ipl-logo

Genesis Vs Gilgamesh Research Paper

748 Words3 Pages

There are two stories we read throughout the semester that have significant similarities when it comes to the plot of a god or gods telling one man to build a boat to escape incoming disaster. These two stories are the Epic of Gilgamesh, and the Book of Genesis in the Old Testament. One was written before the other, one is the basis for a whole belief of religion, and one is a story written for pure entertainment. There are some distinct differences between the stories, however, it is the similarities that bring unrelenting debate to the controversial subject of creation of man and earth. The first story, The Epic of Gilgamesh, Gilgamesh is on a quest for immortality and he is on a quest to find Uta-napishti, the man who has earned …show more content…

This is the source of controversy between if the story of creation given by Genesis is valid or not. Gilgamesh is the oldest written text known to date, therefore, Genesis would have to be written after, and some people may have suspicion that Genesis ripped off the deluge story of Gilgamesh. People have a valid point when arguing this because the stories are almost identical: a man is warned by gods/God to build a boat to survive oncoming disaster brought on by gods/God because of the unpleasing behavior of mankind. Both bring animals and both survive the flood. The duration of the flood is different but the method of finding land is the same; a raven, a swallow, and a dove. Although the blessings were different, both stories had ended with a blessing from gods/God. I believe there is a relationship between the two stories as the book of Genesis: 6 and 7, must have in some way used the ancient Babylonian text Gilgamesh as influence for the story. Real conservative Christians would most likely believe this part of Genesis happened word for word and was not copied or influenced by any other text. On the other hand there are people who believe this part of Genesis was a complete copy of Gilgamesh, or at least in some way influenced by Gilgamesh. Either way, it is an unrelenting debate about the story of creation and it will likely be one that will

Show More
Related
109 Words | 1 Pages

Between “The Babylonian Creation Epic” and “Theogony” there are many similarities and differences that can be found. One similarity between these two is the idea of two beings, Tiamat and Apsu (fresh and salt water) and Gaia and Ouranos (earth and sky) who couple together and give birth to the first gods. In Gaia and Ouranos’s case, these ‘gods’ are called Titans. In the Babylonian story Marduk, a son of the gods, kills Tiamat and creates humankind from the blood of one of the gods who stood on her side. Whereas in “Theogony” Ouranos is hated by all of his children and ends up castrated by his son Kronos.

Read More
1045 Words | 5 Pages

If you have read Gilgamesh the Hero and Genesis 6-9:19, you would think the two passages are pretty similar to each other, maybe even almost the same exact thing. But when we dive deeper into each passage of writing, you start to see that Gilgamesh the Hero to Genesis 6-9:17 are very different from each other. Even though their similarities will also be expressed in this essay, these stories are not as similar as you may think because of the Gods’ motivation for sending a flood, and how Noah and Utnapistim were warned about the incoming flood. The Gods’ in both stories were upset with the way their creation, which was humanity, turned out to be.

Read More
1949 Words | 8 Pages

2. In both stories one man, of similar makeup, is entrusted with specific information about the coming flood. In the bible, the Lord calls upon Noah while in the Epic of Gilgamesh, Utanapishtim is given authority

Read More
226 Words | 1 Pages

Morals and lessons have been learned by people through learning the lessons first hand or by seeing someone else go through lessons. Morals and lesson have to be learned in order for people to grow as a person and a good to be exact. The best for a person to learn lessons, without having to go through the dilemma, will be books. Books have a certain way of getting people involved in the story, either through the different type of characters or by the value of the lesson being learned, but in many ways it has to do with how it explained the morals and lessons. There are many books that have this niche that it can make any understand how to be a better person.

Read More
489 Words | 2 Pages

Growing up, I have always been told that are two sides to every story and nothing seems to be truer at this exact moment when comparing Mesopotamian and Hebrew flood and creation myths. While each story is different overall, the myths all remain somewhat the same.   The largest similarity in the stories is how the earth was created from nothing by members of a higher being. In the Mesopotamian myth, Atra-Hasis alludes to the protagonist of one of the Mesopotamian creation stories as well as the myth's central figure.

Read More
423 Words | 2 Pages

In the epic of Gilgamesh, the Sumerian deities decide to start a flood that will exterminate mankind. “The uproar of mind kind was intolerable and sleep in no longer possible by reason of the babel.” The reason the deities caused the flood was because mankind had multiplied and were causing too much noise. This shows that the Sumerian deities did not care about the mortals that worshipped them. They were selfish and did not think about the outcome of their actions.

Read More
210 Words | 1 Pages

Noah from “Noah and the Flood”, and Utnapishtim from “The Epic of Gilgamesh”, are both chosen and told by Gods or God, to built a boat or in Noah’s

Read More
707 Words | 3 Pages

How the World Uniquely Begins Native American myths and the Christian Bible both offer stories about how the world began.. In “The Earth on Turtle’s Back” and Genesis 1, both tales have similar values and ideas. These two stories compare in that both tell the importance of water, the fact that Earth came out of the water, and the existence of supreme beings; in contrast, each story has a unique idea of how the world came into being. “The Earth on Turtle’s Back,” a story from the Onondaga tribe, an original Native American group, is a myth which relates a story about the beginning of the world. Water is below the Skyland and it becomes an issue when the Great Tree is uprooted.

Read More
244 Words | 1 Pages

There’s over 500 stories and myths around the world that talk about the great flood that happened once and swallowed everything on earth. Noah’s Ark in Genesis from the Bible and the Epic of Gilgamesh that contains a story about a flood are probably the most known stories that talk about a great flood. Both stories are very similar to each other that I think that Noah’s Ark might have been inspired by the other story. Basically the two stories, talk about how gods wanted to wipe out humanity because of their behaviors; therefore they decide to flood the earth and kill all humankind and all life on it. In the first story, Noah was seen as a good man, and he was told by the God about the flood that’s coming, and how to save himself and his family.

Read More
457 Words | 2 Pages

The flood in both these stories represent a fresh start because the flood is the way for the gods to have a clean slate. It also shows that even the gods have flaws and make mistakes, even though they are often portrayed as

Read More
768 Words | 4 Pages

“Extinction is the rule. Survival is the exception (Carl Sargon)”. According to The Epic of Gilgamesh and Genesis, unprecedented floods occurred in both stories. The exception fell on the kind men, Utnapishtim and Noah: they survived the powerful event of destruction. However, in the same theme of the stories, there are sources of similarity and differences.

Read More
2037 Words | 9 Pages

The Epic of Gilgamesh is the oldest story known to mankind, being written on Sumerian clay almost five thousand years ago (Garone). Since the story was originally known orally, the culture and themes from The Epic of Gilgamesh must have existed long before it was finally inscribed (Mark 4). Having known this, the cultures and themes can be compared to today’s society, discovering about how they have shifted and evolved, and also observe how they are similar. The ancient days of Gilgamesh has brought culture that has greatly influenced today’s society. Because Gilgamesh was set around the time of late Babylonian or early Sumerian society, the Babylonian and Sumerian cultures also play a role in shaping the world into what is is today (Mark).

Read More
1133 Words | 5 Pages

God destroyed humankind, and in both stories, the gods promised to never harm human beings again. They both then commanded Noah and repopulate the earth. Any casual reader has to be impressed that there are these points of similarity between these two. On the same token, the reader has to be impressed with the fact that there are some conspicuous and obvious differences. In the Gilgamesh epic, the author has the gods that are squabbling.

Read More
1594 Words | 7 Pages

I argue that The Epic of Gilgamesh, particularly the flood scene, heavily influenced the story of Noah’s ark in the Hebrew Bible. While the exact origins of these stories may never be known, it can be assumed that they arose from the same source. The texts themselves, their origin stories, and physical historical evidence will all be analyzed. Furthermore, the writings and findings of prominent scholars will be used to support my arguments. This research is important because it proves intertextuality can even bridge the divide between sacred and secular texts.

Read More
921 Words | 4 Pages

The Epic of Gilgamesh and the Bible have a few similar events and historians think that they may refer to the same event. The Epic of Gilgamesh and the Bible share a similar event, the flood, and a similar character, the serpent. Though there are still several distinctions between the two stories. The Bible and the Epic of Gilgamesh both contain a serpent as one of the less significant characters.

Read More

More about Genesis Vs Gilgamesh Research Paper

Related Topics

Open Document