ipl-logo

How Is The Estimation Used In 1491 By Charles Mann

852 Words4 Pages

Most students recognize the classic rhyme: “In 1492 Columbus sailed the ocean blue”. This simple and catchy phrase intends to help students memorize the year of the so called beginning of modern life on the American continent. While seemingly innocuous, this rhyme actually reflects a deep eurocentric misunderstanding in modern society. The classic misunderstanding propagates that Columbus landed on virgin wilderness in 1492 and proceeded to easily spread European customs and wisdom onto the primitive indigenous people of that land. In his book 1491, Charles Mann challenges the conventional wisdom of Columbus’s “discovery” of America. Mann correctly argues that Columbus did not land on an empty continent of a few barbaric natives, but on a …show more content…

High counters, like Henry Dobyns, estimated that between “90 and 120 million people” (Mann, 108) lived on the continent. Lower estimates hover around 20 million people. Like all bits of history, deep political implication embed themselves in the estimation of the population of America. Mann writes that he sides with the higher estimation. Although low counter argue that high estimates are based on inconclusive data, Mann’s estimation represents an important shift in the understanding of the history of the continent. As ethnologist Lenore Stiffarm says, “The smaller the number of indians...the easier it is to regard the continent as empty, and hence up for grabs” (Mann, 109). Even though the estimation may not be based on pure scientific extrapolation, the conclusion creates an important political statement that it justifies the imperfect method. By recognizing that dense societies populated the continent, historians legitimize the legacy of native people and their push for contemporary political …show more content…

Although shocking to the classically educated student’s ear, Mann defends his claim with careful historical analysis of the epidemics and specific political decision made by indigenous societies that led to the European conquest. The eurocentric version of history teaches students that native people never stood a chance against Europe’s far superior technology and warfare strategy. In reality, “Europeans routinely lost when they could not take advantage of disease and political fragmentation” (Mann ,104). Mann also explains that Europe’s clunky guns and small armies did not lead to inevitable success. In truth, tiny microbes gave Europeans the upper hand. Smallpox and measles successfully wiped out majorities of native populations creating a much easier path to victory for the Europeans. But not just disease ensured victory for the Europeans. Poor political decisions and societal hierarchy within native societies contributed to their own

Show More
Related
1021 Words | 5 Pages

As economics begins to grow, indentured servitude began to take place and natives were sold to work for companies. One of the first few mistakes that the English did was build their fort on a swampy peninsula which was full of diseases. Another mistake they made was not educating themselves on growing crops which left them with no food. This led them to stealing food from the natives. While Davidson mentions the mass death of Europeans due to diseases and malnutrition, Axtell touches on how the Europeans spread diseases that the natives had never been introduced to, killing a lot of natives.

Read More
939 Words | 4 Pages

Mann first describes going on a trip with his colleagues to Brazil to learn more about the culture there and explore the land on which the Indians lived. He states that his colleagues, Erickson and Balée, have radically challenged conventional notions of what the America’s were like before Columbus. He explains that when he went to school in the 70s’, he learned that the Indians had come across the Bering Strait roughly thirteen

Read More
1577 Words | 7 Pages

In writing A Voyage Long and Strange, Tony Horwitz’s goal is clear, to educate others on early America and debunk ignorant myths. Horwitz’s reason for wanting to achieve this goal is because of his own ignorance that he sees while at Plymouth Rock. “Expensively educated at a private school and university- a history major, no less!-I’d matriculated to middle age with a third grader’s grasp of early America.” Horwitz is disappointed in his own lack of knowledge of his home country, especially with his background history and decides not only to research America’s true beginnings, but to also follow the path of those who originally yearned to discover America.

Read More
598 Words | 3 Pages

Columbus, who was brave and admiring, had a different route to Asia led the journey west came upon the new yet to be explored American continents. According to Document E, it states, “His conquest of Atlantic the outer space of the fifteenth century - is as meaningful to the Americans of the space age as it was to our forefathers who pushed across the vast expenses of this continent.” This quote shows how Columbus’s conquest was an important milestone in the achievements of people of his time and even today. Despite his famous discovery, one of the main reason to set sail for this conquest was Columbus’s greed for riches and fame. In Document A, it states, “I was very attentive to them, and strove to learn if they had any gold.”

Read More
944 Words | 4 Pages

The first chapter of both A​People’s History of the United States (​Zinn, 1980) and​A Patriot’s History of the United States​(Schweikart and Allen, 2004) tells the story of the discovery of the New World. Beginning with the landing of Columbus in the Bahamas, these accounts are told from two separate perspectives. Zinn often refers to the telling of history as a tale between victims and executioners, saying that in the “inevitable taking of sides which comes from selection and emphasis in History” he prefers to stand on the side of the victim, whereas Schweikart and Allen tend to stand behind the executioner. Much of A​Patriot’s History​is spent arguing the accuracy of the number of natives murdered by invading European entities, attempting to minimize the blame reflected on these executioners.

Read More
251 Words | 2 Pages

“Columbus, the Indians, and Human Progress”, chapter one of “A People’s History of the United States”, written by professor and historian Howard Zinn, concentrates on a different perspective of major events in American history. It begins with the native Bahamian tribe of Arawaks welcoming the Spanish to their shores with gifts and kindness, only then for the reader to be disturbed by a log from Columbus himself – “They willingly traded everything they owned… They would make fine servants… With fifty men we could subjugate them all and make them do whatever we want.” (Zinn pg.1) In the work, Zinn continues explaining the unnecessary evils Columbus and his men committed unto the unsuspecting natives.

Read More
1688 Words | 7 Pages

To many, Columbus went too far. Cruel actions, such as enslavement, unfair territory consumption, and rapid production of goods by Columbus and his crew, the innocent and wrongly named “Indians” were pushed to almost extinction. There are two sides to every story, but without

Read More
511 Words | 3 Pages

Dakota Black 9/1/17 Mrs. Eakin Point of View on Christopher Columbus When talking about history, almost everyone will agree that Christopher Columbus sailed to the Americas in 1492, but much fewer people can agree on the kind of person he was. Some say that Christopher Columbus and other explorers were ruthless killers who organized the slaughter of millions of Native Americans, while others people believe that they were brave heroes who started colonizing the New World. Two articles that clearly show these two differing points of view are “A People’s History of the United States” by Howard Zinn, which expresses that the explorers were greedy and cruel, and “A Patriot’s History of the United States” by Larry Schweikart and Michael Allen, a passage that shows that the explorers helped progress.

Read More
397 Words | 2 Pages

During my younger years of education, I was taught and deeply believed that Christopher Columbus was a hero. This belief was established as a reality in not only my mind, but the minds of many young public school students, through indoctrinated textbooks. We were taught to associate Christopher Columbus’s name with conquest, heroism, and discovery, similar to how Kenneth Burke describes the chickens who identified with food whenever they heard a specific bell. We had acquired several meanings for his name, similar to the word cloud below. The idea that Christopher Columbus discovered a new land, educated “ignorant savages,” and bravely fought for a new world became a reality for myself and others.

Read More
854 Words | 4 Pages

In the year 1492, many events took place. Ranging from Columbus sailing the blue to find the New World, now called America, to the expulsion of Jews from Spain and also the driving out of the last of the Moors. Felipe Fernández-Armesto writes this book to educate us on what he thinks revolutionized modernity and what inspired so many events to occur. He says that everything leads back to this year 1492, which planted the seeds for so many things to occur. Whether it was artistic styles people would use to portray whatever they wanted because of the Italian Renaissance or even to exploring the world beyond Europe, their tiny scope on the world.

Read More
830 Words | 4 Pages

Historians differ on what they think about the net result of the European arrival in the New World. Considering that the Columbian Exchange, which refers to “exchange of plants, animals, people, disease, and culture between Afro-Eurasia and the Americas after Columbus sailed to the Americas in 1492,” led to possibly tens of millions of deaths on the side of the American Indians, but also enabled agricultural and technological trade (Henretta et al. 42), I cannot help but reflect on whether the effects should be addressed as a historical or a moral question. The impact that European contact had on the indigenous populations of North America should be understood as a moral question because first, treating it as a historical question is difficult due to lack of reliable historical evidence; second, the meaning of compelling historical claims is contestable as the academic historian perspective tends to view the American Indian oral history as invalid; and finally, what happened to the native Indians is morally repulsive and must be discussed as such. The consequences of European contact should be answered as a moral question because historically, it is hard to be historically objective in the absence of valid and dependable historical evidence.

Read More
696 Words | 3 Pages

Merrell’s article proves the point that the lives of the Native Americans drastically changed just as the Europeans had. In order to survive, the Native Americans and Europeans had to work for the greater good. Throughout the article, these ideas are explained in more detail and uncover that the Indians were put into a new world just as the Europeans were, whether they wanted change or

Read More
883 Words | 4 Pages

Before the Spanish ship that changed it all, which arrived in the “New World” in 1492, thriving organized communities of native people had centuries of history on the land. That ship, skippered by Christopher Columbus, altered the course of both Native American and European history. 1492 sparked the fire of cultural diffusion in the New World which profoundly impacted the Native American peoples and the European settlers. Prior to European contact, Native Americans lived as hunter-gatherers, living and traveling in groups of typically less than 300 people. These Native Americans spoke over 400 languages and practiced a myriad of different religions (The American Pageant).

Read More
919 Words | 4 Pages

Millions of people in the United States of America today truly believe that Christopher Columbus changed the world through his epic journey to the America’s that proved to the Old-World inhabitants that the world was not flat. However, contrary to popular belief Columbus did not become the first person to discover the Earth was not flat. Thus, many historians were trying to figure out how this misconstrued notion became so commonplace in popular culture across America. Eventually, Mano Singham discovers where he believes the myth came from and wrote it in Columbus and the Flat Earth Myth. Singham argues the myth emerges from biased American writings that portray Columbus in a greater light than he was and the unlikely evolution debate which

Read More
155 Words | 1 Pages

They had a head start from the beginning there is no doubt about that. The european countries also had great diseases that wiped out most of their population, yet helped it grow as well. With so much diseases the generations to come would create antibodies to help fight them. Something that those in america did not have. Which is why when they came over and invaded Amarica’s population decreased.

Read More

More about How Is The Estimation Used In 1491 By Charles Mann

Related Topics

Open Document