ipl-logo

How Did Thoreau Propose In Resistance To Civil Government

573 Words3 Pages

Thomas Darr
Mrs. O’Sullivan
American Lit. Adv.
15 March 2023
What does Henry David Thoreau propose in his essay “Resistance to Civil Government,” and how did Thoreau’s proposal influence the histories of the Republic of India and the United States of America?
Introduction
Hook: In 1849, “Resistance to Civil Government” was written by Henry David Thoreau out of spite towards the government, but little did he know the impact it would have on movements across the globe.
Background Information: Civil disobedience was published in 1849 by Henry David Thoreau. Thoreau wrote Civil disobedience to portray his dislike of government and the laws they force people to follow. A main point of civil disobedience is that people should not abide by laws they feel …show more content…

E. How Did Thoreau’s Proposal Influence the History of the Republic of India
Topic Sentence: Thoreau’s proposal of civil disobedience influenced the Republic of India by kick-starting an independence movement, led by Gandhi, that emerged from harsh British rule.
Protesting British Rule (History).
Salt March (History).
Gandhi’s campaign, Satyagraha (History).
Independence of India (History). F. How Did Thoreau’s Proposal Influence the History of the United States
Topic Sentence: Thoreau’s proposal of civil disobedience influenced the United States of America by inspiring people like Martin Luther King Jr. to make a change regarding the treatment of African Americans in the United States.
King led peaceful protests (Mallampalli).
King was arrested April 16, 1963 (J.F.K Library).
Unjust laws must be broken - my own commentary
Everyone will have freedom (J.F.K Library). G. Conclusion
Echo Thesis Statement: In conclusion, Thereau’s proposal of civil disobedience, in “Resistance to Civil Government”, influenced important movements in both the Republic of India and the United States of America.
Lived out many transcendentalism beliefs (Tyrkus).
Make clear your oppositions

Show More
Related

How Does Thoreau Use Anaphora In Civil Disobedience

627 Words | 3 Pages

The essay Civil Disobedience, written by Henry David Thoreau has a history with Thoreau’s own experiences. Thoreau spent a night in prison for not paying his poll taxes where he was inspired to write the essay and with this essay Thoreau aspired to proclaim against the acts of slavery and the Mexican War. a.“It does not keep the country free. It does not settle the West. It does not educate”().

Read More

Letter From Birmingham Jail Rhetorical Analysis

1268 Words | 6 Pages

“Unjust laws exist: Shall we be content to obey them, or shall we endeavor to amend them” (Thoreau 945, par.16). Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. had written about resisting an unjust government in his piece, “Letter from Birmingham Jail”. In his essay “On the Duty of Civil Disobedience,” Henry David Thoreau also discusses the right and responsibility to resist an unjust government. Since King and Thoreau both use current events in their time as examples of injustice, use historical and biblical references, how they can’t wait any longer to make a change, both provide strong arguments on how important it is to stand up against the injustice put upon American people by the government; however, King and Thoreau were inspired to write by different causes

Read More

Letter From Birmingham Jail Rhetorical Analysis

676 Words | 3 Pages

Thoreau believes that an individual who acts with fairness, righteousness, and moral integrity has the ability to make a positive impact and influence societal change. heavily influenced by Gandhi's principles, expands on nonviolent civil disobedience as a collective and organized approach to challenge unjust laws and societal norms. He stresses the importance of direct action, peaceful protests, and that the power of love can overcome hate. Thoreau's "Civil Disobedience" laid the groundwork for later civil rights movements, and its ideas on individual conscience and nonviolent resistance inspired people like Gandhi and King.

Read More

A Rhetorical Analysis Of Civil Disobedience By Thoreau

422 Words | 2 Pages

Throughout history there have been many political changes that are either supported, or not, by citizens. In the given passage from, "Civil Disobedience," by Thoreau, a perspective of disagreeing with the government ways, is provided. Thoreau explains how a government should be in comparison to how it really is by utilizing his words to set the tone and mode, imagery to achieve his audience's understanding, and diction to make his writing scholarly. Although tone and mode are not directly stated, you can infer that Thoreau meant for his writing to be taken as serious and powerful. His implementation of words such as, "inexpedient," "execute," " integrity," and "command," makes one think about their lawful rights and reflect on what rights are supported or

Read More

Rhetorical Techniques Used In Civil Disobedience By Henry David Thoreau

1252 Words | 6 Pages

Published in 1849, a time filled with slavery and prejudice laws, Henry David Thoreau’s essay “Civil Disobedience” was initially written as a speech to help express the importance of individuality amongst those under the government’s rule. Throughout his essay, Thoreau uses rhetorical techniques such as analogies for example, comparing men who serve the government to machines, to articulate his distrust towards the government, while emphasizing the active role that each citizen must play in it through standing up for their beliefs. He found it important to persuade civilians to oppose unjust government because many of the people around him were blindly following the government, without even considering their own moral conscience. Thoreau opens

Read More

How Does Henry David Thoreau Use Rhetorical Devices

1458 Words | 6 Pages

Phillip Vilensky Professor Sadeghipour ENG 1B 19 February 2016 Rhetorical Devices in Thoreau’s “Civil Disobedience” There have been many individuals in mankind's long history that have been characterized by unusual thought and foresight, and whose observations and theories could only be appreciated many decades, even centuries, later. But one of the individuals whose beliefs about ethics, philosophy, and politics must have struck his contemporaries as very odd, even bordering on insane was the great American author, poet, and philosopher Henry David Thoreau, who lived in 19th century Massachusetts. In the era of slavery, westward expansion, and imperialism, Thoreau espoused abolitionism, civil disobedience, conscientious objection, direct

Read More

Analysis Of Henry David Thoreau's Resistance To Civil Government

2124 Words | 9 Pages

India’s leader Mohandas Gandhi (Mahatma Gandhi) was influenced by David Thoreau 's Civil Disobedience arguments while sitting in jail. Gandhi loosely adopted the term “civil disobedience” for non-violent protests and refused to cooperate with injustice. Following his release, he protested the registration law by joining labor strikes and organizing a large non-violent march. After the marches, the Boer government finally agreed to end the most divisive sections of the law. In 1907, he campaigned in South Africa and wrote a translated synopsis of Thoreau 's argument for the Indian Opinion.

Read More

Civil Disobedience Rhetorical Analysis

357 Words | 2 Pages

In the essay “Civil Disobedience,” written by Henry David Thoreau, he stated, “Government is at best an expedient, but most governments are usually, and all governments are sometimes, inexpedient.” This expresses his opinion about the government that controlled America during the mid 1800s. His essay expresses that the government only addresses how to deal with a majority of the population, instead of finding a way to serve individuals. Thoreau’s viewpoint on the government is why he feels the need for resistance. For Thoreau, resistance means doing what a person believes is morally right.

Read More

Civil Disobedience In Martin Luther King Jr.'s Letter From Birmingham Jail

631 Words | 3 Pages

It is out of the selfless act of heroes and heroines of civil disobedience such as Mahatma Gandhi that the society is enjoying the fruits today. This speech is going to demonstrate how civil disobedience has played roles in social reforms, containing unjust rulings

Read More

Cliven Bundy's Civil Disobedience

751 Words | 4 Pages

Some wonder what Civil Disobedience is and what it is all about. Civil Disobedience is an effective, self­acknowledged denial to obey certain laws, requirements and orders of the government or an occupying world­wide power. Around in 1846 a man named Henry David Thoreau wrote an essay over Civil Disobedience. He wrote this while he sent the night in jail because he had failed to pay 6 years worth of delinquent poll taxes(Resistance to Civil Government) . He would bicker with the people saying he couldn’t pay the funds that helped to assist the US government 's war with Mexico, nor could he pay a government that still allowed slavery in its Southern states.

Read More

Similarities Between Civil Disobedience And Martin Luther King

493 Words | 2 Pages

Martin Luther King Jr. once said “One has a moral responsibility to disobey unjust laws”. Civil disobedience is the moral responsibility of a person opposing the state when laws contradict superior ideas. Henry David Thoreau and Martin Luther King Jr. stand for civil disobedience in their works “From Civil Disobedience” and “A Letter From Birmingham Jail”. Civil disobedience has been proven to be justified throughout history and these works.

Read More

Summary: The Case Against Civil Disobedience

1290 Words | 6 Pages

Herbert J. Storing, an Associate Professor of Political Science, in “The Case Against Civil Disobedience,” writes, “One of the practical consequences of this institution [civil disobedience] is to divert disobedience and even revolution into the channel of law” (97). What Storing is saying is that civil disobedience will encourage people to break the laws and they will hide under civil disobedience to avoid the law. Also, civil disobedience might split society by creating disagreements with the people, and it could create a political instability. However, Storing fails to see that those who break an unjust law, as discussed above, do not avoid the law, in fact they show respect to the law as they willingly accept the consequences. By accepting the consequences, they show that they are not acting for their own interests but for society’s.

Read More

Disobedience Is Necessary In The Famous Words Of Martin Luther King Jr.

1813 Words | 8 Pages

A common argument against civil disobedience is that it undermines the rule of law and societal order by encouraging lawlessness and disobedience to established norms. In truth, civil disobedience transcends mere “rule-breaking”. People who engage in civil disobedience, despite wanting to change the law, act with respect, and accept potential consequences for their actions (6). Martin Luther King Jr, for example, was well aware that advocating for equal rights could eventually place him in imprisonment, but his longing for justice outweighed the consequences. People who act in civil disobedience aim to challenge and correct rules that will cause harm to others (1).

Read More

Henry David Thoreau On Civil Disobedience

801 Words | 4 Pages

Throughout all of time, people have needed to live according to their own agendas. Being forced to live a certain way has only caused trouble. That is why Henry David Thoreau supported civil disobedience to help people live according to their own beliefs. In the essay “On Civil Disobedience” by Henry David Thoreau, the author defined and explained the effect of civil disobedience. Thoreau defined it as, civil disobedience is any peaceful action that demonstrates the disagreement of a person or persons with their government.

Read More

Why Is Civil Disobedience Necessary

695 Words | 3 Pages

In recent days, the validity of civil disobedience has once again come to the forefront of political debate. The heart of the argument may be boiled down to whether it is possible to morally break the law or whether following the law is always the most moral option in a democratic society. This essay will endeavor to explain why civil disobedience is necessary, justified, and in fact the most moral possible course of action. Civil disobedience is not only a just part of a democratic society, but a necessary one. Disobedience of unjust laws is one of the foremost ways of making one’s voice heard that is available to those lacking the enfranchisement of wealth and influence, which are increasingly important as wealth and power continually amassed

Read More

More about How Did Thoreau Propose In Resistance To Civil Government

Related Topics

Open Document