be solved if same-sex union was legalized (407). Sullivan continually points towards the idea that any two people should be able to enter into a marriage while Bennett asserts the idea that marriage does not need the flawed social experiment that is gay marriage.

Read More
577 Words | 3 Pages

John Stossel’s article, “The Gay Marriage Debate” allows the reader to grasp and understand both views based on the most popular topic, same sex marriage. The author of this article is interviewing someone who strongly believes in keeping marriage between man and woman. This article lists both pros and cons of legalizing same sex marriage and Stossel’s comments in between the statements that are given to him by the man Stossel is interviewing are borderline sarcastic throughout the entire article. The person who is being interviewed by Stossel states his opinion very clearly in the article and supports his arguments with what he believes are facts. This article is tied together by the author based on his three main points.

Read More
609 Words | 3 Pages

And the struggle began from there, encompassing 25 years, innumerable lawsuits, and multiple hindering bans. The fact of the matter was that no one was willing to accept change. Marriage had been between a man and a woman for so long that people were not willing to see any other option. The topic of same-sex marriage had always been implicitly unspeakable: why recognize it

Read More
655 Words | 3 Pages

John Locke’s Second Treatise of Government and A Letter Concerning Toleration discuss the separation of church and state, the rights of the government and citizens, and resistance of unjust governments. Based on these works, Locke would conclude that Davis is in the wrong, because he would find that her actions are unjust, that the court rightfully jailed her, and that her resistance of the government was unlawful. In deciding to support the court’s actions against Davis, Locke would first assert that Davis’s decision to deny same-sex couples marriage licenses was unjust, as she violated rights guaranteed to those couples. In A Letter Concerning Toleration, Locke goes so far as to say “The sum of all we drive at is, that every man may enjoy the same rights that are

Read More
401 Words | 2 Pages

Senior fellow for policy studies, Peter Sprigg in a Question and Answer article titled “What’s Wrong With Letting Same-Sex Couples Marry?” addresses this matter of controversy by stating-in his opinion- the ‘vast negative consequences’ concerning gay marriage equality. In order to answer these questions, Sprigg uses a cataloging of biased satire, as opposed to factual information in backing up his opinions. Thus, considering his audience consists of those who are for gay rights or, at the least, do not understand such a negative connotation regarding what could be an incredibly life-changing milestone for many, I am very much against his close-minded responses. Furthermore, although it is technically lnews learning that Peter Sprigg in particular thinks allowing gay couples to marry is wrong I can’t say that I’m definitively taken aback when I discover that yet another individual carries this mindset that, “Homosexual relationships are not marriage”(Sprigg P.2), though disappointing nonetheless.

Read More
431 Words | 2 Pages

The author explains how a marital contract should not be given to those who cannot fulfill it, such as children and family (30). He then claims that homosexuals can fulfill said license, but unwittingly contradicts himself by saying, “But it isn’t necessary to prove that homosexuals or lesbians are less--or more--able to form long-term relationships than straights for it to be clear that at least some are.” (30). This clearly shows how disconnected the author is from his audience. This is a persuasive article, attempting to sway people into believing that homosexual marriage should be legal, yet he assumes his audience feels it apparent that some homosexuals are capable of the commitment of marriage.

Read More
873 Words | 4 Pages

According to Four Reasons to Support Gay Marriage and Oppose the Federal Marriage Amendment, “Same-sex marriage provides a more stable environment for children of lesbian and gay couples.” “Should Gay Marriage Be Legal?”, it recognized that “A 2010 analysis published in the American Journal of Public Health found that after their states gay marriage was banned, gay, lesbian and bisexual people suffered a 37% increase in mood disorders, a 42% increase in alcohol-use disorders, and a 248% increase in generalized anxiety disorders.” Legalizing same sex marriage will not harm heterosexual marriage. Society will continue to function successfully and marriage is a secular institution which should not be limited by religious objection. Same sex marriage legalization is corresponded with lower divorce rates, while same sex marriage bans are connected with higher divorce rates.

Read More
1612 Words | 7 Pages

Marriage is a contract between two people and honestly I think that the society should not be interfering this bond. Not permitting the right to marry another human is a severe violation of the human rights and freedom. James Carville “I was against gay marriage until I realized that I didn’t have one.” The statement is self-explanatory: “You don’t get to judge because you don’t have the

Read More
1135 Words | 5 Pages

The ethical dilemma surrounding gay marriages Homosexuality is an erotic reaction to the sexual desire of people of the same sex. It is not only about sexual intercourse with similar sex as this could be as a result of limited sexual chances or even rituals in cultural practices. Homosexuality has been considered as a mental disorder. Some think it is Satanism. The issue of gay marriages is a hot topic in our country today.

Read More
359 Words | 2 Pages

There are many topics in today’s society that challenge the social norm. One significant problem or issue in contemporary culture that challenges traditional norms is gay marriage. In society marriage has always been between a man and a woman. When the law was passed that same sex marriage was now legal there was great controversy. The norm had been changed and many people spoke their opinions.

Read More

More about Gay Marriage Controversy Analysis

Related Topics

Open Document