ipl-logo

How Is Heathcliff An Unfit For Heaven

544 Words3 Pages

As characters in both Catherine’s dream and reality claim that she and her sinful and selfish behavior are unfit for Heaven, they support the idea that she is unfit for Linton and his redeeming qualities and more compatible with Heathcliff, a rebellious character. The angels in Catherine’s dream and Nelly in Catherine’s reality openly deem Catherine’s attitude and conduct unworthy of Heaven. In Catherine’s dream, the angels, upset with her sobbing, fling her “out into the middle of the heath on the top of Wuthering Heights” (80), believing her conduct to be unfit for Heaven and more suitable for a less holy environment, Wuthering Heights. Because Heaven is symbolic of Edgar Linton, the angels also indicate that Catherine is not worthy of Edgar Linton and is more suited toward a less holy character: Heathcliff. …show more content…

Nelly, in Catherine’s real life, agrees with the angels’ stance and tells Catherine that she is too sinful of a person for Heaven, stating, “‘Because you are unfit to go there,’... ‘All sinners would be miserable in heaven’” (80). Nelly believes that Catherine’s rebelliousness, impulsiveness, and selfishness, make her sinful and unworthy of Heaven, a pleasant and holy place, and Linton, a wealthy, kind, and well-perceived man. She expresses Linton’s incongruity with Catherine’s behavior by warning him to leave Catherine after he observes her yelling and slapping Nelly: “‘That’s right!’... ‘Take warning and begone!’ It’s a kindness to let you have a glimpse of her genuine disposition’” (71). Nelly, claiming that Linton’s kind disposition would be unable to control Catherine’s sinful behavior, believes that he should leave and not be involved with

Show More
Related
137 Words | 1 Pages

Francie is heartbroken after finding out that her lover, Lee Rhynor, returned back to his home after war and had married another girl, despite his previous confession of love for Francie. This betrayal causes Francie to lose the last of her innocence, as she was “a girl who had come face to face with some of the evil of the world and most of its hardships, and yet had remained curiously untouched by the world” (463). Francie was six years younger than Lee, and though she was “tremendously innocent” and impressionable during their brief time together, she was deeply in love with him. She snaps back into reality, knowing that those who she truly loves have the ability to break her heart and deceive her, as Lee had done when pretending to be in

Read More
1239 Words | 5 Pages

While she was there, the old Jewish woman’s words finally gained some meaning. She realized that she didn’t have to be at her home to be herself, she would always be Catherine. This made Catherine more mature, she changed by knowing that she was, and would always be, herself. She says, “I am like the Jews in our hall, driven from England, from one life to another, and yet for them exile was no exile.” (Cushman 202).

Read More
833 Words | 4 Pages

This may represent here geographical location on the moors or her oppression in the restrictive 18th century society, when the novel was set. An era in which Catherine's free and open nature, Nelly described her as being "a wicked wild slip " would be unacceptable and expected to change as she grew into a proper young woman - the Victorian stereotype of the 'Angel of the House' (similar to Isabella Linton). Hosseini however may be trying to create a sympathetic, emotional connection between character and reader, to show how the women are more free to be who they want to in a 20/21st century

Read More
152 Words | 1 Pages

Isabella Linton is a sheltered, ignorant, romantic child who longs for love. Watching Cathrine and Edgar's romance causes her to become obsessed with finding her own love. Consequently, she becomes infatuated with Heathcliff and convinces her self that she is in love with him. Cathrine becomes aware and attempts to get her to see reality. Despite Heathcliff’s new civilized appearance, Cathrine attempts to convince Isabella that he is actually still “an unreclaimed creature, without refinement, without cultivation,” a wolf in sheep’s clothing (Brontë).

Read More
1158 Words | 5 Pages

A portrait - very like - of a departed wife, not valued by the husband!” (141). Along with the gathered evidence Catherine has collected and

Read More
99 Words | 1 Pages

Nelly’s dislike of Catherine contrasts sharply with Edgar’s nearly unconditional positive regard for his wife. Nelly’s role in Catherine’s life was different from Edgar’s, and she got a more unrestricted view of Catherine. This difference contributed most greatly to the disparity in the attitudes that the two characters possessed. Both Edgar and Nelly experienced hardship at the hand of Catherine, Edgar perhaps more so, but even as Catherine’s personality changed, neither would give up their conceptions of Catherine. The only major similarity between Edgar and Nelly’s attitudes, then, was their unwillingness to recognize change in Catherine of any sort.

Read More
1052 Words | 5 Pages

Love is not always right especially in the case of this tragic tale. Heathcliff is a troubled man and the abuse he has already experienced inhibits his ability to love properly. This can be seen especially through his reaction and heartbreak to Catherine’s death: “Catherine Earnshaw, may you not rest as long as I am living. You said I killed you--haunt me then. The murdered do haunt their murderers.

Read More
1325 Words | 6 Pages

Still not being completely over her fiance’s death, Catherine plants herself in a relationship with an equally vulnerable Henry. Henry meets Catherine early on and turns from living in the midst of the nightmares of war to a life of a passionate love affair with Catherine Barkley. Henry uses the love he has for her as an aid to distract him from the brutality around him. Even at the start of the book, Henry gives out a cold vibe to his roommate and supposed friend, Rinaldi. Rinaldi much like Henry is an alcoholic womanizer who does not believe in romance and proclaims love to every women he meets.

Read More
637 Words | 3 Pages

(Brontë pg number; chapter 10). Catherine has called out Isabella for a surface-level love and warned Isabella that Heathcliff is too much for her, and Isabella retorts by saying she loves Heathcliff more than Catherine has loved Edgar, which is proof of her becoming more assertive. Heathcliff and Isabella’s relationship quickly turns toxic and abusive and Isabella finally decides to stand up for herself and run away to London. Isabella is an interesting character, the more she matures, the more stubborn and self-protective she becomes, just like Catherine. As a teenager, when Catherine is unable to get Nelly Dean to leave the room, she stubbornly pinches her and makes her leave.

Read More
1531 Words | 7 Pages

Heathcliff and Catherine reveal some pressing matters with letting things go. Before Catherine passes away, Heathcliff asks Catherine to torment him so that he doesn’t have to be away from her, and Catherine obliges Heathcliff’s request. Catherine and Heathcliff have always wanted to be monogamous, however, something is always preventing this. This time, it's a window, symbolizing death, that lies amidst

Read More
375 Words | 2 Pages

When Mr. Lockwood came to Wuthering heights he was given Catherine’s room to sleep in. He awakens from a violent dream because he sees a ghost, of a young girl who called herself Catherine Linton. She tried to come inside, but Mr. Lockwood wouldn’t let her in, even when she explains that she has been wandering for twenty years. It had about been twenty years ago that Catherine Linton died, and Heathcliff had begged her to haunt him until he died. Heathcliff states that he’ll hold Catherine again, even when she is cold.

Read More
146 Words | 1 Pages

Heathcliff could not be portrayed as merely a villainous figure as there was certain aspect that depictures him as a sympathetic figure. His rough childhood was one that kicked off everything, ultimately imposing to the reader that his actions are simply a testament to his terrible upbringing. Although he committed a lot of violent acts it was only to seek revenge for the pain that losing Catherine caused him. Nevertheless, there is an extent until one agrees to stop sympathizing with Heathcliff as he becomes a very angry and villainous character. This thirst for revenge that Heathcliff as is a direct result of the obsession he has with Catherine.

Read More
791 Words | 4 Pages

Throughout the novel, Nelly acts as the voice of reason to many of her mistresses, although sometimes their actions have consequences. For example, Nelly encourages Isabella to renounce her love for Heathcliff. Nelly knows that Edgar would never approve of him as her husband, but Isabella disregards her advice and seals her elopement with Heathcliff anyway. Their marriage provoked the tension that had remained after Catherine 's decision to elope with Edgar rather than Heathcliff. Brontë scholars believe that Nelly is one of the only characters in Wurthering Heights that has the power to "shape the plot" by the fact that she has been a support to a handful of the characters throughout the novel.

Read More
2102 Words | 9 Pages

Firstly the obsessive love between Catherine and Heathcliff. Catherine claims that her love for Heathcliff “resembles the eternal rocks beneath –a source of little visible delight, but necessary” (73). She tells her housekeeper “Nelly, I am Heathcliff –he’s always, always in my

Read More
895 Words | 4 Pages

It contains mixed emotions for example: at one point of the novel Catherine likes Heathcliff and Heathcliff likes Catherine, however later in the novel their emotions change, Catherine begs Heathcliff to forgive her because she betrayed him by marrying Edgar, and Heathcliff is refusing to forgive saying that she has hurt him. This change of emotion causes it to be bitter. The phrase “whirl of wind” suggests that the pain Catherine caused to Heathcliff is constant and will not

Read More

More about How Is Heathcliff An Unfit For Heaven

Related Topics

Open Document