ipl-logo

How Was Conflict Or Consensus A Larger Factor In Shaping American History?

1297 Words6 Pages

Throughout the course of American history, from colonists to Americans, each group had to face the trials and tribulations of multiple events that have shaped our country into the one we all know and love today. As many historians evaluate the events that shaped our malleable country, a key idea remains debated: Was conflict or consensus a larger factor in shaping American history? Conflict is defined as a serious disagreement or argument, typically a protracted one, while consensus is defined as a general agreement upon people. When evaluating events such as early colonization, the American Revolution, and the Civil War, conflict, as well as consensus, battle head to head to gain the lead in which ideology played a bigger part. After analyzing …show more content…

The year in history we’ll begin with is 1760. Currently in history, colonization has been going well, and life in the colonies was beginning to stabilize. King George III has just assumed the throne, which seemed harmless. Everyone was living in a state of peace, and in a state of international consensus. A few years later, things took a turn for the worse. The cause for the turmoil was the Seven Years War (Also known as the French and Indian war on the American Homefront). This war, “which left Britain with an enormous debt and vastly enlarged overseas possessions to defend, led successive governments in London to seek ways to make the colonies share the cost of empire” (Foner 180). The way our favorite royal highness decided to offset the cost was by taxing our colonists for essentially everything they used. Some events, like the Townsend act, which caused taxes on imported goods (which was everything, because they required everything to be exported, then reimported), and the quartering act, which forced British troops into the homes of colonists, were looked at as sort of a redundancy to colonists. The one law that drove colonists over the edge was the Stamp Act of 1765. All this enacted was the taxation on any paper good from the British, whether it be paper, packages, letters, or playing cards. As paper was a key component of most …show more content…

From the beginning of colonization, slavery was a forced endeavor, in which African Americans were taken from their home country, forced to work for white colonists, and could eventually work for their freedom in the New World. At the beginning of settlement, they were seen on the same level as indentured servants. They were not treated poorly, they had many opportunities to become free, and slaves lived in consensus with white slave owners. However, as land was bought up, and space became limited, the dynamic of slavery shifted into something dark and almost unimaginable. It is said “the war became a conflict of society against society, in which the distinction between military and civilian targets often disappeared. In a war of this kind, the effectiveness of political leadership, the ability to mobilize economic resources, and a society’s willingness to keep up the fight despite setbacks are as crucial to the outcome as success or failure on individual battlefields” (Foner 521). This summary of the war shows that conflict was the only factor in the Civil War. the north and south would not agree on anything, and it created a major upset. Brothers would fight against brothers, houses would be divided, and America was at a sense of loss. If it wasn’t for the brave efforts of Abraham Lincoln and the Union, the

Show More
Related
767 Words | 4 Pages

There was a tax on every piece of printed paper used like licences, newspapers, marriage license, and playing cards . The stamp act was made to help get the British out of debt after the French and Indian war. Another turning point was the Tea act Dec 15,1773 a big cause was the Boston massacre where "a taunting mob threw sticks, stones, and snowballs at a frightened group of soldiers guarding the customs-house on king street in Boston" (DOC C). A rule of the tea act was "whoever shall aid,or abet, or in any manner assist in the induction of introduction of tea, from any whatsoever, into this colony, while it is subject, by British act of parliament, to the payment of duty, for the purpose of raising a revenue in American, he shall be deemed

Read More
1106 Words | 5 Pages

Every printed item was taxed such as newspapers, books, and playing cards. Stamps on these items prove that the taxes had been

Read More
866 Words | 4 Pages

This act required that many documents such as licenses, diplomas, contracts and even playing cards to be printed on embossed paper that had a tax on it. This act was the very first attempt to tax the colonists directly for activities that occurred solely with the colonies themselves. After the French and Indian War the British national debt skyrocketed and the Prime Minister was eager to pay it down before the government was bankrupted.

Read More
601 Words | 3 Pages

The Stamp Act of 1765 had a huge negative impact on Colonial Families. The Stamp Act was a tax passed by the British Parliament that required all colonists to pay a tax on any and every printed piece of paper they used. Some of the printed documents included newspapers, magazines, pamphlets, almanacs, legal documents, licenses, bills, and playing cards. This meant that all of these items were to have a stamp placed on them to show payment of tax. The stamps could only be purchased with hard currency which was gold and silver.

Read More
990 Words | 4 Pages

“A house divided against itself cannot stand -- I believe this government cannot endure permanently half slave and half free” (Riggs 1). In the 1850’s the North’s economy and the South’s economy were very different from each other. The North relied on industries and had no need for slavery. While the South mostly relied on agriculture and slavery. After many disagreements over slavery it led to the Civil War.

Read More
1342 Words | 6 Pages

In the years of 1820s through the 1860s, a growing sectional conflict centered around slavery signaled the coming of a war between the north and the south, which almost tore down the union. According to some revisionist historians, Civil War, one of the greatest tragedies in the American history, was absolutely avoidable and resulted merely from “fanaticism and misunderstanding,” along with the failure of the political leaders to compromise; however, this is not the case. Looking back into history, the war was arguably made inevitable by the the cause of slavery. A series of factors in the antebellum age led to the outbreak of Civil War; these factors included social differences, economic issues, as well as political tensions generated by

Read More
773 Words | 4 Pages

In the early 1800’s, and before, the United States prided itself on its ability to discuss political issues and express opinions without violence. However, around the 1850’s and 1860’s, emotions were escalating, and political compromise was thrown out the window. This was because the major political debate at the time was slavery, an issue that throughout America’s entire history was shown to create very strong opinions. Another reason for this change is that northerners and southerners were unwilling to communicate with each other in any meaningful way. Slavery was an issue for the United States since it before it even became a country, and if the Three Fifths Compromise had not been made, America may never have become independent.

Read More
445 Words | 2 Pages

The different acts that were passed to collect taxes angered the colonists little by little until they finally exploded. The Boston Tea Party was a type of protest against one of those taxes. Colonist chose to waste the tea instead of buying it. The colonists were forced to revolt against Britain by all the injustices they made, like the Boston Massacre. British soldiers were not able to hold back their anger and shot 5 people.

Read More
246 Words | 1 Pages

Many of the reasons the American colonies believed they were justified in their rebellion from England lay in trade and taxes. When George III inherited the throne at the end of the Seven Years’ War England’s debt had risen to 145 million pounds and his chief minister believed that the American colonies needed to help shoulder the debt. (Nash, et al., 2007. , p. 134) In attempting to collect these taxes from the colonies to relieve the mounting debt Parliament passed a range of acts, which led to discontent among the colonists as many of them restricted trade, their political maneuverability and left many believing they infringed upon their “right to be taxed only by their own consent.”

Read More
1650 Words | 7 Pages

The American civil war occurred in 1861. This war marked a critical turning point in the United States history. The war pitted the northern against the southern states. The states in these two regions had different social, political and economic attributes. For instance, the North had a booming industrial sector whereas the South relied heavily on the agricultural sector.

Read More
364 Words | 2 Pages

Before reading This Great Struggle, I always viewed the Civil War as just a war that sprouted out of nowhere and just sort of happened over the single reason of slavery. But after reading this book I found that my misconception of the Civil War was extremely inaccurate. While reading this book I learned many new things about the Civil War that I had never known about before and I believe that it has given me a completely new outlook on the Civil War. Although he demonstrates how the war was not caused only by slavery, but he also proves the concept that slavery was a major cause of the Civil War. While reading This Great Struggle, I found that the war was, although commonly avoided and excused, fought over slavery.

Read More
1948 Words | 8 Pages

The struggle between insiders and outsiders has been a central thread in American history. One could point out that it stems from the history of the Americas as a place where a man could win power, wealth, and glory, even if he had to steal it from someone. The United States is also rare as one of the first places where a rebellion actually worked. Outsiders rising up to try to improve their lot in life has been common. But they rarely if ever worked.

Read More
739 Words | 3 Pages

The British knowingly taxed the colonists without their consent or representation, so it was basically bullying and the colonies couldn't stop it (Document 8). They also forced many unfair taxes on to them that made their economic activity significantly harder. One of these major taxes was the stamp act, which basically made it so every single printed item a person would buy they had to pay a small fee or tax (Document 4). The stamp act, however, was not the only thing. The British also stationed 10,000 troops along the frontiers costing the colonies causing even more tax being applied (Document 3).

Read More
277 Words | 2 Pages

The colonist didn’t like the laws the British made so they did many disastrous things the British didn’t like so as things kept getting worse it led to the American Revolution. The two British laws that the colonists thought were unfair are being taxed on sugar and paper, and the amount of taxes increasing. “ The madness begin in 1764 when Parliament passed taxes on sugar and paper”(unknown,1774).

Read More
329 Words | 2 Pages

The Founding Fathers rebelled against the British government for good reasons, which led to the American Revolution in 1783. The Founding Fathers were justified in rebelling against the Britain because the government was not protecting the rights of the citizens, taxing the colonists, and forced them to house British soldiers. In 1756 Britain put the first tax on the colonists. This was the Stamp Act, it required colonists to pay taxes on certain items such as newspapers, legal documents, licenses, and even playing cards.

Read More

More about How Was Conflict Or Consensus A Larger Factor In Shaping American History?

Related Topics

Open Document