ipl-logo

Humanity In Ender's Game

527 Words3 Pages

The Command School authorities made the better choice for humanity's sake at the expense of Ender. What they chose was the intended goal of Command School, and it also saved the most people. Their decision might not be free from ethical questioning, but in the end, it was best for humanity and hence justified.
In a utilitarian perspective, Colonel Graff and Major Anderson did nothing wrong. Their purposeful trickery of Ender and his fellow young commanders was the best way to ensure the largest amount of surviving people. This is comparable to the famous Trolley Problem, where a trolley is about to run over five people, but you have a lever that switches the tracks so the trolley runs over only one person. In Ender’s Game, however, it’s the …show more content…

Humans tend to have an us-vs-them mentality, leading to the feeling of moral superiority and portraying the other side as more evil than they are. Little is known of how the buggers lived and if they cared for their kind, but the mercurial and diverse nature of humans is well known. In some sense, it would be better for humanity to die off, considering our damage to the environment. As eloquently said by Graff, “It isn’t the world at stake. Just humankind. As far as the rest of the biosphere is concerned, we could be wiped out and it would adjust.” (Card 35) During the First Invasion, buggers killed humans in cold blood. To them, killing individual humans is like killing off a couple of genetically identical cells in one body. The buggers, like actual bugs in a colony, are all offspring of one queen. Their unified thinking allows them to communicate instantaneously; all the buggers are of one mind but in separate bodies. In this regard, each and every individual human is akin to a bugger queen. If the buggers had known this, they likely wouldn’t have killed the humans. Due to the incompatible communication styles between humans and buggers, misunderstandings caused most of the bugger wars. After the Second Invasion, the buggers became peaceful towards the humans. However, the humans cannot possibly know this, so they had to kill off the buggers in order to guarantee no further attacks. Thus, the Command School

Show More
Related
1058 Words | 5 Pages

In “Ender’s Game” Orson Scott Card places a young man named Ender in a program designed to train children for battle, the group (a.k.a dragon unit) he is put into is known to be the group of boys who are the weakest and are not the best soldiers, in fact the leaders of the program are forced to shut down that unit seeing that young men who are put into the unit would fall victim of stereotypes and fail to perform to the best of their abilities. Ender is the leader of the dragon unit, so he is in charge of envisioning new tactics to receive a victory over the opponent. While in training Ender and his team receive notice that they are to battle in the upcoming hours. They are excited for the battle as they know they are ready, seeing that the team spends coupons hours of their day training, when the doors open to let them into the battle arena Ender quickly has his tactic to beat the other team, and he does. Within a couple of minutes, Ender destroys the opponent and his team still has an unheard number of people left standing on his team.

Read More
1043 Words | 5 Pages

Ender says, “I can’t do this” (252). Despite this, Ender and his army win the battle, which is exactly what the I.F. desired. The I.F. are more concerned about Ender receiving all of the training that he possibly can, so that he could be ready to fight the buggers sooner than later. This form of manipulation comes at a cost to the physical health of Ender. It leaves Ender continually exhausted, which is not good for a growing boy, like Ender.

Read More
1403 Words | 6 Pages

This is another statement that I see often inn the book and agree have with. On this subject kessel writes “The extreme situation Card has constructed to isolate and abuse Ender guarantees our sympathy.   After Ender is manipulated into entering Battle School, (he’s brought there by lies severing him from Valentine, his only protector) his abuse continues, deliberately fostered by Graff. On the shuttle up to the orbiting school Graff singles Ender out for praise for the sole purpose that the other recruits will resent him.

Read More
1088 Words | 5 Pages

Chapter 1. “Ender walked around him and kicked him again… Stilson could not make a sound; he only doubled up and tears streamed out of his eyes… ‘You could probably beat me up pretty bad. But just remember what I do to people who try to hurt me.’ ” (7) Ender’s main objective is to extend his existence, because of this, he forgets his humanity and continues to inflict pain on Stilson.

Read More
820 Words | 4 Pages

The fact that Ender saved every human being on Earth cannot be under emphasized, in fact it’s simply irrational to think that Ender could be a villain while saving his entire race in the most logical manner. Even Colonel Hyrum Graff (who had been unwilling to show any legitimate praise towards Ender throughout the majority of the book) said [“You’re a hero, Ender. They’ve seen what you did, you and the others. I don’t think there’s a government on Earth that hasn’t voted you their highest medal”](Kindle page 208) It’s possible that the lawyers prosecuting Ender were unaware of the fact that they would be dead if it was not for him, his military intuition was what spared them from the merciless and unforgiving wrath of the buggers.

Read More
1084 Words | 5 Pages

If their style of fighting were not right for the situation they were placed in, Ender would not have chosen them for that assignment. " While the people I his fleet were eating, Ender made it. Priority to know everything about everyone. Showing that knowing your people gets great things.words such as tousle, clench, and supine are words not even used today. But imagine your child in a job interview using these words and earning that job.

Read More
612 Words | 3 Pages

In Orson Scott Card’s book Ender’s Game, Ender is continually set up against impossible odds by the International Fleet, which is part of a plan to train Ender to fight in the Third Invasion and end the bugger wars forever. Ender’s trials are portrayed more convincingly in the book, as the book shows him struggling with the expectations placed upon him more so than in the movie. An important theme in Ender’s Game is that Ender is continually kept in the dark about the events happening around him. This theme is prevalent throughout the book, and sets the stage for the book’s climax, the Third Invasion.

Read More
831 Words | 4 Pages

The whole time Ender had not been aware he had killed them, and the leaders were manipulating him for his own sake. They explain that they didn’t tell him that he actually killed both Bonzo and Stilson; so that he wouldn’t think of himself as a killer. Throughout the book Ender repeats that he doesn’t want to hurt anyone and doesn’t like that he has to be violent in order to be safe. If Ender would’ve found out, it would destroy his motivation and drive to want to be the best he can be. All in all, Ender is an overall better person because of the fact he didn’t know the

Read More
928 Words | 4 Pages

Whilst referring to the attack the narrator uses the phrase “swept out of existence in a war of extermination”. This phrase uses emotive language such as extermination, a word commonly associated with insects and vermin, to convey to the audience the attitude and disrespect the British had for these “inferior races”. Whilst only a small section of the novel expresses his views on the situation, the narrator’s negative viewpoint allows him to use it as a key point in his question as to whether the Martians actions have justification based upon their circumstances. This idea of control over a large population is less of a focus in Edwards’ film “Monsters” though it is still a present concept. The group that has control in the film is the United States army, with the group they have control over being the Mexicans living in the infected zone.

Read More
754 Words | 4 Pages

This was one of the reasons why he was the perfect choice to be the commander. He also had a tremendous amount of guilt after (unknowingly) killing all the buggers and the pilots he and the squad leaders had controlled. This guilt would only be resolved when Ender finds a purpose as Speaker for the Dead and finding a safe place for the egg to

Read More
647 Words | 3 Pages

Quarter 2 Term Paper In Ender's Game, Earth is at war with the buggers, an alien species that has been a threat to humankind for a very long time. The humans think that they are attacking to gain land, but they can not know for sure. Mazer Rackham, Ender's teacher, thinks they have different reasons for attacking. "The buggers don't talk.

Read More
1183 Words | 5 Pages

However, the majority of the battles he fights are constructed and orchestrated and controlled by the Adults. Ender lives in a military archetype which assumes humans are compliant, flexible, controllable pawns, tool to be used for the benefit of others. Ender’s insecurities,doubts and fears, as to why he is so isolated, how he is becoming more like petter, how he is an ostracized genius, all that sets him apart– make him diligent, sympathetic, preservant, resilient, flexible, and above all pliable, impressionable, malleable, qualities far more common in children. Supporting quote: “‘So what do we do now?’ asked Alai.

Read More
206 Words | 1 Pages

I agree with Dink. I think that the buggers are gone, and if they’re not then they are just a weak species, still struggling from the last war and aren’t trying to get back at mankind because they can’t even help themselves. I agree with Dink that the teachers

Read More
1952 Words | 8 Pages

Abigail Turra 3425702 In “Markets in Women’s Reproductive Labor,” Stanford professor and philosopher Debra Satz questions the morality of contract pregnancy through the lens of the Asymmetry Thesis. The Asymmetry thesis is the idea that reproductive labor should be considered differently than other types of labor in a capitalist economy. While Satz upholds this theory, and the idea that contract pregnancies are morally wrong, she finds that most reasons supporting the theory are invalid, and provides “better” support for the theory. In this essay, I will argue that contract pregnancy is not inherently morally incorrect and acknowledge some validity in the degradation hypothesis.

Read More
776 Words | 4 Pages

When Ender was talking to himself he said,”the power to cause pain is the only power that matters, the power to kill and destroy, because if you can’t kill then you’re always subject to those who can, and no one will ever save you,”(Card pg.212). This shows that inaction can make people prone to lose against people who have power can have power over them because inaction leaves them open and defenseless to those they could restrain. This also shows that inaction leads to loss because Ender is referring to the fight against Stilson, Bonzo, and Bernard because if he had waited for the teachers to respond to call for help they would’ve overpowered him and he would’ve lost. After ender defeated the buggers Mazer Rackham told Ender, “you made the hard choice, boy. All or nothing.

Read More

More about Humanity In Ender's Game

Related Topics

Open Document