ipl-logo

Half Jewish, Just Jewish And The Oddities By Sarah Imhoff: Article Analysis

1158 Words5 Pages

Classification in Action Essay The article “Half Jewish, Just Jewish, and the Oddities of Religious Identities” written by Sarah Imhoff, Indiana University discusses how Jewish identity is not only about religion but also involves cultural, ethnic, and ancestry background. In 2013, the Pew Forum conducted a survey where they asked Jewish Americans about their religious beliefs, cultural practices, and ancestral beliefs, highlighting the many factors that contribute to Jewish identity beyond religious belief. In order to determine if the person was eligible for the survey, they did not just ask the question “Are you Jewish”, but instead asked them a range of questions regarding their religious beliefs, and ancestral background. The results …show more content…

The terms “half-Jewish” and “just-Jewish” are too simple and doesn’t fully capture the complex nature of Jewish identity. The author writes that “Jewishness is neither an either/ or proposition nor is it solely a matter of religious adherence.” Jewish identity involves a complex involvement of religion, culture, history, and family. Imhoff also examines the difficulties that arise when identifying with a religion. She goes into detail and explains that religious labels can be restrictive and often leave people out, people often use these labels to navigate different social and cultural situations. For example, people may choose to identify themselves as “half-Jewish'' or “just Jewish” depending on the audience and their surroundings. The author argues that religious identity is not fixed and unchanging, but it is flexible and changes depending on the context and individuals involved. Understanding the complexity of religious identity is very important for creating more inclusive and welcoming communities. Sarah suggests that having a more detailed understanding of religious identity can help us become more informed and respective towards the different ways people approach their religions and cultural affiliations. She says “recognizing the quirks of religious identifications can help us form communities that are more open, adaptable, and imaginative, and that can welcome and support a wide variety of religious and cultural appropriation.” Overall Sarah Imhoff’s article emphasizes the importance of recognizing the complexity of Jewish Identity and religious identification in general for building more inclusive and accepting

Show More
Related
704 Words | 3 Pages

A long time ago, people who were Jewish had to face a crucial discrimination ever since others blamed them for killing Jesus. Nobody exactly knows what the truth was but believes in religion books where the elders’ deformed words of Judaism were recorded. Based on the “Sister Rose’s Passion” documentary, Rose Thering — a Roman Catholic Dominican Religious Sister — questioned this false belief towards the Jewish people and dreamed of a world without religious prejudice, wishing teachers to educate their students to make her dream a reality. No one, especially including the Jews, should be raced or hurt by any opinion that is not based on reason or actual experience. Throughout the movie, Sister Rose encourages everyone to “Be an Upstander, Not a Bystander” for the Jews.

Read More
883 Words | 4 Pages

To the reader the word “Jew” symbolizes pain, suffering, and enslavement. In the end, using hidden meaning behind words are essential when talking about the

Read More
957 Words | 4 Pages

This was an exciting portion of the reading because it resonates with my personal belief that while the church can and should be reaching out to the Jewish community, there is potentially an inherent advantage in the Messianic Jewish community of reaching unbelieving Jews. The Jewish identity is complex, yet there is potentially a deeper rapport between those who are Jews because of shared experiences and

Read More
1664 Words | 7 Pages

European Jews faced years of anti-Semitism, leading to mass emigration from their home counties many coming to America. Many Jewish historians question whether the anti-Semitism differed from Europe to America and whether today if anti-semitism still exists for American Jews. Both Shapiro’s We Are Many and Katz’s Why is America Different discuss the issue of American Anti-Semitism and prove that there is still Anti-Semitism within the American community.

Read More
1348 Words | 6 Pages

Patel wants everyone to embrace the many different religions that we have while believing that they all can coexist in the community “I realized that it was precisely because of America’s glaring imperfections that I should seek to participate in its progress, carve a place in its promise, and play a role in its possibility. And at its heart and at its best, America was about pluralism” (Patel 89). Patel says that pluralism should be embraced and individuals should have a better understanding of one’s religion before mistaking. These mistakes can lead to disputes and ultimately to pandemonium characterized in this text.

Read More
1034 Words | 5 Pages

When venturing through the tenement museum, the signs of Jewish Immigrant life in Industrial America seem apparent, with objects and decorations clearly denoting the Ashkenazic background. Whether it be the copy of The Forward written in a Yiddish type, a voucher for English courses written in Yiddish, or traditional foods, which the museum displayed as being bagels and challah, the signs of Jewish living are clear. But this is not the only location where we find remnants of Jewish life, as the Eldridge Street Synagogue has several features which personalize the space, and turn it into the intimate space that served this community. Among the clearest of these personal features of the shul would be name plaques denoting reserved benches for certain donor families, or name crotched into the side of a tapestry on a Torah scroll covering. Interestingly though, the most notable yet unseemly sign of once prevalent Jewish life that the visitor can see in both sites, are the creases in the floorboard.

Read More
998 Words | 4 Pages

Like we observed with Anne Hutchinson, Individuals with unorthodox beliefs demonstrated that varying beliefs could be found within individual denominations. Unless orthodox beliefs were willing to pay the high price for religious uniformity, kill or banish unorthodox believers, religious homogeneity could not be achieved. Diversity was here to

Read More
970 Words | 4 Pages

A person’s entire personality and life revolve around their identity, because your identity is composed of all your life experiences and how you handle new situations. Religion usually takes up a large portion of many people's identities and for many of them, being without the faith they would become empty and alone. Elie Wiesel is a great example of someone’s identity being changed in his memoir “Night”. Elie as a young boy was consumed by his faith in God and wanted nothing more than to learn Zohar, the secrets of Jewish mysticism. As he and his father travel through concentration camps, Elie starts to show bits of rebellion towards his beloved God.

Read More
655 Words | 3 Pages

Throughout history, multiple religions have budded heads, such as Christians and Muslims. In the book “The Chosen,” by Chaim Potok, the Hasidic and Modern Orthodox people conflict with each other because of their different views of belief. The religion itself doesn’t conflict, but the people of the different religions do. Hasidic and Modern Orthodox are the two sects of the main characters which were divided off from the four sects of Judaism, which are, Reconstructions, Reform, Conservative, and Orthodox. Both religions are “types” of Jews; both of these are stricter than the “average Jew,” but Hasidism’s are considered the extreme.

Read More
1463 Words | 6 Pages

This novel reveals that culture and language has a lot to do with forming one's identity. The type of culture and language a person has been surrounded with affects their sense of identity,

Read More
1190 Words | 5 Pages

Later, the cultural critic Stuart Hall has opined about the changing nature of identity. He says that there is no fixed identity that can be attributed to an individual for his life period; it evolves through several changes in each phase of life. So it can be understood that formation of identity involves several steps: construction, reconstruction and deconstruction. The politics behind this formation may depend on the nature of identity that an individual tries to hold. Indeed, the cultural critic Kobena Mercer reminds us: “One thing at least is clear - identity only becomes an issue when it is in crisis, when something

Read More
501 Words | 3 Pages

Employing the sociological imagination to the concept of religion can help people understand just how religion comes to reflect and shape one's identity and experiences (Datta). In a largely secular country like Canada it is easy to dismiss the importance of religion, but it has a significant impact on many people; shaping their values, habits, and ways of understanding the world around them. Recent statistics indicate that for Canadians, the percentage of people considering religion to be of importance to them is on the rise (Hayatullah). When coupled with the rise of immigration and the diversification of the city, an expanded understanding of religion and how important it can be to one's cultural identity and sense of self can lead to increased tolerance and acceptance of diverse

Read More
1025 Words | 5 Pages

Moral relativism is an umbrella term that carries both subjectivism and conventionalism. Subjectivism is the ability to kill a man and it be accepted because of individual moral beliefs that it is okay to do so, as to conventionalism, you would be incarcerated for most or all of your life due to the fact that society sees murder as wrong. Conventionalism takes the individuals spread beliefs onto a society level through media, networking, or culture. It creates a safety net for knowing right from wrong.

Read More
957 Words | 4 Pages

Introduction The concept of identity has been a notion of significant interest not just to sociologists and psychologists, but also to individuals found in a social context of perpetually trying to define themselves. Often times, identities are given to individuals based on their social status within a certain community, after the assessment of predominant characteristics that said individual has. However, within the context of an ethnicity, the concept identity is most probably applied to all members of the ethnical group, and not just one individual. When there is one identity designated for the entire group, often times the factor of “individuality” loses its significance, especially when referring to the relationship between the ethnic

Read More
885 Words | 4 Pages

Self-identity is defined as the recognition of one's potential and qualities as an individual, especially in relation to social context. In other words, self-understanding. Finding self-identity is more more difficult for some people than others. In the autobiography Black, White, and Jewish: Autobiography of a Shifting Self by Rebecca Walker, the author reflects on her identity as a mixed raced individual which is illustrated through Walker’s reflections. People define themselves in many different ways.

Read More

More about Half Jewish, Just Jewish And The Oddities By Sarah Imhoff: Article Analysis

Related Topics

Open Document