ipl-logo

Humanitarian Intervention During The 1994 Rwandan Genocide

1006 Words5 Pages

Humanitarian intervention is “an armed intervention in another state, without the agreement of that state, to address (the threat of) a humanitarian disaster, in particular caused by grave and large-scale violations of fundamental human rights”. (Goodman 2006) The effectiveness of humanitarian intervention has been the subject of international discussion. (Thakur 2006).

In this case study I will assessing the effectiveness humanitarian intervention during the 1994 Rwandan Genocide. From April to June, Hutu extremists killed 800, 000 to one million Tutsi civilians and Hutu moderates. I will do this by examining the humanitarian intervention provided by the United States and Belgian forces, the International Committee of the Red Cross and …show more content…

The Clinton administration orders to withdraw peacekeeping forces and troops from Rwanda is attributed to the noninterventionist policy enforced after the death of 18 soldiers in the failed 1993 intervention in Somalia. The Belgium government, pressured by public opinion withdrew their forces from Rwanda after 10 UNAMIR (United Nations Assistance Mission For Rwanda) soldiers were killed by Hutu extremists. The withdrawal of troops has been criticised as it has been argued that the Clinton administration and the Belgium government were aware of the extreme tension between the Hutus extremists and the Rwanda Parotic Front (A political group of Rwandan Exiles) in response to the death of Rwandan president Juvénal Habyarimana on the 6th April 1994, and were warned by peacekeeping forces of the Hutu extremists plans to exterminate the Tutsi population. (Stanton 2009) According to Sliver, the ineffectiveness and lack of political will of the Belgium and U.S governments to provide humanitarian intervention was highlighted on April 9th to 11th 1994 when they sent troops to evacuate their citizens from Rwanda (Sliver 2015). This is reinforced by Beardsley, who notes that “We basically had our intervention force on the ground, but it wasn’t there to save Rwandans. It was there to save white …show more content…

The United Nations Security Council ordered Roméo Dallaire , head of the UN peace-keeping not to use force and intervene against the Hutu extremists to prevent the killing of Tutsis and Hutu moderates. Dallaire urged the UN to increase his force to 5,000 troops, and informed the UNSC of the extremist Hutu’s regimes plans to kill Tutsis and their political opponents with machetes. Yet, the UNSC voted to withdraw 90 percent of the peacekeeping force from Rwanda. (Stanton 2009) Dallaire’s force was decreased from 2,500 troops to 270 ill -equipped troops from developing countries. This jeopardised the capability of his force to protect the citizens of Rwanda and enforce intervention. According to Stanton, the lack of UN humanitarian intervention hindered the protection of Rwandan citizens during the genocide. This is due to the fact that the members of the UN undermined the “right to life” and the “right not be subjected to torture… degrading treatment” as stated under the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, and the responsibility to prevent genocide under the UN Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide (Stanton 2009). When the UNSC voted on Resolution 929 on June 22nd which authorized humanitarian efforts in Rwanda until 5000 UNAMIR troops were deployed; the genocide was already concluded (Ghosts of

Show More
Related

What Is The Arguments In Frontline's The Ghosts Of Rwanda

1181 Words | 5 Pages

There are two arguments in Frontline's the "Ghosts of Rwanda. " The genocide was prolonged due to inactivity of the United Nations, including western supporters such as the United States. The inactivity of the United States was from a lack of political or financial interest in Rwanda, and a fear of being involved in a situation which could be similar to the recent tragedies in Mogadishu, Somalia. Each of these points is argued mostly through personal interviews with the diplomats, soldiers, and civilians that were prominent inside and outside of Somalia. The interviews with Lieutenant-General Romeo Dallaire, of the U.N. forces, and Philippe Gaillard, of the Red Cross, act as Logos, Pathos, and Ethos devices in the different acts of the Frontline presentation.

Read More

Was The Rwanda Genocide Dbq

1323 Words | 6 Pages

C. Introduction The Rwandan genocide lasted three months and in those three months it is said that 1 million Tutsis were killed. The Holocaust lasted 4 years and 6 million Jews were killed. Bearing this in mind it would be expected that The Rwandan genocide should be extremely well known because of the loss of lives, impact and brutality of the event and the similarities it holds with The Holocaust. The fact is that the Rwandan Genocide is not very well known and is not thought to be in the same category as The Holocaust, where in fact it is.

Read More

Summary Of A Problem From Hell By Samantha Power

1089 Words | 5 Pages

has given to- wards the prevention of genocide by providing a list of facts and past events to formulate specific strategies that could have been implemented to stop the Hutu insurgency. Power begins by stat- ing instances where the U.S. could have done things differently, she mentions, “Instead of de- manding a UN withdrawal, quibbling over costs, and coming forward (belatedly) with a plan bet- ter suited to caring for refugees than to stopping massacres , U.S. officials could have worked to make UNAMIR a force to contend with. ”(Power 154).

Read More

Commentary On Night By Elie Wiesel

1140 Words | 5 Pages

When the international community responded indifferently toward the Rwandan genocide, “labeling it an ‘internal conflict’,” as the U.S. Holocaust Museum states, perpetrators could commit those genocidal crimes with little constraint; this directly led to the genocide later in the Democratic Republic of the Congo. “Adding fuel to [the Congo’s] unstable mix, some one million refugees, mostly the Hutu fearing the… Tutsis, fled into [the Congo]… at the end of the Rwandan genocide” and before the first war of the Congo. Additionally, leaders of that genocide followed, and “Organizing themselves in the fertile grounds of the massive refugee camps in Eastern Congo,... [they] began preying on the local Congolese population and making incursions back into Rwanda” (The U.S. Holocaust Museum 1).

Read More

Human Rights Dbq

451 Words | 2 Pages

(document 9) Also, in one hundred days more than 1 million murdered. The UN troops ' arrival helped keep order and restore basic service, furthermore; the government of Rwanda is pursuing the policy of punishment and reconciliation. Throughout history, these denials of human rights affected many.

Read More

Rwanda Genocide Response

635 Words | 3 Pages

The American Government 's Response to The Rwandan Genocide The United States often have an had interest in the political, social and civil crises of other countries in order to benefit themselves. American senior officials hid the truth of the Rwanda Genocide to avoid public moral obligation. The government did not give any financial or political support to the country because Rwanda did not offer minerals or political advantages and stability; the US ' government did not want to be involved in another conflict, even though it has helped other countries in the past.1 But what is truly deeper hidden, are the stories of people like Immacule, a young girl, who, unlike thousands of others, survived the catastrophic genocide in Rwanda.

Read More

Canadian Peacekeeping

1042 Words | 5 Pages

“Most of the 2,500 UN peacekeepers in Rwanda at the time were withdrawn after the deaths of 10 Belgian soldiers” (BBC News). The United Nations are challenged to prevent genocides and wars; they withdraw their soldiers because they cannot due anything else. The United Nations lack of power results in Canada being less involved in missions

Read More

Leonardo Da Vinci's Role In Medicine

852 Words | 4 Pages

Leonardo Da Vinci medicine Da Vinci's training in the anatomy of the human body began with his apprenticeship to Andrea del Verrocchio who was an Italian artist and goldsmith and was the manager of an important workshop. He was known by his nickname "Verrocchio" which is Italian for true eye, because of his skill as an artist. He trained many famous artists including Da Vinci and insisted that all his students learn anatomy. As a talented artist, Da Vinci quickly mastered anatomy. Drawing many diagrams of muscles, tendons and other visible features of the human body.

Read More

Genocide In Hotel Rwanda

989 Words | 4 Pages

Terry George aims no less than to demonstrate the Rwandese reality through the extremely violent and cruel scenes in the movie, he manages to convince the audience that really, over 800,000 people were in fact killed in no more than 100 days and more than 2 million refugees had to seek shelter elsewhere in the world (1). To begin with, it is important to understand the root causes of the conflict between Tutsis and Hutus to in turn understand the genocide demonstrated in the movie. Rwanda was

Read More

An Ordinary Man Analysis

1339 Words | 6 Pages

One cannot fight fire with fire. While massacre reigns in Rwanda and people take betrayal to the extreme, Paul Rusesabagina in his book, An Ordinary Man, proofs how violence is unnecessary while standing against the power of the word. As Rusesabagina states, words are “powerful tools of life”(Rusesabagina, 19). The war between the two different ethnic groups, Hutus and Tutsis, and the death of thousands left a mark Rwanda’s memory; the author says: “It is the darkest bead on our national necklace” (222). Even though a large part of Rwanda’s population is massacred, many are saved by one of Rwanda’s timeless heroes.

Read More

Film Analysis: Hotel Rwanda Genocide

896 Words | 4 Pages

Communications were sent by cable, e-mail, and secure telephone from the US embassy in Kigali informing the State Department about General Dallaire’s premonitions months before April 6. However, President Clinton had ordered US forces to withdraw form Somalia after General Aideed’s militia killed eighteen Army Rangers (Genocide Watch). During this time, President Clinton had just signed Presidential Decision Directive 25, which the same policy makers had drafted, limiting US involvement in UN peacekeeping operations. But it specifically allowed such intervention in cases of “genocide.” They therefore resisted the “cognitive dissonance” of reports of impending genocide in Rwanda, which should have created at least a moral duty to intervene.

Read More

Genocide Vs War

1178 Words | 5 Pages

In the UNSC’s article 51, individual and collective self-defense can be authorized by the UNSC under the framework of collective security. However, genocide is never justifiable in the eyes of the UN. Perhaps the most distinguishing feature between war and genocide is the disproportionally ability of those involved to fight back. Within war there is a certain level of understanding that those engaging in the conflict will have an ability to engage in battle. However, historically in genocides the effected groups have had little to no ability to proportionately fight against their attackers.

Read More

Informative Essay On Rwanda Genocide

656 Words | 3 Pages

The death of the Rwandan President Juvenal Habyarimana whose plane was shot down above the Kigali airport in April 6 1994 was the last straw. A French judge blamed the current Rwandan President, Paul Kagame, at the time the leader of a Tutsi rebel group (“How the Genocide Happened-BBC News”). The rebel group wanted to overthrow Habyarimana and return to their homeland. After months of fighting they finally signed a peace treaty but it did little to stop the arguments between the two cultures (“How the Genocide Happened-BBC News”). Then when the plane was shot down the genocide

Read More

Negative Effects Of Globalization: The Rwanda Genocide

848 Words | 4 Pages

This made large divides between the two cultures and later many civil conflicts between the groups. In 1994 when the president 's plane was shot down the government and Hutu militants blamed the Tutsis, radio broadcasts across the country encourages Hutus to take revenge and kill the Tutsis, in the end an estimated 800000 to 1 million people died. The globalization of Belgians colony and the scramble for africa through that part of the world into a blood conflict of cultures and terrorist/militant groups that still rages on

Read More

Essay On Humanitarian Intervention

882 Words | 4 Pages

On the legal grounds, the act of humanitarian intervention is still debatable, On the one hand, there was a responsibility to limit the use of force to self-defense according to the UN Charter. On the other hand, there was strong international pressure to abide by commitments to human rights and the right to life. This has constitute tensions in an international law system, Humanitarian intervention as the justifiable act to intervene while it is contrary to the principle of sovereignty and nonintervention in the UN system and international law. An evolving international norms related to human rights and the use of force.

Read More

More about Humanitarian Intervention During The 1994 Rwandan Genocide

Related Topics

Open Document