ipl-logo

Getting There From Here By Atul Gawande Analysis

679 Words3 Pages

The Equality of Universality
The United States enacts the archetypal form of capitalism. The free market based society has benefits, but the U.S.’s obstinacy with the system, such as with healthcare, is its downfall. Atul Gawande in “Getting There From Here” discusses that although other industrialist nations have embraced universal healthcare, Americans, especially during the Regan and Thatcher era, still associate it with communism: “Yet wherever the prospect of universal health insurance has been considered, it has been widely attacked as a Bolshevik fantasy—a coercive system to be imposed upon people by benighted socialist master planers” (Gawande, 2). In order to understand why the U.S. has not transitioned into a single-payer healthcare …show more content…

James Pfeiffer and Rachel Chapman in “Anthropological Perspectives on Structural Adjustment and Public Health” explicates how [SAPs] encourages neoliberalism: “[SAPs] are the practical tools used by [IFIs] at country level to promote the market fundamentalism that constitutes the core of neoliberalism” (Pfeiffer and Chapman, 150). The thought process behind SAPs is by moving away from Keynesian theory, which is where government helps all forms of economic distress, and towards trickle down theory, which entails removing economic regulation, the economy will grow and benefits will eventually “trickle down” to lower income families (Pfeiffer and Chapman, 151). It is a long-term capitalistic strategy that many oppose because it is harmful to lower income families: “Critics of SAPs hypothesize a number of pathways through which adjustment policies can harm public health including cuts to basic public sector health care services…” (Pfeiffer and Chapman, 152). The U.S.’s economic structure favors the wealthy, and in regards to healthcare, private insurance favors the healthy, which are typically higher income …show more content…

Light in “Introduction: Ironies of Success” examines how health and capitalism are interwoven in the U.S.: “the professionally driven health care system was a capitalist’s dream” (Light, 12). Medical monopolies came into formation to stop the decrease in medical salaries due to the increase in medical professionals. Elitist medical professionals marginalized alternative medical doctors and midwives and began prioritizing developing new medical technology over patients being able to afford medical care. In conjunction, private insurance companies offer low premiums for low-risk patients so that they are less likely to have to pay for their clients’ medical needs. This means that non-profit insurances, like Blue Cross and Blue Shield, endure more high-risk patients: “Risk-related private insurance left the Blues with an ever higher-risk profile left in their community-rated pools” (Light, 14). The disproportion of risk-based clients exhibits how the economy supports privatization over universalism.
Beatrix Hoffman in “Health Care Reform and Social Movements in the United States” explains that universal healthcare will stop the fragmentation of the medical field and the disunification of social grassroots movements: ”Only universal coverage would ensure that patients with different diseases and conditions would not be pitted against each other” (Hoffman, 82). By promoting a free market society, the nation becomes a feeding ground for greed and health

Show More
Related
406 Words | 2 Pages

The US Healthcare system is known for its difficult obstacles to work around. Throughout the article, the audience can see how the author Claire Parker uses Ethos, Hasty Generalization, and Definition to provide a clearer understanding of the Health Care system and its flaws. Parker uses the rhetorical device Ethos to emphasize the importance of United States citizens that do not have access to health insurance. The director of the Global Health Policy Center, J. Stephen Morrison, notes that countries smaller than the US “benefit from a stronger societal consensus around the place that health occupies in the social compact.”

Read More
656 Words | 3 Pages

(par. 2), “one local hospital charged an uninsured patient $29,000 for an appendectomy that would have cost an insured patient $6,783.” (par. 5), and “the uninsured account for only 2 percent of its patients, but 35 percent of its profits” (par. 5). The details and numbers build an appeal to logos and influence the reader that health care is a

Read More
862 Words | 4 Pages

The idea of scientific authority has played an impactful role throughout industrialized society. As the production of knowledge through scientific research is constantly developing, new discoveries have a major influence in policies and practices that influence both social and scientific structures. In a seminar held by Dr. Hayes Bautista, a professor for Chicano Studies Community Medicine 106, he discussed health within the Latino population and his research on The Latino Epidemiological Paradox in terms of science, theory, and data. His research not only questions scientific research and health models, but pose questions that challenge systems surrounding healthcare.

Read More
418 Words | 2 Pages

ARTICLE REVIEW 2- THE MORAL HAZARD MYTH The article mainly emphasizes about the uninsured population in America and the reasons behind the lack of insurance for almost forty five million people. Author states about the research conducted by two Harvard university researchers, and according to them the reason for lack of coverage for these forty five million people is that they cannot afford health insurance implies medical services in America are high expensive and almost one- third of uninsured people are below poverty line. But, according to Bush’s administration plan in their economic report stated that almost one half are uninsured because of their choice which can be challenged based on the research conducted but Harvard researchers.

Read More
537 Words | 3 Pages

In the United States, healthcare is primarily a for-profit organization, this has resulted in unreasonable costs. Additionally, the lack of universal healthcare coverage and insurance options for low-income individuals heightens the problem. These issues have led to a system where access to healthcare is a privilege rather than a right. By viewing the high cost of healthcare through the lens of sociological imagination, I can understand it as a symptom of larger societal problems.

Read More
733 Words | 3 Pages

It utilizes both logos and pathos in order to convince the audience of their standpoint. They list many statistics including how much health care costs per person. With all these statistics, the audience can conclude that America does not have enough money to give every individual health care. The author also runs through the fact that America's government does not have the managerial capabilities to keep this system functioning. When the audience comprehends this fact, they can logically conclude that a universal health care plan will not be effectively instituted if it is set into law.

Read More
841 Words | 4 Pages

Our health is everything to us, whether we’re young or old, white or black. An individuals health could determine a lot of factors in their overall life time satisfaction. However, in our capitalist society healthcare has been turned into a business. With universal healthcare being lauded by conservatives, we have developed an issue of some individuals being left without adequate healthcare due to the fact that they are unable to pay the outrageous premiums some insurance companies charge. The rate of lack of coverage, as well as the reasoning behind it have been provided by the Central Texan Sustainability Project with a survey of Texas citizens.

Read More
693 Words | 3 Pages

The nature of the current debate surrounding the implementation of universal healthcare in America is troubling because it is comprised almost entirely of pragmatic arguments void of concern for the principles behind the project. Before one asks how much a thing will cost, how it will be organized, or whether “the uninsured” will benefit, one should ask whether enacting universal healthcare is in keeping with the values and principles of the American experiment. In other words, is universal healthcare good for America? Universal healthcare is not good for America.

Read More
1986 Words | 8 Pages

Health care has been at the forefront of debate and public policy in the United States for decades. Ever since President Theodore Roosevelt proposed health care reform during his 1912 run for president, reform has been a policy position often espoused in American politics (Palmer 1). Certain types of health care reforms have been successfully implemented, such as Social Security in the 1930s, Medicare in the 1960s, and finally the Affordable Care Act in 2010. As the goal of the Affordable Care Act is to provide care for every American, the healthcare law is the closest the United States has ever approached to a single payer system; a health care system that provides universal care to every American. Despite that, current systems within the

Read More
741 Words | 3 Pages

The real debate is how can we accomplish the goal of universal healthcare in the most affordable and sustainable way. The United States is evaluated as a wealthy country, yet there are more penurious countries who provide health maintenance, paid through higher taxes. “In the United Kingdom and other European countries, payroll taxes average 37% - much higher than the 15.3% payroll taxes paid by the average US worker” (Gregory). With this data, the only reform would be to end the private health insurance companies of dominant health services, and incorporate a single payer system. Conversely, it is factual that taxes will rise, but the implementation of universal healthcare will better the health of American citizens.

Read More
367 Words | 2 Pages

For both the uninsured group and those who are eligible for government assistance because of their low economic position, access to health is limited by the number of private providers willing to treat them. In many cases private providers are linked to particular private health insurance companies and won 't accept patients outside their network. These people must then rely on the overburdened public health system for care, and as such usually only seek treatment in emergencies. The public health system, while filled with competent staff, is nevertheless restricted by its funding and can therefore not always provide all these patients with the best quality of care. The inequality in health care access is a continuing issue in America and as such it is important for future consumers and workers on the Foothill College campus to have a thorough understanding of the issue so they can move to improve the problem in the

Read More
727 Words | 3 Pages

Health care should not be considered a political argument in America; it is a matter of basic human rights. Something that many people seem to forget is that the US is the only industrialized western nation that lacks a universal health care system. The National Health Care Disparities Report, as well as author and health care worker Nicholas Conley and Physicians for a National Health Program (PNHP), strongly suggest that the US needs a universal health care system. The most secure solution for many problems in America, such as wasted spending on a flawed non-universal health care system and 46.8 million Americans being uninsured, is to organize a national health care program in the US that covers all citizens for medical necessities.

Read More
285 Words | 2 Pages

The United States’ plan for having a universal healthcare system is set to be achieved through the multi-payer model of the universal health insurance (UHI) (WHO, 2000). It is important to understand the concept of the universal health system. First, it gives proactive and holistic care at the lowest level and ensures safety and proximity to home. For instance, when one uses the universal insurance, they are not limited to healthcare services within their state. They are free to receive treatment from any state without discrimination.

Read More
811 Words | 4 Pages

Sicko is an American documentary by Michael Moore which explores the status of health care in America. In my opinion, he has presented a clear-cut viewpoint that American health care is not producing results. Nearly half a hundred million Americans, according to Sicko, are not insured while the rest, who are insured, are often sufferers of insurance company deceit and also red tape. Additionally, Sicko mentions that the United States health care system is placed 37th out of 191 by the W.H.O. with definite health measures, like the neonate death and life probability, equivalent to countries with quite less financial wealth. Interviews are carried out with individuals who supposed they had sufficient coverage but were deprived of care.

Read More
1073 Words | 5 Pages

Political leaders across the world ask whether the state itself should provide universal healthcare for their people with the assistance of their taxes, or should the health care market and it insurance be turned over to the private sector. The two arguments come face to face with the way that Sweden and the United States of America have their social welfare and health care provided. Sweden has the social health care that many left leaning political leaders tend to favor more sense it

Read More

More about Getting There From Here By Atul Gawande Analysis

Related Topics

Open Document