ipl-logo

How Canada And United States Ended Up Having Two Different Form Of Health Insurance

938 Words4 Pages

The purpose of Maioni article is to analyze how Canada and United states ended up having two different form of health care insurance. Both countries until the 1940’s shared the same histories with their political ideology and economic development. This article examines how two counties with similar ideology came to have two different welfare states and most important government funded health insurance. Maioni points out two important reason why there was a diversion between both countries in terms of their health care. The first one is parliamentary government and the second was federalism. Federalism is shared power between federal government and provincial government. Canada has a very strong federalism system as oppose to the United States …show more content…

Parliamentary government explains “the rules of the game of legislative politics” (Maioni, 1997). The rules of Canada parliamentary provided a gateway for third party formation, which was unlikely in United States which was very important for health reform in Canada. The second rule was party discipline. Canada imposes a parliamentary party discipline where members from a party have to support the policies of their party leadership. This rule allows major parties in Canada from disagreeing with each other. The fact that United States did not have this form of party discipline, this gave rise to disagreement within the …show more content…

The first message is the impact of left wing party (Social Democratic Party) on the development of both countries health care reform. The Social democratic party that was form in Canada was the voice for a universal health care reform. The fact that United States could not form a social democratic party, the push for a universal health care reform was left in the hands of the Democratic party coalition. Maioni wanted to show the importance of a political party pressuring the government. Although, the federal government was reluctant to re-open the universal health insurance plan, the CCF continued to pressure the federal government. Canada universal health care plan would not have been strong if it wasn’t for the constant pressure of social democratic party, they continue to ensure health care reform was on the health care agenda. Unlike the States they allowed national health insurance to be erased from policy and they were willing to settle for an alternate plan which was health insurance for vulnerable group. Another key message was that the impact of organized labour. Both Canada and America had labour movements that both supported the national program, however, Canada labour movement was as able to translate their goals into legislation. This momentum can be accredited to their political alliances with major parties. Maoini illustrates how important alliances can be when trying to implement policies.

Show More
Related
1433 Words | 6 Pages

Better Now : 6 Big Ideas by Dr. Danielle Martin is a compilation of ideas to try and fix the Canadian Healthcare system. Martin gained popularity after a schooling Republicans at the United States committee led by the Independent Senator Bernie Sanders. The Canadian doctor was invited at the panel to represent Canada, alongside other countries like France, Denmark Taiwan, to discuss the nation’s healthcare system and what the United States could learn from it. Inevitably, one of the issues often brought up by Canadians is the long waiting periods that Capitalists like to blame on the single payer system. Martin argued that when Australia switched to a multi-payer system in the 1990’s, statistics showed that wait times in the public health

Read More
902 Words | 4 Pages

After emigrating to Canada, he had an operation done, but only because his surgery was a demonstration of surgical techniques. In 1944, Douglas established a single-payer health system. I agree with Douglas’ thoughts and ideas behind his model, but the system does have some downfalls. Canada’s system is “underdoctored” which leaves long waiting times for patient’s whose condition is not urgent. When Douglas adopted the system of Medicare in 1961, he proved that the demonstration effect worked.

Read More
826 Words | 4 Pages

Thomas Clement “Tommy” Douglas (20 October 1904 – 24 February 1986) known as “The Father of Medicare”, had done extraordinary work to make Canada a unique country. The problems he faced with short term helped to greatly benefit Canadians in the long term. The experience Douglas had from when he was a child to when he finishes his studies, influenced him to join politics and help millions of Canadians. In 1944, Tommy Douglas became the premier of Saskatchewan and helped raise Canada’s reputation in front of the whole world by introducing new laws and regulations. Tommy Douglas’s own childhood experience led him to join politics and help millions of Canadians by introducing Medicare system in Canada.

Read More
1260 Words | 6 Pages

Source 1 is a political cartoon that depicts Hitler’s rule in Nazi Germany in 1936. The cartoonist portrays Hitler standing proudly and doing the Nazi salute while proclaiming that he has “restored honour and freedom to the German people.” In 1936, Adolf Hitler contravened the Treaty of Versailles and sent thousands of troops to Rhineland, which is to be a demilitarized land and refused to pay the reparations. By doing so, Hitler appealed to the German people who felt that the treaty, including the War Guilt Clause, was a source of shame to the country and he quickly rose to power. Additionally, Hitler rose Germany out of poverty and reduce unemployment drastically.

Read More
1001 Words | 5 Pages

Tommy’s idea of Universal Health Care is a type of health care where citizens are provided with health coverage regardless of their income, race, age, pre-existing conditions, gender, or wealth. This reason being, the Great Depression caused a crisis to Canada’s health care system. The voluntary service and care demanded, exceeded the resources available from the government. Whilst, the Great Depression made most Canadians impoverish, and could not afford the health care needed. The responsibility to solve health care problems fell to the hands of the Premier of each province, as the federal government reduced the fund of health care.

Read More
816 Words | 4 Pages

From 1867 to today, Canada has had twenty-three prime ministers, each of whom helped build and improve Canada. An analysis of former prime ministers William Lyon Mackenzie King, Lester Bowles Pearson, and Pierre Elliott Trudeau of Canada during the WWII, the fifties and sixties, and contemporary Canada, respectively, shows that Canadians should be proud of their nation and the people who led and shaped Canada to what it is today. During WWII, the leader seen as the greatest Canadian prime minister by scholars and academics in Maclean’s surveys guided Canada through the turbulent time. William Lyon Mackenzie King made many accomplishments during his time as the longest-serving prime minister, from 1921-1926, 1926-1930, and 1935-1948, and

Read More
926 Words | 4 Pages

Have you ever been sick, or so they particularly thought. The chances mostly are that you have in a kind of major way. Medical care particularly is very expensive; a checkup could cost hundreds of dollars, which actually is fairly significant. If it for the most part was not for Tommy Douglas and his idea of free universal health care, it mostly is pretty possible that pretty many people would actually be fairly bankrupt or very ill; he for the most part had also re-organized the for all intents and purposes public-school system and made fluctuations to very social welfare in a particularly big way. Although overlooked, Tommy Douglas definitely has evolved Canada as a nation and actually has really had an important effect on the lives of pretty

Read More
760 Words | 4 Pages

Now, Douglas is proclaimed to be very relevant in Canadian history for the reason of the accomplishments that he acquired from the time he was still a politician. He received many loving followers and supporters because of how improved, the government was when he was still a premier. The improved government provided public pensions, expansion of Canada’s social safety net, social programs, especially the introduction of the Medicare. Douglas’s Universal Health Care Program is one of the reasons for his popularity and relevance to the people and Canada, it removes any sort of biasedly and discrimination that could occur in any patients that could be applying for it and for its policy of no charge to any citizens who is using it. Though in America, healthcare isn't free and solely can be obtained by paying for it by each individual, which raises their ideal of individuality, this makes their health care sort-of useless, in contrary to what it is meant.

Read More
1851 Words | 8 Pages

Fiscal Federalism: Power of the Provinces versus Equitable Programs Fiscal Federalism and Equalization in Canada thoroughly catalogues the dynamics of Canada’s federal government and the provinces in relation to equalization payments and the equitable distribution of public services. The book examines the unequal distribution of services in Canada and attempts to offer solutions drawing on foreign federations with equalization payments and comparing the differences. However, as Canada is unique in the amount of autonomy the provinces individually hold, the relationship that the provinces have towards the federal government severely impacts the applicability of foreign systems to address the equity of services. In addition, the inequity of the

Read More
832 Words | 4 Pages

The one major difference between the Canadian health care system and the American health care system is that is that they have a privatized health care system. A documentary such as “Sicko directed by Michael Moore” demonstrates the crisis of American citizens without health care coverage. Canada’s universal health care system ensures those who cannot pay for health to not suffer, contrary to the Sicko

Read More
693 Words | 3 Pages

The nature of the current debate surrounding the implementation of universal healthcare in America is troubling because it is comprised almost entirely of pragmatic arguments void of concern for the principles behind the project. Before one asks how much a thing will cost, how it will be organized, or whether “the uninsured” will benefit, one should ask whether enacting universal healthcare is in keeping with the values and principles of the American experiment. In other words, is universal healthcare good for America? Universal healthcare is not good for America.

Read More
895 Words | 4 Pages

Canada enjoys the benefits of a “universal” insurance plan funded by the federal government. The idea of having a publicly administered, accessible hospital and medical services with comprehensive coverage, universality and portability has its own complex history, more so, than the many challenges in trying to accommodate the responsibility of a shared-cost agreement between federal and provincial governments. (Tiedemann, 2008) Canada’s health care system has gone through many reforms, always with the intent to deliver the most adequate health care to Canadians. The British North American Act, Hospital Insurance and Diagnostic Services Act, Saskatchewan’s Medical Care Act, and the Canada Health Act are four Acts that have played an important

Read More
847 Words | 4 Pages

Analysis of Healthcare to Thesis Healthcare is important to our well being, which is why we have free health care. That also means that Canadians have the burden of paying higher taxes in order to have free health care. Argument #4: The Aging

Read More
727 Words | 3 Pages

Health care should not be considered a political argument in America; it is a matter of basic human rights. Something that many people seem to forget is that the US is the only industrialized western nation that lacks a universal health care system. The National Health Care Disparities Report, as well as author and health care worker Nicholas Conley and Physicians for a National Health Program (PNHP), strongly suggest that the US needs a universal health care system. The most secure solution for many problems in America, such as wasted spending on a flawed non-universal health care system and 46.8 million Americans being uninsured, is to organize a national health care program in the US that covers all citizens for medical necessities.

Read More
701 Words | 3 Pages

Health Care is a huge and important part of Canada and what it is. Canadian citizens all have access to Canada 's healthcare system known as `Medicare`. Medicare is managed by the federal government delivered through a publicly funded health care system, in cooperation with the 10 provinces and 3 territories. Under the health care system, individual citizens are provided preventative care and medical treatments from primary care physicians as well as access to hospitals, dental surgery, and additional medical services. With a few exceptions, all citizens qualify for health coverage regardless of medical history, personal income, or standard of living.

Read More

More about How Canada And United States Ended Up Having Two Different Form Of Health Insurance

Related Topics

Open Document